This is thee spot! Pizzas are greeat! Service is also wonderful! Always polite and always attentive of the orders!

Terrible they changed their name to Saucey cause they sucked as 5 Star and they are still horrible. The cheese is like plastic and the dough is raw!! When you call to tell them about it they hang up on you!!! I do not recommend this place at all. read more

Pizza was delivered on time and tasted great! Sauce, cheese and toppings covered the whole crust, worth every penny. Will definitely order again!! read more

This place uses homemade sauce, homemade dough, and Wisconsin cheese all making for a BOSS pizza! The HUGE 24" PIE-ZILLA is simply the coolest and a must try! Always the best deals for whatever the occasion, great bang for your buck! Veteran ran business with a Local vibe, a kind and friendly staff, with BOSS Pizza, at a Great Price! Five Stars Highly Recommend! read more

So wonderful to find this restaurant open following hurricane Ian. Stopped in to get dinner, staff was extremely busy, but extremely friendly and helpful. The only thing I was unprepared for was the sheer size of their extra large pizza, but it tasted fantastic and I will have leftovers for at least a day! Thank you so much to their wonderful staff, I will be back. read more

Five Star Pizza - Post Hurricane Ian. Open! Great service, great pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

See all

Their meat lovers pizza is just about all of my pizza dreams come true, im so glad this pizza spot is so close to me. Service is always fast and friendly. Great staff. I wish I had picas but we always just dig in read more

We found this place by accident last winter, now it's the only place we get pizza! Very flavorful reasonably priced

I usually stay with the same restaurants I've been going to for years, because they're familiar, they're always good, and they have yet to disappoint. However, I didn't feel like driving out of the way to my regular spot for pizza, so I chose a place on Yelp (obviously) that is rated high. I found Five Star Pizza that is about 2 1/2 miles from where I live. There pizza is really, very good, and I am extremely picky. I'm picky about the kind of pizza sauce that is used, and the quality of the toppings. This place offers high quality pizza, and wings. I personally enjoy the garlic-parmesan, and spicy garlic wings, and the pepperoni-sausage-mushroom pizza. The flavors all come together so well to make the perfect meal. read more

See all

Always fresh ingredients that they use! Love the giant pizza I Buffalo Chicken Pizza read more

The pizzas is great I would stop off if you're in the mood for a pizzas. It waste the flavor like papa John's but their garlic knots I would pass , it's not even a garlic knot it's more like a dinner roll with no flavor of any taste of garlic. They need to make actually Gary knots with garlic in it to make customers buy it read more

I ordered a pizza, it never arrived. I asked for a refund, they refused. NEVER order from this place. thieves. I contacted the BBB. this place needs to be shut down! read more

I was expecting so much more after reading the reviews. Who the hell cuts a round pie into square pieces. The sauce was too sweet, right out of a can. I ordered extra cheese, and the amount cheese was very light. read more

The food is generally ok, last time I ordered the wings were over cooked and dry and pizza tasted like it was sitting there already made stale read more

Utterly disgusting place...Roach baked into the Pizza! The sad part is they cut the pizza right over the roach! How did you not see this and still deliver the pizza! Well one good thing came about... they likely would have flicked the roach off and still delivered the same pizza! Truly and utterly disgusting. I am so disgusted by this. They did however refund the money. They claim this is the first time but I highly doubt that this is a first. This is a big roach! read more

Five Star Pizza - Roach baked into the Pizza! The sad part is they cut the pizza right over the roach! - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

I have been coming here for over 6 years and I can count on them on a good pizza. I prefer the pizza saucy so I get it with extra sauce but pizza is always hot and usually wait times are less than 30 minutes which is a deal. Their wings are really good too. I get the mango harb and its delish! read more

My family ordered from Five Star in August of 2023 and my husband and I have been dreaming about these garlic rolls ever since!!! it was top of our list to have the next time we were back in the area and they did not disappoint read more

Had a friend in town and he was going to order from Al's.. I suggested this place as it was closer. My bad. The pizza was just ok..I've had supermarket pizza better though. The "chicken bites" were awful. A bad soggy version of Mcnuggets..not sure they were even chicken. The cinnamon rolls were just that. rolls with cinnamon on top. At least I tried it..now i know not to make the same mistake again. read more

The pizza is shit has to much sauce I told them light sauce they added more dumb people why the fuck do they pay y'all if y'all can't do the shit right read more

Love it. Good service, good pizza and good value. Would recommend to everyone. Good portion size read more

I waited 1 hour 40 minutes, I order a thin large pizza, I got a FAT ice cold pizza. Check your pizza before you pay

Oooh good pizza. We order their Piezilla ALL THE TIME. It's a MASSIVE pie with square-cut pieces that feeds a party of 10 EASY! Definitely recommend. read more

They're pizza is delicious! So far it's the closest that I've found locally to NY pizza.

The name of this place is correct. We just moved here, and I ordered for the first time. I had a coupon, and the pizza was enormous. I will never go anywhere else. Thank you. read more

We ordered 2 pizzas (one XL and one L) and we received two pizzas both wrong (smaller size and type), ordering via Grubhub. I tried to call the store to get things resolved but they stated that they were too busy to help me and asked that I call back later since it was their rush hour. read more

Solid pizza. I recommend the wings and the cheesy bread. Reasonably priced and with quick service and delivery. The storefront is what you would expect from a small pizza place. Not fancy but it's ultimately about the pizza. read more

Started as an ok experience. We had just landed in Kissimmee and were looking for some quick food and a beer. We ordered and ate a couple slices, saved the rest for leftovers. Here's where it turns awful...eating the leftovers tonight I bit into a chewy object...much to my gagging, I pulled a small latex balloon out of my mouth. I still want to puke typing this. Naturally I called the restaurant. After being put on hold and waiting some time I got the manager on the phone. His reaction was, "I'm sorry but that's just not possible. There's no way a ballon could get in our food." He said there was nothing he could do about it because the order was already closed out. What the HELL? After much pushing he said, "I can give you a ten dollar credit in your next order." Ummm, hello, THERE WAS A BALLOON IN MY PIZZA!!!!!! At the very least I want this order credited back in FULL. Furthermore we are not from the area. We are disputing the credit card charge. Never again! read more

See all

This place has really, solid pizza. Lots of flavor and great bang for the buck. The wings were big but very, very greasy. Delivery service was excellent but wish there was an option to tip after the delivery. I don't like tipping prior. read more

Ordered online at 3:30pm for a 4:30pm delivery. At 5:10 I called and asked if our pizza order was received and if it was coming as it was over a half hour late. I was told that it was the next on out and would be there shortly, then the person on the phone told me if I wanted a specific time that I needed to call, not order online. My pizza finally arrived around 6:20pm, no apologies, no consideration or even a coupon for the next visit, just, here's your pizza 2 hours late. The pizza itself was so-so, ordered with pepperoni and onions, maybe 12 pieces of pepperoni and a thin slice of onion broken up for the whole pizza (very skimpy). will not order again. read more

The pizza was a gift for my mechanic. As I have abstained due the large stomach I grown. The aroma was mesmerizing and very tempting. The recipients were very glad and made quick work of it. Which made very appreciative thanks again read more

This was my first time eating here and it was fabulous! I ordered pizza, wings, and pepperoni rolls. The food was ready promptly and the customer service was stellar. I even met the owner and he was extremely friendly. Overall, this was a great experience and I recommend it to all of my friends. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

Found this place on Apple Maps definitely need to get the pepperoni overload it's one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. I would drive all the way from Orlando to come here and get that pizza. Make sure you bring a large car to it home! read more

Ordered pizza here since I moved to fl from NJ. Love the style it reminds me of home in a way. Better than getting like Pizza Hut and stuff. The Buffalo wings are good and spicy ! read more

This is my favorite place to order delivery pizza. Their pizza is delicious! I've been ordering from them for years. One thing I wish they had was French Fries on the menu but they have tons of other options. They have great prices for their pizza the best in town if you ask me. The other commercial pizza companies like the food chain pizza places are overpriced for not so fresh ingredients. Five Star Pizza has great prices and great tasting pizza. read more

Amazing service. We tried a pepperoni pizza, it was great, very close to NY style pizza.. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

This is our "go-to" place for delivery, if you'll pardon the oxymoron (or is it a paradox?). Anyway, we really like the pizza. I get either just cheese or tomato & onion, and my guy gets pepperoni. We usually each get a 12" which feeds us twice. It reheats GREAT (not true of all pizza). The hot wings are delicious, too. The delivery speed varies, but we are patient people and they take good care of us regulars. :-) Oh, the brownies are awesome and taste homemade. Now I want brownies. read more

Pizza is awesome. Real NY style. Best I've had in fl. Pass on the wings they were way too chewy even when I said extra crispy. Pies are huge too read more

Over priced...... Not that good anyways...... Rude delivery drivers...... Pizza is AVERAGE but not worth price...... Coupons on the other hand are nice, sometimes makes it acceptable to order a pizza..... read more

My family and I ate here about 2 weeks ago on our trip to Disney.. It was a little bit of a drive.. However.. We wish we would have found the place earlier.. We ordered a 26" yes 26" pizza.. Which came with wings and a 2 liter for $30.00! It was cheap and it was excellent! Wish it was closer to home! read more

Five Star Pizza - 26" pizza... Yes that's a 2 liter! - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

Best pizza! Super close to NY pizza. Staff was great, prices are fair and the taste and quality is definitely worth it. They offer monster pizzas which are 24". Place was very clean. #lovepizza read more

Five Star Pizza - Delicious scrumpalicious pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Kissimmee, Florida

The food is good. The fact that they deliver is also good. Only issue I find is the customer service, it can be hit or miss. Delivery normally takes a while.. there's been times I've waited 1 hour and a half and longer. Calling in orders can be frustrating because sometimes the workers are not familiar with the menu and they enter in something wrong, charging issues, etc. I recently went to pick up an order because I was not wanting to wait an hour for deliver and the customer service honestly shocked me. The store was busy and the phones were constantly ringing off the hook. The person in the back was just shouting "Put them on hold!! They have to wait! Do your job!!" It got to a point I believe he said don't worry about answering the phones. His tone was not really appropriate in a store full of customers. My food was not ready, others food was not ready on time, and they even messed up an order - there were no apologies or anything like that for the inconvenience. The guy in the back continued to make remarks to the workers, and it was kind of harsh and disrespectful. I like the food, but I don't know how to feel about the customer experience.. therefore, 2 stars. read more