A great Italian joint! Love the lasagna and the Garlic knots. Everyone seems to love the pizza but I think it needs to be cooked a little more and I'm not a fan of the cheese. It sure looks good though. The place is very small, so you'll probably have to sit outside and during the heat of the summer it's no fun. read more

See all

Quaint little place built in an old house in the heart of palm harbor. The noise level is somewhat high, but it's more like a gathering spot for the locals. Pizza was very good with just the right amount of crispiness. Service was fantastic and I really loved my salad. Next time, will probably sit outside if it's not too hot. This time we sat in a little alcove that appears to have been a former kitchen. This place is on my list of places that we will come back to visit. read more

We live here in Palm Harbor and Fireside Pizza has been at least a once a week stop for us (typically carryout). We've always enjoyed the courteous staff and the great pizza and the meatballs in pizza dough is one of our favs typically 5-stars). Unfortunately, the quality has declined in the last few visits. Today, (11/16/24) our carryout order was the MB in pizza dough (x2). The dough was not fully cooked, not much sauce, and it was cold. Seems they maybe experiencing some training issues with their cooks. I think we'll wait awhile before giving them another try. read more

The cutest tucked in gem of a cafe ! The outdoor seating is so nice , and even though it was hot out there was ample amount of fans which made it a cool visit ! For starters we had the Parmesan fries which were piping hot and SO good , the shape made them all the better , also a side Caesar salad that had delicious dressing and fresh shaved Parmesan cheese ! We then had the margarita pizza and cheese with pepperoni and garlic , all piping hot full of robust flavor ! We will for sure be back to try m read more

See all

This pizza is okay but I'd rather go somewhere else. When you first walk inside, the interior is not nice at all and much more could be done to make it nicer and more welcoming. We were seated right by the door when there was only one other party in the building, who were seated at the other side of the door. Weird, but okay. They do have a large deck area outside with seating but it was raining so that wasn't an option. I personally got the small bianca (white) pizza which was $9.95 I believe. It is 6 small pieces. The pizza was good, a little too greasy but it was good. My parents got a large Margherita pizza for $21 which is 8 large slices. I did not like this pizza at all, there was tons of basil shredded just sitting on top which was very weird and I hadn't seen this before. The tomatoes on it were kind of spicy and just not good. They said they liked it but would not get it again. Overall, I wouldn't come here again because of the quality and portion of food you get for the price. Especially the large Margherita which is $21- you can get a better tasting large pizza for cheaper basically anywhere else. read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - Bianca (white) pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

LOVE THE PIZZA ! NO DELIVERY ? how much business you must leave on the table not offering delivery !

Called in at 350 pm for 10 people at 730 arrives at the restaurant at 715 and no table was reserved and told they don't take reservations after they took my name and phone number for the reservation totally unexcetable read more

Perfecto! Molto Bene! We love this place. Its authentic pizza and great beers are a wining combo! read more

Had an amazing veggie pizza. It was so good and the service was great. Food came out quick and fresh, super tasty. 100% will be back!

A fun, relaxing environment with nice crispy pizza. There is outdoor seating, so on a warm evening, it's great to chill outside. The parking is a little limited, but street parking looks like an option. I luckily nabbed one of the spots outside. My friend and I shared a large margherita pizza with pepperoni and it had a nice thin crunchy crust and the ingredients tasted nice and fresh. The offer wraps and salads, but with pizza in the name, they definitely deliver on that. If you want good pizza and a casual but fun ambiance, this is a good place to relax and enjoy some pizza. read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - Pepperoni on a margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Good pizza, good food. This place gets loud and crowded on the weekend. Prepare to wait for your table. Service isn't fast, but that's ok since the pizza is made fresh. I had the 10 in cauliflower crust pizza. The $16 price was a bit steep-for that reason I wouldn't get it again. But it was really good. My BF had the chicken parmigiana. He said it was good. It seems like a much better deal at $11. They do carry out. read more

First time here. Was on my list to try for a year. Drive over and sat outside. Food is very good. Ordered 2 pizzas. Drinks . Shrimp and eggplant. Will come back. read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

Good pizza. Crapy service. I'm used to bad service after living in FL for 15 years, but I pulled up and called this place 5 mins before their "stated time pizza would be done" thinking most places over estimate the time, and the lady answering the phone was so rude. All she said was "your pizza is supposed to be done at 4:55, it will be ready at 4:55". Ummmm ok. She must hate being in the service industry. Ugh. Update: my pizza was cold when I got home (3 min drive), so it clearly had been sitting there a while. I will say there was some other staff there that were great. Unfortunately, this one woman had to ruin the experience and my pizza. Ugh read more

Best pizza place in Palm Harbor. They're menu is robust, tasty, and not a bad thing on it! Great selection of beer and wine.

Food is delicious every time. Best pizza I have in FL (I'm used to NY pizza). My mom got the homemade lasagna and it was delicious as well. The waitresses are always very friendly & nice. You can watch sports games at the bar/ "brewery" or sit out side and listen to live music from the restaurant across the street. read more

See all

The pizza was great and they took very good care of a party of 7. We enjoyed cheese curds and bruschetta for appetizers.

It's a great pizza restaurant for eating in the restaurant and takeout. I highly recommend it! I haven't had a bad pizza here yet and I've eaten here at least a dozen times. Pizzas and salads are both good here and I heard their spaghetti is good too, but I personally haven't tried it yet. read more

Great pizza for takeout. Definitely a bar atmosphere inside, but they have TV's for watching sports and everyone is friendly. All of their food is really good. read more

We met friends for dinner here & were pleasantly surprised by the food & service & atmosphere. We sat outside near a heater & enjoyed the outdoor cafe-feel in late November. Our waitress was attentive & personable. We ordered garlic knots as an app & totally loved the flavor. Beware though as we were asked if we wanted marinara sauce with the knots. We said yes, & they charged us extra for the sauce on the final bill. We ordered a large pizza with half pepperoni & half sun-dried tomato. The pizza was fantastic. A slight taste of smokiness was instilled in the pizza & added to the flavor. The crust was thin & the toppings were great. I was most impressed by the pizza sauce's flavor. They make an excellent tasting sauce. Overall we enjoyed the food & ambiance. read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - Outdoor seating with heaters. - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

I feel like fireside pizza is one of the best pizza places in Palm Harbor! The only downside is that it is swamped all the time, so if you don't go early enough, it's a long wait for a table and they don't deliver. So when we do to go orders, it's hard to find a parking spot when they are busy to go in and get your pizza. But the pizza is amazing! read more

This is our favorite local pizza joint! They were doing a very brisk business of carry out during Covid but they have plenty of outside seating as well. Their pizza is great brick oven quality. But they also have really good pasta dishes and hot wings. They also feature a very good tap list which includes their neighbor deBine brewing. Order the garlic knots, and ask for a side of their Alfredo sauce. You will not regret it. read more

The wings, wines, & pizza is what we've had. No complaints at all. The wood fired pizza is amazing. The sauce and cheese are so fresh and totally make the pizza amazingly delicious! The atmosphere is family style and comfortable. A/C inside if you want. And great outdoor dining space. The place across the street have live music that you can take advantage of. Really recommend for dinner! read more

Delicious! Love that it's downtown so you can enjoy a beer elsewhere and then go grab a pie.

We have had the pizza here a couple times and it's great. They have a decent tap list, too. Just stay away from the wings. They taste like they were boiled and then thrown in some sauce. Gross!!! read more

Pizza was VERY good, staff were attentive even when busy. Feels a bit crowded and squished but overall it was a good experience. I would recommend pizza only. read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Good spot for pizza and wings. Ok, understatement. The wings are truly finger licking good. The pizza is coal fire baked which is my favorite. Toppings seem to be prepared fresh in house The service is equally as good. Our server, Scottie, was on point. We had a large table of 18, mostly kids and she rocked it. She had great food beer, and wine recommendations. There is limited seating inside and if you go on a weekend you will want a reservation. Do your safe a favor and hit this place up! read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Fireside is right in the heart of Downtown Palm Harbor, which is becoming quite the hotspot. Myself and 2 friends ordered a plain cheese pizza, well done, to make it crispy. We also ordered Bruchetta, which was served with pizza dough pita triangles, which were a nice touch. The pizza was very tasty, but not crispy enough for my preference, but still VERY good. The service was great, even though it got very busy. The only unpleasantness was the family at a neighboring table with a dog that barked throughout our entire meal, startling me every time. People...not EVERYONE loves dogs and wants to hear them yapping through their meal. Bar Fly is right across the street and had live music, which we also enjoyed. Other than the yapper, it was a great evening. read more

Pizza is great. I wish they could handle takeout at all hours. I've been told that pizza orders during dining hrs, take a couple hours or more. "Kitchen cannot handle orders of pizzas at busy hours" read more

We just went for the first time while visiting our parents. Very delicious!! We ordered the fireside wings which were wood fired with onions and the sausage and ricotta pizza. Both were so good and the service was great! We will be back next time we are in town. read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - Fireside Wings - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Saw prior reviews that were good. Ours: incredible pizza. Margherita Pizza. Great service as well.

Great pizza however it was a little cool. We were told 20 minutes and that is exactly when we arrived. Pizza was already done, boxed and waiting for us. Even though the pizza wasn't really hot, it was simply delicious and we are looking forward to our next order there. read more

This was restaurant was recommended to us by a friend and thought we would give it a try. We hoped it would be at least good enough for times when we didn't want to drive somewhere. Weren't we surprised when we learned how off the charts FABULOUS it was! We have been here at least a half dozen times in under 2 months! Everything we have ordered I'd nothing short of AMAZING! The entire staff is friendly and helpful but our favorite is Sherri. She is patient and takes the time to explain anything we don't understand. Always has a big smile and clearly loves what she does. She is half the reason we love coming here so much! She makes coming here fun. Plus, she always seems to know the exact time we need her but never hovers. If you want a place that you can't go wrong with ANYTHING on the menu, this is your place! Ask for Sherri and you'll have the PERFECT evening out! read more

Fireside Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

See all

Best service and pizza! Jenny is best bartender and always smiling! Sandwiches and wings are well worth it. I love thé cauliflower crust too. read more

Best pizza in town period. I'm a little biased because the restaurant is close to my house, but other than that, you can never go wrong with Fireside. The pizza, winds and salad is to die for. read more

Fireside Pizza is my favorite Local pizza joint. Their pizzas and wings Are always on point. This tiny house in Palm Harbor Holds a wood fired pizza oven. They use quality ingredients And a little bit of lovin'. My favorite pizza is the Bianca. That's what they call their white. Garlic, mozzarella, ricotta, It's more than just all right. The crust is amazing Just the right amount of char. Grab yourself a table. Or a seat at the bar. I've also gotta mention The Fireside wings. So smoky and spicy. Can't get enough of those things. The staff is always friendly Tho I usually order To Go. Then I stop in next door At Coolside Gelato! read more

Great pizza. Some of us prefer the cauliflower crust. Btw, the pizza is ready on time ! read more

If it isn't already, this place should be considered a gem of the Tampa Bay Area. My wife and I have been coming here for several years now and they've never skipped a beat. The food is fresh, delicious, and unique. The Fireside Wings are phenomenal!! If you haven't tried them, make that a to do. Their pizza dough is probably one of the best I've tasted not to mention, yeah I know, their cauliflower pizza is just as good. If you think you're a pizza connoisseur then try Fireside, you'll be amazed. The place is a bit small, but it gives you that cozy, hole-in-the-wall feel. The staff is tireless and take care of you even when it's super busy. My Usual - Large all Pepperoni, Half Jalapeno, well done - Garlic Knots w/ extra marinara sauce - Fireside Wings w/ Blue Cheese ZOMG! So good. :) read more

The best pizza in Palm Harbor! Always hot, fresh and delicious. The wings are great also.

Dining in is great, they are aware of cleaning and take care between customers. The gluten free crust is so good I will eat it and I am not affected by gluten. Kudos to the staff, you folks are awesome! read more

Great brick oven pizza and wings! If you're getting to go call ahead early as wait is anywhere from 45 min to almost two hours. Busy place, totally worth it read more