Great food. Solid atmosphere with kind and helpful staff. Even though the restaurant was busy they took great care of me. Highly recommended. Parking was ample. Triple D recommended. read more

Love love love Fat Olives! We have been here twice, once for lunch and the other time for a dinner date, both experiences were great. We have tried their popular honey pistachio pizza, a classic Margarita, the spicy sausage rigatoni, and Margaritas! The service was quick, food was just so-so good, worth all the hype and every buck! They are always bustling and busy. The dough of the pizza is the winner, you know when you get the dough right, the pizza is going to be Gold! Highly recommend you all to give this business a chance. It won't disappoint you! Trust me. Get that slice y'all read more

First time at fat olives for a late lunch, it was still busy for a 2pm lunch but we were seated right away. I liked the goat cheese bruschetta, it was a little different with pistachios and honey. I don't understand why the oven roasted tomatoes on the bruschetta was cold, I put it to the side. You will think with it being oven roasted it would be warm. I tried one of their non alcoholic drinks which was pretty tasty. I wasn't really impressed with the chicken Alfredo, it wasn't anything outstanding. I noticed their pizzas was a big hit among other customers. Their lunch options don't apply towards the weekend. read more

See all

Even when the places was slammed busy staff stayed on top of the service. Unfortunately this place does get really busy however we really enjoyed it. Pizza was pretty great, right firmness and not too greasy which was great! Definitely would come back! Check it out for top notch pizza and don't for get to try guys favorites ! read more

Fat Olives - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

It was all fresh and delicious, nicely designed and friendly. I took my nieces for some Italian soda and salads/ pasta dishes/ desserts. We had fun and enjoyed the grotto ambiance. Thank you:)) read more

This restaurant was comforting and homey...and the service was good. I had two dishes while I was there.... Belgio Dolce Pizza "Pizza with a complex" This pizza feels like it grew up in the big city, but moved away to live the good life in Flagstaff. But after a while, it missed the fancy food of the big city. That's how I would describe this pizza. So many layers of flavor, this unorthodox combination of flavors really challenged my tastebuds. I watched the pizza being made in front of me. Hand made pizza in a brick oven...it doesnt get better than that. The dough was really nice and crunchy on the edges with slight burt edges (perfect). The white sauce is rich and creamy...almost too rich by itself. The shaved brussel sprouts are hidden in in the sauce...you dont notice them until you get a nice surprise bite. The sopressata is perfect for the pizza. With intense saltiness, it really balances out the white sauce and mozzarella cheese. But the honey and the pistachios really change my thoughts on pizza. Think of a bite that would represent the whole meal. An appetizer of antipasti, a slice of pizza, and a slightly sweet italian dessert with pistachios and honey. Thats what a bite of the belgio dolce pizza tastes like. Pesto pasta This was a really nice dish There was no skimping on the pesto sauce. Vegetal and creamy, the sauce appeared heavy, but was actually nice and light. It was thick enough to stick to the pasta and not overseasoned. The crispy proscuitto was the perfect addition to allow you to cleanse your palate with a salty, meaty nibble. It was a very good experience read more

Fat Olives - Pesto pasta - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Food was worth the wait!!! Service was so great. We had the fettuccine Alfredo, pizza, and meatballs...so yum! Desserts were the icing on the cake! read more

Fat Olives - Dessert - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I ordered ahead of time via their website for pick up so i cannot attest to the ambiance. We arrived early and they were almost fished with our order. Which was great because The place was PACKED! We ordered 3 salads, one of every pasta and 5 pizzas. We were staying at an Airbnb across town and by the time the food arrived it was still warm and fresh. Not soggy or cold. Very fresh ingredients! I look forward to dining in next time. read more

The food was very overpriced and made my mother ill. We had pizzas and the artichokes. I think it was the artichokes

So happy we found this on Yelp ! We didn't have a reservation and they were busy but they sat us at the pizza bar. So cool to see how the pizza is made ! Hard working people back there . Servers up front also very good . We ordered a side Caesar salad with their special Belgio dolce pizza . So delicious . More than enough for two diners! Can't wait to return . read more

See all

We had the best experience here for dinner . We loved the all meat pizza and amazing salad . The service was top notch too . Have a blessed day read more

See all

Arrived on a Saturday around 2 pm. It might have been because it was around the holiday season, but Fat Olives was PACKED. We waited around 20 min for a table of 5. Tables were placed very close to each other, I would have been able to reach over and grab the pizza off another table if I wanted. The food was not bad. Very saucy, less cheesy. (My apologies for the terrible quality pictures, my family was hungry!) Because there were so many people I understand that everything takes longer. However, I think our server may have forgotten us after we handed over our card for the tab. It was a good 15-20 minutes before after flagging down other staff, we were able to get our card and leave. I am also disappointed with the 4% service charge. It is stated at the very bottom of the menu, but it still feels like a sneaky way to increase prices. read more

See all

The best pizza I've had since I was in Italy. Fabulous service. Amazing food! I will definitely be back. In the meantime ,I'll be dreaming of this pizza. read more

This Cali girl was impressed! Ambience, service and of course food was AMAZING!!! Pizza and lasagne for 2 thick individuals-we shared and it was enough! read more

Wow this was amazing from the Belgio dulce, no the meatballs, no wait best part- our server Danny. It was very busy the night we visited but the cooks behind the line and bar servers we could see were all hard at work having a good time. It was a nice evening of attentive service and made our date night extra special... thank you Danny & thank you fat olives read more

We were in Flag for a holiday weekend and upon arrival, immediately discovered we should have made a reservation. The place was packed with an hour wait! We were not expecting this on a Sunday night but it was a holiday weekend so maybe it was more busy than usual? We were seated in a separate overflow/private party room, not the main dining area. It was actually really cozy with a fireplace and not as loud as the main area. There was a large party in there so it didn't feel like we were banished away to be forgotten. The pizza and salad was good and actually cheaper for a family of four than the lunch we had at a random place earlier in the day. Would go back but will definitely call ahead next time! read more

See all

Thank you Yelp for a great fine, for the most part. 4.5 stars. Found this place for lunch while on a road trip. Excellent food. Pizza comes out hot and is delicious. Great lunch selection but their main menu is excellent. The staff were super friendly! Our host Teigend and our waiter Aaron are excellent. Attentive. And even went above and beyond to make sure my elderly parents were comfortable. Beautiful restaurant and clean private bathrooms. So why the slight knock? We sat at the pizza bar and got a great view of the open kitchen. Though the pizza chiefs and staff were excellent to the customers, I couldn't help but notice the tension and even the way the staff spoke to each other. I'm hoping it was just friendly chatter among coworkers. But no one seems to smile around each other as they staged the food. Perhaps I'm over thinking it. Still highly recommend. And will visit again if I'm in the area. read more

See all

So tasty. Staff is very friendly and vibes are cozy. They were supper busy and with good reason. :)

I came here for a quick sit down with a friend. We arrived and it was SUPER crowded, this place has definitely built up a loyal clientele, and rightfully so. All we had to eat was the Belgio Dolce Pizza, and wow it was great. The flavors go so well together, I wish we tried other dishes but it was a quick stop. Service was good, food was good, no complaints! read more

Superior customer service and very accommodating. Chicken Alfredo serving can feed a family of 5. Carnivore pizza is very delicious. 5/5 review Highly recommend read more

This place has great traditional italian food and hits the spot. They have a great mix of pizza and pasta. The kitchen is open and fun to sit at the pizza bar and watch. We got the Miss Piggy pizza and the pesto spaghetti and both were amazing. The service was attentive and very nice. The kitchen guys were a joy to watch. Absolutely should come to this place. read more

There are shoutouts for Fat Olives everywhere on the internet when you look up popular restaurants in Flagstaff. Yelp showed positive reviews too, so we decided to make this one of our dinner destinations on our trip. Five of us dined in on a Saturday night; originally they had estimated an about an hour wait but we got our table pretty quickly. Their menu definitely focuses on pizzas but they have other items to select from as well; appetizers, salads, bruschettas, and pastas to name a few. Our sever was very helpful and gave us an overview of the most popular items. They have three VPN certified pizzas available. My understanding of this was that they import ingredients for these pizzas regularly & have a certain method of cooking the pizza. We selected the Margarita D.O.C and Belgio Dolce Pizza. Both pizzas were very good. I liked the more simple Margarita but if you're a fan of meat toppings, the Belgio Dolce is a great choice. They have several others to pick from .. I would maybe get another one of the non-sauce based ones in the future. The only downside of the pizza was that it was maybe a bit salty for us. Otherwise good. We had gotten some olives to start and then tiramisu to finish the meal. Olives, we would probably skip on. But do not skip on the tiramisu! This one probably one of the best tiramisus I've ever had. Super light and fluffy and not overly coffee-y. Loved it. As mentioned before our server was great. He was super attentive and food came out quickly which was nice. All and all, a very positive experience. Would come back! read more

Fat Olives - Tiramisu / Margarita pizza / Olives / Belgio Dolce pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Two of us had dinner at Fat Olives, Flagstaff on 9/14/25. PRO: The food was good. Portions were good. Service was excellent. CON: Prices charged was $1.00 more than the entree menu prices, plus an additional 4% service charge was added. Indiscriminate price adds were very annoying and we will not return to Fat Olives. read more

Great service, delicious food, and very unique meals. we recommend the s'mores pizza but eat in a large group of at least four

Got three pizzas to go. Maragarita, the Belgio Dolce, and bbq chicken! Top favorites were the margarita and belgio. You just can't go wrong with a classic margarita and the belgio was so unique you just have to try it. read more

amazing. the service to the food to the vibe to the everything it's great 100% recommend

We came here after hiking Havasupai and were in the mood for CARBS. The place was packed and the inside was quite small. They have a very small waiting area and two dining areas, one main and the bar area is separate on the other side of the restaurant. We chose to sit at the bar because the wait was nonexistence versus 40 minutes for a table. The food was 100% worth the wait. They have awards and were in food network for a reason. The bartender was nice. I had the white sangria and it was light but not super sweet. They had a HUGE wine list with lots of options. The inside was very authentically decorated and super cute. We started with the Caesar which I thought was FABULOUS. I absolutely loved that their croutons were crumbled and engulfed the salad, it was almost integrated with the dressing which I loved. It was delicious. For dinner we shared two pizzas that were different and honestly some of the most unique delicious pizzas I've ever had. We ordered one of the world renown ones that had prosciutto and pistachios. It was also a white based sauce and it was slightly sweet. It was seriously fantastic. The other pizza was the shrimp one and when they say spicy, THEY MEAN IT. Make sure you like spicy. It was a spice that was still full of flavor. They had ample shrimp and was also a white based sauce. It was also fabulous. I would absolutely make sure to eat here if in the area again! read more

Fat Olives - Caesar - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Fat Olives = W O W. Insanely delicious food, nothing short of amazing service, and a wonderful vibe. Our waiter Joe was spectacular, super friendly, knowledgeable, and timely with his service. Recommended a couple dishes that we loved and provided our dogs a complimentary side of chicken which was greatly appreciated by all parties. Shout out to Joe! The FOOD. Hot, fresh, and just well made. They are one of 90 restaurants certified by the Italian government to make certain dishes (3 different kinds of pizzas). The stone they use to cook the pizza is from Pompeii, and the ingredients are carefully sourced as well. There is only 1 fat olives in Arizona and it is located in Flagstaff, and definitely worth the stop. The Italian sodas were delicious, the food itself was amazing, and we ended up doing dessert (tiramisu and pistachio cannoli) and I really don't think you can go wrong with any dish here. Try it all! read more

See all

Not only is the staff friendly and very accommodating but the food is just to die for! It's hard to find good pizza but this place has officially been our "special events" dinner place! It even gives Italian vibes :) read more

Ordered take out pizzas for a party. Efficient pickup. The Pizzas had good flavor in some areas but the pizzas were cut in different portion sizes which left some pizza without many toppings on them. And the toppings seemed to all be clumped on one side of the pizzas. Additionally some of the pizza had more than a bit of a char from the fire and needed to be removed so it didn't make the whole pizza taste burnt. read more

Fat Olives - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

The pizza was standard fare, nothing special like the other reviews mention. And on top of standard fare you get charged additional service fees, here's the thing, if you're going to do that, I want the pizza to be memorable. I don't want soggy crust pizza or pizza that flops when I hold it in my hand. read more

The best Italian food Northern Arizona has to offer! I'm talking friendly, neighborhood bar vibes with food that surpasses its upscale peers. What I loved: The expansive menu of pizzas and pastas. I don't really like noodles (please don't revoke my elite badge for this) but I tried the lasagna and it's the best of the best! Even better, the pizza is certified by *the* Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana, and while you might find a nod from Naples a bit pretentious, I promise you--they don't miss. I had the marmalade (soppresata, arugala, bacon marmalade, calabrian chili) and while far from traditional the flavor was absolutely explosive. What I liked: The roasted artichokes are delightful. And the creme brulee cheesecake is a fine dessert. Absolutely do not skip dessert here! Service is outstanding, and prices are so fair for the quality of dishes you'll do a double take. Everyone from the desert regions of Arizona takes a trip to Flag to cool off. And nobody should leave town without putting themselves into a food coma at Fat Olives first. read more

See all

Amazing food- we got pizza! Staff is super friendly as well. Happy hour is great. 10/10 recommend!

We ordered pizza to go. The servers were very helpful by including all the utensils we needed for the road. The pizza was delicious- wood fired, thin crust, and a delicious gluten free crust!! We always ask for ours to be fired a little longer to have a bit of crisp to it and they did it perfectly! read more

Ok food and flavor. Maybe not my favorite recipes Our waitress was outstanding and so was the best sangria and tiramisu. Definitely don't like how they bill you and add a percent on it instead of just raising their prices!! They do have gluten free pasta!! read more

Fat Olives - Sangria - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Great decor and cozy feeling but the food is subpar, slow and arrived cold. Our waitress was sweet, but did not seem overly concerned.

Food is crazy good. You will not be disappointed. Best in Flag for sure. Staff is well trained and service is great. Perfect ambiance and nice outdoor area. read more

See all

So hungry I forgot take a picture and the meal was delicious. My daughter had the lunch spaghetti and meatballs. Meatballs and meat sauce were some of the best I have had. My margarita pizza was good. Next time I think we'll be swapping dishes since we both preferred the other's. The service was excellent. Happy to find this gem and look forward to our next visit when in Flagstaff. read more

Some of the best Italian food in flagstaff. And if you are accompanied by a child and ask for some dough, they'll give the kids pizza dough to play with. And the portions are giant! The service is okay as long as you don't go during rush hours. And it's nice inside and is really cool if you sit at the pizza bar, where you can see their pizza oven! read more

This well-known Flagstaff institution is located on Route 66 in Flagstaff. They offer a range of Italian food--including lunch specials that include a pizza, Caesar salad and sodas! We found that they are very popular, and you might need a reservation on a weekend night. We had the pizza that Guy Fieri recommended on Diners and Dives. I would recommend it for a good Italian meal. (Also--our server was great at explaining the whole menu and giving us suggestions!) read more

Fat Olives - Belgio Dolce Pizza (Guy's favorite) - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona