I appreciate the owner reaching out to me to replace the calzone and delivering another one to me.. I accepted the new one and had it made with just mushroom, spinach and cheeses. The difference in the dough was unexpectedly opposite of what I had received before - fluffy, full, crisp and the flavor was quite good. The marina sauce it came with, that I didn't mention the first time, was very tasty. This definitely added to the calzone. I shared it with my friend who owns an art studio in Noe (Art Haus) and she commented that she liked it as well :) Thank you again for being so attentive and correcting this. I enjoyed it :) read more

Let's start by saying that I have had an AMAZING weekend starting off with a Saturday morning & afternoon setting up my crib/nest/home for my chosen family and myself...deciding to treat myself to some "Retail Therapy"...and taking in a "Spur-of-the-Moment"...(literally) & (I mean IT) A Most Fabulous Drag Show (HUGE) Charity Special Event...BRAVO to "The CAFE" for hosting the MFD SHOW!!! Headed home and decided to get ready to go out for an evening of fun in the famous CASTRO DISTRICT!!! I had to run a few errands at the corner drugstore then went to see what the VERVE for the night crowd was like but it was 1:30AM...closing time...I'm feeling pretty good from the munchies and I was parked across the street from Fratelli Pizza...the place was jumping...the entire seating/table area was full, a small line out the door, the service is friendly and firm (know what you're hungry for), eye-candy behind the counter, service with a smile, these guys know how to move a line of hungry people along with their professional/friendly quick service! The Pizza is their "Crowning Glory"...(see my order)...this is the Pizza where you will want to eat the entire slice including the entire "CRUST"...(yes I said it)...whatever it is in the crust...is DELICIOUS...period!!! You know what I mean don't you?!?!?! You eat pizza but how many people fail to eat the entire pizza slice crust and all...come on...admit it!!!!! The only other thing I indulged in was a slice of Chocolate Mousse...I was planning on eating it in my car but decided to wait until I took a snapshot of my favorite items from Fratelli Pizza!!!!! read more

See all

Caught a show at the Castro Theatre and decided to get a slice before the long trek home. Went straight across the street to Marcella's, and the place was packed with a line outside the door at 10:30pm. Walked a block down and caught Fratellis pizza with no theater crowd and was in luck with fresh pies that just came out of the oven. There were two guys working and they were both very friendly and accommodating. Asked for jalapeños and pineapple to be added to my slice and they also added additional cheese. I don't know if it was because it was late at night or because I was hungry, but that slice was delicious even after just having pizza delivery the night before. The Hubbs had a slice of pepperoni pizza and also loved it. He even ate the crust which is very rare. I'll have to order a calzone to go next time! This is a casual order at the counter, pay, and find a spot kind of place. Even for a casual eatery, the staff checked in and asked the diners there how was their food? read more

See all

I love their buffalo chicken pizza! They are always very nice too. Welcome addition to the neighborhood!

The pizza was really good overall. The crust had a nice texture, and the toppings tasted fresh. I just wish there had been a little more cheese, but the flavor was still great and I'd order again. read more

Amazing pizza but most of the workers aren't good...I paid $24 for 3 slices and the guy asked me if I wanted a box - I said yes and he charged me $.50...fine but then he put one slice in a small box and the other two on a plate and told me I should have specified I wanted 3 boxes...if I'm paying $.50 for a box why can't I get one that holds 3 slices? read more

I appreciate the owner reaching out to me to replace the calzone and delivering another one to me.. I accepted the new one and had it made with just mushroom, spinach and cheeses. The difference in the dough was unexpectedly opposite of what I had received before - fluffy, full, crisp and the flavor was quite good. The marina sauce it came with, that I didn't mention the first time, was very tasty. This definitely added to the calzone. I shared it with my friend who owns an art studio in Noe (Art Haus) and she commented that she liked it as well :) Thank you again for being so attentive and correcting this. I enjoyed it :) read more

Fratelli Pizza - New Calzone (much different). Choose my own topping -Mushroom & Spinach with the cheese - ricotta, feta & mozzarella. - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Some more competition to the slice heavy Castro Street. I kinda like this more than the old stalwarts. It's no Tony's and not something you'd get in Manhattan, but it's fine for the Castro. Cheese Slice: Decent. A tad doughier than an authentic NY slice, but I guess that makes it more filling. About $5.50. Buffalo Slice: Two of these and bottle of soda will cost you $19.55. It's tasty for sure, with ample amounts of ranch and hot sauce so it doesn't dry out like other buffalo slices. Some tender chunks of chicken. Maybe my favorite slice here. Meat Lovers Classic Slice: It does indeed have a ton of different meats. And bougie looking charcuterie looking meat, not just your typical pizzeria meat slice. So it's hearty. But it's also kinda dry. It feels like they skimped on the sauce a bit. read more

See all

Popped in for a quick slice well Two actually. The clerk was disinterested, barely got the order correct and questioned us as to what we ordered and paid for vs what he rang up in the register. Came across as rude. Don't bother with the pizza either. It was bad. Like frozen cardboard pizza No flavor what so ever. I mean the pepperonis was ok but no other seasoning. I had a slice of Pepp and a combo My friend had cheese and a veggie. All bland. Plenty more options in the area read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pizza on plates - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

You'd think the crowded pizza market in the Castro would be saturated, but apparently not! The service is decent and Fratelli's is a no frills environment, but they've got the goods if you're just looking for a simple, tasty slice on a paper plate. There are plenty of varieties to grab, and fwiw the slices are slightly cheaper than some of the competition. They also have a nice selection of condiments for those of us who are into that. I've already been there twice. :) read more

Fratelli Pizza - A decent combo slice at a good price with fun condiments. - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Great Food Exelent Service. This Restaurant never fails. The Pasta is amazing and the Pizza freshly made ! they have the best Caesar salad read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

Not bad, and good that it's open late. But I found the crust too doughy/rubbery - it was helped by a bit of time in the toaster oven. The sauce was only ok, it has some heat (which is good) but the heat's being used to mask some lack of complexity. The cheese blend was OK but tended too much towards mozzarella with not enough "bite" from other cheeses like pecorino. read more

Great place to grab a slice before or after a show at the beautiful Castro Theater. The crust is perfection! Friendly service too. read more

See all

Simple, tasty, fairly priced, lots of sauce options on the side and quick service. Perfect for after bar hopping or dancing next door. I like that the pizza crust isn't super thick and has a lot of toppings. read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

All I wanted was a slice. But he was sitting on chair watching his phone. And when I finally said "I'll go somewhere else" he still didn't move until I was out the door. So went to marcello's Either get on your customer service game or close the doors. Good pizza. Crappy service. And cute doesn't cut it!!! read more

What do I appreciate the most about Fratelli Pizza? I think it's the good old fashion cheese pizza with thin crust. I appreciate their late hours. Been going to Fratelli's forever. https://solidairmusic.com/album/1452245/beautiful-world-from-beautiful-world-cd-2017 read more

Ordered 3 slices via Slice at 10pm. Supposed to be ready at 10:29. Went to Fratelli at 10:29 and they first put the slices in the oven. No message that it was ready until after pickup. The pizza had a good crust and ingredients but a bit skimpy. Would try again. read more

Good pizza by the slice! Clean restaurant and fast service. Easy to get a bite to eat.

Tried it twice now, both pizza & calzone are good. The pizza was good, lots of quality toppings. (sometimes Hawai'ian pizzas have like 1 piece of ham & 4 pineapples barely covering it), this had good coverage. First time we tried calling in a pizza order after looking at their website, was some confusion about the charged amount. Cashier at that time was unclear about price difference. Eiad (owner) let me know that there had been changes , but the website hadn't been updated so that's why it appeared to be more expensive than listed when I called in & picked up (vs. ordering online). I have noticed that due to surging food inflation a lot of places are having to increase prices in the last few months. That makes sense and I appreciated his taking the time to check and let me know what had happened.. Came back again today at lunch to try a calzone this time, Eiad (apologies, I called you Elad) was friendly and gave great service. The ham calzone was delicious, with both mozarella and ricotta. (and he was willing to make an individual adjustment - to remove mushrooms). So the explanation of the price change, the tasty food, and the service today means I will return again. read more

Simple, tasty, fast, and chill! This place was everything we needed it to be. There were a lot of great pizza by the slice options - loved the thin, crispy crust. They were super nice and quick while still making us feel chill and welcomed. Pretty tasty ranch too! read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Cheese pizza pretty good. Slices are generous in size. Super cheesy. Really appreciate how quick it was - grabbed it on my way home from work...would recommend if you're in a rush! read more

Came here after a couple drinks in the Castro & this place absolutely hit the spot. The service was fast and friendly, the pizza was fresh, crust was flavorful & every bite of each pizza was enjoyable. My favorite slice was the everything but I don't think you could go wrong here. I'll def be back! read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

I grabbed a slice late night here. It was pretty decent. I'd go here again for pizza.

Every bite was a delight! The crust had the perfect crunch, the sauce was bursting with flavor, and the toppings were so fresh. Definitely my new favorite spot! read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Just what we needed late at night/early in the morning. Really nice people working here and the pizza quality is great with lots of slice selections in the early morning hours. We will be sure to stop here again next late night on Castro. read more

See all

I ordered a pepperoni and sausage slice and chicken tenders and fries from this establishment through DoorDash. I placed the order as my bus home started so about 20 minutes and driver still had to wait for food after my bus ride. By the time it got here I saw they threw some cold sausage and a little cheese on a pepperoni slice and barely warmed it so the sausage was still ice cold while the slice was barely warm. The fries were just raw potatoes and the strips were hardly warm. It is like they missed the order when I put it in and rushed it when the driver got there with no care at all for quality. I had to cook my fries and my strips myself after a long days work. So gross. read more

Wow! That crust! Probably the best pizza crust I've ever eaten!! The toppings are great as well. Quick service. Central to Castro. Reasonable price for the quality for sure!! Environment is clean and simple. It's about quality and efficiency. read more

Fratelli Pizza - Chicken pesto pizza with a drizzle is sriracha mayo and Parmesan cheese. - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Favorite pizza shop in SF. The staff is always super charming and very kind. Will always come back. Also has lots of sauces and toppings as well as other choices of food! The atmosphere is open and warm for a nice dine in experience and a loving ambiance with friends! read more

Eiad has amazing customer service!!! I work as a first responder in the EMS system in San Francisco and he was extremely caring and respectful to me and my partner. We highly suggest coming here and showing some support to our local community businesses. read more

Fratelli Pizza - Margherita Glaze Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

owner said he'd give us a slice for 4 dollars each and then proceeded to charge us over 15 dollars for two slices. He thought that we wouldn't notice but we did. Too bad the ambiance was too lame for us to stay after that. Super disappointed especially considering that he (the owner) had offered us jobs and then lied to us about pricing. Lame. Pizza looked gross anyways read more

A simple slice of cheese pizza is always my go-to benchmark when trying a new pizzeria. The sauce's flavor needs a chance to come through cleanly, as does the cheese and crust flavors. I liked my slice! ($5.00) The hints of oregano in a nicely seasoned tomato sauce perfectly paired with a milky mozzarella and a chewy crust. In addition to slices and whole pies, there are other options to choose from too: chicken parm, wings etc. Welcome to the neighborhood Fratelli Pizza and best of luck! read more

See all

I enjoy that they have space to dine indoors, have big slices in variety, reminds me very well of New York Spots, except this place has kind and welcoming employees read more

Fratelli Pizza - Love the space to dine and having giant slices with variety of toppings is satisfying, employees are kind and welcoming - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Best pizza in Castro! The chicken, scallion, ranch slice OMG! The owner Ian actually makes the pizza and works the counter to serve you. Support this local owned business. read more

A solid pizza slice for sure. The combo and pesto chicken were excellent. Crispy, flavorful, hot and huge! It must have been a pound for each slice. $7 a slice but definitely worth the hefty price. A clean new restaurant, plenty of seating and a super nice owner. Highly recommend! read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pesto chicken and combo slice - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Right place at the right time the pizza is right on time service is great they want to please you read more

Fratelli Pizza - Counter front entrance - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

My husband and I have been coming here regularly. Recently my husband had a slice of chicken pesto pizza and I have had their cheese and their pepperoni slices. When served hot they are excellent. We think their pizza is the best in the Castro neighborhood by far, and some of the best in the city. It's NYC style. We highly recommend you give them a try. read more

Wow amazing service here. I especially want to highlight Ian! The care and compassion he has for people and our public servants is amazing. It's clear that kind of care is also put into their pizza as well. Great crunch of the crust with a nice chew and an exception flavor from the Hawaiian with jalapeños stop by and give them a try! read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Absolutely love this new pizza place in Castro. We needed it so much, delicious flavors, great service and friendly staff. Give it a try, highly recommended. read more

See all

Great slices. Convenient. And the staff is very friendly to their customers. They are welcoming

First visit at this pizza place, cool place n assortment of different gourmet pizzas, loaded toppings worth every bite, inside nice n bright, clean bathroom , n lots of bottles of spicy sauces for your pizza, hot my eyes on HOT HONEY! I must try next visit..open till very late till 2 am yay... come try all slices too... read more

Fratelli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all