Went there tonight with friends. Had no idea what to get for dinner. As any true Italian there are certain things that I just won't order in a restaurant. The waitress suggested the vodka sauce with penne and cut onion chicken cutlet. Very very hesitant as I make mine from scratch all the time. After going over the menu over and over and getting very frustrated, I told the waitress fine give me the vodka sauce with penne and chicken cutlet. The first piece of penne covered in this creamy vodka sauce was heavenly!! It was absolutely delish licking good!!! No I didn't lock the dish but I were home alone I can't promise I wouldn't have!! read more

I am not one to leave reviews but the disappointment on several occasions with the food and management. The food took over an hour & 15 minutes from our reservation time. Other tables around us received meals that were sat down afterwards. We cannot be the only people that have had this same experience. Awful management very unprofessional did nothing to handle the situation the correct way we will not be coming back or recommending this place there are many other places for authentic homemade Italian food. Extremely disappointed with several experiences. read more

My wife and I tried this place for the first time tonight.. it's the place that took over the spot in the old bridge plaza where Benzi was. While the service was friendly our experience overall was not very good. My entree was just average with very little actual veal.. my wife ordered one of their oven pizzas and while we were told it could come out either before or after my entree.. it actually never showed up until we were visited by the manager Steven who was very nice about explaining what likely happend. That said.. I'm not sure we would take another chance on this place when there are so many options out there.. while the atmosphere is nice.. the food we did get to try was ok. And pricy at that. I'm not sure how long they have been operating and perhaps in a year or so if they are still around and I start to hear better things. We may think about giving it another shot. read more

First time here; are at the bar w a friend. Long drink wait; longer food wait & our food was forgotten bt. Food was good but after such a wait we requested a check after getting to-hi boxes. Weren't provided bags for the boxes (a wait staff member asked us if we wanted them after the fact). Our bill was significantly incorrect; bartender had to get a manager to correct... all we got were drinks, pasta & calamari! Expected much better... read more

Don't miss the Sunday Gravy when available. It was really authentic and I thoroughly enjoyed it. Tremendous portion, I will definitelt be back for that. The friend wasn't as keen on the Chicken Parm, but then again...That's what you get for ordering an American dish in an Italian restaurant. read more

I came to dinner last night with my husband and I was served by a young man named Don. He seemed to be rather friendly and passionate, though he was not very attentive. I had to continuously ask him for things and he messed up my entree order. I've been to this restaurant numerous times and never experienced such inadequacy. Hope for a different experience next time. read more

30 minutes for a pizza ? I had to bother them 2 times to get it in 30 minutes . Lol Got home and threw it out . The worst pizza I have ever had in my life Will Never go back read more

When there is a wait or 50 mins to a hours, they rather keep tons of people waiting when all the table on the left are all empty which are reserved for large parties!! They should break down the tables to the left as there weren't large parties at that time, accommodate the folks waiting! We saw many people leave due to the long wait! Besides that, the food is really good. read more

Love this restaurant, this area needed a good italian restaurant. I love the fact that it's for friends, family and kid friendly! Beautifully decorated, warm and cozy atmosphere. The staff made us feel very welcome, we had an awesome dinner. The food did not disappoint! read more

I was at Feast Italian Kitchen last week to celebrate my girlfriend's birthday. Loved it!! The food and drinks were delicious and the service was excellent! We had a waitress Jackie!! By the time we left she was our new best friend! So attentive, down to earth and genuinely nice! Service with a smile!! She gave us suggestions of food to order and she was so right with her choices! She was awesome! When I go back, I would definitely ask to sit at her station!! read more

My husband and I were traveling through the area and decided to stop in about 3:30 on a Sunday afternoon. It wasn't crowded and we were seated immediately in the back behind the bar area. We were offered water in small glasses and a bread basket with 4 slices of Italian bread and a few pieces of flatbread along with a saucer of oil and seasonings. We did not order drinks or appetizers. My husband ordered chicken parmigiana and I had eggplant parmigiana. There was no indication on the menu that the entrees came with any sides. A few minutes later our food arrived. No salad was offered or provided. The chicken came with a side of penne but the eggplant didn't. There was no salt and pepper on the table and we had to ask for them as well as grated cheese. Both the cheese and salt were brought out in tiny bowls with an espresso spoon and the waiter offered to grind fresh pepper for us. The portions were good sized and the sauce tasted fresh but too salty for our taste. The pasta sauce was bland. The eggplant was fried and stacked but there was no sauce between the layers. Nothing was exceptional nor was it terrible. read more

Have been looking forward to trying this out. My lunch companions had sandwiches that were really good, generous size and cane with a side salad. $9!! I had a tricolor salad with one piece of grilled chicken on top. $25!!! I eat out a lot and nice issue paying for a nice sized salad with interesting ingredients. This was not it. It was a total rip off and waste. It a small plate that they called large and one piece of chicken on top. Such a waste. Very disappointed. I will day the greens were fresh but it was simply not worth it. read more

I am so unhappy with this place. My sister is mildly autistic and has issues socializing or doing even other things that is simple for others. Yet she still went out of her way to apply at this place. The restaurant called her in for an interview and she was all excited. She walked all the way there because she isn't able to drive and made an effort to look for a job despite one rejection after another. YET The restaurant manager Robert treated her terribly. He didn't give her the full attention she deserved and at the end lied to her and said they weren't hiring . He continued to degrade her by telling her that they were hiring college girls instead as if she wasn't as liable as them .... He then quickly left without saying bye to her or acknowledging her interest . She felt uneasy yet told him to have a good day then left calling me saying how upset she was of how she was treated and said she felt like he was treating her different because she was "different." I then called them up to see if they were actually hiring and of course they were. So they lied to her instead of at least giving her the respect she deserves. She didn't have to be hired , but at least respect disabled people. It's disgusting that people like this still exist instead of being kind to everyone despite who they are . My family used to come here all the time but we will not be going to this place anymore. Just utterly disgusted with this place and hope they will learn from this incident. Do better. read more

I wish I was here to leave a review about the food - but unfortunately I was not able to have any. My best friend comes here with her boyfriend all the time, and when she and I were making dinner plans she suggested we come here. We waited a good 8-10 minutes before the server Bobby came and asked if we wanted anything to drink. We asked to see a cocktail menu. We looked over the menu and decided to order two glasses of Moscato. The server asked to see our IDs, looked at them, and said "you know, I really wouldn't even know if these were fake or not". We laughed about it although it was already a little awkward. He walked away, and when he came back he told us that he was sorry but he would not be serving us alcohol because he believed our IDs were fake. He said that compared to his ID, ours were "not as thin". We told him that we were in fact of age and they are definitely real IDs, and showed him our credit/debit cards and school IDs. He asked to see our passports, to which we responded that we do not just casually carry our passports around with us as that is careless and unsafe. He continued to refuse us service and said he would get his manager if we wanted that. We agreed that he should get his manager. The manager, Ray I believe, treated us exactly the same. He took my friend's ID, and the whole staff stood in a circle comparing their IDs to hers. At this point we already knew we were leaving, we were extremely uncomfortable. We said "you can call the police, you can scan the IDs, whatever you have to do, our IDs are valid", and the manager just kept laughing and saying he was not going to call the police. My friend said "My boyfriend and I come here all the time, I am really upset about this because I used to love it here" to which the manager responded, "Oh, really?" like he was bored of the whole thing. When we said "Okay, we are going to leave" he said "Aw, I'm sorry guys". This is EXTREMELY poor management and HIGHLY under-trained staff. There was no attempt to diffuse the situation and make it better. How are you running a restaurant AND BAR and you don't know the difference between a real and fake ID?!?! Do you not have a scanner or a black light or a book to refer to or ANY way to make sure you are serving the correct people aside from standing around comparing your customers ID to your staff? Just unbelievable. I work at a restaurant and we are retrained every 6 months on valid identification and how to handle a situation like that correctly. We were outwardly discriminated against because we look young and REFUSED SERVICE, regardless of showing multiple forms of ID. We will never be back here and will be making sure that no one we know ever comes here unless they want to be treated like trash. As I mentioned, we also work in the service industry and tip our fellow servers generously, always. You missed out. read more

I had the best Roast Beef and Mozzarella sandwich ever... wait until you try that sauce...really cool high end design with a price point that suits anyone. Give this one a try... read more

Was at Feast tonight with my family, Old Bridge, it was absolutely horrible. First I ordered mozzarella and tomatoes for app, the tomatoes were green and hard. Next we ordered our food and it took 90 minutes to get to us. My husband and son had pasta and I ordered chicken francaise over angel hair pasta. Chicken had lots of gristle and mushy and the pasta tasted like someone poured lemon juice all over my food. And the chicken dish was $21 and they charged me $5 extra for pasta, which totaled $26. We had manager over twice and she wouldn't take anything off the bill. Oh, and they gave you soda in small little 4 oz glass. Stay away. It was just terrible. A big waste of $92.00 read more

Restaurant just opened so totally understand service may not be perfect but this was just awful. Several times I had to stand up from my table to find a waiter. They also forgot my son's main dish so we all had to wait 10 minutes to eat our food until it came out. I ordered a drink and it didn't come out until after I finished my meal. You can tell the waiters are nice but just awful awful service. Food was solid but when you are constantly searching for your waiter to put in an appetizer order it's not worth it. Many times we were just sitting and waiting for the server which felt like hours. I had to ask 4 different people for crushed red pepper for my pizza. I honestly don't know where the waiters disappear to. Will not be going back anytime soon. read more

Food was good but not practicing 6 feet apart. Place was packed and definitely a little scary. Won't be going back anytime soon.

I have been here quite a few times since it's open. The food is delicious. One of my favorite surprises was the pastina. Talk about a childhood favorite I'd like to say the service could be a little better. I found myself quite a few times looking for my server. Im excited about this new place with affordable good food read more

I understand this is a new restaurant & they are still trying to work out the kinks but had a TERRIBLE experience here. To start my espresso martini, they used old espresso had to send it back. Ordered the fresh mozzarella and meatball appetizer waited over an hour for the app. When the meatball ( you only get one) came out it was burnt beyond belief you couldn't even cut into it not to mention there was no sauce on it . When we told the waiter he said this is how we serve our meatballs. I've had plenty of meatballs in my life, I have never saw one that looked more like a falafel ball. We also, were still waiting for our mozzarella app which the manger came over and said it would be right out. 15 mins went by, no mozzarella. The server asked, if we received it yet which we didn't he than ran into the back where it was just sitting since the manager forgot to bring it out. The mozzarella was underwhelming no taste. For our entrees, the risotto frutti di Mare, was not risotto it honestly tasted like uncle ben's rice the shrimp were completely over cooked and the whole meal was so salty it was almost uneatable. My friends who got the chicken Parm, said it was way to salty & their side pasta was half spaghetti half penne . Never seen anything like that before. Overall, I really wanted to like this restaurant since I am a fan of the owners other restaurant but this was just plain awful. read more

wasn't a fan. Sauce was too thick. Service was eh waitress stunk like cigarettes. Don't think I will be back!

The food was ok, the service was terrible! Who knew when you reserve a table you also had to reserve an outdoor heater anyway that's probably something the hostess could have said in advance when I made the reservations. Our waitress was nice but she kept forgetting all our orders. When they brought our main entrees out we had to ask can they clear out our empty plates I guess they couldn't see the pile of mess. Welp I won't be coming back here! read more

Atmosphere needs work! Feels more like a cafeteria on the left side when you walk in. Food was just okay but pizza was good. Prices high for the quality and atmosphere. Disappointed. They need to redesign the seating area with more ambiance and decor read more

My husband and I went for dinner and absolutely loved it! The restaurant had tables spaced out nicely and was very clean. We felt safe and comfortable. Most importantly the food was delicious. We found our new favorite Italian food spot in the area! read more

Food was OK - my fried (why?) bastardization of chicken marsala was dry and overdone. My problem with this place was the restaurant ran my card wrong; It took 3 outgoing calls to get it fixed and was followed up by a threatening incoming call from the owner where he cursed me out. These animals should not be in the hospitality business. Same on anyone for patronizing them. read more

The food is just ok but the service was phenomenal. Our waiter, Jake, took really good care of us.

Reservations were made two weeks in advance and we were sat promptly. Glasses for drinks are extremely small, about three sips worth (and this was for an iced tea). I was told that they aren't allowed to use the draft glasses for other drinks (including water). Understood, he was following the rules but management needs to rethink this --- I can't tell you how often he needed to get us refills, what a waste of time. Sangria - comes in a pitcher, they didn't pour the first drink - odd. Appetizers - calamari was "ok" not great and they gave us the wrong sauce. Sauce was so spicy we could barely eat it. They then told us kitchen made a mistake. Meatball was delish, Cesar salad had a little too much dressing but good. Hot mozzarella was good, but should be served with something - not sure what. Dinner - gnocchi in pizza bowl was delish, I feel like they could take it up a notch and bake it with some mozzarella cheese. Chicken parmigiana was ok, nothing special. Chicken was little thick for my liking, not enough cheese. Be warned, kitchen will not offer changes to menu. They serve clam, shrimp and veal oreganotto but will not make chicken. Dessert - cannoli was eh, would never get it again. Overall the place has some tweaks the need to work out, service was bad (not enough help), food was extremely inconsistent across a party of 10. I wouldn't go back by choice, but if someone suggested I wouldn't say no. read more

Pricey. Chicken dish was dry. Service was not great I don't think I would go back. Many other good Italian restaurants where the portion is large and price reasonable. read more

Great food, great staff. The twin pork chops are amazing. So glad we found this place.

Went to Feast this past weekend and I would give it 0 stars. The food is not fresh. Mozzarella was refrigerated for long time and tasteless. Steak pizzaiola was in a brown sauce (never ) and the meat tasted like it was definitely microwaved a few times. The manager didn't want to hear any of it. All she did was brag that the owners own a high end restaurant in Marlboro. Will never go back. There are plenty of great restaurants in the area. read more

Perfect place to have a "Feast"! Fun atmosphere, Great Staff, Yummy eats! Love the Capellini Alla Feast, the Margherita pizza always a good choice and the Pistachio Caramel Ice Cream Cake a must have! We will be back! read more

Feast is an awesome at home atmosphere. Great bartenders. Alex is our favorite! She makes the best cosmos ever! Can't beat their happy hour!

This was a very unfortunate experience, especially since the food was good and tasty, however the downfalls cannot be overlooked. Our group arrived at 830 and almost immediately placed appetizer and drinks orders. 20 minutes later, no drinks, no salads, no attention. Our waitress was not checking in on us, actually she was MIA most of the night. After complaining to the bartender after sitting for half an hour with nothing to drink we finally got drinks, but because of lack of communication, the waitress brought out a second set of drinks shortly after. The appetizers were tasty, however, another 30-45 minutes after finishing the apps were spent once again waiting on food and drinks and any attention possible. The service was awful. We did not place anymore drink orders because we knew we wouldn't get it. The time gap between finishing appetizers and getting the mains (not all bc some were forgotten) was 45 minutes. Absolutely never returning and absolutely would not recommend. read more

Had a great night with friends at Feast. Our waiter Ryan was fantastic. He was courteous, friendly and patient with a large loud party. I would suggest asking for Ryan as your waiter. The bartenders were also great. read more

Food nothing to rave about .Drinks ever worse and as far as the service and attitude of the female owner who needs to learn customer service. If i could give a zero i would. read more

Came here for my bday tonight with my wife 3yr old daughter and 9 month old son. We ended up with pizza. Pizza was just okay. It's my fault for not looking at the menu before hand but they had no kids menu. They wanted me to order a full meal for my daughter and their response was ull have leftovers. No thank u!! I will not be back here. Its almost like they want this to be a NYC restaurant in the middle of Old Bridge. Sorry - but this place will not last. I heard a few customers asking the same thing. Who doesn't have a kids menu at a restaurant in this area. read more

I really wanted to love this place. My first time was amazing. My second time was also good HOWEVER, I asked for a specific seat because I had a small child with me. (3 year old toddler girl with an affectionado for sitting in a corner) The dining room was absolutely empty on a Friday because I come in with a small child and I come very early, before the dinner rush. I'm born and raised in NYC. When I asked for that table the girl told me and I quote "that table is reserved for the owners guest". So that's lovely. I mean I get it. But this Isn't Rao's, it's a place filled with That fake element and wannabe mentality. Irrespective of crowd that is drawn to a specific locale, I understood, regretfully. When I saw what walked in To sit at the table, it was one of The "partners" friends. A nice Jewish couple middle Aged. That's fine. But here I am Disabled and with A small child. If you're Gonna pick favorites and prioritize your friends over what would have been your regulars, from NY who are used to the real Italian food, you will only draw the Manalapan/Marlboro crowd. That's fine but keep in mind your demographic location and how every single NY'er who is moving here in droves would react. I get you owned Michaels in Brooklyn but no one needs to here what you own and who yoU are. Personally, I don't give two shits. Especially after I saw who was "VIP" lol The food was good. It's consistent. The calamari wasn't my favorite. Waiter was great both times. The fact that these so called owners don't greet their guests and get to know the new wave of clientele makes me think there are Many owners. It's a nice place. But I was completely turned off by the "favoritism" I would r drive to Bay Ridge and eat at Campani read more

I went to feast for the first time the other night really not impressed the waiter recommended baked clams that had a real small piece of clam in it, Not fresh. Ordered fried calamari that was OK, order spedini alla Romano That was OK and then ordered papadelle Bolognese Which the waiter recommended, very sticky and lumped all together so all I can say is if you don't know how to cook with fresh pasta don't cook with fresh pasta. But I will give it a second try just because I believe in second chances! read more

Thee worst experience ever. Most important my wife got food poisoning from carbonara. A raw egg was placed on top of the dish which we promptly asked to be removed. However the white part dripped down so it was too late. The dish was very salty. She was sick for 4 days after eating at Feast. I had veal francese which was over the top lemony. Just bad news. Also service was terrible-empty flat plates left on our table so dessert plates were placed on top of the unused plates. Also calamari came with red sauce all over the top of the dish instead of in a separate plate for dipping. And a girl came to our table to ask how dinners were - we related the above issues and she said our comments are used to improve. No attempt to do something for the 4 of us who endured such a disgraceful dinner. read more

Food is outstanding; large portions. Service is excellent. The restaurant is so beautiful and the vibe is just as great.