We had such a great time at Goat Hill Pizza's Monday night buffet! The pizza was delicious, the atmosphere was fun, and the staff made the experience exceptional. My boyfriend has celiac disease, and they went above and beyond to accommodate him. They remembered where we were sitting and personally brought each gluten-free pizza to our table, with lots of great options throughout the night. It made him feel so included, and we really appreciated the extra care. If you're in Potrero Hill, the Monday night buffet is a no-brainer. Even if you're coming from another neighborhood, it's worth the drive--easy parking, amazing pizza, and some of the friendliest service we've experienced. We'll definitely be back! read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Let me start off by saying I'm a huge lover of Goat Hill Pizza, love that sourdough crust. I hadn't had their pizza in quite a while. I placed an order thru DoorDash on a Friday evening. I ordered a medium half combo and half Potato Pesto. I ordered crispy and I did not get crispy, the combo was lacking condiments and it was super soggy and wet on the bottom. The Potato Pesto was not great either. I also ordered a salad and the lettuce was turning brown and was not edible. I paid over $60 for an unsatisfactory experience. I honestly don't know what happened if they were having an off night or what but it was not good at all. Super sad read more

First time trying this pizza spot in the city due to their birthday benefit and it was pretty good. I got the Porky Pie and it tastes really good, I loved the roasted garlic on the pizza. I would say it needed more protein on it as it barely had any toppings in general. Service was good too, I just ordered online and when I arrived, my pizza was ready. I ordered for takeout so didn't eat in but it did look to have a nice seating area to eat. Reason why I'm giving this place a 3 star is because this small pizza with only 6 slices was pretty expensive -- a little over $20. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - MD Porky Pie - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

One of our colleagues had won an award so a group of us wanted to celebrate it by going out to a restaurant for lunch to eat. Someone suggested Goat Hill Pizza as it was nearby and we made a reservation to come by during lunch. The place itself has that old Italian feel, a very traditional feel and when you walk in you can see the pizza makers working on the pizza through the glass, you know its fresh! We were seated quickly as we were the first people to come that day, we started off with some appetizers, a few orders of chicken wings and ordered 3 different XL pizzas. I forgot to take a photo of the last one as it was further down the table. The wings came out quickly and we all enjoyed them. I dipped mine in some ranch to give it that savory and sweet combo. The pizzas came out shortly after, and wow, were they huge! We had a group of about 12 and thought it wasn't going to be enough, but we ended up not finishing everything! The vegetarian one was just as good as the meat ones. Definitely a great place to enjoy with friends, and they mentioned that I believe that one of the days they have an AYCE menu, where you can come in and try all the pizzas, where they servce them in smaller portions so you can try them all. I'll be aiming to go to that next time! read more

See all

Pizzas were pretty good. We tried them at one of our fur baby's friend's birthday party previously and then we later got some delivered. Also tried their wings and a caprese salad. All pretty delicious with their sourdough pizza crust. I heard about their very popular All-you-can-eat Monday pizza nights, but we have never been. Only tried them via delivery. Located on Connecticut and 18th Street. read more

See all

No frills sourdough pizza joint in Potrero. The veggie combo slice was better than the cheese slice. After I started eating a staff member brought out some extra napkins and some water. If you're within walking distance you should give them a try. read more

See all

I found this awesome place in Potrero Hill after asking my colleagues what the city has to offer for birthday deals, and I am glad that they mentioned this place! From the front of the restaurant, it looked small, but once you step inside, it goes way back deep with lots of tables and it had that classic Papa Gino's vibe that I loved from the East Coast. They also promote a Monday AYCE pizza and salad night, which looks like it could be a fun and chaotic evening for pizza lovers. What really attracted me to this restaurant was their awesome birthday reward of 19.75 off any pizza! I love sourdough, so this was a great excuse to try them out. Their dough is everything I wanted! Fluffy, crispy, and full of that deep sourdough flavor. I ordered a small Margherita pizza with pepperoni added, and it came out great. Crisp undercarriage, slices held up well, toppings were generous, and the pizza looked as good as it tasted. When I came in to pick up my order, I noticed the big slices they sell displayed near the front counter and I couldn't resist grabbing some too. Prices were very fair for the slices. There was a little mix-up where my reheated slices accidentally got handed off to another customer, so I waited about 20 extra minutes for a fresh one to be made. But honestly, it was worth the wait because the pizza was good. Definitely coming back for their Monday AYCE night! read more

See all

The highlight for me is the crust. Their signature sourdough is what makes the pizza a total standout--it's tangy, crunchy, and sets up the whole pie perfectly. I always recommend going for one of their specialty options; the Hilda's Favorite (pesto and goat cheese) is one of my favorites, but I'm also a fan of the porky pie (with whole roasted garlic cloves and bacon).. My biggest tip? If you can handle the crowd, check out their legendary All-You-Can-Eat Monday night. Just be warned, you'll probably have to wait awhile to get seated, but it's a fun, chaotic tradition. read more

See all

I love their pizzas (I've had several flavors), but their minestrone soup with garlic bread is even better in my opinion!! I swear it's the best in the city. It's full of chunky, juicy veggies and is oh so comforting. The garlic bread that comes with it is a huge sized portion and done just right (not too much garlic). I now order it every time I come here. Their weekend staff is always very friendly. All of this is turning me into a regular here. :) The little table outside is perfect for 2, as it's on a picturesque intersection. It's always calmer on this corner of the street compared to the crowded spot located catty corner from it. Terrific for enjoying a satisfying meal with some good people-watching. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Small Hawaiian Pizza. Yum! - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

I love the variety and the options at Goat Hill Pizza! They don't skimp on toppings and the sourdough crust has a nice crunch/texture paired with the cheese, sauce, and toppings! The pizza isn't too salty and overwhelming, so you can easily eat many slices! I highly recommend their chicken bbq or veggie combo. If you don't know what to pick, try going on Mondays for the AYCE period. You get to try various toppings in mini slices. The staff walks around with slices and you can signal that you'd like another slice, so it's completely up to you how much you eat. You definitely fill up, so I think it's worth the value and a fun experience with friends. Mondays can get pretty busy, but generally you don't have to wait. Personally, I wish the sizes were larger. You can always just get a large, but they advertise a medium pizza to feed 4-5 (which is subjective to how hungry/much you can eat). If the group has big eaters, size up the pizza! read more

See all

I went here for their Monday pizza buffet and it was so fun! I love that the slices they give you are small and there's a lot of variety. They forgot a number of stuff for our table (water, salad, sauces, etc.) but the servers were helpful to bring out the stuff we needed. My fav is their bbq chicken! read more

Ordered to go, but ate 5 mins later down the street. Very tasty when fresh and definitely taste the sourdough when you order the cheese. good ratio of cheese to sauce to bread. Would come back again. Be aware the packaged parm has carcinogenic preservatives in it, but it's a very small serving anyway. Live a little. read more

We got two pizzas for takeout tonight, one was half cheese and half bbq chicken and the other was the Mediterranean. The crust is SO good! I loved the flavors of the bbq chicken and their cheese is really a classic cheese. Everyone was very nice and I can't wait to go back! read more

Great water, i love my usual California pizza. The crust the sauce and toppings are all perfect. I love the location, never had a problem with parking. read more

A neighborhood pizza joint you can go to every week and be happy with. Sourdough crust offers a good tang and you can request how well cooked you want it if you really want more crisp! While I am normally a cheese guy, the saltimbocca is my go to here! Lemon, bacon, sage, I don't know what it is about that combo but I can't put it down. That also have gluten free and dairy free options available which my household appreciates. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Gluten free and dairy free pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

This is one of those places that I consider old school San Francisco, a neighborhood gem and one I wish will never go away and stay just the way it is. I've been going to this place since the early 80's, in my college years, through working various jobs in the city and living in different neighborhoods, and now into the latter years. Its food is good in all regards, a reliable standard, the staff friendly and the facility remains in good order after all these years. So perhaps it isn't just the food, the staff and the restaurant, but in the aspect that it also holds a lot of good memories from the past with old friends and previous dates, it's precious in that way for me. Keep on rockin' Goat Hill Pizza, they don't make restaurants like you anymore. read more

See all

Goat Hill Pizza has a super nice birthday deal as part of their rewards program. You get a $19.75 off coupon during your birthday month and can use it towards anything on their menu! We ordered a small special combo pizza to share and it was delicious and filling. They do not skimp out on toppings, our pizza was stacked with meats, bells peppers, mushrooms. The crust was also amazing, perfectly crunchy and not burnt - they make sourdough pizza which was so interesting because I didn't taste it while eating the pizza until I got to the crust which had a hint of sourness. The texture was amazing. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Small Special Combo - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Unique pizza! You can definitely taste the sourdough crust but it's not overpowering. I could see how it's not for all palates but def worth a try. I loved my saltimbocca - first time having lemon on a pizza and it was yummy. read more

Great service! We were recommended the elote pizza and margaritas. We got a medium half and half which gave us a chance to try them together and I loved it! Such a crispy bottom and crust!! Will come by! read more

See all

I think if you rate this place down, you just don't understand the value of California Pizza, a genre worth your attention. Yes, Blah Blah Blah, your uncles place in NY, Chicago, Detroit, what ever, is the "best" (for you). But you live here now and our food is, well, better so get used to it. Goat Hill has been around for 50 years and it had Sourdough Crust pizza. Not east coast cardboard. Toppings are great and not skimpy. Ambiance. A+ for a pizza joist. It does not try to be a fine dining place (and charge you for it) People are nice, no east coast attitude. Lean into the stuff that makes the City great. Viva la Goat Hill ! read more

First time visiting to get a popular Too Good to Go surprise bag, which usually sell out within seconds. Street parking was easy. The staff took care of me immediately and let me choose 3 very large slices of pizza - I got 2 slices of a classic veggie (bell peppers, olives, mushrooms) & 1 slice of a veggie special with kale and goat cheese. They heated up the pizza for me. Inviting entry with a charming indoor dining area. Both veggie slices were tasty and satisfying with the sourdough crust. Hope I am lucky enough to get another Too Good to Go bag! read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Interior - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

I love everything about Goat Hill Pizza. My family and I have been coming here for yearssss. Truly 20+ years. It continues to have a 'family owned' 'mom and pop' feel and I hope it never changes. Everything from the friendly staff, the decor, to the authentic food is so welcoming. Our go to's are: - Chef's Salad - Wings & Ranch - Mediterranean pizza I also love going to their 'All-You-Can-Eat Pizza & Salad' Monday at their Potrero Hill location. It is from 5-9pm and costs $19.75! read more

Such a good pizza- and im not usually a pizza lover. Small shop with a few small tables inside, friendly staff, we were just getting takeout pizza so ordered and waited 10-15minutes for the pizza to be ready, quick service and you can see them making the pizzas in the large pizza oven behind the till. The sourdough pizza crust is so so yummy- and they load the toppings on so the pizza is very delicious and filling, a medium between two of us left us stuffed! Also appreiciated the large sides of ranch that came with the pizza, and also the lack of greasiness on the pizza, tasted good quality and fresh. Will definatley be back! read more

Cozy homey restaurant with unique pizza! We came in for a reallyyy early dinner and had the place to ourselves. Service was attentive and really kind. Saltimbocca pizza was interesting, lemon-y. Good, though! read more

Goat Hill Pizza - A Medium Saltimbocca - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

This pizza place was highly recommended by the staff at UCSF hospital as the go to place for sourdough pizza. The pizza was amazing as was the entire staff. I highly recommend them. read more

Delicious sourdough pizza with unique toppings!! The pizza is a thin to medium thickness with an extremely crispy and chewy crust. The saltimbocca has slices of lemon which give it brightness and the chicken, bacon, and sage give it a deep richness. Their small pizza is definitely enough for two people. I waited around 20 minutes for my pizza, but they make it fresh so I don't mind waiting! There're plenty of tables inside and a couple outdoor tables as well. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Small Saltimbocca - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

Bbq Chicken Pizza is freakishly good. I liked it more than the veggie combo by a lot. The salad could have been dried more, the leaves were very wet in the takeout container which watered down the dressing. Service was fast and friendly. read more

I had a birthday reward for $19.75 off so I gave this place a try. We got a salad and pizza. The pizza was amazing. The crust is so crisp and chewy. The pizza we got was a chicken lemon kind. It was delicious. Nice and lemony. We also got a garden salad. It was good. They also have the BEST ranch dressing I've ever had. I will come back again and try their pasta read more

See all

I'm house sitting within walking distance so I decided to try it out. The service was great, order ahead though because it's not quick making a pizza. The sourdough crust is wonderful, I will ask for it extra crispy next time, it was a little soft on the bottom. The ingredients were fresh, the garlic sauce was not overpowering, everything blended well together. I got a medium veggie combo add pepperoni with creamy garlic sauce and a Diet Coke, it came up to $37. A little more than I wanted to pay but it's nice to try out and support the neighborhood eateries. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Medium Veggie Combo add pepperoni with creamy garlic sauce - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

Not the best pizza I've had in SF but it's solid and they sell slices! Most pizza places in dogpatch/potrero only sell whole pies and I'm not trying to buy one of those in this economy. Speaking of economics, they also have all you can eat pizza on Mondays which makes no sense but if they wanna go outta business I'll gladly help out. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

One of my favorite spots in the city, the crew is always on point with the pizza and the staff as friendly as ever! Highly recommend for a simple night out with a date or with the family ! The small pizza is definitely my choice for two ! read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

My date and I shared the garlic bread and a small meat lovers pizza. The garlic bread was a little overdone--it had been left in the oven just a bit too long, which gave it more crunch than we were hoping for. As for the pizza, I wished the sourdough crust had been more pronounced, but it was still a unique offering. The toppings, however, were fantastic--fresh and high-quality. Service was solid overall. There was a small hiccup at first when our server accidentally brought the wrong pizza, but he quickly apologized for the mix-up. To make up for it, he treated us to an It's-It for dessert, which was a sweet gesture. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

Quick and made to order slices Popped in for a quick bite to go as was having a bit of a pizza craving Service was quick and to the point, all I needed in a to go order Tomato sauce and cheese slice is $4 any extra topping is $1.25, max 3 toppings per slice Ordered basil and sausage, slices came out to be huge, really only needed 1 slice Good value for money read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Sausage and basil slices - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

It's the dough and crust that keeps us coming back for decades now! Our go-to is pretty standard pepperoni and mushroom and often with black olives. Deeeelish. read more

I got introduced to this place after grabbing coffee with a friend, and it was a delight. Their sourdough crust is fantastic: chewy and a little tangy. It seems like a lot of people grab takeout, but they also have a pleasant dine-in area (very long, bigger on the inside than I expected from looking at the restaurant) and even more space in the back. I appreciated the chili flakes and parmesan on the tables. Service was quick and friendly, and they even have It's-Its for dessert! We split a half-and-half pizza with pepperoni and the saltimbocca - both were delicious. Doesn't beat the competition in Little Italy for me, but I loved going here and would go again when I'm in the area. read more

See all

Lots of space in the back of restaurant. you can't really tell from outside, it looked small to me, i thought it was only a takeout corner. Turns out it is quite spacious, great for large parties and groups. Family time, hangout with friends, casual date night. good ol pizza night. get a salad, a large pizza, and some drinks. friendly atmosphere, server was helpful and kind. food is tasty, traditional pizza meal. easy, lots of parking in neighborhood, no worries! good place to meet with people and not have to think about catching rideshare because it's not downtown where it is so congested read more

Couldn't get a simple take out order right. I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza, extra crispy, and one slice of vegetarian combo. I was told over the phone 5 minutes. That did not sound right, but I wasn't going to argue. When I they had only baked one pepperoni and the vegetarian slice. I was told 4 more minutes. Again, this didn't sound right. When I came back in, the order was still not done. When I came home, I had 2 slices of very soggy floppy pepperoni pizza. Disgusting. They couldn't get a simple order right. read more

Came here with some friends and were seated right away! Good: - Lots of different flavors, specializing in pizza - Super nice staff - Cute diner vibes - Portion sizes were good Bad: - Felt like the pizza was pretty greasy and didn't treat my stomach well Overall would come maybe for the all you can eat. read more

Goat Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Francisco, California

See all

have gone for the Monday night special for years My young friend loves it. Nice horde oeuvre sized slices , good salad, lots if conversation throughout the rooms and the staff is wonderful AND patient ! read more

Ordered medium chicken florentine pizza which has chicken, pinach and mushrooms. Added sausage, black olives, feta to 1/2 pizza. Plain pizza delivered with no chicken, spinach, mushrooms on pizza but additions on 3 slices of pizza. read more