Got a pizza had some hair in it. Ordered buffalo chicken salad no buffalo sauce on chicken got shorted on ranch had paid extra

The location is right near Bent Creek parking is excellent and very accessible. All fresh real Italian pizza and Stromboli and more

Great food .. a great subs !! I like to go for late lunch.. even by myself .. if it's not the busy time of day .. I'll order lunch and bring a book to read.. order enough food to take home ... Of course if they are starting to get busy ...... I would not just sit there and read my book .. it's time to leave !!! But I've just had a relaxing time to myself....oh I almost forgot!! Very friendly service !!! Be sure to leave a good tip... they work very hard .. Try them ....u won't be sorry.. I gave them a 5 rating.... read more

Update after 2 years, we had been ordering out from here when we just don't feel like cooking at home. I think we must have come on a bad day from my original review. They have very decent apps, great calzones and salads! Pizza is still 6.5/10, not the best we've had but not nearly as bad as the time we originally ordered from them. read more

I bought the Italian sub again and it was wonderful! Bread was fresh and there was a lot of meat. The large is a big meal; plenty to take home for later. read more

DiMaria's Pizza & Italian Kitchen - Italian sub, I bought it again and it was wonderful! - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

I called for delivery but they said delivery orders must be placed online. I tried to order online but at the end it told me I was too far a way. Any We got 3 Hoagies and 1 white pizza with spinach. The sub rolls, which I believe to be homemade are excellent.. I love a hard roll that is soft and moist inside. All 3 subs were excellent. We ordered a cheesesteak, an Italian, and a ham and cheese. This place is in the middle of NOWHERE, but I am planning on going again soon. I would go here again. The Italian dishes all look great. read more

I recently ordered from this pizza shop using Slice, but mistakenly had my order placed at their Lititz location, about 45 minutes away from where I intended to order. I had no idea they had multiple locations, and while I understand this was my error, the way it was handled left a bad taste. When I arrived at the location I thought I ordered from, I called right away to explain the mix-up. Instead of working with me to find a solution, the staff directed me to call Slice. After contacting Slice, they confirmed the restaurant wouldn't issue a refund or credit. I later learned the food had been thrown away, which is disappointing, but the real issue was the manager's response. Rather than being understanding, he spent five minutes explaining himself defensively without offering any resolution. For the record, I only ordered one meal--not a huge order--and I would have gladly paid for delivery to avoid the waste. I understand running a business has its challenges, but it would have been nice to see some effort to make this right. Safe to say, I won't be returning to the Lititz location. read more

Having just moved from NYC, looking for genuine NY style pizza is a challenge. I think that DiMarias might have filled our pizza craving- great crust - perfect sauce and not overcooked! The Strombolis are great too...a very expansive menu which we will take the opportunity to explore soon! read more

This is owned by the same family that owned Procopio's in Adamstown. The owner has very high standards for food quality, and it shows. Prices are higher, but quality is high. There is a sign outside that says "Best Cheesesteaks in Lancaster County". I definitely agree. Pizza is also great. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The place is nicely decorated, and very clean. read more

Very good pizza and to be honest, pretty much everything else. Service is very good as well. This is a small place with seating maybe for 28? Easy parking and seams like most people get their food to go especially with pizza the main course. Bathrooms could be a lot better. Drinks are not great as they only have unsweetened ice tea and water if you want sugar free. read more

Excellent pizzas and very friendly service. Will definitely be back for take out . Some of the best pizzas that we have had.

The Red top pizza was so different and absolutely delicious! The restaurant was clean and quaint and the employees were so friendly!

Food was so good and great service!! Will definitely go back when in the area. Had bbq chicken pizza and chicken parm!

There isn't one menu item I've eaten that I wouldn't order again, and again. the pizzas are just tremendous. Try Grandma's Pizza, OMG! read more

DiMaria's Pizza & Italian Kitchen - Chicken Cacciatore is fantastic. - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

beautiful..spotless. clran..aaa..garlic. knots..over. the. top. .o.am. an. 3rd..generation. .n.y..old.school..n.y.pieman..i rate. this. pizza..at..8.9. yes i. dont. say..it..alot. but. i..was...impressed read more

Verdict: A tasty grandma slice but I'm not DiMarried to this pizza kitchen. I'm always on the lookout for a good grandma slice so I had to give this one a go. I'd hoped to find a new favorite pizza spot but came away with mixed feelings. The pizza wasn't bad and $3 a slice seems to be about the standard local rate. The biggest thing is that I didn't feel all that welcome. Maybe it was how the employees didn't seem to want to be there either. Whatever it was, I didn't find myself rushing to go back. The reviews are generally good. You can probably get a quality pizza here. For me, it was simply DiMaria no a'more. read more

DiMaria's Pizza & Italian Kitchen - Menu - Side 2 - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

See all

Thank you for the excellent food!!! Victor and Carlos you guys are awesome. During the rising peak of the Corona virus I placed a large order for my sister and her family. Catering size Lasagna, 2 pizzas, chef salad, greek salad, mild wings, medium wings, cannolis and zeppolis. I wanted the food to last a few days and went to town on their order. Everything was nicely packaged and everything was delicious! They raved and had fun with it all!! We live in another town so I was not actually able to taste anything. It all sounded so delicious and my mouth was watering as I placed the order. Like I mentioned...they all raved and were thrilled to have left overs to freeze and enjoy all week. Such a nice pick me up from this crazy time in all of our lives. I highly recommend. read more

My girlfriends and I stopped in for lunch. The owner provided such lovely customer service. He even carried our order outside for us himself. I will be back! read more

We had the best of luck finding this spot! Ordered the Jersey PizzA.... did not disappoint! Clean, safe, friendly ! Perfect spot for fill-you-up Italian delights. Thank you read more

So I've gone here a few times. Food was pretty decent. Lately, it's gone down hill. Here's an example. I ordered a medium steak boil with double meat and double cheese. Look at the pictures and you will clearly see it's not double. In fact, I would argue it's half. They made sure to charge me for double meat and cheese though. I called back and was assured I was given double meat. If this is double meat what does a regular portion look like?! My advice is go else where. read more

See all

I worked in the neighborhood next to the pizzeria and came and ate 3 days in a row. Best customer service and even better food. Would 100,000,000% recommend read more

We called a week before to ask if they could take a group of 40 of us (half kids under the age of 12). They were not only amazing, but kind, attentive and the food was awesome! I personally had the eggplant parm and it was the best I've ever had. The kids were loud and there was a lot to do, but they did it all with a smile and gave great service all night! Thanks for making our experience in Hershey a memorable one. read more

We love DiMaria's we travel from Mount Joy every Friday for family pizza night here. We love their pizza and cheesesteaks. The customer service is not the friendliest but it is a family business with a great product. We will keep traveling for the yummy food. Their first location still remains in Mount Joy but it is under new ownership and it stinks. read more

Understaffed. But still, we had a lame experience. Ordered a slice of pie for my daughter. There was 3/4 of a pie. Watched the give it to people as they walked in after us. Then waited 20 min for them to cook another. read more

AMAZING customer service! Great food, fresh, hot and always get our order correct! We did not order drink, but received large cups of ice water without requesting! read more

We ordered the tomato pie and a cheesesteak. I had heard good things. The tomato pie was just a thin dry crust of pizza with canned spaghetti sauce on top and a lot of oregano sprinkled over it. Yuck. The cheesesteak was meh. Very little cheese and steak and no sauce. We had to wait longer than I thought we should for food I didn't like. I wouldn't go back. read more

The food here is so delicious! The spinach calzone is my absolute favorite calzone that I've ever had, anywhere!

Finally I found pizza that is just like home, the place is really nice you walk in and you know they are all about good pizza everything I sow looked amazing. House salad was so good I love this place. My new pizza place. Sicilians know how to make good pizza, keep it up don't change one thing. read more

DiMaria's Pizza & Italian Kitchen - OMG tomato pie sooo good just like NYC - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

We had a great experience here. Walked in on a Saturday with 9 people and they quickly pushed tables together to accommodate us. Service was quick and friendly. Loved all the menu options. I was very thankful that they had gluten free pizza as I cannot eat gluten and it was honestly one of the best gf crusts I've ever had. My family was raving about the pizza for days after and wanted to go back before we left (we were on vacation). We will definitely be back. read more

Someone gave us a gift certificate for this place or else we might never have found it... I'm glad they did! The dinners are authentically good Italian and plenty of it. I had pizza there also and it was good especially the sauce. Wait staff is really attentive and the place was clean. read more

This was an amazing place to eat! We were on our way home from the fire and ice festival and found this restaurant. They treated us and especially our son like family! This was definitely the best pizza we've had in a long time if not ever. This is now our place to go for pizza and other Italian dishes. We don't mind making the 35 minute drive from our home, it's well worth it! read more

DiMaria's Pizza & Italian Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Spot on cheese steaks. The DiMaria's Special Steak is excellent, and has the perfect balance of flavor. I've recently moved from Philadelphia and I have to say that DiMaria's rates among the best steaks I've ever had. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive and our food arrived quickly, hot and fresh. They have a small but nice little dining area and it was clean and well maintained. While I can't yet vouch for the pizza, I have to say that with the amount of carry out traffic they have it must be pretty good. My family and I will be returning here so hopefully I can update my review on the rest of the menu. I honestly do not know understand the negative reviews. DiMaria's is a nice little pizza joint in a town with mostly terrible pizza and mediocre steaks. The service is good and we were very happy with our meals. read more

Definitely very authentic Italian pizza. Loving the Grandmas pizza. Service is excellent always.

Love this place. Great service great Italian food! The owner remembers his customers. Very good!

DiMarias is my go-to pizzeria. I have yet to be let down by their cheesy pizza. There barbecue chicken pizza is a favorite of mine, yet not for the faint of heart. The pizza is adorned with a healthy swirl of sweet barbecue sauce and chicken. One slice is a delicacy, and the rich sauce and cheese combo quickly fills the stomach. The service there has never fallen short. A waitress has always quickly served our table and been more than accommodating with splitting checks when my friends and I go out to eat. Whether dinning in or taking out, DiMarias will not disappoint. read more

Buyer beware when ordering a take out! We ordered a 6 Foot Party Sub for our Super Bowl Party! Vendor accepted our order with no questions asked! Presented to pick up our Party Sub Today and found a SMALL tin container with 6 what I'm sure they call 12" subs jammed in the container!! We did NOT order 6 subs!! We ordered 1 - 6 Foot Party Sub!! Very very very disappointed and embarrassing for us to present to our guests!! read more

Moved from reading and never had pizza like this. Cheesteaks were also so good! Our family favorite we all decide on everytime

Always a failsafe place for pizza and pasta. Friendly serice and they're fast with pick up service. Coming from Chicago-this place is definitely second best! (That's a good thing) read more

The best pizza in the area. I live in Ephrata, but it's well worth the drive. You won't go wrong. Eventually, I'll have to try something else. read more

From my wife: Went here for a sandwich. Ordered it w/o mayo, but it was served with mayo. Told the waitress, who was very nice. She apologized and realized that she forgot to put it on ticket. She told cooks and owner. The cooks and owner, all five of them, yelled at her for all to hear for quite a long time. I felt bad for her and told her I wanted to leave. The manager brought me a new sandwich and angrily threw it on the table. I told him that I was leaving due to the way he treated his waitress and his attitude. He pulled the plate back and yelled "CAN YOU BELIEVE HER!" He continued to yell at me in front of my 9 year old as we walked out. Real tough guy yelling at a woman and a child. I don't recommend this place. Especially if they get your order wrong - then they'll really be mad at you. If the waitress who served me is reading this, I'm so sorry you have to work in a hostile environment. If you choose to leave, I'm sure you'll be appreciated elsewhere. You were wonderful. To the owner - I think you need anger management lessons. read more