This place just gets better and better everytime I come and the owner remembered me I felt special genuinely. You need to come here on a Friday night when they do cinnamon pizza it's too good to pass up; Dave portnoy should review this place. Good vibe too tvs music and like a ski surf kinda decoration inside. read more

My wife and I really enjoy going to Extreme Pizza. They have great pizzas, a good salad, and good service. The young man that recently took over is bringing it back to greatness! You really should take a few minutes and stop in and try their pizzas. They are very good. read more

My husband could eat pizza everyday if he could. He asked for pizza for lunch today so I stopped into Extreme Pizza to hook my husband up. Walking in, I was greeted and a beautiful smile. The lady that was working was the only person there but she handled business. There was a gentleman ahead of me. She got his ordered squared away and then got my order taken care of. We talked about the little coffee joint around the corner from her shop. I told her I was going to grabbed a drink and be right back. By the time I made it back, my husband's pizza was done. I have a habit of making sure his food looks like what I had ordered. He works on the other side of town any I don't want to drive back if it's wrong. Opening up that little box, the pizza looked fantastic! There was so much cheese on the pizza. It was pipping hot just coming out the of oven. Cheese pull was awesome! The crust was chewy and thin. The sauce had the right amount of tang to it and the cheese was nicely melted all over the pie. With all of it combined in a bite, it was the perfect sweet and savory combo. I was able to sneak a small bite and it wa so good! I also grabbed a side of homemade ranch and highly recommend dipping that slice into it. Come to find out the gal that helped me was the owner. She was so sweet and genuine! Business owners like that make me want to support them even more! If you're over by Broadway and Front street and you want a good pie, make sure you check out Extreme Pizza. So good! read more

Extreme Pizza - Cutest pizza box for a personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Tried it for the first time today and I just gotta say we definitely will be coming back. Got The Shredder and some buffalo wings and neither disappointed. The service was great, and the place felt very welcoming. Look forward to trying everything on the menu! read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Tried new pizza that had hot honey, pickles and chicken on it. Safe to say I have a new fav. Staff were super chill, I always love talking with the crew! read more

I had a sausage mushroom pizza here last week. It was a good sized pizza, $20-ish and ready within 15-ish minutes of when I called in to pick it up. Overall this was a solid pizza, excellent price, eager college-student level service and served hot in a good quality box with appropriate accouterments. I will say the crust was good quality, done perfectly, on runny soggy or too thin/too thick areas. In fact the texture of the pizza overall very good, the red sauce a tiny bit bland, however, I had a cold so I'm not docking it for taste, I will order here again and there were plenty of competing pizza shops. I chose this one, and have no regrets. It's a solid four stars, potentially five because of the quality. In fact, I can't really put my finger on why not five stars.... except I would probably always get take-out or delivery here. So five stars it is. I will be back. (I ate the whole dang pie in one sitting, so there is the hunger factor.) read more

I drove across greater Boise City to get an Extreme Pizza. Parked and walked to the back door @ 2:45 pm on 5/15/25. Hand written sign on glass door says will return at 3pm. No explanation for my waste of time. read more

Ordered for delivery. Showed up on time, still hot, and absolutely delicious. Their online ordering feature is great. No shouting on the phone so that's nice. And seriously it's as good a pizza as I've had in Boise. read more

We randomly walked to this place from our conference at the university and we are SO glad we stopped here! The Mr Pestato Head is a MUST try! We had a big group and ended up coming here like 3 times in one week and the staff were so sweet and welcoming every time! I feel spoiled and now not sure where to get a yummy Pestato head pizza back home! read more

Extreme Pizza - Mr Pestato Head! The photo does not do this pizza justice. (Also amazing with ranch!) Mr Pestato Head Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Best pizza in boise me and my wife love it the Everest pizza is amazing. Idk why it needs to be a 85 character review read more

Best pizza ever! Put off trying Extreme Pizza for SO Long! Kept getting their mailers and advertisements with coupons and decided to give them a try. So glad I did! They have so many excellent pizzas, way more than your normal pizza place! Love their pizza crust as well; it's not cardboard!! Goodbye Pop Murph, hello Extreme Pizza! We are now Extreme Pizza Frequent Flyers! read more

I've ordered from this place a couple of times and I won't be ordering a third time. It's better than little Caesar's and I like little Caesar's. However for 22 large it's not a better bargain than little Caesar's. I love pizza and trusting my craving with just anybody is difficult I handed extreme pizza the ball and they fumbled. The dough is just too firm and chewy. The toppings were not plentiful. I ordered extra cheese and they just took my extra money and kept the cheese. I couldn't imagine them putting extra on there because there wasn't enough cheese for even regular cheese. I Guess I need to ask for extra extra cheese and probably have to go there and put it on myself. The sausage was not evenly distributed and basically was enough for half the pizza. They put it in random places over the whole pizza. Im just disappointed. Wish I spent my 25 bucks on anything else. read more

Extreme Pizza - Everest. All meat. The dough or crust is a little too durable for my liking. It looks like a lot of topping but nah. - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Delicious. Smells and tastes like pizza should. Delivery faster than quoted. Coupon accepted with no issues. Definitely a new fan here!!!

Extreme Pizza's employees are always so helpful. Rose S. went out of the way, above and beyond, to help us with our order. Thank you from Boise State University Radiologic Sciences! read more

Good gluten free pizza- and the rest of my family got the Everest and loved it! Lots of topping options too-definitely a good option for pizza here in Boise plus it's pretty close to campus. read more

Extreme Pizza - Gluten free pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

First time going to this place, Friday after work hungry in the mood for pizza. Got a Garden one and it was fantastic. The pizza was great cold to. Staff was nice and friendly and fresh ingredients. Definitely recommend trying! read more

The good: the flavor and toppings were good, the bad: not enough sauce and the dough was a little stiff, next time make a little softer dough and a little more sauce and it would be better read more

Super good pizza. Fast delivery. We would order from here again I am looking forward to trying their sandwiches.

Ordered from a hotel located at the airport. Delivery was estimated at an hour out and that is exactly how long it took. We ordered a sub sandwich and a pizza. The sub sandwich was very good but the pizza was room temperature and a bit cardboard'ish. I suspect if doing fine in the pizza would be much better. If ordering delivery I'd go with the sub and skip the pizza. read more

Very friendly staff...feels like Cheers - walking in recognize face and get to know you as a person not just a customer. Food is great- love the garden pizza. Definitely a way to get veggies in! read more

great pizza, will be going back real soon! Order was perfect and great value! Loved all the different sizes you can order, perfect for any size family!! read more

I ordered the endless summer calzone and it came with no cheese. Violently disappointing. Just dough and a few vegetables. I ordered through Door Dash and by the time it came it was too late to ask for it to be corrected. I probably should have at least asked for my money back but I sort of just wanted to forget the whole sad event. I can't imagine how someone could make a mistake like this, so I spent the night wondering what I did to deserve this. I ordered at 8:30 and they close at 10, so I didn't order too close to closing. Maybe it got mixed up with someone else's order, but I can't think of any earthly reason why someone who didn't want cheese would order a calzone. That's like a vegan going to an ice cream shop and ordering just a cone. It's sad and it's dry and there are a lot of good vegan options in Boise and it just doesn't make any sense. Anyway this was either vindictive or grossly negligent and I'm very insulted that I paid real U. S. dollars for this sad, sad calzone. read more

The yard sale pizza is the best! Fast and friendly service. Don't miss out on all their great options.

We got delivery from their website. The website was easy to use and straight forward. Pizza estimated to arrive in 45min, got here in 30. Was warm and extremely tasty. We got a potato pesto pizza. Very filling and the crust was delicious. Highly recommend Extreme Pizza. read more

Excellent pizza, quick service, was easy to order online and wasn't overly expensive for the quality

This place is great!!! We stopped by for lunch during our ride on the greenbelt and so glad we did! Super friendly service and pizza always amazing. read more

Went in for a slice....they had to make one first...took 5 minutes. Tip...do not go in for slices for dinner. My mistake. Service was good. Everybody working seemed to be enjoying themselves. Place was good. A few people dining in. Seemed clean. Pizza....i grabbed a pepperoni slice to give them a try. The crust was a thin style with not much flavor. I enjoy the crust as much as the ingredients. The cheese and sauce were simple. Nothing that jumped out. If you are looking for a simple thin crust pizza, these guys will get you what you need. I feel there are better options for a tasty pizza out there. Cheers Always! read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

This pizza is amazing! We ordered a take & bake of half yard sale and half ghost wave. They were both so delicious but I would HIGHLY recommend the ghost wave if you want a little less meat on your pizza. It is to die for. I will be coming back to try other pizzas, but it will be hard not to just order this everytime. It was my husband's favorite too and he almost always wants a super meaty pizza. Can't wait to have more! read more

We loved our Pandora's Box pizza. It's even reviewable cold, from the refrigerator, hours later. The lady who made our pizza was also a hoot! We will be back 100x for the cheesy, bubbly, delicious pizza; but definitely for the customer service most of all. read more

Really great pizza, not greasy like some places. My son loves the bread twists! Good variety of salads

Tasty pizza with fun and different toppings! Nice customer service and they made or pizza in a timely manner.

This place is pretty great! It doesn't look like much, but the service is friendly and their menu includes a LOT of vegetarian and vegan options which is a rarity in Boise. The pizza was solid, too- all in all, I think this is a great option for anyone who wants the classic family friendly pizzeria experience, especially if you're a vegetarian or vegan who is a little tired of always getting relegated to the cheese pizza purgatory we so often end up in. read more

The Paia Pie was well prepared. The customer service was over excited and much appreciated! The pie itself was hot and tasty! I would definitely give it an 8/10. read more

Extreme Pizza - Paia Pie! - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Tons of variety and all the specialty pizzas are delicious. Staff is friendly and courteous. The Mount Blanc and Raging Rooster are my favorites read more

The Vegan white out is excellent! We ordered for pickup and it was ready at the stated time- warm and fresh. My kids like the knots.

Ordered pizza online for delivery. The wait time was 45 minutes which isn't bad. However, it was almost 45 minutes over that estimate...when it got here, 45 minutes late. The delivery guy said he was sorry but they couldn't give me the ranch I requested because they charge for ranch (I didn't see where to add that online, until I went back and dug a little deeper). This is just a personal pet peeve of mine, but if I'm paying over $60 for pizza and I ask for a handful of ranch...it seems like a very small ask. If it's really that big of an issue, just give the customer a call and ask if they'd like to add that $0.60 to the bill, rather than sending your delivery driver to apologize for manager (his words). The pizza was mediocre. It wasn't bad but I definitely would not order from here again. The wings were almost inedible. I can honestly say I've never had worse wings anywhere else....they did come with ranch though LOL! Overall, definitely would not recommend and would not order again. read more

Pizza was delivered to my home. It was hot, fresh, and the variety of toppings were delicious. The driver was very polite and friendly. We ordered the Averio and the ingredients were fresh and flavorful. We also added an order of pow wows! The kids (my husband) loved them. Chocolate syrup on the side. Yummy. read more

Extreme Pizza was the perfect choice for our group of 7 after a day of travel. We appreciated that it was open later for delivery too! Our group ordered two pizza's and two orders of breadsticks and everything in our order was correct. Our delivery driver even brought it to our hotel room, instead of just meeting us in the lobby. It's a bit more costly than many other pizza places, but overall a great experience! read more

The best place to get pizza being celiac! I feel safe eating here. I recommend this to if you have a dairy allergy and or you are vegan!

Love Extreme Pizza! Just ordered a family sized salad today for lunch! Yum, it was delicious, fresh, and filling. It will last a couple days for sure! Their pizzas are unique, several extreme flavors! Highly recommend!! read more