Recently ordered a sausage and pepper hero with cheese... Naturally expected Italian sausage as the base. Surprised to find that out that it was beef sausage, not Italian sausage. Would not have minded if that had been what was ordered. When sausage & peppers is advertised at an Italian restaurant/pizzeria, one should expect Italian sausage... #imjussayin read more

I was in the area, looked up a well rated pizza shop and came across Domenick's. Walked my way over, ordered a Chicken Parm w/ Vodka sauce. What I got was........refer to pic. Mozzarella Soup in a bread bowl with 4 slivers of chicken. Bread was toasted but ended up being a soaking, wet hot mess. All in all not a memorable dining experience. Thankfully, I don't live in the neighborhood and see no reason to ever return to this establishment. read more

Domenick’s Pizza - Chicken Parm w/ Vodka sauce - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica, New York

This pizza shop is phenomenal! Mouthwatering pizzas, friendly service, and cozy ambiance. A must-try! read more

See all

I came here for my lunch break during jury duty and ordered two slices of the Domenick's special. What a huge slice, topped with a variety of meats and veggies. Only ~$6 a slice, not much pricier than other more regular slices. Decent crust, and fresh tasting. Well lit and clean inside with plenty of seating. Prompt service. Would come back! read more

I do recommend this old school pizza place especially if you are doing jury duty, worker or student in the area. The food is good, they have a diverse menu from gluten free pizzas to sandwiches and wraps. I had to go for the classic cheese slice and a mild Jamaican beef patty. It hit the spot especially with the house coffee...not too strong and not weak- great for a cold windy day and help me stay awake at jury duty. Come by and ask Rubio and the crew for good eats ! read more

We've been dining at This pizza restaurant for decades. The recipe hasn't changed, the sauce a bit sweet, but tangy at the same time. The cheese and crust always perfect. Located on a busy hub, of public transportation, bank, other restaurants and shops. read more

I ordered a chicken parm hero, and the bread was completely soggy and mushy; it wasn't toasted at all. It's clear that the person who made this lacks an understanding of what a real chicken parm hero should be. Very disappointing. Never again. read more

Idk if it's the cheese, or thickness of bread but I think it's not executed right. Tastes good, but wrong proportion. Bread needs to be thinner and crispy. read more

Pizza was definitely delicious and huge, however I paid for pepperoni ($3 extra) and there wasn't a single piece of pepperoni to be had. Also requested 3 garlic knots and they came with no sauce. I understand restaurants get busy but this was ordered at 2 in the afternoon. read more

Domenick’s Pizza - Grandma pizza missing the pepperoni I paid extra for. - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica, New York

3.5 stars For a pizzeria, the chicken parmigiana wasn't bad. I ordered it with spaghetti and the portion was very generous. It's definitely not the best chicken parm I've had but it's certainly enough for 3 meals. The sauce was just a bit bland but I came here when they first opened so perhaps they've solved this issue. The entree also came with a few garlic knots that were pretty good and some fresh, warm bread. So for the portion, great prices.. nice staff. Solid 3.5 stars.. I'll try their pizza next time. Even after a 25 min commute back home everything was hot! read more

The owner and his daughter are wonderful. I ordered for our Holiday Party and the food was delicious. Everyone loved it. I ended up ordering again for the next day for a meeting we were having, and they were very accommodating for the short notice catering order. The food was even better the next day. Everyone should definitely give them a try for your next catering event. read more

You gotta get the deal (L cheese pizza, 6 piece garlic knots, and 2 liter), you can add pepperoni for $4, bringing you to $27.95. Quality pizza (the best I've tried in the area) available for delivery. I have no complaints. read more

I just ordered a lasagna pizza pie through Uber eats and it was horrible. There was way too much meat cheese and sauce to the point where the pizza became a lasagna soup. I couldn't even pull a slice out of the pie without it falling apart. The toppings were literally spilling over to the to sides of the pizza box. The pizza had no structure and I had to eat it like a savage, rolling it up with my hands like a taquito and scraping off all the toppings. It was messy and disgusting but I'm not one to call in and send it back. So I just ate it because I was starving. But I will never order from here again. I ordered on 04/23/21at around 1:40 pm read more

Came in for a quick plain slice and it was really good. Such a friendly customer service as well. Will come back.

I order all the time from Domenicks Pizza for my school for special events. The staff and students love their pizza as well as all their other goodies. The comments that students say about their pizza is that "it is crisp, tasty, and delicious!". They never disappoint with their catering trays such as their meat lasagna, stuffed shells, peppers and sausage, penne ala vodka and especially their chicken parmigiana! They also deliver on time, which is wonderful when it comes to school events that need to start on time. They never disappoint! read more

Local pizzeria with solid slices, good hot sandwiches and nice baked pasta dishes. I normally grab a slice or two once or twice a week. I live close by. I also order a pie or something else more substantial for a meal a couple times a month. It never disappoints. I think the owner sold out just before covid but has since returned to the business. It's a good neighborhood spot. The folks working there are really nice, it's easy to call in an order and the prices are very fair. read more

Domenick’s Pizza - Pie w sliced meatballs, onion, black olives and peppers. Well done (personal preference). Great. - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica, New York

Great spot for wings ! Used Grubhub to order the first time and realized can call them directly to get actual price and they deliver! Second time around as I think it's under new management daughter /father business. Highly recommend! read more

Domenick’s Pizza - Pepperoni pinwheel - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica, New York

See all

Don't waste your money, this company is a scam. They put no meat in their sandwich's It's horrible read more

Delicious! The pizza is just right. I've also tried the salads here, healthy and filling best of both worlds.

Went to this spot with my friend Tony and he crushed almost the whole pie before I could have my second slice. I must say I haven't see him eat that much in a while. Top notch pizza with friendly service! Highly recommend read more

I was craving pizza and hadn't been able to find a reliable pizza spot in my area. After reading the glowing reviews, it appeared Domenick's was going to change that. First of all, the two Grandma slices I ordered looked like they had been out all day and they didn't even bother to heat it up. I get that I was probably the last order of the night but that doesn't mean I don't deserve quality food like every other customer. When it got to my doorstep it was COLD and looked OLD. I'm in my first trimester of pregnancy and I'm rarely able to eat unless I'm really craving something so this was really disappointing. Still searching for a reliable pizza spot because this definitely wasn't it. read more

I ordered a chicken roll the guy grabs it with his bare hands, no gloves, no spatula. NASTY!

Stopped here to grab some pies on the way to visiting family. Service was quick and the pizza was the best I've had in a while. Can't beat the price either. Will definitely come back when I'm in the area. read more

Great pizza for a great price, with great service! Definitely my go-to. Definitely recommend their buffalo chicken pizza - the sauce is perfect and the crust is the perfect balance of crunchy and soft. read more

Domenick's Pizza you are totally remarkable, I had an incredible experience here yesterday. Overall, I think this is a great, fun spot. Every single thing was fresh, healthy, and extremely yummy. Fantastic. Fantastic service and staff. Domenick's Pizza - You guys are really good! read more

Mamma Mia! This has got to be the best pizza in Queens! Great service, friendly staff and very clean! I'd definitely recommend their specialty pies! read more