Very clean everything!! The burgers are all natural, no preservatives. The fries, onion rings, and chicken are fried in beef tallow. It is pet friendly outside and you can even order your furbaby a k9 patty. My pup absolute devoured his patty so quick. He loved it. The burgers were huge and really tasty. The prices were fair. The onion rings were a highlight. So freaking good! There's limited indoor and outdoor seating. It's definitely a really popular local spot, seats fill up quickly. read more

See all

This place is a gem where we enjoyed 2 super fresh 4 ounce cheeseburgers burgers ON HOUSEMADE ROLLS!, one generous sized order of excellent onion rings and a well reviewed shake.. cost $44. Cute outdoor eating area of rentable and chairs facing the street & surrounded by a charming white picket fence. Small unpretentious indoor area. They also have a small selection of games such as uno and jenga while you wait. Self service where you order and pick up food at the counter. Do not be in a hurry- everything is made to order including fries and onion rings. read more

Gimme Burger - Cheeseburger and onion rings - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Eddie Z here again. My New York visit had me craving those drop dead delicious onion rings and cheeseburgers and there was no disappointment . Make no mistake about frying their French fries and onion rings in beef tallow. Not only is it much healthier but the taste is so good. We had a combination of hamburgers and double cheeseburgers and all were terrific.ill be returning here on my next visit from Mooresville,NC read more

Solid burger! A little too talked-up beforehand and didn't quite live up, but still a really solid, simple cheeseburger. Didn't feel as greasy or heavy as most, though still a burger. Adorable '90s decor inside, lots of picnic tables for outdoor seating. Great onion rings read more

See all

Of course I had to go back to were it all began. Oyster Bay. There's not really parking out front. But there is parking around if you know how to find it. Check behind the stores in the area. The outside of the business feels like home. White picket fence and classic windows. It makes the place feel personal. The tables are nice as well if you want to dine outside. Inside, the place is nice, but lacks character. It felt cold inside. At the counter they took my order then took my name. I always find it disappointing when they sell the fries separately from the burger. But you can't eat a burger without fries , so I ordered them. They can bring it to you, or you can grab it. I didn't feel like being waited on, so I grabbed my food. I am glad to report that the burger was really good. I was surprised how much I liked the bun. The sesame on top gave it an added touch. I definitely enjoyed it. Nothing stood out about the fries.they seemed very generic. But they were good. I would definitely go back. I mean, I have to support local business when possible. Also, I have to support their burgers. I canny let one patty goto waste. read more

See all

Great find, burgers were outstanding! Can easily say one of the best I've ever had. Place is interesting, nice outside seating area, inside not much to talk about. Order at the window, food handed to you in a to go bag. Staff could not be nicer. Place was packed with customers. Beef tallo fries! All . read more

See all

Mattttt these burgers are amazing from the toppings down to the tallow onion rings and fries The detail of the burger when you open it I def will make this a regular spot Service was a1 I can tell the pickles were house made Coming back with the family next week read more

Gimme Burger - Now this is a bacon Bacon Hamburger - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Great burger joint! Those buns are off the charts. No frills and a short menu but high quality product. We sampled their cheeseburger (A+++¥), grilled cheese and fries. Kids gobbled up everything. Will def be back! read more

Wow. I expected more considering the renowned Jesse Schenker owns this place. When this restaurant first opened the food quality, service, options, and quantity were all larger and better. Years later, it's embarrassing. Take a look at my photo. $15 for a PLAIN piece of grilled chicken on a bun, the size of a kid's meal? Absolutely ridiculous. Same goes for the cheeseburger. 25 to 50 cents PER VEGETABLE to add? Highway robbery. You'd find this food at a 5 year old's birthday party. Complete and utter rip-off. read more

Gimme Burger - Sorry excuse for a grilled chicken sandwich ... for $15!!!!!!! - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

A real burger! My family and I stopped in on a random Tuesday and we're still talking about the burger days later. I'll admit that I didn't expect much, but to my surprise, this was the best burger I've had in a long time! Upon walking in you're greeted with a vintage feel, simple burger shop. It's decorated with vintage movie posters and Coca Cola, giving it a chill vibe. There's games to play while you wait which I thought was a nice touch. The staff is great and really made us feel welcome, cared for and seen. Thank you for a great experience, we'll be back soon! read more

See all

This spot is a homerun if you want a quick and easy burger and fries to take down before going about your business. Reminding me of yesteryear vibes with the classic film posters on the wall, the counter service with a smile, the decently priced burgers and delicious fries in a bag. The burger I got was so delicious, top notch beef, fresh lettuce, fluffy SESAME SEED Bun, all of these were a hit and I keep thinking about this burger. The fries were crisp, flavorful, perfectly well done, and some left over in the bag which make them extra good. My gf got the Chicken Sandwich, also very good, crispy, spicy, fresh. This place is awesome, would definetly have a burger here again if in the neighborhood and in the mood. read more

See all

Blown away by this little spot!!!! Amazing smash burger (although the patty was still so wonderfully thick and cooked to a perfect medium rare). Extremely flavorful burger, crunchy french fries and enormous onion rings. Prices are really fair based on the quality and size of what you get. They make their own burger buns and everything is so filling. Really nice people which makes this place an even more desirable spot to stop for a bite to eat. They have a few canned beer and wine selections and they also have a keg behind the counter that rotates (on my visit I was offered a $3 draft of Brooklyn Brewing lager). Absolute gem of a burger place in Oyster Bay. Go give them your business! Also- check their social media pages as they have specials throughout the week read more

See all

They have to be paying people for these reviews, I'm gonna say it's the worst burger I have ever had, it reminded me of the miserable school burgers they gave us in public school back in the 80s , I will warn you and I promise you will be totally disgusted if you go here, the burgers are burnt dried up shoe leather, go take a ride to city burger or even McDonalds , words can't describe just how terrible these burgers are. I say the place goes out of business there's no way people would be so foolish as to go here twice . read more

Love this spot. Such a vibe in time. Burgers and fries are delicious, exactly what you'd expect and get. Next time we'll get a shake too . Food was so good, ate it all before we could take a pic. read more

Best burger in oyster bay! Fresh ingredients, no seed oils and cool vibe! Delicious and will be returning...again! read more

See all

I just ordered dinner to be delivered. Simple I thought. Chicken sandwich, fries, onion rings and a cheese burger "plain". The burger came with their special sauce. I called up and told them I ordered it plain, as it said on my receipt, the person that answered the phone said she was sorry but "plain doesn't really mean plain" and "a lot of people make that mistake. Sorry." She went to ask someone else & came back, "Sorry". It was my first time eating there. been meaning to try since they opened, drive by frequently. I told her isn't the best experience for a first order. "Sorry" again. First & last time. read more

Burgers were pricy but very juicy and filling. My friend and I enjoyed playing with the board games left near the seating area while waiting for our food. read more

Cool throwback vibe and love the limited menu and minimalist concept but just can't get past how salty everything is. We've gone a few times but no one ever finishes the food because it is too salty and just overwhelming to the point of being inedible after a few bites. Even our young ones are now over it. If they could cut back on the salt or whatever is causing that flavor we'd continue going back. read more

Service was standard. Games all around were nice until you see how they've been ransacked. The burger itself, again, I marvel at the lack of palate of the residents of this suburban wasteland - who are these people gassing on about the juiciness? Have you never had a burger before? If a burger is not juicy it's dry. That's not a brag, it's just the bare minimum. What of flavor? Salt is not actually a flavor here, I'm speaking of spices but evidently I'm the only one. No. Onion rings were so bland I wondered if I missed my mouth. Not coming back. read more

We were looking to try a quick good place and came here expecting to find a nice burger joint close to home that was somewhat closer to burgerology. What we found was better!! We all agreed that the Gimme Burger is close to Five Guys style ---(which in our mind a compliment because we like five guys) but less expensive and without the peanuts. Thus -it easily was a five star visit. We came for burgers but also got chicken sandwiches and we were glad we did. The chicken sandwich was freshly fried and juicy. The combination of the homemade bread and lettuce and tomatoes just all came together. The burgers were nice. Not too big like burgerology so you can easily finish them which probably why the price is reasonable. Definitely high quality meat and although we don't recall being asked if we wanted to cooked medium or rare --they came out great. The fries-actually --very McDonald's style and excellent. Who doesn't look fries cookies crisp but golden with a nice salt. Finally -they have shakes. Just the basic chocolate and vanilla or a mix. We tried all three and everyone enjoyed it. This really was a perfect pick for the nights. I would not be surprised to see this store multiply on Long Island or certainly become as famous as "the All American Burger" joint of Oyster Bay. Will return. read more

See all

Simple menu. Nothing fancy. We had burgers onion rings and milkshakes. All were good just the way you would expect it. Burgers were fresh and not dry. read more

We visited this cute burger joint after a nature hike nearby. We all ordered shakes and burgers. Service was friendly and efficient. Burgers were perfect, buns were soft and shakes were delicious. They have board games on the side. Would definitely swing by again! read more

Gimme Burger - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Quite possibly my new favorite burger place!! Stopped by to pick up a take out order on a random rainy Wednesday evening. Street Parking was a little tricky to navigate but luckily found a spot. Once I stepped in, I was told my order was being prepared, which gave me a chance to look around. The posters reminded me of my childhood; Rocky, Steve McQueen, Farrah. The pictures other reviewers posted were accurate (and, put simply, better than mine). When the food was ready, the staff apologized for the wait (not long at all) and I was on my way. DELICIOUS. I couldn't get over how much food and how great it tasted. Special shout out for labeling all the burgers in my order - no guessing! (Handwriting should be a font - notice I ate some of the sandwich and realized I wanted to take a pic of the great penmanship.) When I looked at the receipt, I paused - you get more than what you pay for. I am salivating as I write this review - it was that Good. Worth your time. read more

See all

One of the best burgers, onion rings, and shake I've had in awhile. I got the double patty cheeseburger with bacon. The burger is generous in size, very juicy, and bacon is thick and crisp. Onion rings are the beer battered type, and very crispy. Strawberry shake that isn't overly sweet/not artificial, and you can actually taste and see the strawberry chunks. They're also super nice and friendly. My baby enjoyed the food and music. read more

Gimme Burger - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

Best home style burger.Very friendly staff very helpful.French fries were very good. I will return.

Recently opened (late February 2023) restaurant with a simple menu focusing on burgers, fries, and shakes. The burgers are very tasty and are made from a blend of brisket, chuck, and short rib. They are available as single (4 oz) or double (8 oz) and come with or without cheese. Each burger comes with lettuce, tomato, pickle, and red onions and is served on a house made bun. Fries are mcdonalds style and i recommend getting a side of the special burger sauce to dip them in. There is indoor and outdoor seating, but there aren't a lot of tables. Recommended if you seek a delicious burger and are near Oyster Bay. read more

See all

I have been seeing this place all over instagram and decided to give it a try! I ordered a double cheeseburger and fries. The staff is so incredibly nice. The fries were AH-mazing. The burger was also very good. For some reason I thought they were smashburgers, but they're regular burgers, so I ordered a double. Next time definitely only a single! I could hardly finish the double. Great place! read more

Gimme Burger - Double Cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

See all

Quick service, delicious juicy cheeseburger, and affordable prices. It has a quaint fast casual dine in seating area, but we opted to sit outside on a beautiful sunny day. read more

Gimme Burger - Cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

easy on the salt! Burger would've been great, but every bite was overwhelmed by taste of SALT. fries had too much salt too. tomato on burger was nice and ripe, but sliced so thin. thinly sliced onions are great and thin sliced pickles too - great sweet/sour flavor. buns are amazing. but excessive salt ruined two $8 burgers. read more

Gimme Burger - single cheeseburger - Burgers Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

One of the best burgers I've had in a long time . Classic burger joint vibe with great sides as well. Got a double bacon, fries , onion rings , and a vanilla shake and each one was delicious. Matt was awesome and seems like he really cares about his customers ! 10/10 read more

Probably the best burger place in town. The fries and the burger were amazing and service was fast, every one there was nice. Very cool vibe. read more

Told by my son to check this place out. Very casual. Few tables inside. This is from the same owner of 2 spring. Loved the burger. It was cooked perfectly and the fries were crispy and delicious. They also started selling canned beer here as well. I will for sure return to Gimme burger. Loved it. read more

See all

Great burger all around. Well seasoned, nice meat blend, sauce is good, and it doesn't look like a flimsy fast food burger. It actually looks like the pictures! If you know what I mean. The homemade bun is good but can be a bit softer in texture. Probably one of the best burgers around though. The fries taste like old school McDonalds fries. Well done! read more

Simple set up, very much like an In n Out order concept which is great. Easily one of the best burgers I've ever had and the fries were crispy and well seasoned. This cute little spot has a simple menu of burgers/chicken sandwiches, fries, and drinks including shakes. Service was quick and the girl taking my order was nice. Def the spot to go if you're craving a traditional burger. read more

Yes! It's on main street next to Umberto's and across the street from the fire department. I had a vanilla shake, cheeseburger and well-done extra salty fries (it's literally an option). The fries were so good and the burger was very flavorful and juicy. The service was great, the restaurant was super clean. I took the food to go, but there were tables inside and outside. read more

I tried the Burgers, chicken sandwich and fries, Everything was fresh and tasty. Service is also excellent. Premises looks nice and clean and outdoor area is perfect to enjoy the food. read more

Stopped to pick up lunch here after being at the beach in the area awhile back. Good burgers! I'd recommend this place.

We tried this after having enjoyed the fine dining experience from these owners. Was looking forward to the dining after the comments from Four's staff. But sadly this was a letdown. The double cheeseburger was overcooked and lacked seasoning. Wasn't juicy at all and got no flavor from the bun, special sauce or the meat blend. My wife liked the fries but I thought they were over salty. I'm sure the outdoor dining will be nice in warmer weather, and if pavers replace the grass/dirt. But they need to go back and work the menu. If you're going to focus on burgers, chicken sandwich and fries, you need to nail those recipes. It's nowhere near that right now. Hoping it improves. read more

Great burger and fries! Not the greatest space, but the food is great. If you are in the mood for a burger this is the best spot in oyster bay. read more

Read the reviews for this spot and thought we'd give it a try for take out. Place is cute. Trying to be retro but seems to fail short. Like they could have tried a bit harder. Super simple menu as others have stated. That's not necessarily a bad thing if they nail it. Unfortunately, they did not. Burgers were so greasy that on our short drive home the bag was loaded with grease as were my jeans. I have literally never had this happen before. I grabbed the obligatory fry on the way home and was greeted with more salt than the Atlantic Ocean. Seriously salty AF. Got home and tried the burger. First it was a pretty sloppy burger. Flavor was Ok, not bad, not particularly good, just ok. Probably would have been a 3 star review if I didn't have to go scrub the grease out of my jeans. Makes me think that the early reviews are friends and family. We won't be back. Quick addition: they say they have wine and beer. If you consider Miller Lite and Pabst beer, then I guess they do. Why don't you guys have Oyster Bay Brewing? They are really local. read more