Our office went out to lunch today and had an amazing experience with Brandon. He was attentive, asked all the right questions, kept our drinks refilled, and checked in with us multiple times. I would go back just to have Brandon as our server again. Looking forward to our next visit! read more

I have always liked this place. Haven't been here in a while. Stopped in after a softball game to watch football and UConn basketball. First disappointment. No basketball on any tv. Not totally unexpected. I watched it on my phone while watching the Dolphins/Raiders game and waiting 15 minutes for someone to ask if I wanted anything. This was probably because there were just 2 bartenders for 50 people sitting around a bar. Anyway, finally ordered and got an Impossible burger. Very happy they have many items for vegetarians and pescatarians like me. However, had the bartender brought over the Sunday specials menu, I likely would've ordered something from there, as well. I was asked if I wanted regular fries with my burger. I said yes. Foolish me thought they came with the $17 burger. I had a diet soda with lime. Small glass. Finished it quickly. No one asked or gave me a refill. I did finally ask for a refill. They took my glass and brought a new one. Not sure if that's new sanitary rules or because they don't give free refills. I still don't actually know because it wasn't on my check. My neighbor's 4 beers were on there though! I was planning to pay for his beers, but the bartender never asked. He never asked how my food was either. The food was good. The burger properly prepared (but too light on the ranch and absent bbq sauce) and the fries perfectly fried and seasoned. read more

Eli's on Whitney - Impossible burger and fries (the fries were not included in price of burger). - American Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

Can't complain about service, or the servers, and the renovations look great, so I give a star for each one of those categories! That being said, my menu options for ordering have been limited as I am gluten-free, and in particular the menu for appetizers is lacking in gluten-free options. Many places offer at least one gluten-free appetizer, but Eli's does not, and it's a simple menu option to offer...i.e. Corn tortillas for example could be offered as a substitute for Eli's in-house made flour tortillas for a couple of their appetizers, so that those who are gluten sensitive/allergic could at less enjoy more than just a burger or a salad. read more

Signature salad was very tasty. However, when the bill came we were charged an extra $.50 for extra vinaigrette dressing. We were given a very small cup with the added dressing. We were never told of the upcharge and the manager said that is 'always' what is done. We felt it was a gotcha charge. read more

Who decided to renovate this place? Went there this weekend. They've removed the entire hometown bar feeling, the old stained wood, and literally made it look like a sterile refrigerator. I'm not kidding, all my friends called it "sterile looking". The new bar material, the new TV layout, the new ceiling color etc...WHY would you change it?! read more

We had a great experience for our monthly chapter meeting for one of the civic organizations. Everyone was very pleased with everything. The setting was perfect. The staff was great and efficient. The food was delicious. We will be back. Thank you for all your help! Tanya read more

I coordinated a dinner for 50 in Eli's downstairs room. There is ample space for this number o people. The buffet dinner was very reasonably priced and everyone I spoke to told me how much they enjoyed the food. The staff was incredibly helpful as well. They served us effectively & happily. We will be back next year! read more

Had a company retirement event last week which went very well thanks to the staff at Eli's. Robin helped me plan it and she was amazing to work with, then the evening of our server was very attentive and friendly, and the cook staff did an amazing job cooking and then serving the food hot and tasty....Thanks to everyone who played a part in making our Eli's event a huge successes...will absolutely book a future event....Chris read more

I decided to have a surprise party at Eli's on Whitney for my brother. This is the second time I hosted and event downstairs. It was terrific!! The hall is spacious, well lighted, food is really good and the service was wonderful. Robin, Davante, Nicole and Justin were a pleasure to coordinate with. I definitely recommend and would host another party at Eli's on Whitney. read more

I met my friend at Eli's for an early dinner tonight. I was very happy to see the happy hour menu on the table when I walked in. We both ordered from this menu and it was a nice healthy delicious meal. We both had Brussel sprouts with carrots and potatoes and Asiago cheese with balsamic glaze on top. I'm very happy to have gone to Eli's. It is a very nice choice for American cuisine. My friend and I stayed and chatted and had a great time. I will definitely come again and try something else on the menu. read more

See all

Staff was amazing! Food was great. We had two separate parties , one day apart and booking was simple . Hat's off to Eli's !

Oh, there are other Eli's restaurants around the area. This is the original and still the best always has good games on the television friendly people work in the place good food, relaxing atmosphere a nice place to watch the game at night or on a weekend or grab a drink after work read more

We came to Eli's to celebrate my Aunt's birthday. The restaurant was a little busy but we had a reservation and our table was ready when we arrived. The staff were fantastic dealing with our party of 11. Everyone enjoyed their food! The portions were such that I think we all needed a to-go container! Great job!! read more

See all

Had a 40 person gathering last week , Food was very good and plentiful, service was friendly and attentive and room was big and comfortable ...it was very challenging for a few older people to get downstairs with no elevator or ramp... also had a smaller group (12) upstairs the night before and all was very good.... read more

The food was pretty good. The coleslaw was way too vinegary. The fries that come with old bay seasoning would've been great but had far too much on them. The Quesadilla was delicious, lots of chicken and guacamole, pickled onion on top, very good. Everything else was ok. The service was excellent! Our server was Yari and she was friendly, efficient and and an all around pleasure! They are lucky to employ her and we were lucky to have her serve us? read more

Best carrot cake I've ever had. It was the size of my head, moist and perfectly sweet. 10/10 recommend this dessert. Don't sleep on the carrot cake!! read more

I had a funeral repass and everything went well. They were able to get us in the next weekend. Everyone enjoyed the food. I recommend the pasta a la vodka, chicken marsala and grilled salmon. That was a hit! Linen is included with the buffett packages which helped. I just wish they let us take the left over food, which I paid for but they said based on the health and safety rules we couldn't. read more

I love having all of my events celebrated in their private room downstairs. Always accommodating and a pleasure to work with!

We had a bereavement reception for a family member at Eli's on Whitney and they were the perfect host. The room was great, the food was delicious, and the service was attentive and prompt. I was able to play music and display photos on the room monitor to really personalize the event. We all had a wonderful time. read more

Food was spot on. Wish I could give it a higher rating but the service was just lacking. Our server was not attentive to our party of 6, and we had to ask for things like water and forks/knives. Admittedly, I haven't been here for quite a while so I can't say if this is a consistent problem, but definitely left me with a bad taste as I used to frequent here quite often. Was disappointed that they no longer had the desert chimichanga. Food was a solid 4, but the service knocked it down a peg. read more

See all

We recently celebrated my son's baptism at Eli's and it was amazing. Everyone loved their food and the service was fantastic. everyone at Eli's was so helpful starting with Robin who helped us with the planning of the event. Kelly was very attentive as well as the server and the managers. Kelly did an excellent work setting up the room and took the initiative to place the balloons we brought in. We were a group of about 23 people and had the room behind the bar. The room is perfect for a small celebration. We all left very satisfied and will definitely consider Eli's for a future event. read more

Food is always very good, service at the bar is sometimes a little slow. Pretty good drink selection too.

Throughout the entire process you made sure that we felt taken care of and made everything easy. I can not even begin to tell you how wonderful the event was! Let's be clear, I am not easy to impress and have high (understatement) expectations. Your team hit every mark! Everything went off without a hitch and there were so many FANTASTIC comments about the food, the attentive staff, the room, the drinks and on and on! Thank you for all of the hard work that went into making the double graduation party a roaring success! You made us look great!!! read more

This is always a great place for dinner. It isn't upscale but service is very friendly and efficient. Food over the last couple months has improved a great deal. They now have lobster rolls and the latest addition is the excellent crab cakes to rival almost anywhere. It's a totally comfortable, casual environment so I have to give the ambiance 5 stars for what they offer. Sometimes they blast annoying bang bang bang music but not enough or often enough to take them down to 4 stars. Give Eli's a try! read more

Eli's on Whitney - The parlor room. - American Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

From the planning to the actual event. Everything went smoothly. We presently live in Long Island but since my wife spent must of her life in New Haven, her surprise birthday party should be held there. Without ever going to Eli, I went based on my step-daughter pass experience there and Robin's handling of my event made me feel confident it will go well. It went exceptionally well and will not hesitate holding another event there. Anthony and Nicole were excellent. Thank you Eli on Whitney. The Rivera family of Long Island. read more

My experience was great, the food was delicious & the service was on point.. Celebrated my mom's 65th bday she she enjoyed herself. I would definitely book again & recommend my friends read more

I enjoyed my time at this hangout spot. Eli's on Whitney is a very popular local bar in Connecticut as it is located in the heart of New Haven. The bar displays a beautiful wood finish. Finding a place to sit is not difficult as there is ample seating. Bartenders are friendly, welcoming and efficient at serving drinks within a prompt manner. I ordered a vodka cranberry and my boyfriend ordered a high noon. My drink tasted delightfully sweet. read more

Eli's on Whitney - American Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

On Nov. 2 Eli's on Whitney hosted an annual resident retreat for the Waterbury (Yale) Internal Medicine Residency Program. Kelly was a pleasure to collaborate with during the planning, she created a breakfast and lunch menu that was perfect for our needs. On the day of the event our hostess Nicole anticipated all our needs. She was always conveniently nearby, attentive to all details of the day. The food itself was spectacular, continental breakfast with FRESH fruit. Lunch was an arrangement of wraps and sandwiches for all appetites coupled with a fantastic cranberry and walnut salad. Looking forward to planning future event with Eli's on Whitney. read more

what was once a wonderful place to eat and drink with friends has now turned into a place we will not be visiting again. The bar staff use to be so friendly but the small blonde that was working Saturday night was one of the most unpleasant and rude people we have ever met. Apparently she had a migraine which is fine BUT your in the hospitality business, you don't need to be overly friendly but she was not even tolerable. read more

It's always a pleasure to work with Eli's catering. The food is good and reasonably priced, they are reliable, and Kelly is always willing to work with us in terms of the menu and budget. A great caterer! read more

We used to love this place so it pains me to leave this review, but it really has gone downhill in recent months. We got the "ultimate" nachos which came out cold, relatively few chips, and very little cheese sauce. Needless to say, we sent them back. Bartender was great--very attentive and sympathetic. If you go, skip the nachos $17 nachos! read more

Eli's on Whitney - "Ultimate" nachos - American Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

the best Point Judith Calamari you'll have in town. the Eli's Original Steak Egg Rolls are so juicy and fresh. everyone is very friendly and the vibes are great! cheap drinks too!! read more

See all

This is the second year that I've organized a dinner for 50 people in Eli's downstairs room. There is plenty of space for this size group. We had a buffet dinner and everyone told me how great the food was. The chocolate mousse dessert was also a big winner! The staff were especially accommodating and helped us with our specific needs. We will be back next year! read more

I held my sons 4th birthday party at Eli's. The planning with Robin made everything so easy. It eliminated so much stress. They were able to accommodate all my needs without any question. The food was great. The room needs updates but they are actually working on that now and then future photos look amazing. I will most likely be having his birthday here next year as well! Highly recommend! read more

Food: Philly cheesesteak eggrolls would have been super delicious if they had not been so greasy. The sauce on top was a good touch. The cauliflower risotto was the worst I've ever had. The sauce was unappetizing and the chicken was charred and dry. My friend got the penne pasta and the ratio of sauce to pasta was poor. You really only taste the noodle. Service: quick in and out. Constant water to our tables and the check came quick. Ambiance: bar seating is great for watching games. A little cramped at the tables. read more

Eli's on Whitney - Philly Steak Egg Rolls - American Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

Celebrated my daughter's Sweet Sixteen here and had a great time! The whole process went smoothly from booking, menu selection to the actual event night. The food was delicious and the staff were very attentive. I would highly recommend having an event at Eli's! read more

We booked the venue for my sons 18th birthday the food which was served buffet style was delicious. The service team, host and servers were very professional and made sure our party was well catered to. The overall ambience and exclusiveness of the private banquet room was ideal for our large party. We had a wonderful experience and plan to book Eli's in the future for events. read more

Might be my new fav spot! I ordered the Chicken florentine and that came with mashed potatoes and spinach. The flavors were just perfect. Service was amazing. Jess made us feel right at home. The vibes were great! We sat by the well lit bar, every single person in there had a smile, somehow cozy for a huge restaurant. We spoke with the manager Caryl who ran around the business like he had a cape on his back and he made sure every single customer was satisfied. Very accommodating. Will be back very soon! read more

Eli's on Whitney - Sweet chili Sweet Chili Glazed Salmon - American Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

We asked for a Vodka parm on garlic bread, all ingredients in house, denied twice, go somewhere when the client gets what they want. We had an outing planned for there never again!!! read more

Definitely a great spot everything was delicious. I love pasta and the drink was also very good I have no complaints read more

Eli's on Whitney - Cajun pasta - American Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all