Pizza is 4 stars, customer service is 0. Went there today and the lady was incredibly rude. I tried to give her the benefit of the doubt. Maybe she's having a bad day? Maybe if I'm nice and friendly, she'll lighten up? She was annoyed the whole time, basically tossed our plates on the counter dismissively when the pizza was ready. I felt like she wanted us to leave... I was already having a rough day, which might be why it really caught me off guard. I really don't trust that place anymore. I felt like she never wanted to see us again... read more

The biggest pizza I've ever seen. A coworker bought this for us, I'm a pizza snob and really enjoyed this pizza. So far I believe it's the best I've had in Idaho. read more

This place has the best pizza in Boise. Run by a local couple who are there every day. The prices are completely reasonable, and everything about the pie is great; the sauce, the crust, the ingredients. The 14" pie is just right to split with your hubby. You can taste the herbs in the sauce, and although they have a small menu, it has everything I ever want or need, all the classics, plus some more unusual combos. They also have subs which I have not tried yet, but I think I will if I ever get sick of their delicious pizza, which is not likely to occur anytime soon. Order online at 11:00 sharp, and your pizza will be ready 20 minutes later. In the "notes" field, you can instruct them to make it a 1/2 and 1/2 if you want. read more

This was our very first time ordering from there. We were visiting from Hawaii and not very familiar with the area. Did a general search of pizza in the Boise area and their site came up. Even while using GPS apps we were still lost. So grateful that we were patiently and well received with phone directions, as well as a personalized parking Director (the worker/owner) to a spot right in front of the restaurant. Talk about customer service....and the pizza was amazing, nice and hot, great simple ingredients, crispy crust and with plates and utensils to take back to the hotel and gobble up while watching the football games. Definitely will visit there again when we are back in Boise! Mahalo! read more

NY Giant Pizza - 20" Pepperoni and Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Huge slices!!! $7 gets you 2 slices and a drink. If you're on a budget then this is worth it! Didn't do 5 stars cause flavor wasn't all there but for the price it's good enough read more

See all

Stopped in to kill time before our movie. People were friendly. My son got a slice of cheese pizza , he liked it. I got the garlic bread and it was very disappointing bland no flavor of garlic just tasted like cheese melted on bread needs seasoning and way more garlic. read more

NY Giant Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Very cool novelty slice. Great location near Edward's cinema and one slice goes a long way. We love stopping here before a movie.

This place serves 28" New York style pizzas! I drove from Kuna to pick up two of these giant pizzas for a contractor meeting and the consensus was this is great pizza. Pizza is good when nothing stands out and everything works together. Sauce is seasoned just right with a hint of oregano and the dough has just the right amount of flavor and salt that I could eat the dough all day. The pizza is made thin crust New York style that you can fold. The crust was browned with rough bottom texture and not soggy. They actually remove the mesh pan from the pizza toward the end of the cooking to ensure proper browning of the bottom crust. Meat lovers and pepperoni is also not overly loaded with greasy toppings and had just the right amount of buttery mozzarella. One tip is if you plan to order a lot of pizza, it's nice to give them at least 24 hours advanced notice. Two 28" pizzas can fit in one oven rack but more than that might require some preplanning. Supreme, meat lovers, and pepperoni are the most popular and I loved all three. As with any 28" pizza, make sure you have the cargo or trunk space and doorways that can fit the box... read more

NY Giant Pizza - Two 28" pizzas at the office just before being devoured - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Placed an online pickup order. Got a text from the Slice service saying the order would be ready in 15-30 minutes. I timed my arrival to be at the end of that timeframe. Got a text while on my way that the order was ready for pickup. Great! However, when I got there, the order hadn't even been started yet. When I said I had gotten the text 5 minutes prior saying it was ready, I was told that "the app sent that." So you mean to tell me that Slice automatically tells customers that their orders are ready when they aren't? Of course they don't -- and if that's actually the case, you should immediately switch vendors. read more

Pizza is good when it is not delivered cold. Delivery is ALWAYS over an hour, so be prepared regardless of what they tell you.

The pizza was wonderful. The service was fantastic. I don't think you can find better pizza in Boise.

Ordered 4 large pizzas for 9 of us. They were ready by the time we arrived to pick them up. We were looking for some NY style pizza and they were delicious! And had plenty of pizza left over which obviously reheated amazing and got to enjoy it all over again. read more

NY Giant Pizza - three different pizzas in boxes - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

They make the best delicious pizza I have every seen best price I always get pizza from here they are so friendly with customers

Ordered lunch with some co-workers while hanging at Chow Market. They spoke very highly about their go-to pizza down the way at NY Giant Pizza. They always get a White Pizza and add pepperoni and sausage -- whaaaat. Way to be rebels, ladies. Look at the pic. It was just as good as it looks. Pizza rivals Idaho Pizza Co. in the area. Absolutely loved it. I grabbed a side of marinara which was amazingly flavorful, too. Could not have asked for anything more in a good pizza. It was hot and ready in 15mins, too. Definitely would return -- again and again. read more

NY Giant Pizza - big ol' pizza box - 20' pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

The pizza is solid if you have a taste for pizza. Slices are ok in size. My only complaint is I'm a bit of a sauce guy. They don't put a lot of sauce in their pizza. A lot of cheese and bread. Go if you need to fix a pizza crave. read more

NY Giant Pizza is my hometown favorite pizza place to go with my friends and family. This spot is not near where I now live and where I have as I have moved around Boise and Meridian, however me and my friends always take the extra drive and effort to go here over the many options for Pizza. The Staff here is Amazing and always has a smile on their faces. They have always done a fantastic job of providing good service to those that come in whether for the first time or the hundredth time. I always enjoy the food I have and the feeling I get knowing I'm supporting a business I can get behind. read more

Really good pizza two large slice pepperoni and a drink $7 really really good I did have sausage added so it was a little extra read more

NY Giant Pizza - Two slice / drink with extra sausage added to pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

The biggest pizza is huge. The box was the biggest box I've ever seen. Would be great for parties. The slices were huge and floppy just like NY! Pepperoni was good fresh, not the best the next day. Quick delivery. Will order again! read more

Walked in order two #4's which is two slices of pizza and drink. Price was right where it needs to be for this slice and the actually slice is top notch. Having been in NYC many times this is exactly what you would find and expect as slice of pizza from NYC. The size tells it all in its name and is worth everything. Did I mention that sauce??? I need a copy of that flavor, 5 stars hands down read more

NY Giant Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

I came here last night after seeing a lot of great Yelp reviews, and it actually was really good! We ordered a bunch of slices and a calzone & everything was really satisfying. Regarding the "giant" slices, however: these didn't really look like a normal slice of pizza scaled up to be jumbo, rather just a very elongated, somewhat skinny slice of pizza. The "giant" slices are cut from a 28" pizza, so they are pretty big, but mostly just long. The slices were kind of annoyingly long that you couldn't really pick up the pizza without it flopping all over, so you had to slide the pizza off of the tray into your mouth. And the tray they serve each slice on is the size of a full-size pizza tray, so if you order more than 3 slices at your table, the table isn't large enough to accommodate all of the slices. While nitpick-y, these minor annoyances affected the pizza-eating experience. Complaints out of the way, let's get to the taste! You can order any toppings on individual slices which was nice. Just pick your toppings at the counter & it seems like they toss the toppings onto a slice of plain cheese, and top it with a little bit more cheese before reheating in the oven. The crust itself wasn't sturdy enough to support the entire slice, as previously mentioned, but had a nice flavor and wasn't too salty like some pizza dough can be. The calzone was the standout though! It was fully cooked through without any lingering wet dough & they put some sort of garlic butter spread on top so it tasted like a breadstick :) The topping to dough ratio was spot on as well! Overall the price you pay for each slice and the calzone is extremely reasonable. A good spot to stop in before the movies if you want a filling & relatively cheap meal that is also highly satisfying! read more

See all

This is the BEST pizza I have found in Boise!!! The giant pizzas are MASSIVE and sooooo good! We ordered a giant pizza with garlic and sausage and also a small salad with Italian. They were both so good and was SO much food. This is definitely my pizza place from now on! read more

See all

Our favorite pizza place in the treasure valley!. They never disappoint. The pizza and wings are always delicious and well balanced. They also have a pretty stellar crew on their hands. Thanks!! read more

Well the name kinda lives up to what you will get inside. They do have a giant pizza which might be fun to get for a party or something but the NY is not accurate. Definitely not New York style pizza. Not so good pizza here either- although we ordered a combo pizza thinking the veggies & meat would be flavorful- they were not. We added salt, cheese & peppers and still very little flavor Don't recommend them- save your $$ read more

Great pizza, great prices and friendly people. I called in the order and it was ready when I arrived.

Growing up back east, in upstate NY, I was able to and am still able to enjoy literally the best pizza in the country. Anyone who has been to NY and who has had their pizza and/or their bagels...KNOWS there is no other spot that makes either as great as NY. That brings me to this place. I live in Boise, Idaho. You just don't expect to find great pizza in BOISE...IDAHO! We are known for other things () () hahaha! This place is WITHOUT A DOUBT the closest thing you're gonna get to great NY Pizza. I mentioned another place here in Boise, NY Richies" Now, they are very much a decent pizza spot. Howevereeee, they don't compare to this place. Not even close. Both have unique features/aspects about them. This NY Giant Pizza....is UNBELIEVABLY DELICIOUS! The slices are M.A.S.S.I.V.E! much like a lot of spots in NYC. Not sure how they do it, but they come super close to being as incredible as the best pizzas in NY. Garlic cheese bread to go with it too....OOOOOOH WEEEEEE! and HEY! we are all entitled to cheat days once in awhile hahaha! I just wish they had another location. This place is so south of me and I live in northwest Boise. Be nice if they expanded. They certainly could and they'd certainly succeed. The pizza is TA. DIE. FOR! hahaha! Yeah, imo, it IS that good. We went on a Saturday night. Now this is the part where I throw in a "WTF?!?!" bit about this place hahahaha! We went in on a Saturday night. SATURDAY. NIGHT! don't forget that part...SATURDAY lol. We had just seen the new Bohemian Rhapsody movie. Wonderful movie, literally brought tears to me eyes! Anyway, afterwards, we went here. Called a friend to have her meet is here. She drove from Meridian to join us. My friend, she orders two slices of cheese. Ok, great. I'm really excited for her because she gets to try Boise's bestest and closest thing to NY pizza. I get to the counter "hey! Can I also get two slices of cheese please?" Lady: sorry, we are all out of pizza slices. If you want, you can wait THIRTY MINUTES for another one?" HOLD. UP! hahaha! 3-0 minutes?!?! THIRTY. MINUTOS?!?! Umm, hmmm. I was like, "wait a sec, you guys are all out of slices on a Saturday night and at 730 ish when tons of people are literally going and coming from the movies?" I know, I know....blaaaah, blah, blah! This shit happens at restaurants. BUT.....it shouldn't. Especially a place that's busy like this, whose food is PHENOMENAL and not to a place that it literally two steps from the movie theater doors haha! I was able to get once slice. My friend who drove from Meridian, after I built the hype up of this place....ended up with a salad. You gotta understand, the 3 of us rarely eat this stuff. So when we do, we neeeeeeeed it! Especially my friend who drove from Meridian. She has been a such a strict diet for a competition she did a few weeks ago. I was SO. STOKED. for her to eat this, to FINALLY see her eat regular food hahaha and to FINALLY see her enjoy regular food again after like 6-7mos of a super strict diet. It is what it is, right? I guess I'm just super picky and obviously, super outspoken haha! The beginning of this review is the part you TRULY need to pay attention to...because you seriously cannot go wrong with their pizza. Just running out on a Saturday night....very odd to me hahaha! Got home and told my roommate "they freaking ran out of slices!" Roommate: what??? Who runs out of slices of pizza on a Saturday night? So see! It's just not me that's crazy hahahaha! Or who sees how crazy that is. Have I been overly dramatic about this?? Oh yeah, no doubt, hahaha! But I guess when you and your friends limit your intake of calories and whatnot, I think we have earned the right to be dramatic af about this Again tho, if you go to Edward's theater on Overland and are hungry after....do not hesitate in trying this place. You seriously won't regret it. Be prepared for INCREDIBLE tastes and for MASSIVE slices, hahaha! OMG! SO. GOOD! That's it peepers! If you read all of this....I love you! If not, I guesssssss I can try to understand why you didn't read it all....seeing as...it is a long one Reviews are meant to be reviews Short reviews are boring and never give a true look into a place or places. Oh my god, I can't stop hahahaha! Thanks again for reading, Yelpers! Cheers! read more

NY Giant Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Good NY style pizza. A little skimpy on the toppings, but it's probably normal for true NY style pizza. Very small dining room, would recommend doing take out or delivery unless the just 1 or 2 people going in for a slice. We have had their pizza many times, they can be a little inconsistent on how the pizza is cooked. read more

Husband and I passed through Boise Jan 2023. I ordered the 28 inch huge Supreme pizza. We had the rest with our family the next day. All of us agreed it was not just a huge pizza but a really good pizza! On our trip back home, we had to stop. We ordered this time 2-16 inch supreme and meat pizza's to take home and freeze and we decided to try the meatball sandwich. My husband is Italian and we both agreed the meatball sandwich was just as good as their pizza's! We live 5 hours away so next time we go through Boise, we will definitely be stopping again! The mgr/owner is a really nice guy and with their great tasting pizza,'s, meatball sandwich, etc., it's definitely worth it to support NY Giant Pizza in Boise! read more

I was really pleased with this pizza. Great taste and a great crust ! I totally enjoyed it , once I found the place.

Suuuuuuuch good pizza!! Need I say more? This is exactly the kind of pizza that you see in the show FRIENDS and want some but don't know where you can get some thin, delicious New York style pizza. Did I mention that it's good! It's also massive! You get more than your money's worth. Go here - you won't regret it! Also, for my pineapple loving friends. I don't know where they get theirs but it's some of the best pineapple I've had! read more

Omg! Soooo good! And HUGE! We got 3 slices of pizza, garlic cheese bread and 3 sodas for $14! Insane prices for such quality food in such large quantities! We will be back, A LOT read more

NY Giant Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

Great pies! Much better than your canned pizza like Dominoes or Pizza Hut. Great wings too...

Stopped in for a quick bite before the movie across the street started. Ended up being a 30 minute wait for 3 slices of pepperoni pizza. In their defense they did say it would be 30 mins, but I thought that meant for a whole pizza, not just a couple slices. There was only one other customer there. When I asked for a refund (we were going to now be late for the movie) they gave me a hard time saying they told me about the 30 minute wait. I get that, but I had to leave and they weren't able to provide what I paid for in a timely manner so I didn't want to pay for something I wasn't going to get. I didn't even end up getting the full refund for the pizza so they ended up with a little extra of my money, but I didn't have time to further argue with them so I left. Not a great experience today. read more

My husband and I went to NY Giant Pizza for lunch. It was recommended my a friend who claimed it was the best NY style pizza in the area. For $10 total, we got two lunch combos. One was a double of slice of pizza with a drink and the other was a order of garlic bread and a drink. Great value! The pizza slices were huge and true NY style that you can fold in half. The garlic bread was good, but nothing special, though the price was $3.99 for the bread and a drink which is fantastic. We will definitely be back for a pizza and highly recommend that you try out their lunch specials. read more

NY Giant Pizza - These slices are so much bigger in real life! $5.99 for two HUGE slices and a drink (possibly a lunch only special?) - Pizza Near Me - Boise, Idaho

See all

Actually so good! I was pleasantly surprised. If you're from the east coast or just looking for a good pizza, highly recommend.

Not as good as I had hoped for, tasted like Little Caesars with a different style crust. Cardboard pizza.

Stopped here for some pizza on a road trip. They were so fast, amazing customer service, and the food was amazing!! Flavorful and perfect. We got pepperoni, white pizza, and a calzone. Can't recommend this place enough - and we will be back! read more

OMG the best pizza I've found in Boise, Absolutely delicious If you're looking for a real New York pizza you won't be disappointed

The pizza is pretty good for the price, the cheese bread is probably the best item on their menu, the meatball sub is pretty good too. I DO NOT recommend their deserts they taste freezer burned and when received were frozen. The inside of the store is chill, the tables were decently cleaned. The service is always friendly and nice. read more

Staying at the hotel across the street and came across this little spot. I ordered the 2 slice combo which is $5.99. Amazing deal! The service was great, they were fast and friendly and it taste like real NY style pizza! I wish they were in Salt Lake!! read more

See all

Review for Pizza Delivery Free delivery (min $11) but tip your delivery guy! NYGP Boise only has a Facebook page but Yelp doesn't allow that to be added. https://www.facebook.com/pages/NY-Giant-Pizza-_-Boise-Idaho/576582322404749 Hours are 11am-10pm, 7 days a week Menu: http://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/ny-giant-pizza-boise-4?select=GDeNyBS6Kvw6gn4q3FpGgA#GDeNyBS6Kvw6gn4q3FpGgA Square is used for credit card transactions; receipt texted for delivery. I ordered a 14" Supreme ($12.99) - Pepperoni, sausage, canadian bacon, bell peppers, mushrooms, onions and black olives, to be delivered across the complex at the Spectrum Hampton Inn. Delicious pizza with a thin crust with a good crunch. Toppings were evenly distributed and there is very little edge so if you're the type that throws away crust, there is little to waste! Also, slices were cut through nicely - it's annoying if it's cut halfway and you have to rip your slices and rip wrong into the neighboring slice. Expect around 40 mins+ for delivery even if you're nearby. It's an operational hurdle that very few small local pizza joints can work around, unless everything's pre-made or if they can afford many spare drivers. Boise was hit with some crazy freezing weather early this year (negative 9 degrees on Saturday?!) and I wasn't equipped to walk 0.4 miles, according to Google Maps, across the snow for food. Instead of national chains for pizza delivery, I opted for local joints and found that the new NY Giant Pizza has locations in San Diego and seemed to be well-liked. Called at 11am and the friendly guy repeated every number on my credit card aloud. He said it would be a "couple of minutes" which I knew was impossible, but whatever. At 11:12am, he called back to get my zipcode to complete the credit card transaction. At 11:40am, the delivery guy called to say that he's outside my door. He didn't know that payment had already been made and looked at the $3 tip money weird so I had to ask some awkward questions. Overall, I enjoyed the hot delicious pizza and will order again. read more

See all