I love Darios Specialty pizzas. The baked ziti is my personal favorite. They are on the more expensive side, if just going for a few slices. However never disappointed either! I'm a big one on staff and their staff is never smiles and jokes. Always serious and unwelcoming. So for that they get 4 stars. read more

I feel completely ripped off. $8.89 for two of the smallest slices I have seen in my life. So smalll and thin and soggy. They must not have silverware bc I asked and I got plastic and couldn't cut the pizza. They should be ashamed. Wish I didn't give it another try after a previous bad experience. read more

Dario Pizza Pasta Panini - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

It's time they close shop and stop doing an injustice to pizza. Not only did the pizza slices resemble mini slices but their dough was overly chewy, tasteless and lacked the proper salt ratio. The outer dough rim took up the majority of the upper third of the pizza because he's likely too cheap to bring ingredients closer to the edge. The sauce was indeed blah. And the kicker is he took out my slice from the oven and cut off a portion of it before serving it up to make sure he stays in check with serving micro slices. I'm a lifelong NY'er and best believe I know my pizza. Unfriendly service, unsavory pizza and the most bizarre portion controlled slices I've ever come across. It's comical read more

The food and service suck, the owner is a jerk, $23 for a plain pizza, garbage, when I called to tell them the pizza was not good, owner got pissed off and started cussing me out, worst pizza I have ever had and I eat pizza 5 days a week from a lot of different places, this place just SUCKS, guy was telling me his place has been there for over 40 years, not to much longer till he is gone, with his shitty food and attitude. read more

The prices are way too high. The owner must be overcharging customers to make up for the lack of business. This place usually has decent pizza. However, the last time I went, it was doughy and undercooked. read more

Pizza was undercooked, also ordered broccoli cavatelli and a side salad. Pasta had enough to feed a 4yr old and the salad could've probably fed a small colony of ants. But still charged $60 for the food! Never again read more

Dario Pizza Pasta Panini - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

always come here and it's the best pizza i have ever had I recommend the chicken parm pizza and I always recommend coming to Dario's. The building smells great and they have lots of different pizza variants. I recently cane to Dario's with three friends and Dario treated us with great service and we had a great time. read more

Great pizza! Tomato exploding with flavor! Very nice staff would come here again. Atmosphere was comforting read more

Dario Pizza Pasta Panini - Tomato pie with garlic - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I frequent this pizzeria often over the last 15 years.. to me it's amazing to watch a business decline due to unfriendliness and constant changing of pricing... we went in yesterday and ordered a large soda and one plain slice each. We each paid 6.80 which is a lot compared to others.. the very next day we went in and a woman was working with dark hair.. She charged us 7.25 for the same thing! And gave us the smallest slice you could possibly imagine.. aside from the fact that there's too many other better pizzerias he is the most unfriendly person as a pizzeria owner... he doesn't say hello. He doesn't say goodbye and he doesn't say thank you.. you could see him for 10 years and he wouldn't ask how you're doing and she is just as unfriendly.. never returning and neither are my 10 friends read more

$9 just for chicken, when I order chicken fingers, sorry but I thought all the chicken fingers come with fries. read more

Dario Pizza Pasta Panini - $9 for chicken fingers with not French fries ... is the first pizzeria I see they don't give fries. - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

miles, Caden , Luke, and I had a great time. the food was really good. the service was amazing. The ambiance was overall amazing. and last, I love the monkey painting on the wall he looks similar to my friend Luke. He agreed and laughed. -Sam read more

This is my go to place when I'm out running errands in the Toms River area. Always good variety and delicious pizza. Plus it's right by DSW! A win-win! read more

$14 for a large chicken parm sandwich with not even half a chicken breast on the entire sandwich. Basically sauce and cheese with three thin slices of chicken. Complete ripoff. Sauce was good. Will not be going back. read more

I had a delicious slice in the store and came home raving .The next day ordered a pepperoni pie to go only to get home finding a $21.00 pizza with barely any sauce or cheese. The slice in the store was dripping with both ...Succulent! I called and asked for a Manager. NO apology just an excuse! Sorry You lost a great customer! read more

Ordered a pizza to sit and eat in restaurant, counter person waited until we sat down and put pre-made Pizza in oven and reheated it. When questioned about this he had major attitude and denied doing this. Pizza was awful- cheese dry. Think that's the routine- pre-make large pies and reheat as needed. Stay way from this place. read more

Bad pizza, no cheese. Awful service. Mix up with fountain drink, wanted us to buy a replacement. This place must be desperate.

The owner was completely unprofessional and turned away patrons saying he could not handle the amount of people in our party. He offered no solution despite the fact that half of the tables in the back were covered in pizza boxes which could have accommodated us. Owner is just not very nice and could care less about the customer which was quite obvious on the last and final visit to the pizzeria. read more

Total dissatisfaction, I have to say this USED to make good pizza! Not anymore they are dirty! As a customer for over 4 years they completely lost me after I ordered a $15 salad which was completely wilted with dressing all over it after I asked for dressing on the side. I tried to eat it but it was gross and called to let them know about the situation and they actually wanted me to return the salad to prove it !! So I did and they had the nerve to deny me a refund. Totally unprofessional and have forever lost me and the many people that I know come through here. Not worth it read more

don't bother, chicken parm sub lacked every flavor, there was not enough sauce, i felt like i was just eating the bread that felt like it was more on the stale side rather than being toasted properly. you aren't greeted either with anyone that looks like they love their life so i would steer clear from here read more

We ordered out slices and drinks. Food was OKAY. But what bothered us was after we started eating the guy who handed us our pizza put his fingers in his MOUTH. When we mentioned it, after throwing the slices we couldn't eat after seeing it, the dude just strugged and the manager who was standing right there! As I'm writing this, more people are going inside and he's still touching pizzas for a child! UNSANITARY. read more

$7.95 for lettuce ... no wonder you have no employees and zero business . Could buy 3 bags of mixed greens . Owners reply ... it comes with bread .. haaaa never patronize this over priced joke of an Italian restaurant . read more

Not sure what happened this time. My last post states that Dario never disappoints. I definitely take that back. I know times are tough in all businesses in todays world but I've never be so disappointed as my last trip for pizza at Dario's. We had a guest from out of town visiting and wanted to show off Dario's pizza. It was the worst lunch we've ever had!!! We ordered slices like we normally do but clearly these pizzas were hanging around all day and we're ready to be retired. They were heated I the oven but sure weren't served to us hot! I had ordered a salad that was totally uneatable. It tasted moldy. We didn't say anything while we were there but be sure we were totally embarrassed by the lack of quality of food served to us that day. And needless to say our guest will never want to go back which is a shame. Sorry about this post but I had to vent my disappointment. read more

First and last time! Went there based on great reviews. We are in the beginning of a second wave of Covid and was turned off by the young lady with her mask under her nose and no gloves. Touching the pizza without washing her hands or putting on gloves. Took my payment and gave me the change. I asked if there was any sanitizing liquid and she said no. Anyway on to the pizza. 2 tomato Sicilians and a vodka slice. No taste and the vodka slice cheese is sour. You can smell and taste it. Horrible!! The sauce on the tomato Sicilian was bitter. The crust on the Sicilian clearly undercooked. Hoping not to get sick! So disappointed!!! read more

owner rude employee clapping in back customer did not understand they made mistake and blaming on customer. unbelievable owner says don't like to throughway food agreed. gladly pay for another one even for there mistake 2 times in a row. customer for 30 years told to leave. agreed never to return. so dislike situation that i was in. i would never recommend this place to anyone. read more

Nice little pizza spot. A huge selection of pizzas by the slice. I got the buffalo chicken, chicken caesar, and white w/ tomato and brocoli. All three were decent. The chicken itself was very good on both slices, but the sauces were a little overwhelming. Buffalo was a little too hot and caesar has just too much dressing. Those are easy fixes and maybe its not always that way. I would have loved to see a chicken bacon ranch or chicken club with all the chicken selections they already had available. That would be great because the grilled chicken is so good here. Also didn't see a menu anywhere other than a little chalk board with a few specials, like desserts. This place has potential. Probably would try it again if I was craving pizza and in the area. read more

Dario Pizza Pasta Panini - So many options! - Pizza Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Dario's has become one of our favorite places to order out from on a Saturday night. They have a great selection of pizza, pasta, and other dinner selections. The chicken lubrano was delicious as was the chicken Sorrentino. Our son loves the penne and vodka sauce. My daughter loved the eggplant rollantini, I thought it was great too, I had to try some. I highly recommend Dario's. read more

Slices didn't look fresh maybe I need to order pie - not very friendly no delivery or garlic knots????

I've been eating pizza from this place just about from the day it opened, known as Pizza Plaza back then. The Lubrano family are loved by our community year after year. I worked a summer here after high school as the worlds fastest delivery boy with several tickets to prove it! There was this green blur in the shape of a Mitsubishi Eclipse with a sign on the door that was barely legible due to the ludacris speed it was traveling. . Def try my absolute favorite, the Broccoli Mozzarella Foccacia pan pizza. It's must be what the tears of angels taste like. Angelic pizza bliss. Dario is amazing and I'll forever be a friend and patron. read more

They do not deserve any stars. I had just called here trying to make a large order and the guy who answered the phone was very rude. He was rushing us for making our decision and rudely hung up on us TWICE! I will never order from here again. They were very disrespectful! read more

I don't usually write bad reviews, however, their situation with the "Italian" sub has forced my hand. Let me first start by saying their pizza is above average and they have a large selection. I am a connoisseur of Italian sandwiches though and usually get one anytime I am in a pizzeria. Being as this is the closest to my house, I was hoping it would work out....but alas it has not. They put 2 slices of ham and a slice of salami on a half stale roll. The worst part is they use white...yes white onions and roughly chopped romaine lettuce on the sub. Would it kill you to buy a bag of red onions and use them for sandwiches, or not take the lettuce from your caesar salad mix and slap it on my sandwich. I got the same result 3 times, and when I asked the guy who works the front about it he just said "thats how we make it here" read more

This employee literally handled our pizza without wearing gloves. When I walked in he was cleaning counters. So imagine why don't you....employee with a dingy rag and blue solution cleaning up after other STRANGERS bare handed; going right from doing that to asking me, "how can I help you." (In the most monotone voice you can think of).THATS NOT THE PROBLEM... But the gross part was when he just picked up slices of pizza GLOVELESS or with out even rinsing his hands off and sloppily threw it in the oven to reheat. A place is only as good as its employees and the employees are only as good as its boss/owner. We considered to go elsewhere and left them to there mis-handled food. Tis one of the reasons why people walk around with H-pylori and don't even know it. read more

I highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza. It has its own taste like I never taste before. It is kinda expensive place, but defiantly worth it. Just bring your own drink so the bill isn't $700 dollars lol. read more

It's called Dario's now (the owner's name, who took it over from his parents years ago). I've coming here for years and has always been my favorite pizza. I won't try and tell anyone it's the best in the world, because no one has eaten at them all, but this is my absolute favorite. It never lets me down. And I haven't even lived in the area for the last 8 years but when I come back to visit family, I make sure I eat from here at least once. Other than pizza, the subs are great too. I haven't had their entrees but the family owners another restaurant which I have enjoyed the food at too. read more

Huge assortment of gourmet pizza by the slice. Everything from chicken Alfredo / buffalo chicken / steak and cheese etc. They had like 15 to choose from and boy were they tasty. 3 slices came out to $10 + change. read more

Date night with the Mrs. She was in the mood for Pizza. I was happy to oblige. We happened upon Dario, and we are so glad we did. Immediately upon walking in, we were blown away by the huge variety of pizza options... of which we tried none. Go figure! She had the Chicken Broccoli Roll, and said it was great. I had the Shrimp Parmesean, and while the shrimp was slightly over done, the dish was still very good. Then we noticed the dessert specials! Oh my!!! She had the Tiramisu... excellent! I had the Coconut Creme Brulee (if you've read my post about Charcoal in Kitchener, Ontario... then you know how I feel about Creme Brulee). While the texture could be less grainy, the flavor... decadent. Simply wonderful! Dario will be seeing more of us soon! read more

We have been coming to Dario's for years and it never disappoints! The food and service are amazing but most importantly, its consistent!!!

Hands down, best pizza around. The sauce is excellent. The crust is thin and perfectly crispy, but not too crispy. Some thin crust pizza is crunchy..not Darios. It's not drowning in cheese... CONSISTENT! They never disappoint. We always get what we are expecting. read more

Not sure how the pizza is, but we ordered a few pastas, chicken parmesan -- basic NJ Italian items. So disappointed with the quality ....and didn't realize Italian comfort food could be messed up this badly. Basically tasteless and not enjoyable at all. Not sure if they were having a bad night or something, but I think they need to know about this issue. I never write reviews but this was so bad it blew me away. read more

Great pizza. This place always has many pizza by the slice choices. Last night we had the grilled veg, baked ziti, and Sicilian slices. All were great. Very friendly staff. Nice decor read more

I have never thought to have to ask if there was beef or pork put on a chicken parm sub but Which my sub was made with meat sauce. When I asked Dario if they always put meat sauce on a chicken parm sub and he said yes. Weird. So for anyone who doesn't eat beef or pork. Be warned. (Also doesn't mention the meat sauce on the menu) read more