This review is based on take out only... I recently ordered from their website and I loved how easy the site was to navigate. It allows you the option to leave a note for your order as well as select anything you want to add like additional meat or seafood. We haven't ordered in a while and wanted to give it another try. The delivery arrived prior to the expected time and everything was hot and fresh. I ordered the shrimp Florentine with extra shrimp and it was very good! My husband got a pizza and said it was also very good. I look forward to trying more dishes from Genaro's! read more

Genaros Restaurant & Pizza - Shrimp Florentine - Pizza Near Me - Branford, Connecticut

Med. Pepperoni was horrible. Sauce was so sweet. Too much sugar and the pepperoni had a strange salty taste. It didnt make it into my house. Yuck! read more

This was the first time my husband & I tried Genaros Pizza. We decided to do takeout and eat at home. I ordered an ex-large cheese pizza, half with meatballs. When my husband got home we opened the box only to discover that the whole pizza contained meatballs. My husband doesn't eat meatballs so he had to pick all of them off each slice. I myself really enjoyed the pizza, however it was sad watching my husband pick apart his pizza. I would try Genaros again but I'd check the pizza first before leaving the restaurant. read more

A little gem of a restaurant on short Beach Rd it's well worth parking in the back of the building and walking upfront, now if you enjoy Bacon or Mashed potatoes you have to try there Mashed Potato with Bacon I always order extra bacon (because don't all good pizza include bacon on it) along with cheese pizza and Antipasto salad a little weak it needed a little bit more (green olives-yellow peppers) we ate a table inside very enjoyable, we liked it so much that we made plans to go back with friends the following weekend. read more

Genaros Restaurant & Pizza - Two pizzas, mashed potato with extra bacon and the other plane cheese and a Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Branford, Connecticut

Great pizza and have a good takeout service. Also grinders have been delish. Outside seating now that it's warming up.

It's been a while since I sang the praises of this restaurant. They have some of my favorite pizza in the area so I am here again giving this place 5 stars. Something about their sauce on the pizza it is amazing and we do love it. We always take our pizza to go and eat home so I can't speak about the restaurant experience but all I know is they consistently have really great pizza time and time again. We get our pizza from here pretty much every Friday night so thank you! My son's favorite is the House Pizza. You keep making great pizza and we will keep ordering it! Thanks again! Highly recommended. read more

Always offering great quality food at a reasonable price. The pizza is very good with just the right amount of s spice in the sauce, great ratio of sauce to cheese and a crispy and chewy crust. I LOVE their garlic bread it is loaded with garlic and cooked to perfection. Great local place for a last minute dinner. Offering fast, friendly delivery. read more

Genaros Restaurant & Pizza - Cheese Pizza with garlic bread w/ cheese - Pizza Near Me - Branford, Connecticut

Recently ordered a pizza from Genaros. Been wanting to try! Got a medium with cutlet and cherry peppers on it. Pie was good size, sauce good but was a little disappointed how sparse the toppings were especially the chicken cutlet. Some pieces of pizza didn't have cutlet on them or only a tiny piece. Not sure if it was a fluke or not but will probably give them a second chance down the road. read more

Genaros Restaurant & Pizza - Chicken cutlet hot cherry medium pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Branford, Connecticut

Would like to review since they all have been so positive. Unfortunately I made a reservation 3 weeks before Christmas for dinner for 4. Literally call 6 hours before reservation date and was told they could not honor the reservation. Why book a reservation? Will never eat there again and every one I know will also know to not bother. Tell me how they "forgot" to call earlier. read more

We at work had the pleasure of dining on Genaro's Pizza. It was quite good. Everyone enjoyed it.

Stopped in for a sammich on the way to the Trolley museum. What a treat! Got a chicken cutlet with pesto roasted pepper and mozz. Very impressed with the renovation job also. We will be back soon read more

Genaros Restaurant & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Branford, Connecticut

Dinner delivered. Pasta carbonara was good. Disappointed with the dinner salad. Lettuce a slice of tomato and cucumber. Salad dressing wasn't in the bag. Delivery was great and timely. read more

Visiting this area and was in need of dinner to be delivered. Genaros came to the rescue! My meal was delivered to the house well before I expected. It was quite a pleasant surprise. I ordered a shrimp salad. It wasn't the best salad I've ever had... but I mean it's a salad lol. It was still delicious. I don't eat a lot of dairy or meat (other than seafood) so I don't have a ton of options here. However, I would order from here again. read more

Today I wanted a quick sub and I was happy to have the owner, Juan great me. I asked him to make a special order sub with eggplant cutlets, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers with balsamic glaze. It was delicious. This is a great place fir take out or dine in read more

See all

The Food is excellent, the customer service is unmatched. Have had multiple entrees and all are top shelf. Delivery is always on time and the pricing is fair and reasonable. read more

Our 2nd try here and to be honest prob our last. Good is just ok, we had several dishes this visit and each one had its own issues. Our server was friendly and helpful and the place was very clean. The seating however is very uncomfortable metal patio chairs? We have ordered pizza from this place in the past also and it was also off the mark. I had one of their signature dishes and it had all the ingredients for a great dish but lacked flavor. Calzone came out with cold sauce? Baked shells were tasty but also Luke warm. Your mileage may vary, but our mileage has ended. We like to support local businesses please give them a try but if you are expecting Italian you may decide it's more kind of Italian. read more

My local neighborhood pizza joint and now with Giffords ice cream in cones. My advice is ask for the pizza extra well done if you like your crust crispy New Haven style. All the basic pizzas are good! Along with the pizza we love any of the eggplant dishes or eggplant parmigiana and the stuffed breads., read more

In search of decent pizza in this town. Veggie pizza toppings sloppily thrown together, bland, dry.

Went because it was ranked among Top 3 in the Shoreline Magazine. One of those pizzas where if it weren't in the New Haven area or NYC it would be the best pizza in the city, but for being in the area I tend to be more critical of pizza. I think I would have almost just preferred a cheese pizza than getting any toppings. For paying $4 a topping I would have expected more toppings than what we got. Seemed like there just wasn't much toppings added, maybe 1 or 2 pieces of pepperoni per slice. Pizza tasted great, but couldn't really taste the toppings. read more

LOVED this spot! My family and I sat outside for pasta night. We ordered 2 pasta dishes and the calamari, the food was fresh and delicious. I highly recommend sitting outside on the cute patio! read more

Genaros Restaurant & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Branford, Connecticut

See all

Mostly mediocre or poor quality food and an over charged credit card. That sums it up.

Ordered the White Rustica pie last night. One of the yummiest gourmet pies I've ever tasted. There was a sweetness to it I couldn't place, but it was outstanding! read more

tried a lg calzone and pizza calzone ok taste, but the ricotta was liquid. The large pie was at best a small the pie in size. The crust was 2- 2 1/2 " thick from outer to start of the pizza. Basically a ring of crust with a little sauce & mozz. also very put off about price online menu and p/u cost varies place has potential but in my opinion, not worth it. I would use a little less basil and oregano in the sauce. The sauce for the calzone should be a marinara or a tomato, but not salsa chunky.. smooth is the best. I would like to see this place do well, I would say aside from Dave Portnoy, I consider myself a Pizza Master, it is my favorite and most loved food. THe attitude they have in the restaurant is great and welcoming, I know the next time I decide to try the food, I have faith that it will improve.. read more

Great delivery option-never has been late ! The baked ziti meal with ricotta is perfect comfort food after a rough day- or week :)

I love this place. The food is good, the staff is conscientious, courteous, helpful & polite. It's a great neighborhood spot and local hangout especially for families. The vibe is welcoming and kind. The ice cream is GREAT!! The owner will do whatever he needs to do to make sure you have a pleasant experience. Support this small business owner! read more

We order take out and everything is delicious! Chicken Piccata, Marsala, Angel Hair Pasta always made just right and meatballs are really tasty! read more

Can't say enough about Genaro's. They are our #1 pizza and the meatballs are the best! (not bready!) Dining in used to be a treat, however, THANK YOU for all the delivery, especially to us! We enjoy multiple items and doing a mash-up. I love the cheesy garlic bread dipped in their Alfredo sauce! read more

I tried Genaro's for the first time tonight and it did not disappoint! I ordered delivery through one of the apps. Two items I chose were not available and the restaurant actually called me and gave me recommendations for substitutes. Usually the restaurant just leaves out the items but not this one. They were so accommodating and pleasant. The customer service was outstanding! And, the pizza was delicious, too! I had a sundae for dessert that was one of the best I've had in a long time. I will definitely be back to try some of the other menu items and to have another sundae!! read more

Great pizza!!! I visit this pizza place when ever I have to visit the hospital and the food is great and the service is good.

Only have tried the pizza so far but that was great! Reasonably priced and very hot yummy with the perfect balance of cheese and sauce. The place looks nice and the service was great. The only thing I was concerned with was that the take out menu seemed inconsistent price-wise with the dine in menu. I don't know if that was intentional or maybe someone forgot to update one of the menus... read more

This pizza is awful. I ordered a large pepperoni and it was cut into 8 slices. There were 2 pieces of pepperoni per slice. I ordered a small white with broccoli. They charged $2 for the addition of broccoli. There were tiny flakes of broccoli. Not to mention on a small pizza there was about 2 inches of crust and 3 inches of pizza per slice. (See photo) If they weren't so stingy with the toppings and cheese it might be semi decent. read more

Genaros Restaurant & Pizza - Too much crust d stingy with the broccoli. $2 for this much broccoli on a small! - Pizza Near Me - Branford, Connecticut

Very bad margarita was good,a little salty,house special very salty no mozz.didn't know I had to ask for mozz.margarita had plenty and mods was on that one.I ate a slice and a half all I could do on a large pie.wings were not crispy and not much sauce.waste of 72.00.now we know.it really sucked but thought we would give it a try.won't see me again fool me once.... read more

We were hungry and in town for the weekend and saw the great take out reviews. It was very close so we got a to go salad and some chicken rosemarina. 2 miles to pick up and take to our beautiful weekend Airbnb. Chicken was excellent and the salad was great. Not sure about other things but these were just what we wanted. read more

We got take out pizzas from genaro's this week. The staff is friendly and the we didn't had to wait more than 15-20 minutes to get our order. There is a couple of tables inside and the environment is clean. The pizza were well sized and the crust and toppings were ok. Is it the best pizza ever ? Probably not, but the overall impression is good and the price is really good. We live not so far from short beach and we will definitely go back to Genaro's The idea of having this kind of restaurant in this neighborhood is really good and will be a real plus during the beach/summer season BTW There is an extensive menu of pasta and Italian food that we will have to experiment in the next weeks read more

Love this place. Stopped on a drive to Boston - best chicken cutlet sandwich that I have ever had. Wish I lived closer - would go here all the time. read more

Ordered a calzone and steak and cheese grinder. Picked up as we were on way to movies that I prepaid for got a call letting us know they gave wrong sandwich. So we turned around knowing we were gonna miss beginning of movie. I walked in and no apology or anything. Was told we will make your right sandwich now. Told the lady at counter not to bother. First no apology for mistake then you have to make the sandwich. My question is where is the sandwich I ordered if you need to make it? Now I work in the food service also. I make mistakes yes but I apologize for them and then comp what my customer ordered due to fact it was mistake. I also apologize for it. I felt really disrespected by the way this mistake was handled. I hope in future you apologize and try to fix your mistake as for myself I will not be going back. read more

We finally got to try pizza here last weekend and we were impressed overall. I had stopped earlier in the day to grab a menu as we were going to get takeout for dinner. The gentleman working seemed very nice and I told him we would be back. Hubby and I decided on two small pizzas (since we obviously don't like the same toppings) - he opted for sausage and spinach and I ordered chicken (with no red sauce). I requested chicken me grilled and not fried. They said about 20 minutes, we picked up the pizza, came home and dove in. My first critique is that my chicken was not grilled as I had requested. Not a HUGE deal but I would have preferred it. Besides that, we really enjoyed the pizza and a small was still plenty large for both of us with lots of leftovers. I am not much of a pizza fan so to me, it was delicious. He likes pizza a lot and he actually said this was in his top 5. Always room for improvement - we have no tried any other food there so I plan to update at that point. Genaro's is a mile down the road so we will frequent here quite a bit I hope! read more

Love this place and food is always good . Delivery on time , nice and hot . Staff very personable .

It's nice to have a little pizza-and-Italian restaurant right in the neighborhood, but even better when they are as exceptionally good and exceptionally friendly as Genaro's. Juan, the owner, continually strives to improve the atmosphere, quality, and customer experience while maintaining a neighborhood vibe and reasonable prices. You could pay the same for a lot less elsewhere in Branford. Try it! read more

Excellent Food Excellent Service Great spot in the neighborhood Hopefully the neighborhood supports Genaro's read more