This is a classic San Francisco spot locals love. Highly recommend the clam and combo pizzas…read more Watch out though as it can get busy, usually a bit of a line especially on the weekends No place to sit inside unfortunately, but you can either eat on the street or take it to Washington Square Park nearby.

Very tasty pizza!! I really enjoyed the clam and garlic pizza - def recommend! The ingredients…read moretasted high quality The slices are pretty large - 2 slices had me full. The half pan comes w/ 4 slices! It's pretty affordable given the quantity of food. There's no seating and the line does get pretty long - we went during a festival day so we waited ~30-40 mins but were pretty happy w the pizza afterward! Staff were all very friendly.

Pizza by the slice in SF near Bill Graham. Been craving some pizza and found this place. Came in…read morenear closing so only had limited options. Hit the spot for some NY style pizza! The pizza was heated with a crispy crust and topped with fresh basil and Parmesan. The pepperoni was solid. The square pizza was a bit doughy. Spicy vodka sauce and pesto base were tasty. These slices satisfied my cravings! Ranch has nice dill flavor to it. Quick service and they have seating inside. Street parking.

If you like NY style pizza and need to grab a bite to eat before a show at bill graham, this is the…read moreperfect spot! I tried the puttanesca and chicken tinga. The puttanesca had a very nice bright taste thanks to the capers. The brine wasn't overpowering the other aromatics. My favorite was the chicken tinga! I love a green sauce and there were dollops all over the slice I got! Chicken had a pleasant char. Downside is the place is small and seating is limited. But otherwise a delicious choice!

I was on a business trip and Square Pizza Guys was just around the corner from my hotel. After 12…read morehours of business travel, I was ravenously hungry! Their pizza/ I mean pie was amazing and brought this exhausted traveler back from the dead! The almanac lager helped too!

it's quiet in here on a weekday at lunch. order then find yourself a seat. pizza takes a while…read morebecause theyre making it fresh for you. nice interior, clean and spacious. you can even hangout upstairs where there's even more seating. the larger tables are downstairs. solo dining upstairs would work. service was kind and gave me lots of water to go with my meal PIZZA was GOOD. tried the buffalo chicken. it's more of a rectangle shape and just a good size slice. pretty filling! you will be full with just 2 slices. lunch time hours offers half pie so you dont have to buy a whole pie

This is one of my favorite spots to get pizza from! The crust is sourdough which makes it more on…read morethe thinner side. It is very crispy and they're pretty generous with the toppings. We ended up getting a large loading dock pizza for 3 people. We had two slices each and had enough for leftovers. I enjoyed their ranch as well!!! There is a good amount of seating in the restaurant! There's also a 21+ seating section in the back for more room too. The service didn't take long as well. So good for sourdough crust!

overall overhyped i fear :((…read more buffalo chicken pizza was my fav. bonus points for breaded chicken. think they'd probably be better on a "chicken parmigiana pizza". pepperoni pizza was decent. wayyyy too oily for my liking. pizza on the thinner/floppier side. not my pref tbh.

Had an impromptu birthday dinner with some friends here…read more The seating outside was great for six people, and the service was fabulous. Especially given that we were bringing in our own birthday cake to have and share among our friends that night. We got five different pizzas, and the four-cheese one was the fan favorite between us all. Definitely would recommend either a date night here or a night out with friends if you're in the area.

We visited Il Casaro Pizzeria on a Saturday evening and were seated quickly after joining the…read morewaitlist, which we appreciated after a long day with tired, hungry kids. Service was generally polite but a bit sparse given how busy it was. I specifically asked whether the kids' pizzas were small personal sizes or large enough to share, and was told they were personal-sized. Unfortunately, we ended up with more food than we could realistically finish and essentially paid for a pizza that went to waste, which was frustrating. The food itself didn't quite meet expectations based on the reviews. One of our pizzas also came out slightly undercooked, but the kids were too tired for us to send it back and wait for a remake, so we just made do. Overall, the experience was just okay, especially compared to other pizza spots we tried during our trip. After visiting places like Tony's, which we loved, this one fell short for us. The restaurant was busy and had a decent energy, and others may have a better experience depending on timing. For us, though, it's not a place we'd return to.

Amazing NY style pizza right in SF! Huge slices for 5.25 per slice regardless of what flavor you…read moreget. They heat up the slice for you on the spot. Flavors changes on a daily basis. There's one dine in table. Love the asparagus flavor pizza, they drizzle pesto on top. Julian was also delicious. I prefer the white base pizzas.

Ordered delivery from the Hayes St. location last night and the pizza arrived looking like it had…read morebeen carried sideways the entire trip. The entire pizza had shifted in the box, slices were folded over, grease was splattered all over the lid, and it was no longer hot by the time it arrived. What made this even more frustrating was the amount paid for delivery. In addition to the food cost, I paid a $3.99 delivery fee, a $5.70 service fee, and tipped the driver $5.50. For that kind of added cost, I think it's reasonable to expect the pizza to arrive level, intact, and hot. The restaurant is about 4 miles from my house, and it appeared the delivery was made by bicycle, which may explain why the pizza ended up tilted and damaged during transport. I can't say that for certain, but something clearly went wrong between the restaurant and my door. The pizza itself may have been good fresh out of the oven, but the delivery experience completely ruined it.

Has good pizza, good customer service, and good ambiance, that's all I'm going to sayread more

Most similar to NY style pizza I've found in SF so far. Thin crust, no flop…read more They're often quite busy with almost all of their 10 booths full, which is a testament to their quality. On a busy Friday night, they ran out of cheese and a few other options for a while since they were so busy churning out whole pies to go. I get 2-3 slices (they're big but thingdepending on how hungry I am. $4.75 for cheese, and $5.75 for all other toppings. Out of the couple times I've been, Pepperoni Mushroom has been my favorite slice mostly due to how flavorful it is, followed by Cheese/Plain, then lastly the Julian (red pepper, onion, mushroom) which I found didn't have enough tomato sauce for my liking. My friend tried the Tomato Garlic and didn't like it much, maybe just because there wasn't any tomato sauce.

I ordered the grain bowl through doordash for pick up because I thought I'd have to get back to my…read moredesk quickly, however, when I picked up I realized I did have enough time to sit and eat so I sat at an outside table with my to go order. I am aware that I didn't pay for table service or dine in fees that most SF restaurants have now so I was trying to be out of sight and not make any mess for the staff to clean up. Some restaurants don't even let you sit outside to eat if you do pick up so I was just hoping they didn't come out and ask me to leave. Not only did nobody ask me to leave but 10 minutes into my sitting someone came over to offer me a glass of water. I declined because I do feel wrong accepting service when I didn't originally order that way or tip properly but I am very appreciative that they went out of the way to offer water! The grain bowl was also very delicious and filling! very generous portions for the price. It was my first time going even though I've been working in the area for a couple years and I'm happy to have a new go to lunch spot!

Order a pepperoni thin crust well done. The pie came out great. The sauce is good and the cheese is…read morevery pronounced, although the over all pizza could've been cooked longer to make it crispier. The service is world class though. I was acknowledged immediately, the pie took 10 minutes during dinner time while it was very busy, and the staff were super friendly. The place is a small and cozy spot, great for dinner time. Paid $20 for the pie with $2 tip. Let's get that pizza crispier! I can't wait to try them again.