Fattusco&#x27;s

You can't go wrong at Piezano's any day of the week. The specialty slices are reasonably priced …read more Had my go-to Veggie slice and ventured to try the Baked Clam slice . The Veggie was loaded with many vegetables baked to perfection. And that Baked Clam slice was incredibly tasty. Baked Clam filling baked perfectly into Piezano's amazing crust. Everyone is so friendly at the counter as well as the dining room crew. Such a comfy spot in Northport to dine with friends or family.

A great local spot to grab slices. They have a huge counter of options. Some of their slices are…read morethicker but taste light (vs. heavy dough Chicago style pizza). All of the pizza is fresh and hit the spot. Highly recommend the Buffalo chicken slice. Grabbed a few slices to go and they did not disappoint. There is a decent size dining area to eat and looked like plenty of space to sit during lunch time. Everyone behind the counter was so kind! Will definitely be back!

Welcome to Piezanos

Cute menu

See all

La Porta

4.0(137 reviews)

1.9 mi

I visited La Porta on a Saturday afternoon for lunch and enjoyed the experience. First of all, the…read moreNorthport village is beautiful so I'd suggest taking a walk around Main St and the nearby parks. Both the food and service at La Porta were excellent. My wife and I ordered 2 pies: Al Funghi and a half Margherita/half 4 cheese and all 3 were delicious and we still had 2 slices left. Prices were also fair. They don't take reservations but around 4pm there were many tables available. Keep in mind if you go during peak hours here may be a wait. There's street parking but at the nearby parks there are free parking lots (5 minute walk).

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was packed. Went here at 8:00PM on a Friday, was able to get a table with no reservation. Place was clear by time we left. Price - $110 (2 appetizers, pizza, 2 drinks, tip) Food - 2/5 - tasted premade. Service - 3/5 - fine and on par. Ambiance - 4/5 - decent vibe inside. Overall - 3/5 - ok spot that doesn't have the best food in town. Did have high expectations going in here but food was a let down. Pizza was ok but appetizers tasted old and potentially premade (i.e. not made fresh). Drinks were fine. Service was good but waitress was noticeably put off when we didn't order entrees. Inside was actually really nice. Open kitchen design and renovated nicely. Pizza oven is on display too. Cool place but not worth a stop. Best Dish - Carmine Pizza Would Return - Not Likely

Many available seats at 4pm on a Saturday. But if you go later there may be a wait.

Mozzarella gigante

See all

Sicilian mule

Gino's of Northport

3.1(88 reviews)

1.0 mi

The customer service in this place is terrible. I put in order to pick up on Saturday August 8th…read morearound 1pm. I went to pick up the order around 130pm. I went to the register and told the young man my name and I was here for pick up ,he read back my order which was incorrect. He look up to see who took the order the young lady was at the back register. She came right over with an attitude like she took the order it can't be wrong. Then continue to agrue with me about it. She was telling I ordered something that my family would never even eat. I told her to keep the order I dont like her attitude and walk out the store. This is not the first time I had issues with ordering over the phone. They have messed up the order several times. They do have so good options but there are too many good places around the Northport area to deal with that kind of customer service. I call Gino's of Kings Park right away had no issues. They seem to put more quality people answering there phones.

I've been eating at Gino's for over 12 years plus and always have fantastic food there along with…read morethe service and Alex and the rest of the staff. I made the mistake one day going to Piezanos and I had a hair in my food and I went back the next day cause I ate late and little Joey the manager was very rude not professional and definitely does not know the hospitality business so stay away from there & he wouldn't even give me my money back and I brought the food back so don't go there... Gino's is the place to go & the Commack location.

Nice dining area

Sausage Pepper Onion

See all

Timothy's Pizzeria

4.5(42 reviews)

3.0 mi

I had an amazing experience with ordering from here. I ordered a large pie, mozzarella sticks,…read morefried raviolis and cheese garlic bread. I ordered this online and they use the slice app for delivery. Everything came fast and hot. The mozzarella sticks were huge and long! They also supplied a huge tray of marinara sauce. The fried raviolis were so crispy. The pizza pie was really good! The only thing that I wasn't crazy about was the cheesy garlic bread. But otherwise it was amazing! I loved it and will be ordering again.

SOOO good! come with my girlfriend all the time. $10 for 2 amazing slices and a drink. Can't ask…read morefor better. Staff is great, my guy is always so friendly. They have their own parking lot so it's very assessable. Right next to millpond so it's a nice location as well. Quick drive to the water or Herron park. 5 stars!

This pizza looks absolutely beautiful.

See all

Buffalo Soldier

Dough & Co. Pizza - Northport

4.0(6 reviews)

0.1 mi

Excellent NY style pizza, crispy/chewy ratio the best I've had in LI, maybe even better than…read moreL'industrie in BK. Their dough is now my go to for my at home backyard high heat Gozney pizza oven. A nice high hydration you won't get from most pizza restaurants or worse a grocery store.

Really good pizza not flimsy.? Chicken Caesar wrap was good but a bit disappointing. Too much…read morelettuce and a very hard wrap. Chicken was good though.

See all

Sardo's Pizzeria

4.3(43 reviews)

3.3 mi

Pizza is absolutely amazing as well as all of the kitchen food. You can never go wrong with any of…read morethe options. The owners and staff are super friendly and absolutely hilarious. I definitely recommend. You really can't go wrong here. Great job Sardos!

Went in since it's been a couple of years and it's not the same Sardis as when it opened. Grandma…read morepie totally Soggy and wet. Not even worth this review as something must have changed. Old saying nothing is forever. Back to Broadway pizza where it's always consistent and zero attitudes behind the counter. Too bad for Sardo's.

Assorted pies at the counter

10-9-25. Sweet chili chicken slice. Very good.

See all

Chicken Rolls

Amore Pizza

3.9(74 reviews)

2.2 mi

Slices and the full pies are just a little better here than other nearby pizza places…read more The crunch on the crust is top notch. Sauce is way above average. Just a very very solid pie. Day to day Staff, management, ownership are always welcoming!

Simple, welcoming ambiance. No nonsense food. Great, crisp pizza and quick, efficient service. I…read morelove this place. I am from Orange County, CA and visit the used bookshop across the street, owned by an old friend and her husband. I always stop at Amore's for a couple slices before a long drive. Thanks, Amore! I will be back.

See all

Intermezzo Wood-Fired Pizzeria & Ristorante

3.2(105 reviews)

1.0 mi

•$$$

While I can't speak to their white linen service, they do offer slices, and baby, this is by far…read morethe best BBQ Chicken pizza I've ever had. Sorry Schlotsky's. The grill char taste that permeates the chucks of fresh poultry and cheese is a delight for the senses, my friends. As good as Alfredo's Pizza Cafe. IYKYK

The prices on the menu are laughable. I get that most of Northport is expensive, but if you're…read moregoing to charge $15 for a meatball parm hero, maybe remember to fill the entire sandwich and put more than a dripping of sauce on. 95% of the time, a meatball parm is 2 meals for me, and I was able to eat this in one sitting because it was mainly just bread and what seemed like a half portion of meatballs. I noticed right away when I picked it up that it felt oddly light in my hand. You can't overcharge AND have small portions. The going rate on LI for a meatball parm is 10-12$. $12 for 6 wings? $9 for TOMATO SOUP!?? C'mon...

Front entrance of restaurant.

ORECCHIETTE BARESE

See all

Penne Basilico

Cazzio’s Pizza & Pasta

4.0(28 reviews)

2.9 mi

Local pizza spots that is reliable and very good. The cazzio slice with mushrooms and a marsala…read moretype sauce is always a great choice-unique and delicious. We have also used cazzio's for catering and all went smoothly. There are 2 other pizza places closer to my house but I drive a little father for cazzio's since it is worth it : )

This spot is newer to the neighborhood, and there are some good folks who work here. Very friendly…read moreand enjoy serving their customers, and also very appreciative of your business when there are so many pizza spots to choose from. First off, the variety, this place has some crazy combos for pies and slices, as I was reading through the menu I was saying, "wow that's an interesting mix" so they try out different pies for you to try. Also, pricing is very accommodating, this place has some amazing deals throughout the week, and in todays economy that is a serious help in deciding where to get a pie. Finally, quality, I had the Drunken Grandma Slice and Buffalo Chicken slice, she had the Chicken Bacon Ranch and White Slice. All around really delicious, Grandma Slice with the Vodka Sauce was the champion for me. Great place, will return, recommend for a pie or slice!

See more unrecommended reviews

Drunken Grandma Slice and White Slice

4 Knots Hot out The Oven. Fresh. Delicious

See all

Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice and Buffalo Chicken Slice

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

30 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Verjin H.

2 years ago

If you're searching for the pinnacle of pizza perfection in Northport, look no further than Fattusco's. After a few hours of hiking, our quest for pizza we stumbled upon Fattusco's, and from that moment on, if we are in the mood for pizza we only order from Fattusco's. There is no turning back! Fattusco's isn't just a pizza place; it's an experience. With a mouthwatering array of options. The crust? Absolute perfection. It strikes the delicate balance between crispy and doughy, providing the ideal foundation for every topping combination. But let's talk about the sauce. Oh, the sauce! It's a symphony of flavors that dance on your taste buds, leaving you craving more with each bite. From classic favorites to inventive creations, Fattusco's offers something for everyone. And once you've experienced their pizza, there's simply no going back. So, to all the pizza lovers out there, if you haven't tried Fattusco's yet, you're missing out on a slice of heaven. Trust me, once you take that first bite, you'll understand why Fattusco's has become our go-to pizza place in the neighborhood. read more

Kelly F.

8 years ago

We can not say enough great things about this wonderful, family owned restaurant!! We dine in & take out very often and are never disappointed. It is a great place for a family dinner. Food is delicious. Gluten free? No problem! They have extensive GF options. We go so often we have been able to sample almost everything on the menu. Seafood is always fresh (red snapper is my sons favorite), pizza is always cooked to perfection (cauliflower crust with a pesto sauce is a must try), not to mention their incredible pasta dishes. Try one of their amazing soups or salads to start! Remarkable service from the moment you walk in the door. We come in for a quick Sunday dinner and end up spending hours talking to the staff & enjoying our wine. This place is a GEM in our town and we are so lucky to have it close by! read more

Santa L.

15 years ago

I am so impressed with the food at Fattusco's. I can't wait to go back for more. The menu is unbelievable and offers authentic Italian food from Italy. It is the same taste as if I was in Italy. The Chicken Fattusco chicken with pears and gorgonzola with a demi glaze sauce is out of this world. It was so hard to choose from the menu. The grilled vegetable panini and the stuffed pizza along with Nonna's pizza and Grandpa's pizza were incredible. I just can't wait to go back to try more dishes on the menu. Besides the food, Owner Rob Scalza is a sweetheart. He makes everyone feel like family. My family just loves going there. Besides the dishes, the desserts are fantastic. I highly recommend going to this wonderful place to eat. read more

Robert D.

12 years ago

Great pizza, friendly service, The chicken parmesan dinner and the meat balls are better then a 4 star rated Italian restaurant I've. been there 5 or 6 times and all the dinner entrees i had were always cooked to perfection.. You can tell from the taste of the food that they only use the best ingredients, and the tomato sauce, OMG came straight out of grandma's play book.. Also the menu has many different dinners to taste and enjoy..I highly recommend this place for a family looking to enjoy a fun night out , with great food, good people..and you dont have too spend a lot of money..Just Eat drink and be happy...Berto. read more

Bradford P.

13 years ago

There are a lot of pizza places in the area and this is by far the best - great and fresh ingredients, good tasting crust. We were thrilled to find it having moved out from the city and struggled to replicate our city favorites. So that was our starting point but then we tried the pastas (creative, flavorful) and the salads (fresh, refreshing). The food is really good. If you are in the area, try going in with a good bottle of wine and eating there with a few good friends. Very fun. Rob the owner is a great guy and will cook you anything if you just ask. read more

Joel B.

8 years ago

2/2019 Hands Down our favorite place to dine!!! The BEST perfect portioned Chicken.Marsala, Francaise, penne a la vodka, and salad PERIOD! Very limited seating as the main dining area is under construction. Poor reviews??? I don't get it! It can get a little loud while dining cause the patrons clearly enjoy where they are! Staff is all in- hands on and they treat you like a loved family member. This place is a Gem! Also, BYOB! That's a REAL PLUS!!! (more budget for food!)There are soft drinks, water etc. Make a reservation, but DON'T take my table! read more

Diane C.

8 years ago

I never write reviews but thought I should give credit where credit is deserved! My family and I eat at Fattuscos about 3 times a week and dine in with friends once a week. We never had a bad meal. Food is always consistent and delicious! The owners Marc and Virginia are the nicest people you will ever meet! They treat you like you are sitting around their kitchen table. I am gluten free and they always accommodate me. Definitely try out this restaurant. You will not be disappointed. read more

Georgia R.

13 years ago

By far the BEST pizza in this area! I lived in NYC for 11 years and got spoiled by great pizza there. Fattusco's is the only place that can compare. The only thing I'd say is they are a litle expensive. BUT, it is worth it. best grandma slices around. Also they have a signature pizza with portobellos and balsamic vinaigrette. yummy. thank god this place is around for when I just want a slice of GOOD pizza! Brick oven style crust too. read more

Tom T.

15 years ago

FATTUSCO'S IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA IN LONG ISLAND . I work upstairs and I eat this pizza everyday since they opened .I have gained 5 lbs already and dont care . Everyday I am in there for lunch I hear a new customer say how this is the best Buffalo , BBQ, Veggi, 4 cheese pizza they have ever had . I'm not just saying this and I'm not realted to them in any way the pizza is that good ! I know they are going to be a huge success . read more

Valerie G.

13 years ago

Great find!! Have never posted on Yelp before and this place prompted me to do so. Pasta is good and pizza is outstanding. You have to ignore the location; it was worth the trip although later we learned they deliver. Feels like family and if you are Italian this might be what it would feel like to eat at home. It should be noted that Yelp filtered out my review (!!) so i have gone in and hope this time it will post. read more

L S.

15 years ago

What a variety of pizza! And each one is great! Panninis are awesome especially the roasted porchetta and the roasted veggies! They have delicious meals with the quality of a fine restaurant! All made with fresh and imported ingredients. The staff is friendly and the place is always neat and clean. read more

Marlene And Frank C.

11 years ago

This is without a doubt the best Italian food ever outside of Italy. Everything is especially fresh and creative and so delicious. We are Italian-Americans who cook extensively at home and I am prepared to turn in my apron and pots because everything here beats home cooking. read more

Lisa M.

15 years ago

I was visiting relatives on Long Island and we went to Fattusco's for lunch. The food is amazing! Everything is so fresh and the staff is very friendly and accomodating. They made whatever we asked for, even if it wasn't on the menu. Definitely will be going back again! read more

Madeline B.

10 years ago

The food was a little bland for us plus the service seemed a little rude and standoffish. We aren't really picky people but we felt very uncomfortable. Probably won't go back it's a little out of the way for us. read more

Tiffany T.

8 years ago

This is a great place ,, my husband and I stumbled across here as we just moved to the area ,,, the food is so phenomenal ,, the service is just as amazing ! It is our def go to place for now on !!! read more

Denise R.

14 years ago

We have eaten in and taken out. They have fresh ingredients and amaze us each time. The dishes are always great and original. My husband is Italian and its his favorite! read more

Adriana F.

5 years ago

Excellent food and service. Owners are wonderful and staff is very attentive. Never had any issues dining in or out from here. Thank you!

Juliana C.

2 years ago

I seriously love this place. Everything from the food to the service. Actually impeccable. Best pizza spot in northport by a landslide.

Regan M.

2 years ago

Truly the best pizza ever. The owner is the best and there are so many options to choose from. I've never been disappointed 11/10

Kolby A.

2 years ago

It had pizza, tasted good, the people were nice/respectful, and the restaurant it's self seemed neat, clean, and tight

Fattusco's - italian - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Fattusco's also viewed

Mema's

4.3

(108 reviews)

Memas Treats customers ,and size of orders equal in all ways. Last night I asked about Neapolitan…read morePizza, This Staff member gave all details down to type of flour. I usually order a Greek Salad, Chicken Parm Hero, or specialty slice. From the Food Quality to the takeout service I give 5 Stars. Thanks JP

So far so good! The fresh garlic and perfected flavor on that shrimp and garlic slice were to die…read morefor. If they made that as a regular pie with some red sauce id like to try it. So much potential there. Have T had their regular slice yet though. The meatballs were actually very good and better than the last four places ball I've tried.... . The stuffed knots were understaffed and under cooked but somehow I know they are still good and if they'd just fix that it'd be incredible.

Chefs of New York

3.6

(141 reviews)

While I was visiting this establishment, a six-year-old girl and her 40-year-old father came in to…read morebuy pizza. The owner "made a joke" to the little girl, six years old, maybe eight years old. "Is this your boyfriend?" I thought that was very strange. To ask a six-year-old girl if she was dating a 40-year-old man. Very inappropriate. I spoke up and I said that the comment was weird, and the owner and what seemed to be his son were defending it saying that it was a Italian culture thing and it was funny. I'm sorry I just think that it's inappropriate, and at this point in time we can maybe move away from the pedophilic jokes. The pizza and food there is pretty good, but I personally don't support behavior like that.

Delicious sauce and pizza. The Upside Down pie was excellent! The house made salad dressing needs…read moresome work as do the garlic knots. Ours were raw and doughy on the inside. Soft drinks were $4 but we had free refills. The restaurant is casual and very accommodating to young families as noticed while we were eating. The shared parking lot is very busy and tiny so be careful when parking.

Don Jono's Pizzeria

4.4

(70 reviews)

As a transplant from Queens, this pizza reeks of said boro. Long Island pizza is too thick, too…read morecheesy, undercooked, and overwhelmingly bloatedly bland. As for your Traditional Neopolitan, The Don has a perfectly balanced sauce, and just the right ratio of cheese. To be safe, I always order Well-Done, but I really do like the char flavour of a hot oven! We have had some other food here- Chicken Française, which is spectacular. Nice crunch on the chicken, loads of lemon and fresh herbs. Garlic Knots- small, packed with the purest Garlic, Oil, and Parmesan. Grandma Pie. Haven't had not a single bad bite food in all of the years. Coming back to visit NY, there is always the anticipation of taking a pie out.

SO GOOD!! The best garlic knots in Long Island... and pizza reminds me of Queens ones! People say…read moretoo little cheese but I think its perfect ratio. I dont like when cheese slides off my pizza. Glad to find this pizza spot with ubereats!

Pizzaiolo Gourmet Eatery

4.0

(65 reviews)

Best Pizza in long island queens brooklyn new york united states the world. Family owned and…read moreoperated friendly staff. Cozy but plenty of seats.

If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! I recently threw a party for 120 people at my home and…read moreworked with Dom from Pizzaiolo in Commack--and let me tell you, he was an absolute lifesaver. From start to finish, Dom made the entire process stress-free. He helped me figure out the perfect menu, the right quantities, and even recommended appetizers that ended up being a huge hit. On the day of the party, Dom went above and beyond by arranging two separate deliveries--one for appetizers and another for the main dishes a few hours later--so we didn't have to worry about keeping the food warm. That level of service alone deserves five stars! And the food? OUTSTANDING. From the garlic knot meatball parm sliders (which disappeared in minutes!) to the creamy penne alla vodka, everything exceeded my expectations. My guests, who came from all over the country to celebrate my parents' 50th anniversary, could not stop raving about the food. Dom was easy to talk to, flexible, and truly cared about making our event perfect. I can't recommend Pizzaiolo and Dom enough. If you're planning a party (or just looking for some good food), this is the place to call--you won't be disappointed!

Mama Angelina's Pizzeria Restaurant

3.3

(147 reviews)

Went for lunch with the family…read more Mozzarella Sticks good Rigatoni Vodka excellent Chicken broccoli rabe hero good Good value for the mone

If this was five years ago, they would've had five stars! I used to eat here everyday for lunch and…read moreit was always delicious. I will go there with my mom and a friend of mine pretty regularly like I would drive from Patchogue to get their pizza. Even after I stopped working in the area... The ambience is elevated peace joint, and the service is always wonderful I went there by myself and felt it just fell off! It returned two more times with my mother and friend that I frequently done there with and unfortunately, they both agreed :(

Bellina's Pizza

4.1

(38 reviews)

There food from soup to salad to pizza hero's fantastic ! The grilled chicken with broccoli rabe…read moreOMG the best! The service is really good and friendly staff.

There are numerous pizza choices in the area, but most places don't get the crust quite right…read more Unfortunately, this was no different. The cheese slice had a nice crunch on the outside with a soft interior, and technically, it was cooked perfectly. The problem was that the crust had almost no flavor. Perhaps the dough wasn't salted enough or wasn't allowed to ferment long enough. Whatever the reason, even good sauce and cheese can't make up for a tasteless crust. With pizza, everything has to come together. The sauce was also overly acidic for my taste. I prefer a slightly sweeter sauce, and this one seemed heavily seasoned with dried oregano. Given all the glowing reviews, I expected something that stood out. Instead, I felt the pizza was no better than roughly 80% of the other pizzerias in the area. The crust desperately needs more flavor, whether that comes from a longer fermentation, more salt, or a combination of both.

Three Bambinos Pizzeria

4.4

(52 reviews)

I had food delivered and it was there at the promised time…read more I love the chicken franchese hero. I ordered extra sauce on the side is amazing. The buffalo wings are also very good.

4-11-25. My first time here. Ordered a chicken Marsala…read moreslice and a regular slice. Both were delicious. Prices are on par with the competition. Staff was fast and friendly. There's a decent amount of seating if you choose to dine in. If I'm in the area I certainly wouldn't mind returning.

The Pie at Salvatore's

4.1

(178 reviews)

My wife and I walked in not knowing they didn't serve pizza but the slice. I convinced her to stay…read moreand order and see how it was. Thankfully we did, because the food was incredible and we were super pleased. I wouldn't say hidden gem, this place is a pizza goldmine! We started with the Caesar salad which was so fresh and delicious. We ordered a small Neapolitan and a small Supreme pizza for dinner & WOW were they delicious. I grew up and Queens & my expectation for pizza is high. This met that and more! The pizza is thin crust & ingredients are so fresh. This is our default "go to" spot in Bay Shore, and we have brought numerous friends and family here. Not one bad meal!

Homey pizzeria, small menu but really good pizza, can bring the entire family. Good wine super…read moreaffordable. Service is excellent. I was craving a salad, the Caesar salad hit the spot. Opted for a glass of Pinot Nior which was fresh. I am a Pinot Nior girl so I can tell when a bottle has been opened for a while. The wine is affordable and does not taste cheap. The garlic bread is a huge portion with a good amount of garlic. I love garlic so it was spot on.

Gino's of Northport

3.1

(88 reviews)

Nonna's Pizzeria

3.4

(97 reviews)