Nice restaurant offering a great menu selection. Outstanding service and food. Tenderloin Tips and…read morepork chops were excellent

terrible service twords me and my boyfriend very rude an rushing well he was thinking of what to getread more

First , hot delicious buns with whipped butter. Coconut shrimp and sushi for an appetizer…read more.. amazing. The sushi was superior quality. Large salad with tomatoes ,cukes, greens with homemade dressing. Entrees were superb ... crab stuffed juicy breaded chicken. and lovely seafood medley. We shared the hot butter cake with vanilla ice cream. Calories well spent!! Nirvanna!. All the desserts are hand made. I do not think you can go wrong ordering anything from the menu. Additionally, our waitress was accurate and attentive. We will be back!

Great service, cute spot, good food. Walleye was great. Interesting mix of traditional Lake food…read moreand sushi. Heard the sushi was fantastic. Seafood stuffed Chicken was ok. Decent wine list.

We tried your restaurant for the first time and found it to be a great dining experience. The view…read moreof the Bay added to the atmosphere and the food was excellent. We felt welcomed and were delighted with the wonderful service provided by Riley, our server. In addition, we found the table you had reserved honoring our lost veterans was a great way to honor our fallen heros who fought for our country.

The service was so friendly and Bloody Mary was best way to start the visit. It was a meal into…read moreitself. There on a Friday for fish fry so on point.

My wife and l came here for our 42nd anniversary and had a wonderful evening. My wife asked about…read moreone of the specials and our server Tanisha highly recommended it. My wife loved her meal and said it was one of the best she's ever had! I chose the Bison meatloaf from reading a review and was not disappointed, it was excellent. We enjoyed a glass of merlot to celebrate with our dinner. The atmosphere was inviting and the view was beautiful and relaxing. There is no other restaurant in the area that offers anything even close to what you experience here. The food was excellent the view and atmosphere was wonderful and our service was exceptional! We live on the Bluff and decided that we're going to be regular customers at the area's best restaurant. Great job Freshwater Tavern! Thank you so much.

Phenomenal Location Great Bar…read moreOutside Patio to watch the bay Great food. Group enjoyed the specials and the fish and chips

Outstanding meal. Ordered the octopus appetizer and the family platter for three people. Octopus…read morewas so tender and tasty in veggies. The mixed family platter was outstanding (lamb and chicken kabobs + Kafka). Rice was tasty and fried well above an average. My new favorite spot.

The service was great. They were friendly and answered all our questions. Food was really good.read more

This place in Fish Creek, Door County is not to be missed! The owners are very friendly and…read morewelcoming. We were given a history of the fish boil and a demonstration before we ate the delicious food. I had shrimp and my husband had fish...both were fantastic. And definitely take a bottle of their unique homemade cajun cream sauce home with you! All with view of the bay. Definitely one of the top dining experiences of our lives...and we have traveled the world.

Pros: very clean and all the staff was very kind and attentive when we asked for things…read more Otherwise I really don't have anything else positive to say. I would definitely not go here with children. We made our reservation for 5:30, arrived at 5:15 per the restaurant and didn't actually eat until well after 6:00. We also ordered the option for the white fish boil (the kids meal and the adult option (as I was planning to share with my 9 month old) - both the kids meal and my meal were still Cajun. I'm guessing the actual Cajun option would have been spicier, but I could not share with my 9 month old and my 6 year old also struggled to eat her meal due to the spice level. I even confirmed on the phone prior to arriving due to some of the reviews I have seen about similar issues. The alcohol options were limited and overall for the price this meal was not worth it. I truly wanted to love and share a cool experience with my family and went away extremely disappointed

We love this place! It's great to sit outside and watch the boats while eating delicious food…read more Tried the whitefish chowder and the wedge salad this time and both were super. Key lime pie for dessert... Our server was great...Sydney I think. She was very professional and friendly. And patient, especially as other tables were requesting separate checks. Nothing phased her!

Great, friendly service! Briana spoiled us! Seated on patio…read moreand was a picture perfect day! We enjoyed the perch basket. Nicely breaded and very tasty! A nice portion. Enjoy!

We came for the fish boil and returned for breakfast!…read more You can't visit Door County without experiencing a unique and traditional Fish Boil! We loved hearing the history behind the fish boil and watching it come to life at the Old Post Office Restaurant! The dinner and experience was very reasonably priced at $30 per person and they offer options of fried chicken or ribs for those that don't care for fish. I'm (personally) not a big fish lover but I had to at least try it and it wasn't too bad! Dinner is also served with 3 different types of bread and a slice of delicious cherry pie! (Cherries are grown all over the peninsula). We sat outside on the front porch and watched the sun slowly set and the sky fill up with brilliant colors as we finished our dinner. I left with both my belly and heart as full as possible! We enjoyed the restaurant so much that I wanted to stop by on our way out of town, the last day, and try out their breakfast menu. I splurged and ordered the fresh cherry pancakes with a side of one egg and bacon. I planned to just eat half of my pancakes but I almost devoured them completely! My mouth is watering - several days later - as I am thinking about them and writing this review. I highly recommend the Old Post Office if you are in the area. Unfortunately you have to call the restaurant to make reservations but it's definitely worth the little bit of extra effort.

Sitting on the patio for a breakfast was a must to wrap up our Fourth of July weekend. The vibe of…read morewatching the boats cruise through the harbor, watching folks on their morning stroll and enjoying an excellent cup of coffee was unbeatable! Service was incredibly friendly and attentive. And the food was spectacular. Pancakes paired with the omelette was super tasty and everything we needed for a great breakfast!

The food was amazing, had the ribeye. Our server ben was the best thing you could ever want from a…read moreserver. Patient, funny, respectful, friendly. No notes. Outdoor seating was lovely!

I have rarely had a more pleasant evening out. We had delicious drinks. The food was delicious. I…read morehad the whitefish and it was perfectly prepared. My wife enjoyed her shrimp and grits as well. For dessert: carrot cake and, rather than the gooey, too sweet icing, this was light and creamy. But, really, I have to say the service was amazing. Our server, Joseph, could not have taken better care of us. He paid attention to every detail. We will absolutely be back. Thank you!

We have been here several times and always have a great time. The beer is exceptional and the…read moreflights are fun to figure out what you like. The last time we went at 2pm on a Thursday during a heat wave in the summer. It was not busy. we had been out running errands and stopped in for a quick beer and appetizer. Wait staff is always so nice and it was exactly what we needed. They have something for everyone and the food always is fresh and doesn't seem frozen or processed. Definitely one of our go to spots on the west side

Attended a corporate function in the private party room (towards back of restaurant). Hinterland is…read morethe type of place where you can be super casual but also enjoy a more elevated dining experience. The main dining room can get very loud on busy nights so I appreciated the more closed off space for a large dinner event. The caveat being we received spotty service - for example, water pitchers were set in the corner and you had to get up to pour your own water. At minimum, it would've been better to just leave pitchers on the table directly for faster access. Food was hit or miss. While we loved the appetizers, half of our table found their main entrees to be MEH. For example, my halibut arrived warm but the curry was room temperature. My colleague said her burger was one of the worst she's had. My other colleague said his steak was mediocre. People who ordered pizza loved it. An unfortunate mixed bag given the lively environment and nice ambiance. I'd come back again to give it another try because the menu rotates enough where I'm sure I'll land on some better food options next time.