Everything Bagel is all that it's cracked up to be! Lots of bagels. Lots of cream cheese. Lots of lox and corn beef. It's like stepping back in time into the NYC of old. The sandwiches are awesome and the staff are friendly. They have deli meat and cheese on sale as well as tasty spreads. The ambience and smell of freshly baked bagels make the experience more satisfying than other bagel shops in the area. Don't miss this place if you like bagels. Take home a dozen! read more

See all

We randomly chose Everything Bagel based off of proximity to our condo and previous yelp reviews. We ordered a dozen bagels and have enjoyed all of the different flavors we picked. The lady working was provided excellent service to us and was patient as we chose from the different flavors and selected our flavored cream cheese. The inside was a nice and clean as well. read more

I do not believe they make their own bagels; my dining companion and I, both from "bagel country" in NJ, noted they tasted packaged. The counter server was not sure what we meant when we asked if any were still hot (meaning they never are, I guess). The egg sandwiches were good, but we were disappointed the bagels were not made in-house. read more

Just moved to the area. Thought I give the local bagel shop a chance. Man that microwaved egg and bacon made me want to pack my crap and move back home. Nice people though!! read more

This used to be the best bagel place! It has switched owners I think. The establishment looks and feels dirty. The bagels are still good. The staff is no longer a welcoming kind crew. And the prices are ridiculous. I was charged $16 for a bagel with cream cheese and smoked salmon. When down the highway I can get a better bagel with the same stuff for half that price. They microwave their eggs and keep adding I. The weird money grabbers like macarons. This is no longer a clean small bagel shop. read more

Excellent, high-quality, chewy (this is what we want, people) bagels. Great everything bagel w scallion cream cheese. Admittedly have not tried many other menu items. Long lines, but they move 'em quickly. Some limited indoor and outdoor seating available, but I always grab and go. read more

It's a bagel in the sense that it's round, but other than that it's just a dense piece of bread. $8.25 for a bagel with CC and a fountain iced tea. Wanted to get eggs but only do scrambled. Didn't get cold cuts but they have Boars Head which is a bonus. read more

Everything Bagel - Everything bagel w CC - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

While I can understand the owner's frustration during these times, my previous review clearly did not take away the tastiness of these bagels. If you are not of high risk or don't care if you get/spread Covid, you can make the personal choice to go into this shop to get these great bagels. I am not out to destroy a business. However, if you or someone close to you is of high risk, I would not recommend entering this shop. Numerous other businesses have large, clearly posted signs that you cannot enter the building without a mask. Unfortunately, while I was here, the majority of the patrons did not have masks on at all, some (not all) of the staff did not have them on correctly (covering the nose, there is another photo on Yelp of this occurring) and to add to it there is no ventilation (ex. door open) in this small shop. I would be happy to update this review should there be clear policies/signage regarding mask wearing. I simply cannot give a 5 star review to a business that I can no longer safely visit. read more

Great place for some bagels! A bit pricey for breakfast, but they fill them with toppings. Service was great and fast. read more

See all

The food was good and generous. I shared a bacon sausage egg and cheese bagel and a honey almond cream cheese bagel and both were delicious! The restaurant has outdoor seating and a great vibe. Lots of customers coming and going so it must be a crowd favorite too. I'll be back! read more

Everything Bagel - Honey almond cream cheese sesame bagel. - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I visited Everything Bagel on a recent trip to St. Augustine. It was so good I had to go twice during my four day trip. Food: Overall, the food was really great. We went on Christmas Eve and by the time we got there our favorite bagels had sold out but we still enjoyed our back up selections. We went again on the 27th and got to try our favorites which were yummy! Friday turkey special sandwich: I tried this sandwich on the first trip and it was incredible. All the flavors blended so well together and the veggies were incredibly fresh. The pesto aioli was so flavorful but not overwhelming. I enjoyed this so much that I got another one to take home on my second visit and it was just as delicious as the first one. Salt bagel: for the true salt lover. This is one of the better salt bagels I've had. Lots of salt on top that doesn't fall off easily. BEC on and everything bagel: getting the BEC on an everything bagel is a must. My boyfriend got this on a plain bagel during our first trip and on an everything on the second trip. He said that the everything bagel made all the difference. Service: service was great considering how busy they were on Christmas Eve. There was a long line when we walked in but the staff was quick and we received our food in no time. Ambiance: the store had a traditional deli look. Cases displaying meat, cheese, and baked goods. They had a nice condiment and coffee station set up with much more condiment selections than most places. The tables were very unique and aesthetically pleasing. There was outdoor seating as well but it was too cold to take advantage of it. I really enjoyed my experience and will definitely be back when I'm in the area. I will also be dreaming about the Friday turkey special until I can eat it again. read more

Everything Bagel - Friday turkey special - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

He Said: I'd like to think we caught them on a bad day, but we had three different bagels and all of them had the same issue: cakey/dense and mildly undercooked dough. They were, unfortunately, not good and given the ratings here we were quite surprised. Maybe it's us and everyone else is right, but here we are. She Said: I know it's not easy to make great bagels, especially at scale, but I was so disappointed since I hadn't had a bagel in several months. Like He said the dough just wasn't good. They also got the order wrong (I asked for pumpernickel and got plain), but we could have checked before we left so that doesn't go in to our star rating. We are leaving two stars because the people were nice and we're allowing some benefit of the doubt. Potty Points: No trip to the potty for me today! read more

Grabbed bagel sandwiches from here on our way out of town and, honestly, some of the best bagels I've had in Florida. The service was also great, quick and nice. We got there at about 10:30 am and they still had plenty of bagels, but some varieties had started to sell out. Again, some of the best bagels in FL and definitely has the hometown family owned bagel place vibe. 10/10 would come back read more

Everything Bagel - Lox and cream cheese on an everything bagel, cream cheese turkey bacon and sprouts on an egg everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I stopped by Nov 18 to pick up a couple of muffins cranberry because it was my husband's BD the muffins were old like a week old I'll never stop again read more

I was visiting St Augustine for New Years and stopped in at Everything Bagel on my way out of town. It's an unassuming small "diner" with a friendly hometown feel. I ordered a 2 egg and cheese sandwich on an everything bagel (seemed fitting) and added avocado. It was easy to tell the bagel was fresh. It was fluffy/soft on the inside and lightly toasted/chewy on the outside. The egg to cheese to bagel ratio was perfect and all the sandwich needed was a little hot sauce. The food is simple but delicious and done right. And the staff makes you feel like family. read more

We were in town from Orlando for a wedding and decided to stop at this bagel shop before heading home.... I'm upset that there is not one in Orlando. Highly recommend this bagel spot if you are in town. The bagel was soooo good, it taste like NY bagels! The ice coffee was really good, and the hash browns also. I wish they had more locations in Florida. 10/10 read more

We have eaten breakfast here EVERY DAY since visiting St. Augustine. Lox on an everything bagel is the bomb. Good coffee too and nice ladies working here. A good place to spend your morning. read more

Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Bagels and service are fantastic. We wanted custom bagels and they fixed perfectly. We will definitely be back

How do I love thee, Everything Bagel? A lot, actually! It's the only place I can get a pumpernickel bagel. Or a cranberry walnut. Or several other flavors that are fabulous. I stop in anytime I'm doing early morning errands in St Augustine, and I grab at least 6 to tide me over until the next time I'm in the area. Bagels are life, and the ones at Everything Bagel can't be beat. Go get some. Hey, bring me a pumpernickel while you're at it.... read more

Probably one of the best bagels I've had. The only down side is that they do not have any non dairy alternatives for cheese or cream cheese. I would definitely be here everyday if they did! read more

Everything bagel is an amazing gem that I wouldn't have known existed if it weren't for the great reviews other Yelpers have left for them. Seating is limited in this tiny spot but the selection is NOT! There were several different types of bagels along with donuts, pastries, breakfast sandwiches and deli sandwiches/paninis. They were generous with the cream cheese on their bagels and the everything bagel was literally EVERYTHING! Would def recommend read more

Everything Bagel - Mmmm everything bagel with cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Very good but have gotten expensive since new ownership. Agree their lox and cream cheese sandwich is great. I Bagel and Lox read more

Went to everything bagel today. Bagels are listed on their menu at $12.00 dozen. Rang up at $21.00 discounted after 2:30 at 50% was told they didnt have web site. Then showed and was told its an error. Oh well... read more

This is where you want to go to get bagels. The bagel breakfast sandwiches are generously sized and reasonably priced compared to other bagel shops I've been to. Love the classic bagel shop vibes here and the staff is great. My go to order is a honey wheat bagel toasted with egg, cheese, and sausage; sometimes when I'm feeling frisky I'll add cream cheese. I'll come back here for a bagel every time I'm visiting town. The cookies and muffins are great as well read more

The place is friend and they always say hello when you walk in. They have a smile. The bagels are fresh. The lox and bagel sandwich is very good. We had the Italian sub which was huge. It will feed 2 people for sure. So much meat on it. The prices we great for the amount of food you got. We will return. read more

Rude inefficient service on top of AWFUL STALE and uncoated bagels. If you appreciate good bagels and service: AVOID. All brewed coffee was out. Out of three huge vats to brew, the manager starts with decaf with a line of angry people out the door. Idiotic. Super rude service at the front with a line out the door. And after all that, the bagel was horribly stale. read more

For those who want a quick review: Solid, cheap bagel place with friendly staff & quick service. For type A readers: Food: 5/5. You can taste the home-made in the bagels & the spreads are light and fluffy. There are multiple types of bagels, spreads, & sandwich combos to choose from. There's something for everyone and every something I've had here has been great. The iced coffee is the best I've ever had. Location: 4/5. The place isn't well advertised & a bit hard to find, as it's nestled at the end of a shopping center, but parking is super easy and convenient. Aesthetics/space: 4/5. If you're looking for a fancy place for an extravagant bagel- this ain't it. & if you're looking to sit down with 5-10 pals & eat- this also isn't the place. Seating is very limited and the place is just a local business with no glitz & glam but the food and customer service makes up for it. Staff: 5/5. All friendly, all professional. Some call you sweetie and remind you of that nice lady at the bank when you were a kid. Everyone smiled and they got my food out quick. Summary: This is my new go to weekend breakfast place. Try it out. Highly recommend. read more

See all

These bagels are amazing. We stop here every time we visit town. Bagels are beyond fresh with the perfect amount of chew! Our favorites are the garlic and the pumpernickel. And you must try the flavored cream cheeses. The scallion cream cheese has a bite to it that brightens up every bagel bite. Thanks for a quality breakfast guys! read more

Stopped for a bagel this morning! Walked in an it looked like a New York Deli! The bagels were delicious and the honey almond cream cheese was delicious! They have a wide selection of bagels along with a variety of sandwiches! If you are in St. Augustine, stop and try a bagel with cream cheese! read more

See all

Best bagels in St. Augustine. The owners and staff are welcoming and efficient. The bagels are fresh and deelish. Huge variety of bagels, spreads, and sandwich items. Great place to grab a bite to eat there or take to go. read more

Excellent bagels and very friendly staff ! The vanilla coffee is so good. Last trip we tried the cannolis and they where delicious.

The best bagels in the area! Cute little cafe too, but just wish they had waiter service.

Tried for the first time with my S/O. Fairly busy, to me at least, on a Thursday. The space is very intimate/comfortable. It makes you feel very welcome. If you don't want to sit inside there are a couple seats outside. Anyways...Amazing how they just kept churning the customers out! It was so fast. Friendly staff(all smiling & acknowledging us), quality food, great time. We probably waited no more than 5 minutes for our order. They are very generous with portions. I ordered a Croissant with Lox, Egg whites, and Gouda and they loaded me up! It was all delicious. For a reasonable price! Everything Bagel is a gem in St. Augustine that I can't believe I've been missing. 10/10 would recommend. *They have a menu that offers way more than bagels. For those who want to switch it up. read more

Everything Bagel - Order of toasted Croissant, 3 Egg whites, Lox, and Gouda. - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This is the place has the best bagels! The staff are incredible! They are so patient and helpful/ knowledgeable about all different bagels, spreads and bakery items! This is a little hole in the wall place! There's seating inside and outside (not much but they do have it)! I come here on a weekly basis! read more

I read the other reviews and was excited to try this place. The inside is a bit old looking and a bit clumsy to navigate. The egg sandwiches are good and there is a lot of egg in each one. But I didn't find the bagel to be all that great. It wasn't bad but definitely not to my NY standards. My wife's bagel had a major smear of cream cheese which is always a good sign. The coffee was very hot but the flavor was just okay. Lots of food choices. Perhaps I caught them on a bad day. read more

I tried this bagel shop quite some time ago and since I was in the area, I decided to see if anything has changed. Today, me and my friend decided to try their bagel and Lox. Now, you can just get the bagel / lox for $6.95 but if you want all the fixings; capers, red onion and tomato, it's just a dollar more. I had mine on a toasted everything bagel, my friend's was on an onion bagel. The bagel was delicious unfortunately, the large amount of cream cheese and small amount of lox (two thin slices) overpowered the star of the show, which should have been the lox. Since I do not eat lox very often, when I decide to have it has to be the perfect ratio of each component, not a mouthful of cream cheese. They also stated it was a platter but the bagel came out fully assembled. So, the bagels are delicious because I believe, the owner is from N.Y. and we know how to make bagels. Again, we enjoyed it and would definitely go back, but no so sure I would spend the money on lox and cream cheese again. It should be noted that everyday after 2pm, bagels are 50%! read more

See all

Microwave eggs are gross. The bagel was good, muffins were good, but microwaved eggs = gross

Good. Service was ok not the friendliest but food was decent. I'd go back if in the area. It was empty but also mid morning.

We found this place by chance and so glad we stopped. Very friendly, great choices and it was busy so we knew it would be good. Portions are large for the money. read more

Everything Bagel - Friday special and I ate half before taking photo. - Bagels Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Bagels are excellent but the prices have skyrocketed over the last year, almost a 100% price increase in less than a year! I used to make the trip from Nocatee to buy a dozen bagels per week but no more. Prices have increased from $12 to almost $24 a dozen including a new service charge of about 4% because I used a credit card. That's highway robbery! Does not seem as though they want to sell bagels in bulk anymore. They are not my go to bagel joint anymore! read more