Nicely appointed dining room, a bit more upscale than the other Peddler's Village restaurants. Very attentive service from multiple staff, especially our main server Ashley. Lobster dumplings appetizer was very good, fresh tasting seafood with a pleasing soy ginger sauce. Mains, filet mignon and scallops were tasty and prepared correctly. Was there during peach festival so specialty peach cocktails were excellent. Reservations are recommended. read more

It was fair, but nothing totally special. Some things on the menu were really good and scales with the price of the dish. This was kind of odd, because usually the dishes all are made to the same quality in a restaurant. Our group had two salads, a burger, and I got the Chicken Kebab dish. Both salads were good, the peach special came with buratta which was great, the Caesar was fair and matched the price. Kebab was cheap and the greens didn't taste fresh or crisp like the salads. The tzatziki sauce wasn't very flavorful. The burger was also good because they actually served it rare as requested, normally restaurants will overcook them. I'll also mention the tables around us were served significantly faster than us despite arriving the same time or later than us. Took a little over 30 minutes for ours. read more

Earl's New American - Chicken Kebab - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

Wanted to correct my prior review and I cannot edit the prior review. Ambiance* not ambulance- silly autocorrect read more

Earl's New American - Lobster Mac and cheese - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

We made reservations. I recommend it. It gets pretty busy because of all the Christmas decorations in peddlers Village so close by. Fantastic service at the hostess stand from Kathy. Rachel , really took care of us. I loved her recommendation of the Seabass. It was really magnificent and so fresh and perfectly cooked. We also got the dumplings for an appetizer The decor was very relaxing, and I kind of felt like I was in a ski lodge. It was kind of chilly out and the restaurant was just cozy and very relaxing. We loved our food and would definitely come back! read more

See all

We arrived for lunch at around 12:40 (on Labor Day) and we were informed that they had already run out of Ribs, which my GF had been keen on having. The burger that she ordered instead arrived rare rather than medium as she had ordered. I don't think we will be going back read more

A terrific restaurant in the heart of peddlers Village near New Hope Pennsylvania. This place just was exactly what we were looking for after a day of shopping and having a few cocktails at Peddlars Village. The ambience is gorgeous, very well appointed you'll love eating in this place my scallop with mashed potatoes and green beans dinner was Heaven On Earth! Ate every bite and loved it We also got a steak over mashed potatoes again. You really can't go wrong here. The food is so delicious! I was surprised that a restaurant inside peddlers Village would be so good, I thought you'd have to go away a block outside of the village in order to find a good restaurant, but I was wrong. Highly recommend having dinner at this restaurant while visiting peddlers Village, you'll love it! read more

See all

Visited peddlers village with my husband over the holidays and decided to eat at Earl's. Our friends live nearby and recommended it and we were not disappointed. Definitely make reservations ahead of time as they do get super busy. We started off with the meatballs , lobster dumplings , burrata and tuna crisps . I really enjoyed all of it, it was delicious. I also got a butternut squash soup which was so good. For entree I ordered the shepherds pie and it was great and very filling. Everything was wonderful from start to finish. This is a great spot if you're ever in town. Definitely give them a try! read more

See all

This is my second time dining at Earl's New American. Both visits were terrific! When visiting Peddler's Village, I would recommend making a reservation in advance. Earl's is no exception. For a large party, we booked 2 weeks in advance. The restaurants book very quickly during the holidays. It's a beautiful atmosphere with a wide bar area and tons of available seating. With our group, we were seated in a private area, which was perfect! Our waitress was excellent- knowledgeable and accommodating. She provided us with great menu suggestions. Earl's had a seasonal lunch menu. I ordered the butternut squash soup and chicken salad sandwich. Other favorites included the Turkey club and crab cake sandwich. They were terrific! Our party loved the winter sangria as well. We did order desserts, too. We found them to be on the average side. Earl's is also surrounded by some shops and a beautiful gazebo photo op! Definitely a place worth checking out! read more

See all

I have nothing but positive things to say for Earl's! This was our first visit after moving to the area and our first time to Peddler's. We came on a busy Sunday evening during fall festivities and walked in without a reservation. We asked for outdoor seating which they accommodated right away. The outdoor seating was wonderful on a nice day. Service overall wasn't the fastest but we didn't mind. For drinks: I was pleasantly surprised that they easily made me a custom cocktail with seasonal ingredients upon request (apple cider - since I saw it on the menu for other options - and bourbon). For food: The fresh bread to start was warm and perfectly sized. To start we shared oysters and the seasonal gnocchi, which I wouldn't order again. For entrees we split the scallops and short rib - both were great! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Staff & service is always top notch. Setting is calm and welcoming, and the food is always done with intention. read more

Earl's New American - NY strip entree - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

Very classy pretty place. Fancier than a casual place. Right next to Peddler's Village. Definitely the best nicer place to eat. The short rib Mac and cheese was incredible. The pork sliders were decent. The house made potato chips were great. For the location and niceness, on par pricing. $15-$20'for an entree seemed standard. More for fancier options. read more

Earl's New American - Short rib Mac and cheese - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

See all

Our family held a baby shower at Earl's. Everything was perfect, from the initial planning, food, drinks, etc. They have a private room on the 2nd floor for events. The employees (Steve - Mgr & his staff) kept the food & drinks stocked & made things run very smoothly. The room was beautiful - they supply the tables, chairs, tablecloths & napkins, we supplied the decorations. The food was excellent - we had appetizers, a breakfast brunch buffet, soft drinks & they even worked with us on two different signature mocktails (which were both a big hit). I can't say enough good things about how wonderful the room looked & how wonderful the staff & food were. I would recommend this to anyone read more

See all

We ate here again last night and I thought I would update my review since the last one was t years ago. The wedge salad before dinner was great. It had plenty of dressing and was the classic iceberg wedge. The fried porchetta was a great surprise and replaced the traditional bacon. It tasted great. The ribeye was cooked perfectly rare exactly how I ordered. It was tasty and was exactly what one would expect for the price. The service was great. The server even fixed our table as it was a little wobbly when we arrived. For wine, I had 2 glasses of the Zinfandel which was deep bodied and tasted great. Peddler's Village is a fantastic place for a restaurant and you can always walk around after dinner. The bottom line is that this is a very nice upper end steakhouse located within Peddler's Village. I would recommend it for a nice night out with your significant other. read more

See all

Well it started good & ended badly. Apps to forever, but were very good. I had the clams casino & my wife had the lobster dumplings. Clams were good, dumplings were better. Then it got ugly. We both ordered the prime rib, which we ordered rare & medium rare. Both came out dry & tough as shoe leather. The accompanying baked potatoes were covered with fried onions & covered with a thick piece of cheese. The potatoes were barely cooked, still hard & revolting. The accompanying carrots, hard as a rock. We also had to chase down staff for drink refills & they weren't even busy. Those disgusting prime ribs dinners were $50.00 each, so not a cheap meal. Too bad, it's a pretty place, but the food was awful. Would not return or recommend read more

All of the above my family of six went from Mother's Day brunch yesterday service excellent food delicious a perfect perfect Mother's Day outing. Thank you so much. It was a wonderful wonderful day. read more

A great fine dining restaurant to go to while visiting Peddlers Village. We came on a Monday when it was quiet and peaceful to see the scarecrow after bike riding on the D &R trail. We sat outside where we were surrounded by beautiful flowers. The service was very quick. I ordered the short ribs and it was delicious! Only complaint was the carpets were not fully cooked. My husband had the shrimp with grits. It was kinda sweet but also very good. I definitely recommend going here snd I'm sure we will be back once in the area again. read more

See all

LAHASKA: Earl's New American is a restaurant within Peddler's Village and has a beautiful outdoor patio with dog friendly seating. The menu is contemporary and an eclectic mix for all. The chopped salad is fantastic and paired with a raspberry chill cocktail - a perfect meal. A bit classy, the patio is open everyday, weather permitting. Earl's is the only fine-dining restaurant that allows dogs on the patio in the village. Fuel up before all the fun in the area! read more

Earl's New American - a dog sitting under umbrellas - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

Had lunch at Earl's for the first time. we were there early and it wasn't busy yet but it still took longer than expected. we ordered the pork schnitzel sandwich and the shepherds pie. Our waitress said the delay was due to the shepherds pie needing to be baked which would have been ok if it was good but it wasn't. There was hardly any meat and not many vegetables (no peas at all). I would not recommend it. The schnitzel was good but not good enough to give it more than just an ok rating. read more

As someone who is fortunate enough to spend many summers in NJ, my standards for seafood are very high. I started with the crab soup and it was very creamy with lots of crab meat. The star of the day was the crab cake sandwich. Without a doubt, the best crab cake sandwich I've ever had. It was recommended by one of the servers and he wasn't wrong. It was all crab with a tangy sauce and some corn that perfectly complimented the crab. It was amazing. I'm still thinking about it days later. Typically we make a reservation because it can get packed during the holidays. read more

Earl's New American - Crab cake sandwich - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

See all

It's not a perfect place, but the ambiance and location are prime. I've been back 4 times since my first review. I've only been for lunch service which I can say is always really good. The calamari appetizer? Amazing! Crunchy and delicious, we all ate it up in minutes. The chicken thigh sliders are consistently delicious. The hand cut fries and chips are a highlight for me personally. December is a busy month so make sure you make reservations! I haven't tried any desserts yet, but that will be my mission next time. Ehrin (spelling?) is also one of the most professional servers I've ever seen and I appreciate his excellent service! read more

See all

We have been going to Earl's for years. Primarily to savor ( and I mean SAVOR) the she crab bisque. It is truly spectacular! Every spoonful is like culinary heaven! Today , my husband and I both had the bisque and the special Irish cheesesteak. Corned beef with sauerkraut and a cheese sauce. Fabulous!!!! The staff is awesome, friendly and spot on. Earls has a great atmosphere, is immaculate and family friendly. If you haven't been there.... Go! read more

Straight up garbage! Overpriced underdelivered. The cuisine is absolutely tired. Service is good, but nobody working there is more than sad.

We had a wonderful, comfortable meal at Earl's on the first night of our vacation. I normally don't think much of restaurants in malls, but this one was special. Very nicely done interior--just what we were looking for after a long day in the car. My husband had the 5-hour Braised Short Rib and loved it. I had the Pork Chop which was juicy and tender and came with mashed split peas (first time I've ever eaten them and they were really good). Chocolate cake for dessert. Great start to our vacation! read more

Adorable staff. This lovely mature lady who seated us was fun, jovial and complimenting. I'm going back just to meet the lady Our server Keira was so sweet. Food was good. Calamari with English mustard seemed a weird combo though Lobster bisque was coagulated. Crab cake was really good but aoili was super salty Burger was outstanding. So we're the fries But I'd still go back read more

Beautiful fall day...Indian summer as it was 80 degrees. Perfect day to dine outside at the height of busy season at Peddlers Village. The popular scarecrows all around. I kept forgetting about Earls and finally today my friend and I decided to have lunch there. Weekday...but still very crowded therefore we were surprised to be able to get an outdoor table at lunch. Once we were seated and ordered our drinks and food we realized just the reason only patrons with dogs were sitting outside at their beautiful patio. Bees! Yes, they were annoying as we swatted them away throughout our lunch. It was a bit uncomfortable but felt stuck at this point bc the inside was full. Now I understand the surprise look the host gave me when I requested outside seating. We should have been warned about the bees. The umbrellas did NOT do a good job of shielding the strong sun and that added to an additional annoyance. Sitting outside was definitely a poor choice. Our bad and hopefully learned from this mistake. The menu was not large but had nice choices. I started with their fall featured martini which was a "ruby tini." It sounded interesting but unfortunately it sounded way better than it was. Not a great pour and was a bit overpowered with grapefruit. I don't recommend. My chicken panini was good (not memorable) and homemade chips were quite good. I took half my sandwich home which was not great as a leftover. Just too dry. My friend started with the lobster dumpling which she enjoyed. She also ordered a humus plate. The very small amount of hummus was overpowered with oil and the pita bread was disappointing...needed to be softer, grilled or whatever...it just didn't work. Seemed like it came right out of the package and onto the plate. Overall, I was glad to try Earls but since we were not blown away we will move it to the bottom of our list. read more

I wanted to give 5 stars, but they were out of so much. I feel like i should have been warned before sitting down. The lobster dumplings, however delicious, only came with 4 dumplings (used to come with 5). The waitress was very nice and attentive; always made sure our beverages were full. Salmon entree.... amazing! Would order again. The new york strip steak was not good. It was SO TOUGH and mostly fat. My boyfriend had to send it back. He ordered the filet instead, which was AMAZZZZING. Glad he exchanged it.】 read more

See all

Don't bother trying. Uptight restaurant. They think they are a NYC 5 star and thier a PA 3 star. Don't bring kids for sure. I should have looked up the rating before I came, it is a 3 star place, they deserve the rating they have. Go anywhere else!! Plenty of good restaurants in New Hope. read more

Had a 3:30pm reservation for a party of seven. Although the restaurant was practically empty, five of us were not allowed to be seated until all seven arrived. That is the policy. So, the five of us could have been seated and ordered drinks and appetizers. Instead, we stood and waited. Foolish on the part of management - they lost sales. Once the seven of us were seated - we did not order drinks or appetizers. The meal was mediocre. One bright spot - our server was great! Take Earl's off my list for the future. read more

Incredible service and ambiance. Best pork chop I ever had! Also got the short ribs which were so good! Can't wait to go back! read more

Earl's New American - Earls Pork Chop - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

See all

Host and hostess are rude. Went in on Saturday with a few friends for lunch. They told us there was a wait of over 1 hour. Mind you there were a lot of empty tables on both levels of dining space. Food was mediocre at best. read more

Wow such excellent food! My mom and I saw this venue while we were driving and decided to give it a try. We order the Lobster Dumplings with sweet soy for the appetizer, and the Pan Seared Scallops and Pam Seared Salmon for our entrees. Wow all dishes were exquisite and the flavors so unique and original-like! The scallops were curried and had a hint of peanut butter. The salmon was over a bed of chickpeas with light tandoori spice and yogurt dressing with cucumber, golden raisins, honey, lemon, and mint. I also had a pear drink with rosemary that was okay. I felt it needed some more flavor to it as it was too subtle, but it didn't take away from the amazing meals. Our waiter was very cool and also took our picture for us a couple times to make sure it came out good. Looks like we found a go-to for eating out. Very nice fine dining establishment! read more

See all

food was great here. Waiter was awesome as well. Got the short rib sandwich. Was in the area to do Christmas shopping and stopped here quick , no wait but it did pack in around 1-2 as we were leaving. Highly recommend read more

Earl's New American - Short rib sandwich - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

l loved this restaurant! The most delicious lobster roll I ever had for lunch.... Our waiter was such a nice man who automatically gave us free refills on our soft drinks....The atmosphere was quiet and upscale.... We had bad service at Buttonwood and walked across the street to Earls and so glad we did.... We were a party of 4 adults..... We will return! read more

Stopped into Earl's after very cool aquascape class that was held upstairs. Sat at the bar for a late dinner and glass of Prosecco. We were able to order some food before the kitchen closed at 8. I was so pleasantly surprised. The food was amazing and fresh flavors abounded. Complimentary warm rosemary bread with a whipped sweet butter came out while we were waiting. Raw oysters in the half shell, lobster ravioli and the she-crab soup were amazing starters. The soup was fantastic actually and maybe my favorite. Enjoyed the fried tomato and burrata and swordfish specials for an entree. The swordfish was fresh and served with a fantastic cucumber peach salsa. So happy we decided to stop for dinner. The service was very friendly too! read more

I'm shocked how many positive reviews this place has. I've eaten here multiple times over the last year and my biggest complaint is the lack of consistency. The drinks are rarely good. I've ordered martinis and mixed drinks, and they struggle to produce a decent drink. The food is also mediocre at best. I've had a few good meals but also bad oysters, poorly cooked steak, gross sauces and incredibly slow service. I'm sure if you're visiting it'll be ok but for a regular this place needs some upgrades. read more

We were visiting peddlers village for the day and planned to have lunch here on Sunday afternoon. We were seated immediately at a window table which l always love because we can people watch. We started with shrimp cocktail which was served on ice, that's exactly how I like my shrimp served! The she crab soup, and lobster dumplings. We shared everything, the dumplings were the best we ever had. They were cooked perfectly and the sauce was perfect. We also shared the crab cake sandwich, which we always get with no bun. I loved the color on the crab and it came with delicious corn salad and house made chips. I could tell everything was made in house, the food and service is great here! read more

See all

This is a five star restaurant in peddlers village. Who would have thought. Great flavor and top quality. I never had a better bisque soup than the one I make myself, until tonight. The shrimp and grits, scallops and polenta were perfect. Service was good and they gave us a nice quiet table. read more

Kale salad with grilled chicken, Brussels sprouts, apple, za'atar dressing, lunch special, really good salad; great service, pretty place read more

Earl's New American - Kale salad with grilled chicken, Brussels sprouts, apple, za'atar dressing, really good, great service, nice place - Seafood Near Me - New Hope, Pennsylvania

We've been going to Earl's for years, especially on Easter Sunday. Great service and enjoy the food. Nice non-alcoholic refreshing drinks too. Just wish they'd bring back the traditional Caesar salad with parmesan crisp. It was so good with steak on it! Not so good with 3 cut strips of supposed "charred" lettuce and a drizzled dressing. Please bring original back! read more

Everything was excellent from the service to the food. We were looking for place to stop and have lunch in Peddler's Village with our pup, and read online that Earl's had an outdoor patio where they allowed dogs. The staff was incredibly accommodating and even treated our girl to a little piece of bacon. :) The burger and sandwich were delicious. Looking forward to returning. Thank you, Clint! read more