Oh boy was this good. Additionally they have Penn State Creamery available. Need to make one more…read moretrip while I'm still in town.

Very friendly atmosphere with a wide selection of products and a very helpful and friendly staffread more

What a delicious experience, First time here I ordered a small soft chocolate in a sugar cone. The…read moreice cream was delicious and I love the signature pretzel added to it. I was amazed how they were able to handle the large crowds. The facility was very clean. Employees were friendly, fast and helpful. They have plenty of seating inside and out.

Very nice and clean place. Staff is friendly and location is ideal, anything on Carlisle is a good…read moreidea. It's nice to have a mini golf place right next door. But the ice cream itself, I'm not sure if it's frozen yogurt. Maybe I've gotten too used to custard but this was the opposite in texture. And flavor? What flavor. We tried the peach soft serve sample, I didn't think it was terribly hard to make considering chick fil A owns it! But yeah this was like peach flavoring you put into water, with Splenda. The blackberry just tasted like purple, idk it makes no sense. And the sundae that is literally vanilla with fudge and mix ins...the best part was the pretzel. And these waffle cones are not even meant to hold a transfer from hand to hand. I had to ask for a second one after the first broke. I'm disappointed! I wanted a good spot in west York, and this place looked so good from the outside

Our group of six had a great time here! The building has a historic charm that made the wait (about…read more15 minutes) more enjoyable, and the outdoor line even had a fun game to keep us entertained. We passed another ice cream shop to try this one after a tour guide mentioned it was among the best in the country according to a recent news article. While my two-scoop cone definitely hit the spot on a warm August afternoon, my daughter pointed out that the article's author might not have sampled some of the fantastic dairy stores and ice cream shops we have back home in the Midwest. I'd have to agree--I've had better in Minnesota and Wisconsin. Still, this is a charming stop with tasty treats and a fun vibe--worth a visit if you're in the area!

First time in town and decided to give this plave a try. We had orange pineapple and coffee ice…read morecream. The ice cream was creamy with good slightly "chewy" texture. Flavors were on point without being too sweet. The staff was friendly and helpful. Highly recommend!

Amazing ice cream and portion sizes for a relatively low price. Very nice staff and fast service…read more The decor is amazing with memories on the walls and a candy shop vibe.

As always the foods great and ice cream even better. Love this place! Bring CASH!…read more Make reservations for inside to eat. Outside there is seating. To order ice cream-order outside window.

I can't see a better place to leave a review for the coffee shop inside, but I have to share how…read moreimpressed I was with it and the co-working space of The First National Bank! I had tea; my friends had specialty coffees. We had a pastry, muffin, and packaged fruit bar. Service was fast and friendly. And we visited in a relaxed space for a couple of hours. I will come back!

Pretty spot, amazed at their delicious nondairy ice cream: 3 flavors! Service is friendly too…read more Great vibe.

I love coming to Cubby's! I always get something different than my norm. Today was watermelon…read moresorbet with strawberries and a cherry on top!! I liked it so much I went back for it again a week later! When I got there I checked out their pay-it-forward board (please note I don't actually know what the board is called) and I was able to find a note that applied to me! I love that Cubby's has this option. It's so caring and really makes you feel connected to others and what the business is about. I was particularly grateful for it because my free sundae allowed me to treat a friend to a quart of their favorite ice cream. It's chocolate marshmallow and it was heavenly! The staff here are so friendly! I've never had any issues ordering and I've been here more than a handful of times. The place is really cute. I love the large outdoor deck with oversized games. Too cold, or not for you... there are regular sized games all throughout inside. I just think that's the coolest thing. So if you're bored or need a date idea, this is a great place to get a treat, play some games, lounge, and enjoy each other's company. SUPPORT SMALL BUSINESSES!!

I'm being generous here with 4 stars. Probably only 3 to 3.5 based on value. On this most recent…read morevisit, the serving sizes were incredibly small, but as always, the flavors of the ice cream were absolutely delicious. There are closer and better valued options for those who live in Harrisburg or on the west shore. Probably not going to make a special trip here again, but if nearby, possibly stop in for a treat.

Some people wake up early to go to the gym. Some people wake up early to be productive members of…read moresociety. I set an alarm for National Ice Cream For Breakfast Day. When Candy Mountain Creamery announced they'd be opening at 7am for build-your-own waffle ice cream sundaes, I felt personally called to action. Because if you're not celebrating extremely niche food holidays with reckless enthusiasm, what are you even doing? Also working in my favor: I had recently signed up for the Cumberland Valley Coffee & Chocolate Trail, and realized Candy Mountain Creamery was a participating stop. Two birds. One waffle-shaped destiny. Alarm set for 5:45am on a Saturday. Commitment level: alarming. At 7:52am, with temperatures hovering around 15° and wind chills that felt emotionally aggressive, I walked into the shop smiling like a person who makes excellent life decisions. Parking was easy thanks to their strip mall location -- always a win when you're battling winter just to eat dessert for breakfast. I fully expected chaos. Lines. Fellow sugar enthusiasts wrapped in blankets waiting for their moment. Instead? I was the only one there. The universe clearly said, "This is your main character moment." The staff were warm, friendly, and somehow just as excited about ice cream as I was. They told me to pick three flavors and they'd take it from there. My pre-caffeine brain selected: Cherry Cordial, Banana Nut Bread, and Maple -- which in hindsight sounds like the ice cream equivalent of chaotic good energy. While they prepared my masterpiece, I completed my Coffee & Chocolate Trail check-in and used a coupon for a free medium latte, because nothing pairs with ice cream breakfast like financial efficiency. Moments later, they handed me a golden waffle piled high with three enormous scoops and pointed me toward the toppings bar AND a roaring gas fireplace. I nearly ascended. The toppings bar had everything -- Reese's Pieces, whipped cream, strawberry topping, caramel, peanuts -- and I exercised exactly zero restraint. Reese's Pieces? Yes. Peanut butter drizzle? Obviously. Whipped cream? Don't insult me. Then I settled into a cozy chair by the fireplace and proceeded to absolutely demolish this breakfast like a person with no regrets and excellent priorities. The ice cream itself was fantastic -- creamy, flavorful, and distinct enough that each scoop held its own despite my slightly unhinged flavor combo. The latte was piping hot and perfect for balancing out the sugar-fueled chaos. Honestly, aside from the waffle sundae itself, the fireplace deserves its own Yelp listing. I expected to be freezing while eating ice cream before sunrise -- instead I was warm, cozy, and deeply at peace with my life choices. A few other brave souls eventually wandered in, which reassured me that I am not the only person willing to eat ice cream at breakfast in sub-freezing temperatures. Huge thanks to Candy Mountain Creamery for being one of the only local spots open early enough to support my commitment to food-based holidays, for having incredibly friendly staff, a fantastic latte, and a warm space that turned a cold winter morning into something genuinely memorable!

Delicious ice cream and great customer service! Fair prices too! Cookie Monster ice cream was top…read morenotch!

Tasty ice cream. Friendly staff. Affordable home made ice cream. Do you need more than that?…read more Very tasty ice cream. So many flavors to like! Peanut butter is a family favorite. Basic chocolate is excellent. The best surprise is the teaberry - try it on a hot summer day. You won't be disappointed. This is a family run place that serves classic ice cream. We get pints to take home, but it's a struggle not to eat all of them at once.

They used to make awsome ice-cream but now triglycerides are in there ice-cream. Not home made…read morechemicals that kill.

First time checking out this ice cream place. Was a bit difficult to find at first because Apple…read moreMaps made me turn a bit too early. The shop itself is bigger inside than it looks from the outside. Very cute pastel colors all around. Was impressed with the variety of flavors and how everything is house made. Some of their proceeds also goes to cat rescue and thought that was very sweet too. The staff kindly let me try a few flavors. Was still indecisive and ended up mixing 3 flavors in my one scoop: -pirates treasure: per their recommendation -lavender elderberry: great for those who like fragrant floral flavors -key lime pie: more on the tart than sweet side, especially liked the bits of crust layered in Looking forward to coming back to try their other flavors!

This is a cute & clean shop with very pleasant employees behind the counter. The only thing that…read moreprevents me from giving five stars is the ice cream. For many people - especially kids - it will be fine! Who doesn't like ice cream? But those with more discriminating tastes will find it, "meh." (Our daughter says we're "boujie" about ice cream.)

So, we had lunch reservations on Sunday for 11:30am. I was looking forward to it since many people…read morerecommended it. It looked popular but they were seating everyone. Not sure what was happening with staffing. It took a while to get menus and even longer to get our order put in. The waiter did check in on us to apologize for the long wait but it took over an hour to get our food. We saw other people waiting forever too and next to us, they were frustrated waiting a long time just to get their bill to pay. Another party had a woman finally flag down a waiter telling them no one has even taken their order. Where was upper management? It's not necessarily the waiters fault. Are they over-seating for short staff? The kitchen isn't keeping up with the orders, want to comp something from the bar maybe? One hours for food to come out is really disappointing. The food was good but not amazing or unique. The drink was suppose to be a blood orange old fashioned but tasted horrible so, probably not going to return for any mixed drinks. Scenery was very pretty bd relaxing. Ambiance was nice but restaurant service was so disappointing.

They use a 3rd paty reservation system, you speak to someone who is not an employee of AB …read more... Terrible customer service. Food is very good but the service is lacking and so slow to get the food out. nope ....