I think this is a great location and a great chain! The pizzas are fun and full of flavor. I recommend the green lantern or the killer veggie. The candied walnut and grape salad was also delicious! Plenty of options for a vegetarian. Plus, they offer red cream soda! Hooray! The only thing I wasn't totally in love with was the pistachio cheesecake, but they do offer other dessert options (hello jenis!). read more

This is my favorite place to eat in Columbus! Dewey's Pizza is so delicious and has so many options. The restaurant is very clean and has a fresh feeling to it. As soon as you walk in, there is a big open window where you watch the kitchen staff make your food! Another thing I love about Dewey's is that the servers work together and make sure you have everything you need whether or not they are your specific server. Your glass is never empty! Dewey's has amazing salads! The servers are very knowledgeable about the menu and know how to make something vegetarian/vegan friendly! This restaurant is great for families, hanging out with friends, and date night! read more

Pretty good. Nice crust. Fresh toppings. Enthusiastic service. Loved the Harvest Salad. Will go back for more.

Come here often. Great pizza and service. This visit, we just ordered two calzones. They were brought out by the manager, Eman, who said they were a bit smaller than normal (they were a bit smaller, but still plenty for one person), so he had the kitchen make two more calzones that we could eat or take home, free of charge. We didn't complain or ask for anything extra, we were just preemptively given the extras because the manager felt the originals didn't not meet their standards. This is one of our regular spots and we'd be back regardless, but the service and attention to detail at this restaurant is just above and beyond. Come here. Eat incredibly delicious pizza. Enjoy absolutely excellent service. Leave with a feeling of satiation that is unrivaled. 10/10, would highly recommend and eat again! read more

I literally dream about this pizza. It's a perfect family spot. If you're a ranch fan like I am-you will love this place. I'm pretty sure they make it in house, and I want to dip literally everything I can get my hands on in it. The crust is heaven-totally perfect. They have a decent beer list and we've always had great service. Carry out times can be a little dicey because of how popular their carry out seems to be-so just keep that in mind (it wont be 15 minutes like, say, pizza hut.). Definitely try it! read more

Ball Park pizza is amazing. I also had the BBQ chicken pizza. Both rate an "OMG". Best pizza ever and I have had a lot of pizza. Crust is incredible!!! read more

This place is a must try in Central Ohio especially if you are tired of that same old pizza like jets, donatos, marcos. This place will blow the doors of any chain pizza place, The dough and toppings are so fresh and you can tell. While waiting the kids can see pizza makers hand toss the pizza! Go here and bring people as you will enjoy! read more

My husband is from Philly and this is the only pizza he will eat in town because it the most East Coast!

My daughter requested to go here after a piano recital last night. All 3 of my kids love this place. We ordered a a large cheese pizza, and a large 1/2 caprice and 1/2 billy goat. Also 3 of us shared a large Cesar which was very good. All 6 of our party was very satisfied and we even had about 6 pieces left to take home. Especially love their crust. Service is great too. My daughter liked watching thru the kitchen window as they made, cooked and then brought out our pies. It's not my favorite pizza in Columbus but it's very good, fresh, fast, great service and good for the price. read more

great pizza! great service! great setting! The pizza crust is great crunch on the exterior and fluffy inside. Sauce is not over spiced or over cooked and not overly sweet either. Cheese is delicious and real. Trifecta of pizza yumminess. Enjoy! read more

What a great pizza joint! My family tried Dewey's Pizza for the first time recently, and thoroughly enjoyed the food and dining experience. We ordered pizza and calzones, and my calzone was one of the best I've ever had. The calzone had a hole in the crust, for which the server apologized and explained that the kitchen would be making me a new one that I could take home if I liked. Very impressed by that gesture! We will be back again! read more

Love this place. Perfect for lunch even if you are short in time. Great atmosphere and amazing salads. You must try the Ryan's Inferno Pizza. read more

Best salad and pizza in town! The crust is amazing and you cannot go wrong with any of the salads. There is always a seasonal choice available so you won't get bored with the menu either! Amazing! read more

We are huge pizza lovers and my wife and I both agree this place has the best pizza in the Worthington area. The only con that we noticed is they don't have any breadsticks are Garlic Cheese strips as a side option. Besides that, this place is a winner and worth a try. read more

My favorite restaurant in the city! My husband and I love to ride our bikes to Old Worthington and order a pizza. The service is impeccable and unlike any restaurant I've ever seen. They work as a team and have a system for every detail. Not only that, but their pizza is to die for. I am constantly craving their Dr. Dre pizza! It's a great, family-friendly environment. read more

The pizza is phenomenal as is the general feeling of the restaurant. I'm not a big fan of the open style of serving they have. It is different to have different people take the orders and deliver the food and check. I feel it takes away from the service because one is found to be waiting longer because no one person is responsible for you. read more

Decent Pizza, on the expensive side. But whatever you do don't get the Greek salad. A bag of weeds with rancid garbage on top. I'm pretty sure whoever came up with this salad has never had a Greek salad. It's truly disgusting. read more

You never go wrong with Deweys! Their crust is amazing and the really unique choice of gourmet pizzas keeps me coming back for more. I've been eating here since the original so was opened down in Cincinnati and have never been disappointed! read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Hawaiian and green Lantern next to a green Lantern and Bronx bomber - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Nice atmosphere and location. Very friendly staff. Limited menu but excellent pizza and salads. Good microbrew selection too. Watch your pizza being made. Fun for families too. read more

Great pizza very relaxed setting. The glass window where kids can watch pizzas being made is awesome and I love the Edgar Allen Poe pizza.

Very good pizza! The wait staff are friendly and all the ownership of ensuring you have a great experience. Highly recommend!!

MOST AMAZING SERVICE!!! We placed a pickup order and when while we were waiting for out order the manager came up and told us that she had dropped our pizza and that it would take another 10 minutes to remake. She proceeded to refund our ENTIRE order (2 lrg pizzas & 3 salads). She also gave us a couple of beers while we waited. This is how you take care of a mistake and keep customers coming back. Thank You! read more

I've been to Dewey's many times since it opened a few years ago and the food is always amazing. The crust is light and airy, the toppings are unique, the pizza always arrives piping hot from the oven, and the salads are delicious. We always receive excellent service, there's a great atmosphere, and there's a window to watch the pizzas being made, which is especially fun for children. It can become very busy on weekend evenings, but you can get seated quickly if you go for an early dinner around 4pm. Overall, one of the best places to eat in the area. I highly recommend. read more

Great Pizza, Wine and Service! I recommend the Dr Dre and the Smashberry Red Wine. You cannot go wrong!

I think I got spoiled with the Grandview location. Grandview makes some good pizza. However, the Worthington location suhcked. The crust was undercooked, doughy thin, and they seemed to be really cheap on the toppings (maybe someone was counting the number of black olives and pepperoni put on the pizza so it met the minimum number). Whoever was cooking the pizza didn't do very well. I'll stick the to the Grandview location, the crust is a thicker, always cooked gourmet hand tossed one and everytime the pizza is good. fyi, picked up yuck pizzas from Worthington location Friday Nov.8 around 4:30 PM. read more

Best pizza hands down. We come from 3 hrs away just to eat here. Rodney is a great manager, always great to see him. Keep up the amazing work!!!! read more

Wow great pie! Half Edgar Alan Poe and half Socrates Revenge. Love the crust and fresh fresh ingredients. Soft roasted cloves of garlic, not overwhelmed by cheese. Delicious! And, most importantly, the store manager ran across the street to House Wine, where we were enjoying our wine with dinner, to ask how we liked our pizza. THAT is called customer service! read more

My husband and I came here for the first time last week, we got the Porky Fig pizza and it was very unique and delicious! They have a lot of creative pizza options, as well as create-your-own. read more

Good pizza. Unusual combinations and quality ingredients . I would recommend skipping reheating leftovers the next day since the pizza tends to fall apart - but it is great when fresh. Our family favorite is the green lantern. read more

We went to Dewey's yesterday. Great experience! We tried a half and half pizza as well as a calzone (with plenty to take home). The food was delicious and the service outstanding. We will be back, probably with others. read more

I love Deweys. Their pizza is always good. We haven't had a bad one yet. The Bronx Bomber is our of this world. I love pizza and I get a lot of it. Have searched for a better one and haven't found it. read more

The pizzas are great, but the salads are fantastic. I love the seasonal ingredients. Good beer selection for a pizza joint too .

We went for a late lunch 1st time there - heard about this place from a friend. We started with salads - Greek & Harvest - both were fabulously fresh with excellent in house made dressing. Of cause we ordered a pizza - we selected 1/2 Green Lantern (red sauce) & 1/2 Billy Goat (white). Both were excellent....but my vote goes to the Green Lantern. The ingredients were all super fresh an flavorful. We recommend a visit - my guess is you will be like us......you will be back to try the other options. read more

We're in town from North Carolina and HAD to get our Dewey's fix! We miss the Edgar Allen Poe with added prosciuto!

Best pizza ever, down to the last bite of the yummy crust! The salads are also unique and tasty.

I LOVEEEEEEEEE this place. The pizza is great. The salad is great. The staff is great..Everything about this place is great. Did I say this place is great. Go there...you will love it! read more