It's all about the great view, cocktails and good music. I wouldn't say this is our go to place for…read morea great meal but this time we were pleasantly surprised. Crab cakes were delicious without a ton of breading/filler, the chicken Marsala with garlic mashed was perfect for a chilly night on the beach, skirt steak was cooked perfectly and the vegan burger was tasty. Come for the atmosphere, sunsets over the bay or to watch the weekend warriors pour off the ferry onto the Island, but stay for a nice meal on the back deck - you may be as surprised as we were.

This place hits the island vibe spot.... Great drinks and service... Brandon our bartender is a…read morenative of the island and knows a lot of things... we had arugula prosciutto flat bread that was great!

I took the ferry today from Bayshore Long Island to go to Ocean Beach fire Island. It was my first…read moretime there. So I was walking around and I was looking for something quick to eat didn't wanna spend a lot of money and I saw this little pizzeria and I figured I'd give it a try. I ordered one regular slice and one Sicilian slice and I also got a soda. It came out to 1765 yes, a little pricey. But I gotta say I'm pleasantly surprised both slices were really good. I would probably even say 8.5 out of 10. Both slices were a little crispy chewy and definitely tasted fresh right amount of cheese the right amount of sauce. I added a little red pepper for a kick. No lie the pizza was really shockingly good did not expect that from a beach area. My only regret was not ordering another slice but I'll definitely come back. Also the girls were very nice there and helpful .

We ordered the Calamari Arrabiatta and 3 slices of pizza…read more ALL WERE PERFECT! The flavors that dance around on your tastebuds from the calamari Arrabiatta are amazing. The tangy little kick from the sauce is absolutely memorable. We dipped our pizza into the sauce and BOY OH BOY that changed everything! The perfect NY pizza can not always be found outside of NYC or the boroughs, but you better your a55, you'll find it at Beacheria. The place is clean and quirky. The employees seem to take so much pride in their place of work and the foods made. I even think I heard the manager telling the cooks how much we enjoyed our food. The best thing is to know that they received our feedback immediately. OH! and they have PAC-MAN!

I have to knock them for uneven service with ice cream…read more Was fine paying net $26 for four cones one day because they scooped and applied topping generously. But another time they went real light when buying 2 cones. And prices aren't listed so they charge whatever they want. Again, out here, most people aren't gonna care and I know seasonal businesses have to do what they can when they can. But while they're reliably open and convenient I can't really recommend them if they're just gonna cheap out on you randomly.

Such a nice place to come and get breakfast. Cute deli that has some seating. Super friendly and…read moretotally pleasant. They Make a solid bacon egg and cheese. While eating, the manager, Bobby came by and gave us some of his homemade banana bread. It was delicious.

Love it here! Great customer service and yummy pizza! Shout out to Nick and Thanos! Great people…read morewho made me feel so welcomed! If I could give 6 stars I would. Coming here every time I'm on the island.

Pizza was good. A slice is like four dollars not too bad for fire Island. Probably the cheapest…read morepizza out there right before you get to the beach. The service was great. The young kid took care of us. Very nice and kind and polite. Yummy small you can eat there or take it out. We ate outside great in front and enjoy the breeze. I like this place.

I had the time of my life at this place. Right on the water, $5 cover charge, great 90s and 2000s…read moremusic. The people were friendly and fun. You can party all day and all night on a Sunday and probably even crazier on Saturdays. Several bars so you're not waiting for a drink. Lots of shaded areas. Food was an extra plus: fresh and delicious. Chipotle Chicken flat bread.

The Flynn-tini is the best drink on fire island and they always have the best specials for dinner,…read morehighly recommended

The pizza here is very good but watch the board for their specials, often posted on Instagram. The…read morecrab bisque and crab cakes were absolutely delicious. Always happy to support this nice family run business.

where do i even begin with this muppets market. this sandwhich was so gross. the muppets legit made…read moreit- was it turkey or bolongie? im not sure but it was so gross and it took legit 5 hours to make.

Stopped at Castaway for a midday snack. Oysters were fresh and a good size. Even my friend who…read moredoesn't particular enjoy seafood thought they were delicious. We also got the wings and parmesan fries. The BBQ wings were good--saucy and not too small. Fries were just meh. They're just fries and a good shareable but nothing special. The staff is so sweet and accommodating. My friends and I were here a few years back and sat at the corner table outside. Our waitress didn't hesitate to prep the table for us when we requested to sit there again. When I was here a few years back, they had nachos and they were probably the best I've ever had. Been thinking about them ever since. Petition to bring the nachos back!

No wait for a table, Service was exceptional, food came out fairly quickly, I would give it 7 out…read moreof 10.

great deck table. server allie was outstanding. i had the bacon burger that would have been a solid…read more10, but the bun was weak. clam chowder was of best i have ever tasted anywhere, even in seattle and sf. beautiful. tuna poke salad and salmon all great we loved the place period..5 rum drink was solid

The view is amazing.... Brody our waiter was great... the wait time for food was long but it's an…read moreisland so it's island time. Steak sandwich was good and so was my wife's poke bowl. Margaritas were refreshing... if you want a nice fire island place come here.

Stopped in here with our family group of 20 or so. The owner and our young man server tokk great…read morecare of us and the salads fish and tostadas were very good. As well as the setting

Waitress was not friendly. Asked what kind of fries came with cheeseburger and she stated curly…read more Asked if shoestring fries that were on the menu could be substituted- she said no that there was only enough shoestring fries for the steak dinners. 2/5 burgers came out charred. No one asked for well done. The shrimp cocktail came out 10 minutes after everyone got their meal. Spray bottle of cleaner left next to table/chair. Stared at it entire meal. At least remove the cleaning supplies so they are not next to where you are eating. That was a one & done restaurant . Too expensive of a place to have that experience.

Excellent service. I walked in and was greeted by a wonderful woman who sat us at a booth we got a…read morewaitress who got our order fast and the food was amazing. The wings were 10/10 and the environment was perfect.

Was encouraged to dine here by another shop owner in town and I'll be honest, I had my mind set on…read moreanother place but she assured me Albatross had the best food and specifically told me to get the fish tacos! I came right over and got there just as they opened. WOW! Fish was super flavorful and it was a great portion size for the money! Service was also fantastic!