i order a pie in person.after it was made they forgot i was sitting there so my pie sat on the top of the oven for 10 minutes. i took it home and it was luke warm. had to heat it in my oven. i won't make that mistake again. read more

BEST PIZZA IN ORANGE COUNTY HANDS DOWN! I've been going to this place back when it was Sal's Pizza, which has been like 6 years. This place has been cemented in my childhood for having amazing pizza and huge slices for cheap prices. Their best pizza hands down though, their crazy chicken pizza. Comes with chicken, bacon, ranch, bbq sauce, and their secret crazy sauce. I can't tell you how many times I have gotten this slice that is bigger than my plate and just grinned ear to ear. Their Stromboli's are good too, massive as everything else sold here! If you're looking for a good burger this isn't really the place for it but how can you expect that from a pizza place! Their menu is very extensive for a pizza place and they also cater. I will always love Tosco's pizza forever and ever. If you're a guy however, do not even try to apply for counter help... I've applied once and asked again later, just to see a new counter girl the next time I go there... read more

See all

Staff is not friendly and the food got me sick! Had a cream of broccoli soup that absolutely messed up my stomach and everything else i order did not taste fresh will not be returning. read more

The food is really hit or miss. I have had a good meatball parm but often the slices of pizza taste like they have been sitting out for way too long. Most of the food I have had was very meh. I really kept going back because it was next to a laundromat I used. The main issue I had was the customer service (or major lack thereof) and the amount of people who smoke right outside the door. In the warmer months, they keep the front door propped open so that smoke wafts right on in. Who wants to smell a ton of smoke while eating? I get that you can't control what other people do, but maybe ask people to walk a few feet away. It doesn't help when the employees join in the smoking The interior could use an update. Maybe they have done so since I was last there. The pizza I had the last time was so greasy you could have fried french fries in it. Gross. One of the delivery drivers smokes like a chimney. I'm sure that's fine for some people but my partner is allergic to smoke. I feel like Tosca's in Pine Bush is owned by the same people but the quality is significantly better. Not sure why this location is so blah. read more

Sal's Pizza has been around for 30+ years. I used to go here frequently growing up as a child in the 1980s and 1990s, but we stopped going because the wait times were terrible (especially for delivery), and because Sal had an attitude and temper. Over the years, I had stopped in occasionally to get a few slices and the restaurant was dumpy and outdated. Until now, I haven't been there in several years. I tried Sal's again at lunchtime while running errands on Christmas Eve. I called ahead to order a meatball parm hero and was told it'd be 15-20 minutes. That's a long time to warm up a sub. Are they making the meatballs from scratch, I wondered? When I arrived exactly 15 minutes later, the food was ready and packaged, waiting for me. The interior of the restaurant has been completely renovated since I was there last and it looks great. A few families were sitting down eating their meals. The 2 employees who were working were friendly and were on point. The meatball parm was one of the best I've ever had, complete with grated cheese sprinkled over top of the parmesan. Even the appearance was neat and looked like it was out of an ad. read more

Today, i ordered a penne ala vodka pizza pie. That. Was. THE. best. Pizza. EVERRRRR! I have eaten at many pizza spots in Orange County, but Tosco's New Windsor is Number one. A couple weeks ago, i ordered a pasta dish (chicken francese) along with wings. Also top notch read more

Staff was very friendly, was at Post Office in same shopping plaza on hot day. Sign in window caught my attention Sub Combo for.less than $6. Sub was ok, my preference is a different type of italian bread, like at Jersey Mikes or Jimmy Johns. Will try pizza next time read more

Food is ok. Staff is rude and consistently mess up your order. This was my last delivery. Manager was supposed to call me back and never did. They've lost my business. read more

Sal's - a pizza with cheese and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New Windsor, New York

See all

It's called Tosco's now. Horrible attitude by the staff. Especially the girl answering the phone who was the person I got twice and the first time I went, she was just completely uninterested in anyone's presence. Food is okay at best. Was much more pleasant when Sal was the owner. Get it together. read more

Ordered a large pizza from these guys and when I get it home, I open it and it is two halves from separate pizzas. You're reading this right - 4 slices from a pizza made at one time, and 4 slices from a pizza made at another time. Someone call Dave Portnoy - this just ain't right! read more

Best pizza we've had since moving up from the city. Sal greets us in Italian so I get a chance to practice whenever we stop in. Pizza is good and specialty pies are even better. Try the chicken bacon ranch pie it's awesome. The shrimp fra diablo pizza is also very good. Decent sides as well. Have had fries and wings all very good. Delivery always hot and on time. read more

I was not impressed with this pizzeria at all. I came on a weekend around seven and was not very welcomed. When I first walked in, it smelled of fish from next door. The woman at the front counter barely looked at me and when I asked what a specific slice was, she said it looked like chicken and parsley.... Try a smile.... I will not be returning to this establishment anytime soon. read more

Another crappy tasting pizza joint. No wonder they print coupons in the local paper. No one wants it unless its almost free. With regard to the previous poster, the proprietor thanks you in person because there is never anyone in there. Only the locals who have never tasted real NYC pizza like the cardboard served here. read more

You know the pizza is good when the proprietor cooks, serves, and thanks you in person, before heading back in the kitchen to make more pizza. read more

Place has gone down hill so quickly unfriendly staff crap pizza less toppings I will not be continuing to buy any food here

So this is my second time going to sals for pasta, both times were a disappointment....and expensive for low quality and flavorless pasta. Wouldn't recommend pasta from this dump. read more

Stopped in for lunch on July 4th. Place is now called Sal's Original Tosco's Pizza. Had the Stromboli and my wife had a calzone. Food was very good and the staff were very friendly. read more

Renovations make the place feel more homey. Fried Oreos are to die for. Lunch menu has a great variety. Staff is always friendly and attentive. read more

Best pizza and even better service! I always leave satisfied and with a smile on my face! You just don't find that kind of full service place anymore without paying for it - but at Sal's they give you great food and great service because they love what they do and enjoy pleasing their customers. That's the kind of local business I want to support! read more

I love this place!! The best Pizza in town and generous slices too.

My husband and I love Sal's (Tosco's). We get their chicken bacon ranch pizza there a lot as well as the rolls (steak&cheese and buffalo chicken). Their garlic knots are good but not exactly the style we prefer but definitely still tasty. They make a lot of different specialty pizzas, the pesto chicken is really good. We also like the penne pizza... so tasty. We've had mac and cheese pizza... delicious. Overall rarely do we have a bad meal. The only thing we aren't crazy about is their subs so we get the rolls instead which is kind of like a calzone. read more

Food is very good I order takeout and have it delivered to my house. I especially like their Stromboli and their Sicilian pizza it's very good and very yummy & prices are very reasonable and restaurant is not that faraway from where I live. Once in awhile I order their pizza pies which are very good same with their hot heroes like chicken Parmesan and egg plant Parmesan subs one of my favorite hot subs! Overall I am a happy customer!! read more

I use to really like this place. But the past few times I've ordered the wings have been raw! I mean still bloody. I brought them back and he made a new one, but the wings were still bloody!!! Ordered a Stromboli as well the dough was still raw! At least 35 percent of the dough was raw. Every time I ordered a grilled chicken Caesar salad, the chicken was dry and burnt. He's made me sick a couple of times. His flavored aren't bad, but the execution and food safety, not so much. read more

Sal and family have been doing things right for a long time. Thanks.

Oh yes, yes, yes! I love this place. I can order anything on the menu here and I know it will taste good! Also Sal and his wife are very nice, friendly, hard working people! I love them! read more

Great slice and always great price. Seems to always be open too. Me of the best light pizza crusts. Staff is always nice and u get your food fast. I wouldn't go as a sit down place but for a quick slice it's great. read more

The pizza at Sal's is great. So tasty and so flavorful. Sal's also has great sub's, meatball especially, great antipasto salad and the eggplant subs are awesome. read more

This used to be a good pizza place. This last year it has been awful!! Thankfully we found a really good replacement and will never ever order from Sal's again! From under-cooked pizza, having deliveries where they forget things and have to come back, but take 40 minutes, to ordering and going in to pick up 30 minutes later and your wings are ready, but they forgot to make your pizza, so I wait longer for the pizza to be done and they finally hand it to me and say here you go have a great night and walk away. Then I'm yelling to the girl, what about my wings?? Which were then cold, and that's just a few examples of how bad it has gotten. The last straw however was when I was charged $140.46 for a large pizza and 2 garlic knots. When I called, and I was annoyed, no one apologized, nor really cared, they refunded me the money less the large pizza and knots and sent me on my way. Bad pizza, bad service, see ya never again! read more