Went there on Father's Day got there about 310. They had a Father's Day special and he wouldn't even give it to me.??!! very rude customer service he needs to learn how to respect his customers. I would never go there or recommend anybody go there. read more

Perfect neighborhood pizza joint. I came here for a late lunch and it was still surprisingly busy. I soon found out why. From the moment I stepped in you immediately get the mom and pop shop feel. They were polite and expedient while taking my order, and I went with the lunch deal which was a soda, slice of cheese pizza, and 6 hot wings for 10 bucks. The pizza was that perfect New York slice combo where it flops over when you hold it but the crust is golden brown and sings if you scraped the bottom of it. Sauce and cheese were also both on point. It's nice to see that they put so much effort into a lunch slice. The wings had a decent size and had a good crunch that gave me the indication they were probably deep fried. Buffalo hot was classic they didn't stray at all from the flavor we all know. Highly recommend. I can't think of many better neighborhood pizza shops on the westside. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

My wife and I have been here before & loved this place. This trip, we had to keep asking for each item that we had ordered. I received my meal almost 15 minutes before my wife. I had to go up & ask were her food was, " we're working on it". She ordered garlic knots, she had to go back up and ask for them 20 minutes after she got her meal, she also had to ask for her salad, the Ranch Dressing was as liquidated as milk. Not satisfied. read more

I go to Dons often. It used to be pretty good but lately the quality has gone down hill. I ordered two slices and they were raw. Mushy dough under the cheese and the bottom was floppy. Mozzarella seemed cheap. No stretch to it, it just kind of disintegrates in your mouth. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

After being told our delivery would take 45 minutes, we waited nearly 2 hours before even calling to inquire about our food. They still took almost 20 more minutes before the driver arrived with our old & cold food. $65 for pizza & wings is a joke as it is. We miss the old owners! read more

Great cell structure on the crust. The crunchy texture eats like a fresh Sourdough or French bread. Pizza had lots of toppings. We ate in. Cheese pull on those first few slices removed from the pan were noteworthy. While I enjoyed the amount of vegetables on the veggie pizza, I enjoyed the flavor of the buffalo chicken pizza more. Buffalo chicken pizza was more tangy than spicy. Even my child who doesn't like spicy foods ate a slice of the buffalo chicken pizza. People at Don's New York are welcoming and friendly. They checked on us a few times. Coloring books and crayons are available to help keep kids occupied. read more

See all

What happened to this place got a med pizza deal with 10 wings.added pepperoni and they barely even added any of the topping plus wings were supposed to be honey hot instead received buffalo hot. For 42 dollars I could have gone out and had a better pizza and wings and a cold drink too. Sad I use to really like it here read more

hi.. been eating dons for years at one time i raved about the chicken ceasar salad NOT ANYMORE barely any lettuce some romaine i dont even know what the other was spinach? 6 croutons barely any parm cheez but it was packed with chicken probably 10-12 ounces way to much no balance like in the days when dons was great i disposed of the dry chicken im very disappointed the owner is a real nice guy he tries hard to please his customers i think he needs a new general manager for quality control good luck god bless read more

Amazing pizza in the Peoria area. Their white pizza is PHENOMENAL, and I order it again and again. Also can't go wrong with their cannolis. Plus, it's always a pleasant conversation on the phone when ordering for delivery. Keep it up Don's! read more

I went later at night for pick up, the staff were quite friendly and the food was absolutely delicious. I've tried other pizza places and this has been my favorite so far. Compared to all the other places I've been, the prices were quite reasonable for portion and taste. I'm a fan! read more

Delicious and nutritious. Ok maybe not nutritious but it was great. Great service good fried wings and crispy Pizza. Been back a few times.

Thought I'd try a second time and same old crap. When my husband called to complain the cook got on the phone was rude and told my husband he was wrong because he made it. Well we don't complain for no reason. Since new ownership this place is just NOT the same. Will NOT try a 3rd time!! Sad. We really liked this place before. The new ownership has ruined a great thing!!!! read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Always loved it here NOW? Under new ownership and HORRIBLE. Everything is DIFFERENT!!!! Pathetic Caesar They forgot the Chicken again!! - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

It's taken me some time to write this because Don's has always been our go to pizza spot. Over the last 6-9 months Dons has gone downhill. The first time we got something not so great, we just brushed it off as an off evening because we've NEVER had problems. Two visits ago our pizza tasted off, sauce was different, and it was $20 for I think 12 zucchini sticks(can't remember the exact amount but I thought it was insane that deep fried zucchini would be that expensive). Yesterday will be the last time we order at Dons. We ordered at lunch time, asked for well done pizzas like we do every time for them to be mushy. They honestly tasted like they were from the day before. The sauce has changed. The dough seemed off. A cook was eating his food where they make the pizza, and to top it all off I pulled 4 slices of tiramisu from their dessert cooler to give to them because they were covered in mold. The person who was eating behind the counter looked annoyed at me and said they must've missed that last night. These pieces of tiramisu had been there moldy for a longer than just the evening. Please bring back the old owners. read more

Upon hearing me out, they have fixed the issue with DD. I'm back to ordering weekly. ;)

This place is horrible. my Ma order Pizza and wings for me and my family to come over on Sunday to have Sunday dinner the wings were disgusting mild wings sauce was watered down and the wings were pink when I showed these pink wings to there driver who was disgusting as well and suggested the pink color might undercooked chicken and when my ma called I heard a rude manger that refused to come to the phone and so my ma decided to take the awful wings and get her money back and the manger refused to give her money back and was so rude so they riped my ma off almost 100$ and had no remorse on top of this the owner decided to call my mother in a threatening manner at 9:30pm to change my review And then lied to Yelp saying that I wasn't a firsthand customer so I shouldn't be allowed to make these reviews I was the one who was supposed to be eating the food I was there so this was my experience be careful people where you eat this place needs to be shut down read more

As someone who grew up in Brooklyn, I'm always skeptical when I hear 'NY" or "NY style" pizza. However, this place hit the mark 100% and had great welcoming staff to boot. Would absolutely recommend. read more

Bomb wings = 4 stars! They were prepared perfectly: crispy, lots of Buffalo sauce, spice level on point. We got the 14" NY Supreme Pizza and it was loaded with toppings, but not overloaded! 8 big slices was more than enough for us two + left overs. Definitely will be back when I'm craving wings; maybe pair it with garlic knots or fried zucchini. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Ordered it twice while we visited my sisters place. Delicious both times! Nice customer service too!

Chicken Cesar salad was excellent and the Baked ziti was delicious at first glance you wouldn't know how good the food was I highly recommend Dons NY Pizza read more

I forgot to get photos, had fried zuchinni, pepperoni pizza large and a pepperoni and olive gluten free wow absolutely delicious!!!!! Got 24 CT. wings bone in and boneless. Wow read more

The pizza is tasty and I would definitely eat here again. The honey hot wings were also quite good. I thought it was a good price for the food. My one disappointment is I just put the pizza box in the fridge with a couple pieces left...yes it should have been in a plastic bag...but the next morning when I went to move it to the bag the bottom of the pizza had stuck to the paper/cardboard-like material that is sits on in the box. Like engrained into the bottom of the pizza...wasted three pieces. read more

Don't waste your time or money. The pizza tasted worse than a frozen pizza box uncooked. I should have seen the sign when there was no one there. Note I spread love where it's deserved. read more

This is the second time I have ordered delivery from this place and the food has been extremely late. I call over to the restaurant and all they say is I am sorry. I typically do not complain but this place is not worth the hassle. read more

Well, fourth time ordering from Don's and it will unfortunately be our last, even though my husband and I love the food. We love it so much in fact that we have already recommended many friends and family. Tonight, I thought I would use their online feature to order dinner for delivery. My husband and I ordered the two pizza special for $30.99. I wanted a cheese pizza with jalapeños and my husband wanted a pepperoni. The online order system says: 1st Pizza Toppings. I selected jalapeños. It adds $4 to the total. (Note, while this is pricey, we know that they change $4 for every topping and don't mind). It allows you to select as many topping as you want for the first pizza, but as said above, I just wanted jalapeños. So I moved to the next section, second pizza toppings: I selected pepperoni. While ordering I was concerned that it would add both topping to both pizzas, but when I selected both toppings for both pizzas it added $16 to the total. So I was confident we were only getting one topping per pizza as our total was $38 (it would be $47 with both toppings on both pizzas). Well, our order arrived an it had both toppings on both pizzas. I was so bummed because I don't eat meat. Please know that I am 26 years old and my least favorite thing to do in the world is complain about food. I NEVER send food back. But I mustered up the courage to call. The woman on the phone was nice as I told her about the issue, but when I concluded telling her what was wrong she said, oh I'm so sorry that happened....we'll have a good night. I think she realized the awkward pause on the phone because she then sheepishly asked if we wanted one of the pizzas to be remade. I apologized profusely (again, even thought it wasn't my fault) but asked if they could both be remade because we wouldn't be able to eat either one. She said she would have to check and came back on the phone and said, "the cook said he would remake them but he told me to tell you not to use the online ordering system ever again". I apologized and thanked her. I then got off the phone and cried from feeling so embarrassed. My husband and I gathered up some money to give the delivery driver a tip again. When the food arrived about an hour later (which is not problem) I met the delivery driver outside, thanked her, gave her the $7, and grabbed the pizzas. As I was walking away she told me they needed the old pizzas back. I told her okay, and went a grabbed the uneaten pizzas (Don's, they were uneaten because we COULDN'T eat them like we said). I handed her the uneaten and cold pizzas feeling completely embarrassed once again. Coming from someone who has ordered four times in a month, and left a 5 star review, let me say you lost a costumer. Thanks for remaking the pizzas you made wrong, but we won't ever be back. Also, fix your website. read more

Absolutely awful customer service. Slow and rude. So over priced for mediocre food. Do not order from here.

The pepperoni and cheese pizzas were excellent! The custom pizza was a little inconsistent with the toppings but would still come back again! read more

Just moved to this area and was looking for good pizza. Well I found it! Delicious pizza, lots of flavor, and filled with toppings. Check them out you'll love it! read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Mushrooms and NY special - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Knew this would happen with new owners! The pizza served to us today tasted like the sauce was watered down, the cheese was running off the pizza over the plate and the crust was as thin as cracker. When asked what happened they said it's because it just came out of the oven, the previous owners never served anything that looked like this! We love to support local small businesses but today will be our last visit to Don's. Such a bummer too because we loved this place, the new owners cared about their customers and quality they were presenting, don't think the new owners do. read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Since Don's was bought out the quality has gone way down! We've been eating here for years but today was our last day. - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Oh the crust, the crust, the heavenly crust! It's unusual pizza in that it's kind of plain, but somehow that doesn't detract from the deliciousness. The sauce is solid and the cheeses and topics are on point, but the crust is the real hero. Very fairly priced, too - and fast! This is a staple every time we visit Phoenix. read more

I've never revised a review so this is the first time. My first experience with Dons was incredible. Pretty close to NY pizza as far as our valley goes. Unfortunately upon my last three visits I was hoping that I'd have the same experience as the first, this was not the case. I wrote in my previous review that I may order "light cheese" next time but came to the realization that I shouldn't have to special order a pizza in order to get a solid pizza. Don's, to me is just another place that piles cheese on their pizza to appease the people that use Dominos as their go-to pizza spot. Unfortunately will not be coming back again read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Phenomenal crust - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

I'm so sad it's under new management or ownership. So not the same. One of the times I've called in for a delivery I barely could understand the person who answered the phone and I don't believe she could understand me either so that became very awkward. Another time and the last time, another female was just rude. The prices are higher which I can understand but the quality isn't there anymore and the customer service is lacking big time. Sadly, we won't be ordering from here any longer. I wish them luck but I no longer can patronize this place. read more

Been ordering from Don's for many years. Last few times service has declined significantly with food being cold upon delivery. We called after over 1 hour for delivery, they told us they don't see the pizza and driver is out so should be a few minutes. 15 minutes later, nothing. We called back and manager was horrible and said get off my phone. Horrible and they've declined big time. Don't recommend them. We're done with them. read more

First time trying Don's NY pizza tonight and it is absolutely amazing! Great service from the time you walk in the door til you walk out! Highly recommend! read more

Good pizza, we had a supreme. On food alone, I would have rated this place a 5. I would order out next time. The music was way too loud and was hard rock. That really detracted from the experience. The young woman who took our order was very pleasant. Just incredibly hard to hear over the music! read more

Must explain why this place is rated trash . The service is terrible and I can tell you for a fact ( THEY DO NOT WASH HANDS ) . I would never recommend or definitely eat at this place . NY DONS - you are a failure- need to work on staff training food health and definitely customer service . THIS COMPLETELY EXPLAINS WHY THEY DO NOT HAVE LUNCH TRAFFIC - I went at noon --- not one person in there --- THIS PLACE IS TRASH read more

Always on the lookout for different pizza places to try and today we found Don's. Located in an older shopping center in Peoria the parking lot is large and we easily found a spot to park. When you first walk in you are greeted with a counter where the menus are on the wall. Once you place your order you are given a number and they will bring your food to you. The inside is large and quite a few tables to sit with friends or family. We ordered the garlic knots, fried zucchini, 18 in pepperoni pizza, hot wings and baked ziti. We were also given a salad that comes with the ziti. You can buy individual fountain drinks or a 2 liter of soda. We did the 2 liter and they gave us some cups. Everything came out pretty quick. At first glance the zucchini looked burnt to me, but it was delicious, outside crunchy and zucchini not soggy. My garden salad was the least favorite part of the meal. While the lettuce was fresh and crisp the cucumbers were soggy and super dry. I lost total interest the second I ate one. The garlic knots were good, portion was a bit small though. There were five of us and only four knots. The pizza was HUGE. It looked and smelled so good. We were advised to give it a few minutes once it came to the table because it had just came out of the oven . It's definitely a NY style pizza, thin crust and soooo cheesy with plenty of pepperoni. I'd of preferred a more flavorful sauce, but still really good. The wings weren't over sauced and crispy. The baked ziti was shared by my daughter and her friend. It comes meatless which is good because her friend is allergic. They devoured most of it. They both really liked it. Service was great. I read some reviews with so many people saying otherwise. But they were so welcoming to us, smiled and checked on us throughout the meal. I'd come beck again for sure. They offer sandwiches, calzones and more as well. If you don't want to dine in they also do delivery and carry out. read more

See all

This place was pretty decent. Love that it's family owned. We got cheese pizza and 10 Buffalo wings special. Only problem wings were not crispy like we asked and got the pizza little cooler than I expected read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Don's is always my families go to when we don't know what to eat! The food is very good and I've never really had a bad experience! Usually people take the food to go but the dine-in experience is very good since there isn't usually lots of people inside! read more

We ordered Don's while staying in Glendale because of the good reviews. The person taking the order was surprised because there was another Don's closer to us. He was cool and explained that the other one was closer, but was owned by a different family. I said that's ok and ordered anyway. We had the meat lovers and wings. The pizza wasn't greasy at all. The crust was thin, yet held up like New York style pizza. Overall, the pizza was really good (as my wife is very picky when it comes to pizza). We also got the hot wings (the hottest sauce they had and regular Buffalo). The wings weren't small, wasn't over cooked and dry, and both sauces were tasty (the insane sauce could be hotter). Overall, this was the best pizza we had in Arizona so far. People say it's expensive, but it's reasonable compared to where we live. If you order cheap pizza, expect cheap ingredients and taste. For those that like good pizza, you won't be disappointed. read more

Got a 16 inch pepperoni and 20 wings for and a 2 litter soda $51 dollars. Wings were a pretty good size but the buffalo sauce was a little lite however the pizza was 10/10 will be back again read more