Timothy's Pizzeria

Amazing barbecue on long island! We got the ribs and brisket with green beans, mashed potatoes and…read morewatermelon salad. It was more than enough food for 2 people but no complaints!

The food was delicious! I will there had been a bit more greens in the collard greens, but the…read moredifferent sauces were very nice with tender ribs. The mashed potatoes were my favorite and the cocktail was a nice amount of sweetness.

See all

Brown liquor

Old Fields

4.0(334 reviews)

1.3 mi

Went here for my boyfriend's birthday dinner. Ambience is so cozy and well designed. We had shrimp…read morecocktail and arancini to start- both delicious, the Cacio e Pepe sauce for the arancini was new and very good but it definitely is not a light app. For dinner I had the beef and goat cheese salad- not super filling but lots of beets and pecans which I enjoyed a lot. My boyfriend loves the skirt steak here and the mashed potatoes were amazing so 10/10 there. The food came out quickly and our waitress was pretty prompt with service. Overall great dinner and excited to try other dishes next time

Find out for yourself why this place has had great success with their marinated steaks since 1956!…read more Dark wood inside, fireplace always crackling, comfy booths, and an old school bar. Service is always attentive & informative. Every item on the menu hits the mark for everything you hope it to be. I can never get over their Old Bay Fries or their perfect burger. I dream about this place. (Please bring back the Banana Old Fashioned!!) Parking next to the railroad.

Steak special at the bar

See all

Happy Hour Bluepoint oysters

Salted. On The Harbor

4.0(278 reviews)

1.2 mi

everything. The service was perfect, not too much, very attentive, very friendly, very…read moreprofessional. The food was outstanding. I had the strawberry salad with grilled shrimp. A little pricey, but worth it. Really nice ambience, felt very comfortable and a little chic!

The place is small (around 10 tables) so you will probably need reservations (unless you want to…read moresit at the bar (which takes half of the sitting room). We opted for two different margaritas which we thoroughly enjoyed. The menu had a chicken sandwich that came back by popular demand and I'm so glad they did bring it back. The thick chick was very good, and it was accompanied by one of the best fries I ever had. My wife's dish was the Asian inspired rice and steaks. She said it was the best dish she's ever eaten but I think most of that came from the margarita, but I do agree it was very good. It was a very pleasant experience at Salted

Inside

Short Rib hash 10/10

See all

Drinks

Elsie Lane Huntington

4.2(96 reviews)

We were at Elsie Lane yesterday for my granddaughters first birthday celebration…read more I cannot say enough about how GREAT everything was! The atmosphere was perfect - bright with plenty of room to mingle. The food was absolutely delicious and the service was wonderful - the best (kudos to the entire team)! The day was perfect and we are all looking forward to celebrating at Elsie Lane again soon!!

The other night I ordered take out from here. I ordered the boneless wings with Nashville sauce and…read moreFrench fries on the side. The wings were cooked pretty good, not greasy. The fries were okay as well. I enjoyed the Nashville sauce a lot. It was not too spicy. The food was made quickly and delivered quickly as well.

Fun atmosphere & great staff!

Fried Chicken Mac Quesadilla

See all

Buffalo Caesar Chicken Sando

The Special Cup

4.5(175 reviews)

Well. I'm not a coffee drinker, but I do drink chai so I can tell you that both of the chai lattes…read moreI've had here are TOP. Pricing is reasonable, shop has an upstate or even Vermont feeling. Staff is kind and patient. Polite. Lemme talk about the food for a second. Got the Feeling Tot burrito. Subbed cheddar for smoke Gouda and added bacon. HOLY HELL. This burrito brought up emotions I haven't felt for a breakfast in centuries. Warm and melty, it wasn't like any of these greasy, wet, fat covered offerings from other delis or breakfast shops around the island. Or that I've had in NY in general. They chopped the bacon, which let's be serious here, is the only way to do it. Eggs were fluffy, light. Cheese was nothing short of smoked magnificence. But the pièce de résistance, the glue that brings your taste buds to their knees, the tots. If you don't like tots, you're wrong. And these tots were somehow crispy and soft. No oil, no sog. The chipotle sauce brings it all home and then they grill the whole damn thing and serve it to you on a platter of gold and diamonds. At least that's how it felt. Do I recommend this? Uh duhhhhhh. 5 stars. All day.

Hands down the best breakfast burrito in the area. There's absolutely no comparison. We got the…read moreFeeling Tot and sub the cheddar for Gouda and added bacon. Can't praise enough. This coffee spot has cozy upstate vibes too and the baristas are super chill. Love this place.

Lemon Poppy Pancakes

See all

Latte

The Shed Restaurant - Huntington

4.3(1.1k reviews)

The food was phenomenal. The food looked good and tasted even better. The serving team was…read moreprofessional and friendly. I've enjoyed The Shed in Sayville. It was good to see the other outlets were of equal quality. ( Now, you need to put one in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn! )

This spot was ok. I just needed a quick bite…read more Picked up their sea bass sandwich and a small Caesar salad. Um the Caesar actually tasted bland. Usually, I would complain that places put too much dressing. Oddly, this time they didn't put enough. They over cooked my fish. I did enjoy the slaw though. I feel like they make better drinks than food. I sat at the bar and the bartenders were pretty awesome. Knocking out drinks and they seemed to just genuinely care it was right. They checked on me a few times. I didn't have time to fix my food. Honestly, if you can't get a Caesar salad right... It'll be a waste of time hoping it would be better a 2nd time.

Interior

Short Rib Melt

See all

Bloody Mary

Buffalo Grille

3.4(81 reviews)

1.3 mi

First time trying their wings and they were deliciously fried to perfection! You have a choice of 6…read morepc (comes with fries), 12 pc, 24 pcs,, 60pcs or 120 pcs with several sauce options. I went with their Cajun choice which is like a slightly spicy dry rub. OMG!! Blows wing stop out the water in my opinion. Their chicken fingers are equally delicious. It's fried with breadcrumbs instead of that heavy flour based breading. You can actually taste the chicken! Honestly all of their food choices are great! It's a very small take out spot and doesn't look that spectacular Aesthetically but the items coming out that kitchen will blow your mind! 10/10 highly recommend

Stopped in for lunch today to this unpretentious establishment. It's not fancy and it appears,(at…read moreleast on Sunday), that lots of people order wings for takeout rather than eat in. I think ordering is usually done at the counter but we were served at a table by a very sweet server. We ordered onion rings to start and where asked if we wanted sauces, we chose ranch, horseradish and barbecue. The order came out hot and fresh and perfectly cooked. You can tell a well cooked ring because when you bite it you get a clean break without pulling onion from the rest of the breading. We had a chicken Cesar wrap which was stuffed with grilled chicken and a garlicky dressing and their Voodoo sandwich consisting of batter fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, grilled onions, mushrooms and bacon. The sandwich was served on a toasted hero roll and was huge. We had baked potato's with butter and sour cream. Everything was good so if you're looking for good food in a super casual atmosphere this is the place. Oh and they have bubble gum machines !!!

Bubble gum machine

6 pc Chicken fingers (I ate the other 3)

See all

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Laurel Road Cafe & Deli

4.6(24 reviews)

1.8 mi

Great deli in the area. Good breakfast, and a rare nice space to actually sit down to eat. Interior…read moreis clean, and the little patio they have out front is super nice on a sunny day. Don't sleep on the lunch also, the hot bar they have is great. This chicken was crazy good. Oh and all the staff are super friendly

Come on. We just got multiple sandwiches and the farmer's omelette. The omelette is advertised as…read morecoming with homefries. There were none in the box. Two of the sandwiches had sausage on them and between the sandwiches, it didn't look like they made up a whole sausage patty. There is 1 cut "strip" of sausage on each half. If you ran out of sausage, say that when we order? If this is how you always make your sandwiches then that is abysmal.

Shrimps tacos lettuce pico de gallo lime and salsa Verde tortillas

See all

Main menu

Vauxhall

4.0(538 reviews)

Good beer. Good burgers. Good Mac n cheese. Good wings. Good fries! What's not to like?…read more It's always a good time with good food and drinks. This place always hits consistent home runs!

10 years later, they must be doing something right. Sunday…read moreevening, it was not crowded at all but still very very noisy. The waitress was nice. We started with the pretzel and the artichoke dip, they were both ok. I shared a burger with my mom, it was a 2 patty smash burger, no cheese. It had cooked onions, pickles and some kind of sauce, we both liked it. We also had truffle fries. Everyone at our table got a burger and everyone liked them. We had to get out of there because it was so noisy, even the staff were pretty much screaming. Next time I'll sit outside!

Inside

Sweet Potato Tots

See all

Amazing filthy martini

Sur Argentinian Steakhouse

4.3(436 reviews)

3.3 mi

•$$$

Food was amazing. Celebrated husbands birthday, staff was great. We had two kids under 4 and the…read moreambiance was good

5 stars: Paella valenciana 5 stars: very attentive service…read more(notably the waiter who would sing/celebrate birthdays) 4 stars: skirt steak 3 stars: tres leches Other notes: easy to make reservations online, street parking can be tough on peak nights, skip the empanadas and Americano coffee, many tvs in main dining room - we saw mexico/Uruguay soccer.

Chaja

Mar y Tierra

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mo A.

0

38

0

12 years ago

From the moment you walk through the door you are treated like family. I had the BBQ chicken pie it was incredible. This is great Italian restaurant food at pizzeria prices... what a great find! read more

Mark B.

0

3

0

8 years ago

The best deep dish chicken slices you will ever have, we get our pizza here every time.

Nancy w.

110

2

0

18 years ago

best deep dish barbeque chicken pizza...HANDS DOWN!

Timothy's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Timothy's Pizzeria also viewed

Benedetto's Pizza & Pasta

4.1

(11 reviews)

Wow!!!! Was I pleasantly surprised. Gave this place a try yesterday, Monday, 6/29/26. Saw they had…read moresome family specials, and being we are good eaters, took advantage of one of them. We ordered a pizza, penne ala vodka, chicken parm hero and garlic nots, all for $30!!! The food was excellent!!! The pizza was great, the chicken parm was fantastic, and my wife who is " the world's greatest pasta critic,"" even said the penne was good!! Not to mention, you just can't beat the price!! This is my new go to spot for pizza and things. I highly recommend you give this place a try, you won't be sorry!! PS They made " PIZZA GREAT AGAIN""

I liked the pizzas we had. One plain was cooked to perfection and the sauce was tasty and flavorful…read more The second was a plain Sicilian pizza, full bodied and weighty. The sauce was a little different but acceptable. The pie had large slabs of mozzarella and the whole thing was cooked in a pan at the time of ordering. I will go back.

Vitos Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.5

(17 reviews)

My husband and I went to Vito's yesterday for our weekly Pizza Night. It was our first time…read morevisiting. Since we were staying and eating in, no one directed us to sit. We actually stood at the register, ordered off of the paper takeout menus, and then walked over to a table. There were no silverware, salt, pepper, etc, on the table, only cheap paper napkins. Yes, I know.. it is a pizzeria, but at other places if you are eating in, the table is a bit more welcoming. Speaking of welcoming, I question this quote from their website: "Come to Vito's, where you enter as a guest but you leave as family. Hope to shake hands with you soon." One of the owners was working that night and she walked right by us, never smiling or "shaking our hand." She didn't even ask if we enjoyed the food. We were the only patrons eating at that time. The pizzeria is very small. She couldn't have missed us, considering I looked directly at her, wondering who she was at first while she took a seat at the next table. Now let's move onto the food, the real reason we came here. We ordered an antipasti salad and asked if could be chopped. The funny thing is...yes, they chopped the veggies into teeny tiny bites but left the meat and cheese whole. I should have taken a picture of the salad because we thought it was quite unusual. BTW, the salad dressing was delicious! We also ordered the Margherita pizza. It was very good. I loved the crust and cheese but the sauce needed to be a little sweeter. The only other thing we ordered were drinks. Since the soda fountain was not working, we had ours in bottles and can. You guessed it...no glasses or ice anywhere in sight. Our bill for the night was a little over $51. We had prepaid at the register in cash as to not be charged the credit card fee. I'm not exactly sure how long this establishment was open, but it does have potential. We will probably try again, but only for takeout since we really did not feel welcomed at all.

This was our first time going to Vito's Pizza…read more My family is always saying how great the pizza is and it truly is deliicous. Our favorite slice is the Buffalo Chicken, it is a thicker crispy crust and a bit spicy. We had 2 slices. The owner and the staff were all very friendly.

Tony's Pizza & Restaurant

4.6

(112 reviews)

Stopped in with my father and son on a weekend trip. We're from western NY and I had heard that…read morethere was no good pizza on Long Island. This place has something to say about that. We just got a pizza and some garlic knots but some of the sandwiches looked ridiculous. If we come back, we'll be back here.

Service was great Tony his self works very nice guy spoke to us as he served. 4 slices for about…read more$15 but the pizza was very good. A nice size place with two sides to it. Today only plain was ready we was early but they have a lot of special slices

Broadway Pizzeria

4.2

(57 reviews)

Over the years we've tried and frequented many pizza restaurants in the area (Huntington,…read moreCenterport, Northport, Greenlawn), and we've chosen Broadway Pizza to be our weekly go to. In our opinion, they have the best tasting sauce, and the proper sauce-cheese ratio.

Great ny pizza and very friendly team. I almost got an impulse slice of Sicilian because it looked…read moreso good!

Mozzarella's Pizza

4.1

(82 reviews)

Come here for specialty slices all the time, and love em all. Great local pizzeria, highly…read morerecommend!

I stopped in the other day for a quick slice. I was excited to see that they had many options. Not…read morejust the regular slices. They had ravioli, eggplant, chicken Francese, Sicilian, and many others. It's not the biggest display but the prices are great. There is plenty of seating. The staff was so friendly. They got my slices done quickly. I was in and out. I ordered the ravioli and eggplant slice. They were so good! I highly recommend.

Short Stop Pizzeria

4.0

(51 reviews)

Solid pizza and super friendly staff . The prices are very reasonable . This is my family's go to…read morewhen in KP .

Long Island has a pizza parlor on every corner. It doesn't mean they're all good. If you're looking…read morefor that perfect, no-frills, consistently delicious slice, Short Stop Pizza absolutely delivers. The pizza is exactly what you want it to be...crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right balance of cheese. Every bite tastes fresh and well-made, not rushed or overly greasy like you find in a lot of places. It's the kind of spot where you know you're getting a solid, satisfying meal every time. It even arrives hot with delivery. Beyond the food, iIt feels like a true neighborhood staple, the kind of place you keep coming back to because it never disappoints. Simple, reliable, and genuinely good pizza and subs. Highly recommend.

DiRaimo Pizzeria

3.9

(107 reviews)