Federal Hill Pizza has pretty decent pizza! Ive tried their margarita pizza before (nothing too crazy) and it was great, even though it is very simple pizza. It had good flavor, wasn't bland, and I happily finished the entire pizza by myself. Definitely will swing by to try their other pizzas in the future ;) read more

Simple menu. Pizza and salads, it feels like an elevated neighborhood place. A nod to the bike path is referenced with hanging bicycle decor. It was beyond my expectations. Crispy crust and thin. read more

I hate writing bad reviews about small businesses. But this really was the worst meal I've had me quite some time. It's a nice little place. Kind of on the main street in Warren. My friend and I had heard that they had really good pizza so we were looking forward to it. We had a great table right in the window and could see everyone walking by. The server was very nice. Great start. We ordered the meatballs and the fried garlic bread for appetizers. They do a Detroit pizza special on Sundays. So we got that instead of the regular pizza. Sounds like a great start right? It all went downhill from there. The meatballs were first. I kept the bizarre firmness of the meatballs to myself. The fact that they were plated in a weird pool of ricotta cheese and not much sauce didn't bother me as much as the strange texture. That being said, my friend did mention how firm they were, which led to a whole series of double entendres between us, which made the overall lack of taste and enjoyment a little more fun, at least. Little did. I know that was going to be the highlight in terms of flavors and food. Next came the fried garlic bread. I'm not sure what I was expecting, but I definitely wasn't expecting three doughboys soaked in pools of some kind of butter or oil and covered with chunks of garlic and a little parmesan cheese. To say that this was visually extremely unappetizing would be an understatement. And while I can be a picky eater, I was there with a foodie and they said the same thing. I tried to cut a piece off of the end that wasn't soaked and saturated, but even then giant pools of whatever that yellow liquid was made it look and feel like a sponge. I went with one bite and was kind of done. Then came the Detroit pizza. I'm not sure they use the right dough, I'm not sure they use the correct pans if they use pans at all, they definitely don't use the correct cheese blend. What I am sure of is that they don't know how to cook it. The bottom was a dark brown, overcooked and almost impossible to cut through. The middle was not cooked enough and didn't support any of the toppings and the top third was barely cooked at all. The sauce was bland and unappealing. The cheese had no taste and the crust was more of an annoyance than anything. You can't cut it, you don't want to chew it, it had no taste and it was basically uncooked on top while being just short of burnt on the bottom. Bottom. Visually it looked okay but in practice it was not very good at all. We both ate about half of one slice before we quit. In summation l, I wish we tried the regular pizza, but based on the other two items that we ordered, I'm not sure it would have been much different. What I am sure of is they should learn more about how to put together at Detroit style pizza if they're going to offer it as a special thing on one day a week. There was nothing special about it. They have a nice spot. It's nice inside and very pleasant. The people are nice. The server was good. She wasn't particularly attentive even though we were the only people there, but she was friendly when we did see her. I did find it kind of strange that we returned 70% of one appetizer and 80% of the pizza and she didn't ask if we liked it or not or try to offer something else or make amends in some way. Maybe she's used to that. I'm not sure. I like everything about the place except the food. I would love nothing better than to write a great review, but I'm simply unable to do that. I'm sorry. read more

Federal Hill Pizza - The "Detroit" pizza. Notice the amount of yellow liquid saturating my knife from trying to cut the dry end off the fried garlic bread. - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

Fast service, delicious and hot pizza, and incredible background Italian music...what more could you ask for???? Definitely recommend hitting this place up for some delicious pizza that will instantly satisfy all pizza desires!!!!! read more

Federal Hill Pizza - 12" Margherita/Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

See all

Food: sorry no pictures! Forgot to take them We ordered "the way it should be" pizza, fries, calamari, and chicken wings. All the fried foods were crispy and good. It wasnt the oily crispy it was light and fluffy crispy . The calamari and pizza were my favorite. They also gave us a plate of desserts for Easter which was very kind of them! Definitely would recommend if you're in the Warren area of RI!! Service: Our server was very nice, nothing much to say about him. But whatever we asked for he delivered and came right away! Atmosphere: like your typical Italian pizza shop. With some paintings and baseball decorations hung up lol. Bathroom was pretty clean to! read more

Very disappointed. Took friends. Their chicken cutlet sandwiches were way overdone and their bread (pizza dough) was burned (mine was not). Chicken was quite dry as a result. We did let them know and were told that's how it's made. To moisten the chicken we ordered a side of sauce and were charged $5. You would think it would have been gratis since the chicken was over done and dried out. I deducted it from the bill with a note. My left overs; i was given a paper bag to put the sandwich in! Had to ask for foil to wrap it up first. Their pizza is great, but I probably won't go back. Sorry to write this as it's always been top notch. Maybe just a bad night. read more

I figured I would give this place a chance because it seemed nice on the outside. I was incredibly wrong - this place was terrible. The customer service was terrible and the price for 2 slices is $16? What kindve slice is this? I asked for pepperoni and each piece had 2 pieces of pepperoni on it. Never going back and do not recommend. read more

Federal Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

Extremely solid 4! As a person who absolutely loves pizza in every shape and size, I was beyond pleased to have stumbled upon this finely feathered establishment. Don't pass it by on account of Yelp's incorrect name! (See pic) Right on the main drag in Warren sits this quaint pizzeria. It's quite clear they are taking the time and care to provide supreme quality. The ingredients are fresh and the products made from scratch. They must get their leaven from heaven! Take a peek at the pics, they don't lie. They are worth a thousand bites! Service with a smile to boot! Bon appetite!! read more

See all

Didn't have high expectations. Just looking for a quick slice of pizza and the location was convenient. Paid $7 and waited over 20 minutes for them to "prepare" what ended up being a mostly inedible overcooked rock. I could've gotten better pizza faster and much cheaper at the gas station. Gave it a second star b/c it had a cute atmosphere and I got to watch tv while I waited. read more

Federal Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

What an amazing place! We had our furbaby with us and dined at the outside tables on a beautiful day. It was an awesome experience! They have elevated a simple cheese pizza to perfection. Cannot wait to return ! read more

I have ordered from Federal Hill Pizza a couple of times now and it has not disappointed. We tend to order half veggie and half special with goat cheese and prosciutto. Yum. The owner goes the extra mile for his customers. read more

Ordered the Italian sausage pizza and it was okay kinda dry and then ordered spaghetti and meatballs and it was no way worth $18 that was highway robbery. Barely any spaghetti and two very tiny meatballs. Kinda a slap in the face for expensive pricing. Don't think I'll be returning unless they increase their portions or lower their prices. read more

My first time trying Federal Hill Pizza and by far it was an amazing experience! Delicious food fantastic customer service. Unfortunately, I got a flat tire parking before heading into the restaurant and with no hesitation the owner Christina decided to help me. She made me feel very comfortable in my time. 10 out of 10 I would do it again!! I will for sure be heading back with a group of friends . Thank you to you and your staff for making me feel comfortable and making my tummy happy . read more

Hands down, the best pizza in the Barrington area. Great chicken parm too. Friendly service.

I'm not trying to kill anyone's business. But this is the second time. Same result. They have great ingredients... good dough and perfect in sections...... but, don't know how to cook it. A third burnt. A third cooked perfect. A third doooooooough ugh. Hire someone and stick them there who knows how to cook and move the pizzs so the whole pizza gets cooked evenly or move to a conveyor. Stop calling it federal hill... go there... it's not and mediocre at best. read more

Federal Hill Pizza - Burnt pizza. It's not charred. - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

My daughter graduated last Friday from RWU. We arrived relatively unannounced and this place couldn't have been more perfect. Christine and her staff were attentive, friendly, made great suggestions and took care of our group of ten. The pizza was excellent and was a combination of thin crust with a nice chewy outer crust. Speciality pizzas were amazing. Couldn't have asked for more. We will be back! read more

Federal Hill Pizza - Funny and enjoyable casual atmosphere l! - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

5 stars all the way! Totally blown away with their pizza and the crust!! My husband and I couldn't decide on one pizza, so we decided to get 2 smalls to share! I had to have "Zorba The Greek" It was amazingly delicious!! Cooked with Mozzarella, Kalamata Olives, Garlic Infused Olive Oil, Meatballs, Feta Cheese & Red Onions finished with a fresh Tzatziki Sauce and Basil. OMG! The flavors in this pizza completely blew my mind and the crust was cooked to perfection!! Totally loved it!!! The other pizza was "Aloha" which consisted of Mozzarella, a delicious Red Sauce, Pineapple and Prosciutto!! Another WOW! This pizza restaurant rocks!! read more

See all

We tried the margarita pizza and the Nutella fried dough bites. They were both great, I'd go back for sure! read more

Federal Hill Pizza - NUTELLA DOUGH BALLS 12" MARGHERITA - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

It is no wonder why Federal Hill Pizza has been made famous for their Neapolitan style brick oven pizza. It is a very unique, lighter dough that bubbles up nicely in the brick oven. Their dough is delicious, hands down! We went for the Aloha pizza (yes, pineapple does belong on pizza) and the Zorba the Greek. Both were delicious, and I would certainly get them again. Their menu has some unique specialty pizzas that I would like to try as well. Certainly worth coming back to try them all! read more

See all

Went for trivia and was extremely disappointed in the food. I got a gluten free meatball pizza and the crust was actually pretty good, but the meatballs were practically inedible. The service was good, but the prices are absurd for the quality of the food and the casual dining atmosphere. I think I paid $18 for a 10in pizza. Would not recommend. read more

Despite the Corona virus scare, this establishment knows how to keep customers happy. With the reduced menu, but still wide variety of quality food to choose from, we are happy that we can do curbside pickup. We feel safe ordering food from here. The staff and the management is working together with customers to keep our dining options open in the East Bay in this challenging times. Their garlic and flavor rich food - anything on the menu, really, are family pleasers. Get off tour couch and order some quality food from Federal Hill Pizza! You don't have to go to the Hill to get the same quality food in Warren. We will be back again and again for sure. read more

See all

Friends said "best pizza in RI". Don't know if I can go that far as everyone has their own take on what is a great pizza (think NJ vs. Pa. vs wherever you grew up) but these are darn good pizzas. Parking nearby if you hunt. Great service. Large selections of craft beers and cocktails (but the latter with pizza?). We had a 16" (more than enough for 2) "FHP Meat" ($24). Great thin crust, proper burn, decent amount of meat, and very cheesy. All in - a very good pie. Wait time was pretty long (did they burn the first attempt?) - don't expect the few minutes of a Neapolitan pie. A few beers and tip and damages were $60. See if this is "one of the best".... Food 4/5 (first visit - so can't go 5 yet) Service 5/5 Value 3/5 (average) Cleanliness 5/5 Noise 5/5 (quiet) Decor 3/5 read more

Federal Hill Pizza - THE pie - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

Great pizza, ambiance and selection of draft beers. I'm sure the other items on the menu are good too but I've only had the pizza. Staff is friendly and always smiling. read more

We ordered a few pizzas for pickup. Delicious! I'll order them the next time I'm out in Rhode Island. We over-ordered and have nothing left but cardboard. My only gripe is that they didn't cut the pizzas. Maybe it's a regional thing. Nothing a knife couldn't fix. Well worth the work. read more

This place was a very pleasant surprise. Stopped in on a Thursday. The antipasto salad and the salad dressing exceeded expectations. The meat lovers pizza was excellent. Excellent dough sauce and cheese. The toppings make it even better. read more

See all

Ordered their Boss's Special pizza and it was amazing. The crust was perfect and is a meal into itself. Service was good as well. Definitely recommend read more

I've been meaning to try this place, and I wish I didn't. I got the chicken parm and the pasta was not cooked. My partner got the pizza, which was so thin and wet it was super floppy. I also got an espresso that came with a dirty spoon. Service was slow as well. For a place that's pricey, it was deeply disappointing. Will not be coming back. read more

Mixed views about this place. I've had good and not so good experiences. I've tried their Zorba the Greek, Margherita and the way it should be. Their zorba the Greek pizza was quite good though we ordered the other two pizza's yesterday and were disappointed. The pizzas were doughy, felt undercooked and the crust wasn't good. Overall Aok experience, wish they were more consistent. read more

Overpriced and the pizza was awful! Won't see me again! Only reason why I put 1 star is because it won't let me leave review

I hate to write a bad review but unfortunately that just the way it goes for the pizza at this restaurant. It's pretty horrible. The dough is not good in flavor, and the pizza is floppy and squishy. I wish I could say that the flavor was at least good, but it isn't. The sauce was not good either. Overall just pretty horrible pizza. Sorry for the brutal honesty. read more

First time at the restaurant and I can't wait to go back. We ordered fried mozzarella and the meatball pizza. The best we ever had. read more

Federal Hill Pizza - Meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Rhode Island

See all

Coming from someone who lives in NY, they have good food and service . Love the bread that sh*t good. Everything good the pizza, sandwiches and desserts read more

For a place that is supposedly Italian the sauce tastes like it came out of can just plopped on the pasta, what little of it there was. I am Italian and I am super picky on my sauce or gravy as we like to call it. Living in Rhode Island where there is absolutely no shortage of amazing Italian restaurants that can master something as simple as a good or basic sauce this place is a major fail for their sauce, definitely not anything close to Italian unless you like watery, bland canned Hunts! Another disappointment is the chicken wings, they are all the same with just sauce on the side, much like a very cheap pizza joint, do yourself a favor and skip them there are so many other places to get real wings that are flavorful, sautéed in the sauce and not served plain with just a side of sauce. On a side note I did eat there in the spring and the sauce was slightly better with some seasoning/flavor to it enough to make me order it again, not sure why they changed it but it really is awful. read more

I've never written a review. positive or negative, for anything. The pizza here is terrible. I ordered 2 12" pizzas. I also clicked the "well-done" option. I arrived before they were done which I like to do so they don't get soggy on the way home. I live 3 minutes away. Both pizzas had zero crisp, not even the crust. It was still wet dough. I have no idea how this place is still in business with all the great pizza in Rhode Island. I'm honestly just trying to save people time and money by saying DO NOT EAT HERE. It's an embarrassment. You would think they would take some minuscule amount of pride in their product, however, they do not. read more

Met the owner for my first time at federal hill and i had a blast! Excellent customer service, timely turn around, and great personality. So glad to support women owned business as a newbie to the area. Classic pepperoni slice can't be topped! read more

Food, service AND ambiance were extremely lacking. "Executive Chef" wasn't in so the only thing you could order was pizza & anything meatball. Pizza was soggy with too much cheese, meatball sandwich had no sauce. I ordered a side of sauce, they bring me a soup bowl of sauce and charge me 4$ for it. Maybe they should put the appropriate amount of sauce on it to begin with! . Will not be back and don't recommend. read more

We were sat down and waited for 20 minutes wasn't even acknowledged. They were busy but it's nice to be told "hey I'll be with you shortly". Wouldn't recommend this place at all. read more

I have had Federal Hill Pizza at the Providence location but the other night was my first time at the Warren location. While attending an event at the cute bookstore across the street I kept looking over at Federal Hill Pizza and decided that was what I wanted for dinner. I wasn't sure how long I would wait for my takeout considering I just walked in and ordered, but it was ready in 15 minutes. While waiting I was offered water and a seat. Customer service was extremely friendly and the pizza did not disappoint at all! I opted for East Street pizza which was meatball and red pepper, highly recommend! read more

Love this place! Pizza is fantastic and so is the service. Cool place too. If they have the fagioli on the specials get it. Get the biggest bowl you can also. It is something special. I'll be back soon read more

WOW!!! First time and last time!!! I Ordered a pizza it got delivered before I even had a bite I was chasing the delivery man down the road. It seemed like maybe they forgot to cook it or just wanted to warm it up. After ripping the crust open and seeing the raw dough I call them and explained the situation. They were very apologetic and decided to cook me a new pizza and deliver it. So I gave the first pizza a zero and the second a one just because it was actually cooked. But can you say flop, I dont even know how to eat this. After getting my fork and knife and having a few bite I have to say it is one of the worst pizzas I have ever had. Back to Balascos it is read more

See all