What...was that?…read more Perhaps that's the issue. I remember what One Guy's used to be. It was formerly a place that I'd recommend to anyone visiting from out of town as a local favorite. It was a place I went when I cared less about convenience and using a coupon for some chain pizza and instead wanted something absolutely delicious. Sadly, it's not that anymore. The salad out front was decent enough, albeit pretty basic and definitely nothing special. The calzone was watery. Yes, watery. I don't even know how or why, but there was an excessive amount of watery liquid coming out of it. The pepperoni pizza was decent enough, but definitely no better than you're going to get from a chain, or (I can't believe I'm saying this) frozen. The sauce was particularly off-putting and gave me a different kind of nostalgia than I thought I would get eating here. It reminded me of eating Chef Boyardee vlin microwavable bowls as a kid. I was told that after taking the leftovers home and trying them the next day, they were even worse reheated. I didn't have that misfortune myself as I was done with it after the meal. The service was adequately good, but there was no crowd like I would have expected, and it's easy to see why. I'm fully aware of the reasons things may have gone a different direction (specifically downhill) at One Guy's and that there are now more options in town. I just hoped that this location still had some of that pizazz that made it special. Sadly, I was disappointed.

Awesome place! The white pizza is a MUST. They also have really good tiramisu. The guys that work…read morethe counter are so nice. Lots of seating inside. I can't wait to go back next time I'm in Lubbock.

A little out of the way, as it is located downtown. However, it's worth the time to drive down and…read moretry the place. Ambiance is casual enough, but you can dress up and not feel out of place. Not dim, but not overly bright lighting. Service was quick, friendly, and came by the table often. Now the food. I had heard good things about it, but I was quite pleased with how good it actually was. Bread is complimentary and comes out early. Very good bread. We both had the Pink Parmesan and it did not disappoint. If you don't know, that is Alfredo sauce and red sauce mixed. Chicken was well cooked and not dry at all. The tortellini it comes with is SO good! We had one plate with this, and then one with fettuccine noodles. Both are topped with the pink sauce. Tortellini was our favorite of the two, but we're both very good. Portions were generous. My wife and I could have split an order and it would have been plenty of food. Did not come with a salad or soup. I'm sure that could have been added, but was not included with the meal. Also had seafood items, but we did not try any of them. Pricing was on par with other restaurants in town. Most entrees were in the $11 to $20 range, with a few more expensive items. We will be back for sure.

The food was absolutely amazing with great bread rolls as a started and the main meal was really…read moregood. Good service and cheap for what you get.

I love this pizza; it is a great one to take and freeze. I also love to get the crustless pizza…read more Heat and put over lettuce. YUM I wish there were more stores.

Food and service are always excellent. The Ambiance says PIZZA as you enter. Thank Youread more

Wonderful place, amazing staff, delicious food, and chill spot! I will be coming back!read more

Great pizza place. Food was delish! I ordered the Not Your Father's vegetarian pizza with…read morecauliflower crust. It was yummy and a large portion. I would highly recommend.

Hi I'm most likely a little disseminating on the food as I am Boston Italian not sure what i…read moreexpected in lubbock had chicken parm it was disappointing not much flavor sauce was poor as well , my girlfriend had Nonna's pizza which was good I will say the drinks were very good and though it was busy ( TT Graduation ) our waiter though frazzled did pretty well. it's casual dinning family friendly kind of place

Last few visits were good - tonight was sadly underwhelming and we will be reluctant to return for…read morea while. Pros- Service, ambiance, bread service and fair pricing. Cons- martini tasted watered down, could barely find any meat in the bolognese sauce, house salad was smothered in dressing, zucchini chips were way strangely over salted/seasoned, crème brûlée had a soft top ( I mean what's the point-just call it vanilla pudding) and the strawberry sauce served with cheesecake was rancid -had that tingly metallic taste -not fresh at all. We both agreed that next visit, if there will be one, we will just get a bowl of chicken soup and eat the yummy bread butter or split a pizza. Nothing we ordered was worth the gas to get over there ... sigh

Shoutout to TJ who gave us the works!! Great service and great food! Highly recommend going to see…read morehim and his crew!!

In general, a standard calzone is filled with ricotta, mozzarella, and Parmesan/ Pecorino Romano…read moreand the dough is fresh made with some oregano and a little salt and pepper. This was not it, just cheap mozzarella and cheap ham (Canadian bacon). The dough is bland and it's basically a large Hot Pocket. I don't know if this place is still owned by the original owner, but I don't think so. 1 calzone took 30 minutes to make. Waaaaaaaaay too long. Several other customers after me received their food first. I had to inquire if something had happened to the order and they told me it would be a few more minutes. I'm sure the college kids don't know any better and the business will survive, but I'd skip this joint. If you're from NYC, fogettaboutit.

We recently stopped into our old stomping grounds for dinner because it had been some years since…read morewe had been to the original. Our experience was fantastic! The mafia queso was to die for (I love the garlic bread with it), our salads were fresh and fast out, the tortellini and spaghetti with meatballs and sausage hit the spot! All hot and fresh and timely just like we like. Our servers name was Mercedes and she was great and gave us fast and friendly service. We sat in the area behind the bar ,which we never had seen before. That was cool! Everything looked extremely clean and bright. We will definitely be making our way back over there next time we have our Italian craving!

There is a reason this place has survived many years. You feel the Italian vibes and the servers…read moreare fantastic. The food is delicious. The chicken spaghetti is tasty and wonderfully seasoned. The garlic bread melts in your mouth. Green Chile potato soup is a hidden surprise. Definitely warrants a return trip. Too bad I live far away.

Love coming for the drinks! The wings were great this time around. The bartenders are sweet. I love…read morethat they keep the lights low.

I came in about 6:00 on a weeknight, not too busy or crowded. Greeted by the bartender/waitress,…read moreand then it was ALL downhill. Ordered a draft, cold but weak on carbonation; the ribs came out REALLY quick, but tasted like they had lived under a heat lamp and "refreshed" with BBQ sauce from the fridge - cold, but the fries were warm. Almost through with everything, 2/3rds of my beer and the ranch beans remained. I covered my beer with my phone and went to the restroom to wash my hands; no napkin wipes to clean up after the ribs. When I returned, the table was cleared; my beer? Gone, as well as my phone; it was at the bar. Last time