We visited this location tonight after driving from Prairieville specifically to try the different…read moremenu compared to the standard Rotolo's Pizzeria. Unfortunately, our experience was very mixed. I ordered the Shrimp Caesar Wrap, which was excellent -- fresh, flavorful, and exactly what I hoped for. I did need to substitute a salad for fries because the oil was being filtered around 8:00 p.m., but the salad was perfectly fine. The service, however, was disappointing. We were the only customers in the restaurant at the time, yet we were not provided silverware and had to request it, along with every drink refill. My husband ordered the cracker crust pizza, which unfortunately arrived very overcooked. The bottom of the crust was burnt, the pizza had little flavor, and the cup pepperoni was extremely crisp -- almost hard. He was unable to enjoy it. Because we made a special trip from Prairieville to this location, this was especially frustrating

I don't like writing bad reviews. The service was not very good. We did not see our server for long…read moreperiods. On two occasions we walked to the bar and ordered water for the table and a second time we ordered wine. We ordered the thin crust classic. It would have been good if it would have been warm. It was cold. I don't want to pile on but the place was dirty. There was no one in the place but the staff was not interested in the three tables that were seated. I hate this review but it is what it is.

I want to start off by saying once we found this place we kept going every two weeks. Pizza is…read moreamazing! The red sauce isn't too acidic so it's a good sauce if you have acid reflux. Not saying it won't give you that at all but less acidic is good. Their large pizza used to be $20 back then but they have really gone up in prices recently so we don't go as often as we used to. Servers are always friendly. You go and sit where ever you like, they have large booths and tables.

Paid $15 dollars for spinach dip and instead of bread we received clumps of raw doughread more

We arrived around 6:20 pm on Saturday night and was immediately greeted and seated. The restaurant…read morewas full and thought there would've been a wait. The food was better than expected and huge portions. In other reviews, I felt that the temperature of my food was fine. Not too hot and not too cold. I don't like burning the inside of my mouth lol. The ambiance is really nice, too. They have modern light fixtures and decor. You can dress casual or upscale casual. The temperature of the inside was a bit on the chilly side, so a light sweater or jacket would be needed. Everything was so nice and would def return the next we are in BR.

July 3, 2026 at 3:04pm . . Out of some pretty specific items entirely too early in the day. …read more Lasagna, a simple staple of "Italian" cuisine. . Out of it, option is the same ingredients on top of pasta. It is good, similar to Lasagna but not there. While there, we heard at least 2 more people wanting Lasagna . . Entirely too cold in the bar area with "explicit" instructions not to touch the air conditioner, forcing the customers to eat in an overly uncomfortable atmosphere. In an instant, your meal will lose all its heat today, on the table. My biggest instruction for today is to bring a jacket and prepare for a cold atmosphere. . Eat quick and hurry out. . As always . . Have a great dining experience and make every meal an enjoyable one.

There are many Pizza places around.... Rotolo pizza is just better than any... others may be less…read moreexpensive but if you want a GREAT pizza ... Rotolo's is the place

Fantastic Pizza and Calzones. Love going there. Great people, and great service. Always a great…read moreplace to go.

The menu is pretty good. I'd def recommend visiting during happy hour so you can get more bang for…read moreyour buck. I always get great service when I go. Nice place to eat and typically very clean and upbeat. The new vodka sandwich is amazevballs

My wife and I have been passing this place for months and finally got the chance to stop by. I'm…read moreoriginally from Chicago and she's originally from New York so we have the Pizza debate all the time. She has friends who eat there a lot and keep saying how amazing it is. First Impressions: This place is NICE. When I got the chance to look around it is the perfect first date spot for *anybody*. The menu is diverse for a Pizzeria. They even have a chef selected Salumi Board. In the end we split a Sensation salad(which is the best I've had), Calamari Fritti, Carnosa and Mushroom Medley. The Good: Our server was Andrea. She was outstanding. She did her best to take care of us and in the end she went above and beyond with her service. The Calamari was ok but seemed to be more breaded than actual Protein. The first thing that came to mind when I tried the Marinara was "Fresh". It tasted like it was obviously done that morning. The Not So Good: When Andrea took our order she made it a point to tell us that she would space out our order. That didn't happen. And she told us the kitchen didn't follow her orders. Everything came seconds from each other. I understand a sense of urgency because the parking lot is always full and they want to push the crowds in a way where the next wave can have a place to park...But the restaurant wasn't even full. The Parking lot was but there were plenty of tables available. In the end we felt Serve and Burned. The Pizza: The char on the doh was great. I love a good fired oven pizza. But the pizza itself didn't seem like it was cooked all the way through. When I picked up a slice it just flopped down. My wife's pizza was dry. She ended up asking if they had any kind of garlic butter. And Andrea understood the assignment. She came back with the Shrimp Scampi sauce it ended up making it seem to be the one thing the Mushroom Medley needed all along. (I 100% Recommend it.) My pizza was ok, but only when the 3 slices I took a bite of had all of the toppings on them. Less than half of the pizza had Pepperoni on it. I did not get the impression that this was something that happens all the time so we will be back. I would still recommend this place to everybody.

My family has been going to Isabella's Pizzeria in Baton Rouge off and on since our girls were…read moreyoung. They're not the busiest Italian restaurant around, but they do have a really good menu and some good deals too. We enjoyed the BBQ Chicken Pizza and got a free small cheese pizza; the flavor was great. I especially loved the whole garlic cloves on the BBQ pizza! Also, the Tuscan Chicken Panini was the bomb!! I'd stop by here early day to grab one if I could! The ambiance and service are good too. Clean and plenty of seating inside. No complaints. Hope to continue trying many more options on their extensive menu.

TERRIBLE OWNERS! Owner yelled at me because I parked in the wrong spot like this is not a strip…read moremall. Once I apologized and agreed to move he said: "Yes please do it immediately." Absolutely terrible behavior and went in the restaurant and owner was still passive aggressive and rude.

Amazing customer service and delicious pizza! They know how to take care of you!…read more They make sure that you are completely satisfied with your experience and they did everything possible to make my experience the best it possibly could be. Thanks and keep up the great work!

Management has absolutely NO INTEGRITY. I tooka delivery driver job at a new store on Wax Road in…read moreBaton Rouge, but since my commute would be an hour each way I said I would need 8-hour shifts. Then, after driving there to complete onboarding and investing hours doing onboarding paperwork from my home computer, the manager reneged on our agreement. Also, the job ad was a bait & switch.

Had a pepperoni pizza. It was tasty but the crust was a bit doughy and could have used a bit more…read moreof a crispy char on the bottom. Also had a muffuletta sandwich. Was thick but smaller in diameter than I'm used to, especially for the price. The olive mix added the expected salty/tangy flavor, but the rest was a bit blander than I was expecting. Anthony's Italian Deli and Monjuni's both make a bigger, more flavorful version of this sandwich. The best part of the meal was the cannoli. DELICIOUS! Service was prompt and attentive without being too familiar and overly friendly. Ambiance was about what I expected from a small neighborhood establishment; kind of reminded me of an Italian "Cheers".

Food was delicious as always ! We decided on a whim to go…read morehave lunch there ... was busy but not too busy ... Homey atmosphere great waitstaff Great Homemade Italian food

Went on Christmas Eve right at opening and had a great lunch at Rotolo's Pizzeria. The food came…read moreout quickly. We shared a fresh garden salad and ordered the Krewe calzone and deluxe combination calzone -- both were hot, soft, and packed with toppings. It was Wednesday $7.99 calzone day. We split the salad, drank water, and each bill was about $13, which was a great value and kept us full the rest of the day. Excellent service even with only one waitress handling lunch. Casual spot and the calzones were just as I remembered. We'll be back.

The Prairieville Rotolo's continues to disappoint. Our waitress forgot our appetizers, left us…read morewaiting for drinks, and charged us $13 for plain spaghetti noodles because she didn't know how to ring it up properly. We just paid and left out of frustration. They also rarely have the beers they advertise, and when they do, they're often warm or taste off. The food is good, but the service and bar management really need improvement.

A typical 'make your own' pizza place but they have beer on tap that you pour yourself!…read more I went right at dinner time, so the place was packed! I always love how you can see your pizza being made at places like this. I was very simple and got a cheese pizza with black olives. The pizza came out fast and was nice and hot! I also like how this place has booths that you can sit in... I feel like most places don't have booth just tables, so I appreciate that. The hand washing station, next to the fountain drinks and beers on tap, is very cool and keeps little kiddos occupied. I have never seen this, so this was very cool. I also liked how there was paper you could rip off and take to your table that had games like tic tac toe, a word finder, etc. Very clean, plenty of parking and so many pizza options!

Well I gotta be honest I like the selection on the menu but I wish they had a few more items on the…read moremenu. Now the toppings that they offer are nice but I wish that the fountain drinks were offered in a larger size. One complaint that I do have is that some of the cooks almost burnt the crust they just need to pay a little more attention when baking the pizza. Now I do love ordering on the app it's nice and the atmosphere of the restaurant is clean and nice but other than that it's a nice place to go eat ate .