Let's get one thing straight up front. These guys have great pizza. Hand tossed, perfect crust, and everything else as it should be. But. I wish the service would back off just a bit. Maybe it's the new cool thing to have every employee and manager stop at your table 3 times each over the course of a half hour. But sheesh. It's exausting saying "thanks we're good" over and over. I have 2 toddlers in tow and I'm trying to have a conversation with my wife. And how much beer do you want me to drink? It's like they're mad that I only ordered a medium pizza, and they're gonna bum rush me like those club guys on Saturday Night Live! And no, I didn't save room for your choco-sinful-decadence-flourless-richness cake! That is all. read more

Grandview location great, amazing food. Worthington made so many errors with our orders, we wondered if the workers were OK.

I love everything about my dining experience tonight! Great pizza! Outstanding service by everyone! Super clean! Interesting beer and wine selections. Extra star for offering an interesting and tasty variety of vegetarian options! We ordered the Edgar Allen Poe and the Billy Goat. Gourmmmmmmet! I will be back and I will be spreading the good word about Dewey and her (or his) pizza! :) read more

I really love this place. The atmosphere is so wonderful for a pizza place, first off. I mean it actually has a romantic tinge to it. The bar is small but also very quaint and the bartender(s) have always been friendly and warm. A plus about Deweys if you go right now, at night, the place lights up with the Christmas lights in Olde Worthington so it just adds to atmosphere. I love everything about their pizza, from crust to toppings. Last night I had the veggie and as usually, spot on! I also enjoyed their seasonal salad that had pumpkin seeds and figs and it was very tasty as well. It's a wonderful place to go and have pizza and a pint. I highly recommend! The end. read more

I was not impressed. I asked if the pizza was spicy. It was my first time. I guess it is wrong on my part to think I could ask an employee questions about the pizza. I have stomach issues. I cannot eat the pizza. We never got a receipt too. All in all the pizza was awful. I threw it out. Businesses are worrying but breaking even during Covid. You never will continue to make it with poor business practices. I will not ever go back. read more

We live in Worthington so it's really nice to have a place where we can take the kids and enjoy an easy night with no cooking/dishes. The kids are endlessly entertained watching the people in the kitchen twirling dough, which means I get to relax at my table enjoying a glass of wine. The pizza is good, but their seasonal salads are my favorite. Even my 6 year old daughter loves the salad and begs for more! Win-win. Afterwards we walk around downtown Worthington, which makes for a nice little night. Love Dewey's! read more

Fabulous pizza - love the crust and wonderful fresh ingredients. In light of the coronavirus restrictions, they brought the pizza to our car and gloves were worn. Great customer service! read more

Great pies. Seasonal offerings keep the menu interesting. Also have seasonal beers. Pick two is nice option as an opportunity to try different combos. Staff at this location is always extremely friendly and service is good. The only challenge in Worthington is finding parking. For a great experience get a pizza to go and enjoy it across the street at house wine. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Red pop! - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

Searching for good pizza here in CBUS...got carryout, three different pizzas...veryn expensive for what we ordered. Few toppings and not enough sauce. Will not go back. read more

First time trying Dewey's and very disappointed. Probably will not try again. Ordered carryout of two small pizzas. One without cheese and extra sauce, with sausage and pineapple. I emphasized a cheese allergy and that the extra sauce was important w/o cheese. When we got the pizzas home, neither had much sauce and with stingy with toppings. The no-cheese pizza didn't even have enough sauce to cover the entire pizza, let alone the extra sauce requested and paid for. Very sparse on the toppings also. Not a terrible pie but certainly nothing special. Much better options in the north side of Columbus. read more

I went to Dewey's last night and ordered a 17" pizza to go. When it was time to pay they told me it was free because the pizza was not in perfect shape. I would not have even noticed the square inch spot where the cheese was not as thick. It was definitely an unnecessary but much appreciated treat. They have high standards for themselves and treat the customers exceptionally well. The food is consistently top-tier. read more

Great place, friendly staff who are quick to recommend food and beer. The salads are light and delicious and the pizza is unique but still tastes great. The crust of the pizza is great, nice and chewy. read more

Let me just say right off the bat that my kids love this place, and actually eat well here. This is nothing short of miraculous. Mostly we get the pizza to go, but if it's not too crowded it's kinda nice to just sit and relax for a bit. I personally like the calzones loaded up with vegetables. The salads are also good - especially the one with fig and goat cheese. The salads tend to rotate seasonally, with different fruits/veggies, and really we've enjoyed them all. My worst "complaint" is that once we ordered a bottle of soda with a to-go order, and it was flat. Also, can we get some breadsticks on the menu?! All around this is a solid go-to option for us. read more

Love this pizza!!! Best in town. The staff is incredible and I always want more. The salads are the best in town too!

Great service and good atmosphere. The pizza was really good. Outside patio was very nice too. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Outside patio - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

There's nothing else to say but YUM, I loved my salad (Peppercorn Ranch), I loved my pizza(Porgy Fig). Everything was delicious.

Don't come here unless you: 1. Want to walk 2 or more blocks to get here. Horrible parking. 2. Don't come here unless you enjoy waiting for a table with other people's kids running all over the place, I actually tripped over 2 of them, said excuse me and the parents looked at me like it was my fault. And 3. See #2. Full of millennials. They don't watch their kids, allow them to run all over the restaurant screaming. I am not anti kids, but get a hold and teach them some manners! read more

Pretty good, the dining was nice we didn't have to wait long till we got sat down and they got our stuff out pretty fast. The only thing I would have to say that is bad would be how long we waited for our extra order after we got our original food read more

This place has the best harvest salad I have ever had. The pizza is excellent and very nice staff. Have been going back a lot.

Went here for the first time last night. Wow. Good all around. We loved our half Don Corleleone and half Caprice. Soooo good...as well as the harvest salad we started with. You'd never know this place is a chain. The staff was so friendly and attentive. They do team serving...we had our main server and lots others come to our table but they all knew what we were had ordered, what we were drinking and our glasses were never even half empty. The manager served us our pizza...he actually made it! I really like the idea that everyone does everything and shares tasks. You'd never know it was chain. It's not a huge space and it's really cozy inside. We'll defiantly be going back! read more

I was teetering between 2 and 3. I gave them three, because the service was really good. It was my first time there and had heard good things. The wait was 25 to 35 minutes, and people were coming and going with take out orders. The glass window in the waiting are is cool for kids to look in on the pizzas being made. There was a decent selection of local beers on tap to enjoy while we waited. The pizza on the other hand fell flat. It looked amazing on the menu, but just did nothing for me on the plate. Since the traffic is aweful and parking is scarce, I probably won't be back. read more

ordered the cheese pizza for pick up and it tasted like pizza. fine and dandy no complaints.

I. LOVE. DEWEYS. PIZZA. I've only been here twice in the last two months, but only because I have to force myself to not come here every day. Their menu is full of customizable pizzas, calzones, and salads. I have had both their calzones and pizzas, and enjoyed both. I get my calzones with pepperoni, sausage, and green pepper. They offer pizza sauce and ranch on the side if wanted. Try their ranch- it's homemade and amazing. Very friendly and attentive staff. Great atmosphere. read more

Wow! This pizza was AMAZING. The harvest salad was also really good. Customer service was really professional and able to explain their brand very well. I have found my Friday hangout spot. read more

All ingredients seem fresh, it's just not my style. Everything is very California Fusion stuff than just good pizza. (Example: Goat and feta cheese instead of plain old provolone, mozzarella). But my mediocre rating is because there were four of us on a late Friday night 8:45pm). The place was busy, but plenty if extra tables. We were seated and served promptly. The hours were open until 11pm. We ordered a decent sized meals and drinks. Starting as soon as we paid our bills, the wait staff began ignoring us. No more refills, no offers to clear the table. Then they turned out the lights to our table, I guess as a hint to leave even though 1. The restaurant was nearly empty 2. It was an hour until it closed. Needless to say, it won't be our date night/friend night again. read more

Gourmet pizza with unusual combinations that work. Reminds me of a California Pizza Kitchen-- thin crust with lots of veggies, cheeses and thin sauces. If you like white sauce and stronger cheeses there are many good choices. It's also fun for kids who can watch their pizzas be made. The salad was good but a little over-dressed. We will be back. read more

Dewey's Grandview needs to take a lesson from Dewey's Worthington. The service and food were excellent at the Worthington location and I give it a high recommendation. Two stars knocked off for the absolutely horrible Grandview store...but Worthington Dewey's is terrific! read more

Amazing, awesomely priced cheese pizza. The rest of the specialty pizzas are great, just too high of a cost for me to partake. I stick with the giant cheese pizza for $16 and always have a delicious pie! read more

Good pizza. They even cut it into pie shapes! I have always had good service and the wait time is as expected for pizza. Located in a nice historic neighborhood. read more

The pizza is excellent and the service very pleasant. They do a great job with vegetarian and vegan pies. I will definitely come back. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

This our second dining experience at Dewey's Worthington. We were impressed the first time and they didn't disappoint the second! The pizza is great (nice variety) as well as the beverages but it is truly the staff that makes for a great atmosphere. They are knowledgable, helpful, friendly, and clearly a great team! Great job guys! We will definitely be back soon!! read more

First time here - stopped in while exploring Worthington. Pizzas were delicious, so you can tell everything is as fresh as advertised. My girlfriend raved about the house salad and meatball pizza. I had the Edgar Allen Poe & took home a Bacon-Black Bean Salsa - Meatball calzone. Let's be honest - there are a ton of great pizza places in Columbus. Their is incredible and I'm excited to try more of the menu. The kicker though - their staff and service makes us a return customer. That's what also separates them from the others. read more

The harvest salad was the bomb. Staff was FAST and very friendly. If you get a chance check them out. read more

Dewey's Pizza - Worthington - The bar area. - Pizza Near Me - Worthington, Ohio

One of our favorite spots to grab a pizza when we're on this end of town. Service is always excellent. Loved being able to hold my spot through yelp. Ingredients always taste so fresh. On this visit just got a simple pepperoni pizza and was surprised how delicious it truly was. Already looking forward to our next visit. read more

I'm skeptical of pizza, but this is good and made just right, great people can't go wrong, salad was outstanding!

Good service, great pizza and even better salads! We tried the wild mushroom and the southwest BBQ chicken pizza. Although I generally love the mushroom pizzas better than any other, both My husband and I liked the southwest pizza more. We also got the Greek salad with their red pepper dressing which was pretty good. Our server was quite friendly. Since I'm pregnant, I also asked him to check on a few ingredients and he did so happily. Overall the food and service was great except for the dessert - chocolate cake which was strictly ok. read more

First time here. Weird that there are no traditional appetizers. Service was quick and constant. House vinaigrette was excellent. Ordered the veggie pizza which had a great crust. Only detractors were the cold tomatoes on the pizza, seemed added after the fact. Otherwise a welcome addition to downtown. read more

Pizza was good, and the menu had a good variety of choices. Service was very good. Any time my drink dropped below 2/3 full any member of the staff nearby would refill without asking. read more

This is my favorite place to eat in Columbus! Dewey's Pizza is so delicious and has so many options. The restaurant is very clean and has a fresh feeling to it. As soon as you walk in, there is a big open window where you watch the kitchen staff make your food! Another thing I love about Dewey's is that the servers work together and make sure you have everything you need whether or not they are your specific server. Your glass is never empty! Dewey's has amazing salads! The servers are very knowledgeable about the menu and know how to make something vegetarian/vegan friendly! This restaurant is great for families, hanging out with friends, and date night! read more

I've known Dewey's Pizza since my days in Cincinnati as an undergrad. Their pizza is always top quality, but their service at this location is especially notable. We were seated and taken care of quickly for our drink orders. The special sounded delicious (fig jam, gorgonzola, carmelized onions, and prosciutto!) but I wasn't feeling a whole pizza, so I asked if they could make that into a calzone, and YES they could! Not only did our waiter continue to check up on us, but there was another staff member (manager maybe?) who checked in once or twice to make sure our food was superb and our service was top of the line. Great experience all around. Delicious pizza. Oh, and get the house-made ranch dressing. It's amazing! read more