Love the food and drinks! The fried chicken is amazing. There's staff is always friendly. The restaurant is normally busy so reservations are recommended, it tends to be loud but the food is worth it. read more

Maybe a better place for just drinks and great service? Execution on food could be a lot better. The food that needed the least amount of cooking were the stars. Aka the salad that comes on the side and the creamed spinach. I had the surf and turf that which comprised of ONE scallop and pork belly. The food came out cold and wished it was better tasting. They did reheat it after my complaint. My husband had the fried chicken (not pictured). The chicken was crunchy but that's bc the batter on the chicken was hard. Our server was really nice and attentive. read more

Five Eleven - Surf and turf - 1 star - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Our server was pretty quiet. House appetizer was cold bread buns with butter. The entree portions were so unbelievably small and mediocre for how expensive they were. I got a filet of steelhead and a smear of pureed potatoes for somewhere around $35. The ambiance doesn't exactly give fine dining, but I'll give 2 stars for being sat in a nice booth + they were playing Sparklehorse. read more

So, this was honestly one of my favorite places but unfortunately, things have shifted with their menu which is a HUGE disappointment. I am giving them two stars simply because of the excellent service. During our last visit, this was the only positive. My husband and I come up from Santa Rosa just to dine here. We've specifically enjoyed their happy hour and fried chicken which was hands down THE best. I understand that restaurant's change menus for what they think is for the better but not in this case. They have new fried chicken recipe which was flavorless and too heavy on the batter. The new chicken is served in a spicy sauce and with spinach which was an interesting combination. The happy hour menu which previously included THE best wings has also shifted to offering fries, sliders or fish and chips. They even changed the bread offered. While it's a nice location and provides great vibes, we will not be back. Our server (also the bartender, I don't catch her name) was beyond attentive and nice but the food was horrible. Super disappointed in the changes they have made. read more

Hard one here. We have tried again and again, and we both remember a time when this place was the bees knees in old town Eureka. But alas, they have failed us in some way or another on our last four visits. It was her birthday dinner and we ordered a lot, so here goes... Sloppy, Under and Over Cooked, some things maybe good, but nothing at all was great. three apps: Arancini - over fried to a hard crunch, a bit far for my liking.. finding difficulty in cutting it with the edge of my fork. flavor ok but way overdone. Polenta with ragu great flavor but strange watery sauce and custard-ish texture to the Polenta. in my opinion, not well thought out or tasted. Gnocchi with black truffle - under cooked, almost raw very soft, no bite. cream sauce was good but the black truffle shavings had zero flavor, I could not taste or smell the essence of truffle at all. Cesar Salad - On point and delicious actually the star of the show. which that alone is terrible. sloppy plating. Lasagne Bolognese - Not super hot or evenly heated. One half of my Lasagne was Luke warm, the cheese inside on that side still solid. Bolognese was good but not great. Carbonarra - Not traditional, small skinny pasta which was al dented, but entirely Luke warm which ruined the dish. panchetta was crispy almost too crispy, but completely lacked the deliciously creamy rich consistency of a light egg sauce that the dish requires. this was dry, awfully luke warm and dry... it should be godly, divine, gently served, with a peppery personality... we pointed it out and showed it dry and cold when asked, but the waitress soured on us after that... drinks: Negroni - was ok but not great Whiskey Sour - was served on ice after being ordered and emphasized with no ice please. we were instructed after that we should have ordered it "Up" then it would have come with no ice... Ambiance: Drunk girl cackling at the bar from before we went in till after we left. she kept going into the kitchen and talking to the staff, that was the only time the ambiance was on point. her voice was sharp, she was loud, drunk, and I could hear her after we left 40' away from the door. Whomever you are visiting back there knows better. to the waitress with the long curly hair (tara?), thank you for always giving a shit, thank you for offering to help or remedy even though you were not our waitress. you've always been a star. unfortunately we won't be back. that's $500 over 4 visits in the last 3 years. 3 yrs ago the meal was so off that when the waiter could clearly see our issues with the mains they comped the whole meal... It's just not worth it anymore. we did a whole Italian meal tonight and none of it was up to par, all of which are staples in Italian cooking... consider straying from the Italian twist on the menu if it can't be done right . training, more training, , tasting, and iron fisted supervision is what this place needs... overpromised and under delivered. Luckily for you guys the majority of the humboldt food scene has no idea how bad this is... par for the course for up here... read more

See all

Good location. Food was hit-and-miss. Pizza and pasta were good but all the other dishes we ordered have wrong texture. Risotto's texture was like grit, overly cooked. Brussel sprouts were more like steamed not roasted. Pork chop was burnt and very very dry. Chef needs to go back to learn some basics. Service was not too good either; food was served real slow but the check was given real quick. Two of us were still eating yet the check was already placed on the table. Have no idea what was the rush as the restaurant was half empty :( read more

We went on a Sat evening and thankfully had thought ahead and made a reservation, as those walking in had a 45 min wait. We requested a booth so our reservation was made for the Pearl Lounge, which is attached. it did seem quieter than the Five Eleven side (same entrance). cool vibe. bartender/waiter Eric was great - accommodating, totally honest about anything you asked him about the menu, great personality and always with a smile on his face. Drinks were good, filet mignon was perfectly cooked, shrimp scampi was flavorful, crème brulee was delicious and the bananas foster cake was superb. Little pricey for us, but we were treating ourselves for our 15th wedding anniversary so it was worth it. read more

See all

We sat at the bar and ordered drinks, apps and dessert. The food came out quickly and was pretty good. The drinks were okay, neither had muddled fruit as described and I think the tropical was also missing the coconut cream so it just tasted like straight tequila. read more

See all

Visiting family came on recommendations for a nice birthday dinner. We were seated upon arrival and ordered drinks. I chose the Scarlet Ruby - a seasonal option- and hubby ordered an old-fashioned; they were just okay. We were served a bread and butter basket--nothing remarkable with the two bread options. After many questions with our waitress, we ordered the Burrata appetizer, steelhead with lobster risotto, and Bolognese with Wagyu and garlic bread. Our selections were served promptly. The Bolognese received rave reviews, but the garlic bread was burnt. The steelhead was lukewarm and overcooked, with the edges burnt. We were not checked on once we received our food. We decided to take a chance with dessert as we were celebrating - Choose a Banana foster cake with ice cream and a flourless chocolate s'mores torte. What a mistake. The banana cake was so dense and flavorless, even worse, the torte was burnt, and you would have needed a hammer and chisel to cut into it! We flagged a server down - she even attempted to try her hand at sampling a taste with no luck. They removed the torte from our bill. We left disappointed. T read more

Great spot! Servers are super nice. I did ask for a dessert menu and was waiting on it quite a while. We ended up asking for the check because about 30 minutes passed and I never got the dessert menu. Besides that, great spot. I really enjoyed it. read more

Five Eleven - Filet minon - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

Worst most expensive 3 piece over fried chicken ever. With mashed potatoes you mean the 2 tsp? With tax and tip this came to about $40 for something that could have got better at KFC for $4.99 read more

The steelhead dish is done very well and their poke nachos have fresh tuna. I've been here 3 times and they have yet to miss the mark.

Pork chop was dry and burnt on the outside. Took a long time to chew. The entrees took ~45 min to be served. AVOID.

This place is great. Great drinks and great food. The wait staff is on it and the kitchen puts out amazing food. My only complaint is we ordered the agnolotti and got some odd shaped ravioli. We will be back! read more

Five Eleven - Not agnolotti - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

Thankfully, I'm not sick right now. Showers curtain in the bathrooms, filthy floors I don't believe they use Snake river wagyu, never use a ciabatta bun for burger. Who puts prison lettuce on a hamburger, straight taco night left overs from the hospital commissary read more

Located in Old Town Eureka, Five Eleven is an upscale restaurant with a casual environment and fantastic food. We had reservations for 7:30pm on a Saturday. The restaurant wasn't super full but there were a decent amount of filled tables. Service was prompt, professional, and attentive. We ordered two cocktails: a gin tarragon collins (a special) and a dirty gin martini. A small bread basket arrived to the table in short order. For food, we settled on two small plates: woodfired Brussels and polenta crostini. The crispy parmesan and caramelized onion in the Brussels were particularly good, though they could have been warmer. The polenta crostini was a real show-stopper, with delicious mushroom marsala that may have been my favorite part of the dinner. For my main, I ordered the mushroom and butter bean cassoulet. It was very good, though I will say that it didn't feel too dissimilar to something I would make for myself at home. Also a little salty for me, but in a way that was really delicious, just a little bit heart rate increasing as well. My dinner date (my mother) ordered the filet mignon because YOLO. She asked for medium rare and I would say, in my inexpert opinion, what came out was closed to medium well, maybe medium in the center. Still, she enjoyed it tremendously and had no complaints. Delicious dinner with a nice view of some very cool old buildings in an area of Eureka that has clearly seen a good deal of investment in the last few years. Before tip, it was also under $150. Reasonable prices, great service, great food. An overall fantastic experience. read more

See all

When we choose a night out, we almost always at least consider coming here. It is a favorite and always delivers good service and food. My personal favorite is the Filet. Tender, juicy, always cooked perfectly. However, I really enjoyed the steelhead with lobster risotto tonight! My husband always has the same thing, the Fried chicken. Crispy and delicious every time. They have good appetizers. Great burgers. I haven't had anything I didn't like. The staff is friendly and attentive. It is a little loud in some areas but not overwhelming. I highly recommend this for your next night out!! read more

Five Eleven - Steelhead with Lobster risotto, Delicious - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

We had a wonderful time No reservation on a Saturday -great drinks and good food. Our server was attentive,nice, and made our experience easy going. Will definitely be back. read more

Five Eleven - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

The meatballs, crab ravioli, and chocolate martini were delicious and will be my new regular order. The service was incredible, the servers were very friendly and accommodating. Will be coming back here often. read more

We started with the burrata and it was served with Asian pears and was delicious. I had the filet mignon and it was cooked perfectly and came with broccoli and some delicious scalloped potatoes. Everything was tasty! read more

Five Eleven - Filet mignon - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

Always a treat to go here for dinner never not satisfied, very classy and great atmosphere

This place is for sure a hidden gem! We went over the holidays and were blown away by how innovative and delicious the food was. Every course was better than the last and the service was impeccable too. Finally, this restaurant is unique bc you can choose the ambiance; half of the place is a sports bar type vibe with retro booths and a wraparound bar and the other half is a romantic and intimate venue with individual tables. We chose to eat in on the quieter side and would definitely visit here again next time we're in the area! read more

Are there last night. They were out of four things on the menu, three of which we were ordering. They were out of rib-eye, duck leg Mac-n-cheese, starter bread and the Kombucha. Then we got our food and the meat from quite a few of the ravioli had apparently fallen out during cooking so it was mostly just meatless ravioli. Overall not a great experience. The tomato bisque was good though. read more

Damn good food! What else is there to say? Service was good as was the ambiance . Highly recommend.

Four-stars for food, Two- stars for service. Right when my husband and I walked in, we were greeted by a young woman who didn't exactly seem to be in an amazing mood. She began to take us towards the back of the restaurant when it was a beautiful day outside, we wanted to sit in the front next to the window. We asked if we could please sit in the front instead, she seemed a little bit bothered by this request? We sit down, a very nice woman with long blonde hair came around and was very good about refilling our waters, then our server came. Younger girl on the shorter side, her attitude made my husband not want to leave a tip at all! Never will I feel good leaving only 12%, but she was that bad. I don't know if something happened before we got there that put the staff on edge? But our server hardly came to our table, and when she did, she would ask us questions in a very direct way, and when we would politely thank her, zero response. We are not difficult people, we understand being a server can be hard work! That's why it sucks when we get bad service. We both got the fried chicken plates, which was pretty good, clam chowder very good, I got the cherry Bolt drink which I liked, my husband got the mango jalapeño margarita, which he said had no alcohol in it. Lol. We did think everything was very over priced, but we appreciate they are trying to clean up Eureka and give it a more upscale feel. I can deal with a rude hostess, but a rude server? She made the experience quite bad. She hardly came to our table, we asked for more bread twice, and it wasn't even busy. She knows who she is, not a cute look girly. read more

Wandering around Eureka, looking for a meal that isn't the usual burgers and fish and chips. Stumbled on this place, didn't have a reservation, but they still let us in. So happy they did. The bartender took care of our table and was fabulous. She recommended some delicious cocktails with berries that were off the charts. Best cocktails I have had in a while. For our meals we got the flank steak and steelhead salmon and they were phenomenal. Best sides, cooked to perfection and delicious. I got a peach and almond cake to go which was a wonderful dessert. Loved this place! read more

Five Eleven - Antioxidant and a pale ale. - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

The ambiance was nice, the service good (and friendly), and the food pretty good. The place was clean, and they had enough staff -all working hard. We were in town for 1 night on a Tuesday. We were seated quickly without a reservation (about 5:30). Our drinks were served promptly, and then basically our server disappeared for a bit. Fortunately, there was another server that kept the water glasses full, and made sure my hubby didn't need another beer. Someone else served our food, and then we did see our server again when he checked on how the food was. My hubby ordered the New York and Shrimp. It did not appear to be a New York (maybe a sirloin?). He had ordered MR, but it came out MW. He tried it as we always do and it tasted good enough to eat so he didn't send it back. It was a good flavor, just tough. We really try not to send food back, as it feels like a waste, and you don't know if what you get is going to be any better- and you end up waiting longer. If it's decent and edible, we keep it. My food was good, no complaints. I had the hamburger (no bun). It was flavorful and the bacon was amazing. We didn't get dessert or appetizers. It was a nice meal, just not one that would make us run back to Eureka to repeat. read more

So good!! Amazing food , service, atmosphere and selection. Great place to enjoy dinner read more

Five Eleven - Filet - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

Food was amazing. Waiter recommended the steelhead. It was great. Drinks, dessert, oysters were all top notch. Highly recommend.

Had the best time. We got the surf and turf along side all of happy hour bites. Food was tasty and service was great! Would happily come back here next time we are in the area. read more

Arrived at Happy Hour time and informed the hostess that we did not have reservations. There were ample tables avail but she sat us in the dark ambiance side bar to the left. Tara helped us out in the bar area and got us some great food and drinks! My faves that I ate include the Soft Shell Crab Taco $6, and Green Curry Clams and Mussels $11, were so on point, just wished there was a little more rice. Wings had a nice spicy breading. My co-workers had the duck breast dinner over polenta entree and dozen oyster + taco. Both were happy! Upon leaving we noticed lots of tables were still open and they had bread to munch on. This left us feeling a bit second class . If I'm up in Eureka again, perhaps in the summer I will give them another shot. Hopefully to be seated in the main dining room! read more

See all

Heard at the table next to us: "I need to tell him exactly where we're meeting. What's the address here?" Duh... Well, it was the first night of our road trip up to Portland, and we decided to take 101 this time, so Eureka seemed like a good spot to stay. I haven't been here in more years than most yelpers have been alive, I suspect. It's a funny little town, built primarily as transit point from ships to trains. We toured around to see all the amazing Victorian architecture before coming in for dinner. It was a warm night, and they left the front door open allowing a lovely sea breeze. We were seated towards the back, which was good, because the noise level was a little lower back there. I neglected to record prices, and their online menu omits them (which really irritates me) so I'm afraid this review does not show them. Our starters: WOOD FIRED SCALLOPS: on the 1/2 shell, citrus & herb beurre blanc - 3 stars. I had debated about choosing these vs the ahi poke, and our server, who was excellent, highly recommended these. Looks like he and I have different tastes, because while the beurre blanc was well balanced and the perfect texture, the scallops were overdone. I think if they'd just seared them on top and then added the sauce they would have been better. They seemed to have cooked them in the sauce. GRILLED ROMAINE CAESAR: parmesan, croutons, white anchovy, charred tomato vinaigrette - 4.5 stars The salad was perfectly balanced and I liked the novelty of the charred tomato, though I think this probably disqualifies it as a Caesar. The boquerones were plentiful and delicious. Entrees: FISH & CHIPS: local smelt, crispy potato gaufrettes, plum tomato horseradish sauce & tartar - 4.5 stars Although this was listed as a small plate, it was just the right size for my appetite that night. I have wonderful memories of my grandma making me fried smelt, and these did not disrespect that memory, too bad Grandma never made those crispy little potato squares. I especially liked the homemade cocktail sauce BUTTERMILK FRIED CHICKEN: sautéed greens, duchess potatoes, gravy - 4 stars I didn't actually taste the chicken, but Tim said it was well fried and juicy, but needed a little more coating and more seasoning. I did however taste the greens and they were silky, hammy, slow cooked wonders. I could have eaten a whole bowl of them! They took it from a 3.5 to 4 stars A surprisingly sophisticated find in this little town. Food: 32/40 Service: 18/20 Atm/Intang: 17/20 Value: 17/20 Overall: 84/100 read more

Five Eleven - Fried chicken, baby - New American Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Love the fried chicken! That, and a manhattan cocktail are my favorite combo, never order anything else! Yummy! Love the front window table best and we're always well taken care of. Definitely our special occasion favorite. read more

Last night was our second visit. My husband is picky about restaurants especially ones that are on the pricier side, but he loves 511. They were slightly short-staffed and told us that up front, but we didn't mind. We sat in the Pearl Lounge side where we had a comfortable view of the TV so we could watch the baseball game. It wasn't crowded or noisy in there, which we appreciated. We started with Bacon and Egg - braised pork belly with a sunny-side-up egg on top. This is the part of the pig that bacon is made from, and it is accordingly rich and fatty. So good. My husband had the carrot-ginger soup, which slightly tasted of curry and was creamy and sweet. I had the Caesar salad made from local Romaine - crisp and plentiful. I would have liked a little more Parmesan and some anchovies but other than that it was a great salad. We ordered the Bolognese fettucine and the pork chop. My husband wiped the sauce from the pasta plate with their excellent house-baked bread. I loved the grainy mustard sauce on the chop that went with the Brussels sprout-fingerling potato hash underneath. To finish we ordered a flourless chocolate torte. I would describe it as very dense and fudgy, not too sweet, and very dark and intense. They were very busy but service was good. We love this place. Photos attached are not the best but should give an idea of the delicious food. read more

See all

Finally got to try this place last night after hearing good reviews. Everything was delicious! We ordered a bunch of apps - raw and cooked oysters, calamari and shisito peppers, scallop and shrimp ceviche, and a bowl of clam chowder. Oysters were fresh, calamari had the perfect amount of breading and breading was light and crisp. Ceviche was fresh and light. I got the lemon brûlée cocktail and it tasted like summer. Entrees were halibut and clams and pork chop - both yummy and good portions. Didn't have room for dessert but will definitely be back to try the creme brûlée! read more

Chicken the best! Usually call for reservations. If full, pretty noisy. Service is good and attentive. read more

Delicious duck, great restaurant - highlight of eureka and I'm a very very picky eater so really enjoyed this one. Will be back when I'm in town. read more

Food, service and ambiance. Fried chicken was unbelievably amazing. Husband had the flank steak. Cooked to perfection and the sides were awesome. read more

We had a good time at five eleven last Saturday 5/11, everything was just right, from start to finish, excellent service and great customer service really enjoyed the place read more

The service is top notch. Make reservations on busy nights. The house made bread is mouthwatering and you can't go wrong with a campfire old fashioned. The fried chicken and greens are always worth an order. They spoiled my girl with a beautiful creme brûlée on her 10th birthday. They handle food allergies with ease. And they always make leave us wanting more. This restaurant is a family favorite and we alway love the evolving menu. read more

Five Eleven - The duck with polenta is my favorite. - New American Near Me - Eureka, California