Best place to eat in Gallup. We travel from Farmington through Gallup at least once a month on our way to AZ. On our way home we saw signs for Fratelli's and decided to stop in. We are so glad we did! Fratelli's is locally owned by Ruth who is one of the most authentic and friendly people we've had the pleasure of meeting. The food is top tier! We got the homemade Hawaiian pizza, pesto, and New Mexico roadrunner - absolutely delicious. Ruth brought us over their signature Alfredo fries, talk about a guilty pleasure! So tasty! Next time we go through we are trying the wings too. We capped off dinner with their homemade Gelato and sorbet, talk about the proverbial "icing on the cake" 5 out of 5 stars. We will absolutely be stopping there every time we drive through. read more

Fratelli's Bistro - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Stopped for a late lunch while traveling. Had pizza and calzone and both were excellent. Had gelato for dessert; suggested a new flavor of gelato by combining other flavors. Our server made it for us and it was fantastic. Our server was wonderful and we will return when we come back through! read more

visited in July on our road trip. Interesting place from the outside considering its an Italian restaurant located in Gallup. Was not sure what to expect. Very pleased with the service from Danielle who made some recommendations. Our food (pizza and chicken dinner) came out quickly and was delicious! Surprise no leftovers at all! Several families were dining as well and looked like they were locals given the interactions with the staff. Well worth a visit if you are in or going through Gallup! read more

Outstanding food, with large portions. The staff was friendly and very helpful. It's more of a family restaurant so don't expect fine dining. read more

Fantastic spot! Loved flavors of marinara. Meatballs were very tasty. Salad was fresh with a flavorful Italian dressing. Turtle cheesecake was a great way to finish my meal. Homemade gelato here as well as homemade banana nut bread and other varieties. Thoroughly enjoyed. Wait staff pleasant and helpful. read more

See all

ATTENTION ALL SOUTHERNERS THEY HAVE SWEET TEA! The owner was very friendly and the Pizza, Calzone and Gelato were very good! Ive been to at least 25 restaurants on this trip and this one ranks up there! Not to mention I haven't had sweet tea in weeks! we might make Fratelli's our annual stop read more

See all

We were passing through Gallup on our Route 66 trip and read about this place on yelp. We ordered the Lobster Ravioli, salad, bread (not to be missed), and New York cheesecake. Everything was amazing. The pasta was fabulous. I would not have changed a thing. If you're entrée doesn't come with bread be sure to order it. You will love this. So glad we found this place and we will definitely stop in again if we are out this way. read more

We had really high expectations due to the rave reviews on Yelp. In fact the real decision maker was when we read about the fresh baked bread with marinara sauce. And that's where it started to fall apart for us. The pizza guy makes the bread and I'm assuming he was late because we were there at 5:40 and he was just arriving. So no fresh bread for us. Then dinner arrived and it too wasn't fabulous. I had chicken piccata and my husband the Cesar salad. Both were reasonable, but we were expecting deliciousness. In their favor the gelato was good and the Chianti was very good, so I guess it was a partial win. Just not worth a return trip from us. read more

Pizza was very thick, doughy, but incredibly cheesy! I enjoyed that but I had better pizza before. My son was so tired and fell off the chair and I immediately responded to his aid, while everyone else (staff) watched and one laughed. No assistance or "is he okay?" So that was kind of annoying. But I mean, the gelato was great! read more

Don't go here. I ordered a turkey bacon avocado sandwich, and it was horrible. I had one bite and asked the waitress if I could order something else and she told me I would still have to pay for it and whatever else they brought me. I paid and left without eating. Terrible customer service! Go somewhere else! read more

Wonderful pizza and dog friendly patio! We had a cauliflower crust carnivore pizza and it was so yummy. The marinara sauce makes the pizza crust extremely flavorful. Ruth recommended the 1/2 order of Fettuccine fries. So good! Great recommendation if you've never been here or want to try something new. They have homemade ice cream we were tempted but too full to try. The restaurant staff was very friendly and helpful. The ambiance was very friendly and laid back. Highly recommended. We will return if we are ever in town again. read more

Fratelli's Bistro - Rocko hanging out on their dog friendly patio. - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Solid food . It's no gastronomical wonder but its solid diner fare in a highway town . .poor boy wings were crunchy and had pine nuts. Carbonara I suspect is more Alfredo than carbonara . Alfredo fries ... you will like them if you like covered fries . 3.5 stars read more

Picked up some decent Italian here on our cross country trek. Chicken Parm and pasta in vodka sauce, both sizable and tasty.

Excellent pizza and gelato the best! Traveling through but will be back! Service very good!

we stopped in for gelato only bc we already ate. Place is packed at 8 this is the Gallup hotspot. Super friendly staff weren't annoyed by our extensive sampling. The only problem with the gelato was that there was gelato options to choose from read more

Great pizza and salad. Perfect stop for our road trip! Service was friendly. The gelato looked amazing but didn't want to risk that on the road! read more

Wonderful place to dine with friends. Elevated atmosphere with a lot of local charm. Exceptional menu and good wine list.

We were staying overnight in Gallup and we're in the mood for Italian. As there were not many Italian restaurants, we chose Fratelli's. We were seated promptly and asked for our drink order. My husband chose a draft draft beer which was no longer available, so he chose another. He was pleased. We decided on our selections and I ordered the Garlic Rosemary Salmon with penne and grilled green beans. The menu stated that all entrees came with a salad. I ordered a salad with balsamic dressing on the side. Our server told me I had to choose between the green beans and the salad as the computer would not allow both. This clearly was not stated on the menu, so I chose the green beans. My husband ordered the Alfredo with bow tie pasta and wanted to add chicken. He ordered a salad with Bleu cheese f dressing. The server brought his salad with balsamic. I brought that to her attention that he wanted Bleu cheese. I guess the salad that I expected with the balsamic was sadly discarded. Our entrees were delivered by someone other than our server. My salmon was poached and not pan seared as described and the green beans were boiled and not grilled. The salmon had no garlic or rosemary seasoning as described. My husband's entree had a small amount of pasta, very little Alfredo sauce and no chicken. Our server only came back to our table to ask if we saved room for dessert when my husband, after eating half his meal, stated that he did not receive chicken. She asked if he still wanted it, he said no and to take it off the menu. We were very disappointed in the many missteps in our experience, the quality and quantity of food and now know that Italian is probably best enjoyed elsewhere than in Gallup. read more

Food was pretty good. We got the pasta with mushroom capers, artichoke and chicken. It had a butter lemon sauce loved it. The service was OK. But the ice cream was delicious. We tried the lemon Oreo, Elvis and coconut. We loved all three. read more

French dip sandwich was good but needed more meat in our opinion. The au jus was delicious and the flavor of the sausage rustica was good just needed more sauce, there wasn't enough to cover the bow ties. Very busy on a Friday night. Waited an hour for a call in order to be ready as well as others were waiting for a table to dine in, call ahead and then expect to wait aswell. read more

Husband and I went here for a to go order and they said 20-25 minutes for the food. An hour later we finally got our to go order. After a short 7 minute drive we sat down to eat and found the calzone pretty much raw and the meatball linguine watery and under seasoned as well as cold. The linguine was way over cooked almost mush. After reading the reviews we had high hopes. Maybe it was an off day as they were busy and most the staff seemed frazzled and scattered. While waiting for our food we heard a number of people complaining about not being served even though they had a table and had been waiting for staff to come take their order for some time, having to wait so long for to go orders, and even having reservations and sitting having to wait over 30 minutes and still not being seated despite having given ample time to prepare. read more

Fratelli's Bistro - Undercooked calzone - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

Been going to fratelli's for YEARS! Amazing wings, great gelato, and the service is impeccable (shout out to Ruth!). Favorites have to be the Alfredo fries, poor boy/traditional wings, and any of their pizzas. Calzones do take a bit of a time, but are great. read more

Fratelli's Bistro - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Lovely service with adequate food. Beef ravioli was tasty. Good amount of food for the money. Cash discount.

Good pizza. Bomb beer. Great service. What more could you ask for! You won't be disappointed. read more

We had the Macaroni and Cheese and a Thin Crust Gluten Free Pizza. The Macaroni and Cheese was fine, but the pizza was really good for gluten free!! Gorgeous mushrooms, delicious and flavourful Italian sausage with a generous amount of stringy, melty cheese!! The crust had bite until the edge and that was yummy and crunchy. I'm so glad we stopped here. I'm even happier we have leftovers to take on our trip through this beautiful state. read more

We were only in Gallup for the night and Dwight said the desk clerk at our hotel told him Fratelli's had the best chicken scallopini she ever had and since that is one of my favorites he wanted to make sure I got the best. We drove over and sat on the covered patio. There was a storm rolling in and the temperature dropped about 20 degrees while we were sitting there but the light rain storm left us a beautiful sunset. I of course had the chicken scaloppini (with bowtie pasta because spaghetti doesn't agree with me anymore) and Dwight had the Fratelli's Carbonara. It came with salad and garlic bread and we had ordered cheese bread so we were breaded out! It was complimented by a nice glass wine. Our server, Ruth, had been there for 5 years and she was phenomenal. Ask for her if you go. read more

See all

Gluten free crust is tasty, ingredients seem high quality. Patio is dog friendly. Hannah did a great job taking care of us. Recommend if you are passing through. read more

Very friendly staff, excellent food. Vodka sauce for my bowtie pasta was very good. Sausage, while not traditional Italian was spicy with a good flavor. Didn't serve bread with the meal but happily brought it when I asked. Definitely will be returning. read more

Fratelli's Bistro - Pasta rustic a sausage. Very good sauce, spicy sausage - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Best food best customer service and very fresh food. Nice ambiance I will definitely return

One of few, One of quality, and great service! those are the few of the many things that I experienced upon dining at Fratelli's Pizza Bistro!!! I came here with my parents, and I wanted to see what all of the rave was about. I tried the Spicy Alfredo over Linguini , and I was excited to see what flavors would be presented within this dish! I ordered the Garlic Red Chili dry rubbed wings as an appetizer , and was overwhelmed by the deliciousness of spice and flavor that these wings had!!! When my main dish arrived, I took the first bite and tasted hints of garlic, red pepper, and that savoriness of olive oil and fresh garlic combined! I finished the pasta down to the last bite. Our waitress was great, even though she couldn't hear very well!!! If you are in Gallup and craving good Italian, checkout Fratelli's!!! read more

Fratelli's Bistro - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

My meal was terrific. Exceeded only by the attentive, effective, and fun service. I was en route so I'm unlikely to be back, but Yelp's recommendation is much appreciated. The ambiance is fine, though not special. Worth a try if you're from out of town. read more

I am a super fan. Outstanding. Pick up or service in. Plenty of safe parking. The place to go locally for a classy, pleasant, authentic Italian experience. Classic dishes and home spun recipes. Pizza or pasta or calzones or subs or kids meal. Oh, and delicious Wings! Nice salads. Great appetizers. Italian (or American) soda and Italian deserts. Nice beer and wine selection. And a wide variety Gelato you can order for the meal or for carry out! Food quality is excellent with individual dishes tasting anywhere from good to fantastic depending on taste. Environment is relaxing and fun, and also better than most local restaurants. Owner-manager is always working to improve the very pleasant indoor or outdoor ambiance. You can order a fifty dollar meal, or get out with a twenty dollar excellent and always filling wholesome meal. Now: the best part is the kind, interested, caring staff. They are local young men and women who are being trained by the owner who is herself deeply committed to an organic and authentic, memorable and pleasant experience for each of her customers. I am always glad to come. Tip well. Be prepared to be happy you came. And if something isn't quite right, ask to discuss it with the owner. read more

On a long drive from Santa Fe to Flagstaff, we were in the need of some good food. Once we hit the first decent-sized town, we pulled out Yelp and searched for a goodie. Fratelli's Bistro was one of the restaurants that came up and we were sold when we saw Alfredo fries were highly recommended by Yelpers. Didn't really know what that would entail but you can't say no to Alfredo fries. Fratelli's is located in a small shopping center so we were able to park easily. The restaurant is large and it was full on a Friday night. As you're waiting to be seated, they have gelato at the counter which is a great sales tactic. We were too stuffed for dessert after our meal but it was tempting. Started off with the Alfredo fries of course which was enough for an entree for two even though it was an appetizer. Take a bunch of fries, smother them in Alfredo sauce, cheese, bacon, and banana peppers, and there you have it. Addictive! They also start you off with some warm bread which was a nice touch. Split the vodka pasta which comes with sausage which was also quite good. They give you a side salad with your entree. So much food! Had like four boxes upon leaving, enough for another two meals. More places need to do Alfredo fries, they were glorious! read more

Fratelli's Bistro - There's some salad in the pic but it's the alfredo fries that are the main attraction! - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

Highly suggest the poor boy pasta and mix it up with different kinds of wings! Service was great, the owner waited our table. She's wonderful and we'd go back just for the hospitality. read more

Fratelli's Bistro - Wings - Italian Near Me - Gallup, New Mexico

See all

I came in for dinner and I was really excited to have lasagna as that is one of my favorite dishes. The server just had sold out of lasagna which is quite upsetting but typical. I ordered the Vodka Sausage Rustica which was super bland and almost flavorless. Based on this experience I do not recommend this place. Super disappointed. read more

Ruth is a gem!! She makes us feel like locals. Our family makes a point to stop here any time we are headed on a road trip and passing through Gallup. The pizzas are really great (kitchen sink is our favorite) and our kids love the gelato. Worth it to stop and enjoy a nice meal on your road trip or if you are a local! read more

Homemade everyday Italian dishes. Very quick service. Amble portion on the plate. Very clean restaurant plenty of seating for big parties. Plenty if parking and easy to find just off I 40. Make it a must stop trave read more

See all

Gallup consistently in delivers. I'm always disappointed with dining options as I pass through and still, geographically I can't get there without being hungry, damnit. This time I tried to find a few places that were open a 8pm on a SATURDAY NIGHT! Everything was closed because the local Gallupians were getting their weekly tetanus shots I guess. This place was advertised for miles since the AZ state line, it was open and we went. Surprise! They were open, had tasty food, nice servers and packed with late night (8pm) diners. The gelato was mostly gone, but we got a blast of Cap'n Crunch and it was good. Eat here. You won't get hives like when you eat at the Panda Express (shudder). read more

There are days when this place is absolutely insane, every table food, quite boisterous. Usually Fridays and Saturdays. I'm here to tell ya: if you'd like a leisurely lunch without the cacophony, come at mid-week for lunch The food is usually very good. My go-to here is the poor boy wings. So much so that I brought my Italian-*Italian* friends here For The Poor Boy Wings; they luvd it! The most unique dish in all of Gallup, IMO. But today I want to praise the servers: I love Diana, and Aleta (from waaay back) and Amanda and some of the others (so sorry, I can't recall everyone's names rt now ) . Today, it was all about Ruthie. Literally. Bc when I arrived around 1215, she was the only one on the floor; it wasn't nuts yet, but picked up fairly steadily. She hosted, and greeted, brought everyone to their tables, took orders, kept an eagle's eye out on everybody, refilled drinks, provided to-go boxes, and gelato and rang everybody up. By herself. When I left at 1355, she was still bussing the tables and answering the phone. In some way, this is to commend Ruthie for long-overdue praise. Last December, our office held its Christmas party here. The place was hopping, every table full, and we had reserved the back room for 50+ ppl, including some 12 kids less than 16. Ruthie was the one tasked to take care of all of us; it's the first time I'd ever met her and I was in awe. So, Ms Ruthie, well done, as always!! Whether it's a party of 53 or just one, you never fail to impress. Thank you for making each visit to Fratelli's feel special! read more

Great food. Pizza and chili dry rub wings is a good selection. Nice beer selection. Great service. Friendly staff. Manager is a hard worker. You can't go wrong. Fast food is a quarter of this experience if you can find it in this town. Look it up on yelp! Oh yeah! read more