A friend found this place online in early May, and I happened to be in the area and gave it a shot…read more I am originally from NJ and have lived in FL for 37 yrs always chasing the pizza dragon of old. I have found it. I have been back 6 times and I live an hour away. The NY style is true to its name and I don't have to fly up north to get it. Great job. Cannolis are tasty as well.

To go review; No…read morenotes on the service or the ambience. I love greasy New York style pizza with a good crispy crust. I'm also slightly weird that I really enjoy pepperoni and pineapple pizza. So as you can see from the pictures, we got a half and half. The pizza was absolutely fantastic, however, it was ice cold when it arrived. It's hard to know if it was a long delivery time, it's been super cold outside, or if it sat for a while before being picked up. I don't blame the restaurant that, and the pizza was very delicious! I'm looking forward to going in person and trying them out. Garlic knots were delicious pizza sauce was fantastic, and the chocolate chip cannoli was devoured and enjoyed by all. It was a little pricey, but then again everything nowadays feels more expensive. I did really appreciate on the to go box that they had a flyer to purchase online noting that they deliver and you can save money versus Ubereats or GrubHub. Will update the review after I go in person.

Cariera's Fresh Italian is a pretty solid option for Italian if you are in Winter Garden, Florida…read moreand seeking that wonderful cuisine. Cariera's Fresh Italian is located in the Tri City Center on West Colonial Drive (State Road 50). The service here was friendly and the place has a pleasant enough ambiance and vibe. If you are in the area, I would definitely recommend Cariera's Fresh Italian.

We always love coming for authentic Italian food here at this Wintergarden local spot right off of…read moreWest colonial and Dillard. Overall, the service is always friendly and quick, and in the background you can see live footage of the Rialto bridge in Italy. The food never disappoints either were always delicious and we always bring them as leftovers anyway cause it's quite filling. Overall, this was a good experience in our server Ryan was very attentive. I tried to the new lasagna special made with sausage and a Arrabiata sauce. And our daughter really enjoyed their kids menu of macaroni and cheese. My husband always orders the same thing usually the chicken piccata and per usual it was still delicious. Didn't save room for dessert but one day I'm gonna get that cannoli.

Wonderful time couldn't believe it meet and greet very nice staff very friendly staff and amazingly…read moreaccommodating and helpful unbelievable beautiful people

ordered bruschetta and I got a slice of tomato and a slice of mozzarella on a piece of bread. It…read moredefinitely was not like the picture in the Ordering app. Pizza was just ok.

I went into Joe's Pizza for a quick lunch. The pizza was so very delicious. It was like going to…read morethe Italian section of New York City. The crust was perfect. All the ingredients were top shelf and they have Peroni on tap, and it was ice cold! The service was fast and friendly, and I recommend this place highly

How's Pizza always delivers hot and delicious food. Their pizzas are great! The sauce to cheese…read moreratio is on point and the crust is perfectly toasty. Even when we reheat the leftover pizza, it is excellent. The place is always very clean and their customer service is great!

This is one of the most unique places to get a pizza on the west side. This is my second time…read morecoming to Pinottis and it does not disappoint. Interior feels high-end and the dining experience there is very elevated, but the service and vibes are down to earth. It's just like your classic mom and pop shop only a little fancier feeling. This is a great place for both a date night and a family gathering. I got the large pizza and pal, vegetarian zucchini and half chicken. The staff is really nice to let me know that that's an option and who doesn't love a little variety. Be prepared their prices for a large are a bit up there and this ended up being close to $40. It's definitely delicious and was checking out. Dig In!

Pinotti's Pizza isn't just a local favorite in Winter Garden; it's a culinary experience waiting to…read morebe discovered. This independent pizzeria consistently tops the charts as one of the most popular spots in the city, and a single bite reveals exactly why locals are so loyal. Forget the chains and immerse yourself in the authentic taste of Winter Garden by trying their acclaimed dishes. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, a visit to Pinotti's promises new favorite flavors and a true taste of local pizza perfection. Pinotti's Pizza no es solo un favorito local en Winter Garden; es una experiencia culinaria por descubrir. Esta pizzería independiente encabeza constantemente las listas como uno de los lugares más populares de la ciudad, y un solo bocado revela exactamente por qué los lugareños son tan fieles. Olvídate de las cadenas y sumérgete en el auténtico sabor de Winter Garden probando sus aclamados platos. Ya seas residente de toda la vida o solo estés de paso, una visita a Pinotti's te promete nuevos sabores favoritos y una auténtica experiencia de pizza local.

The pizza and wine were amazing, but Maria was even better. Great service !!!. She was really greatread more

We had such a great experience at this Italian restaurant! We ordered the garlic knots, their…read moresignature salad, and a pizza, and everything was absolutely delicious. The garlic knots were perfectly warm and flavorful, the salad was fresh and well-balanced, and the pizza was spot on. The service was excellent--attentive, friendly, and made us feel really welcome. We chose to sit outside, and with the beautiful weather, it made the whole experience even better. The atmosphere was relaxing and enjoyable. Overall, it was a fantastic meal from start to finish, and we will definitely be coming back!

I went back to AJ's on Saturday and sat at the bar. Lauren is THEE BEST. She was helpful and…read morepatient with my indecisive questions about which pizza to try. I love my go to pizzas, but I wanted to try something different. I was torn between the White Vesuvio and the Mount Garden Veggie. She suggested I make the pizza 1/2 and 1/2. I took her advice and asked for a drizzle of hot honey on top as well. The pizza was DELICIOUS. AJ's never fails! I also asked her to concoct a mocktail of her choice that was tasty and she made a delicious drink as well and i cannot wait to go back and ask her to make me another one! The restaurant is always clean, the service is always good and the food is even better. I will be back soon.

OBSESSED with this spot! My husband who is a PA native says this is the best pizza he's had in…read moreFlorida. We had done takeout previously and it was just as good. The ambiance inside is fantastic. The flooring inside is filled with iconic pictures with pizza photoshopped in. We will absolutely be back again and again and again!

Rating: 5/5 Fantastic first visit to Mister O1 in Dr…read more Phillips. Our server was incredibly welcoming and guided us through the menu with excellent recommendations. She even brought out a spicy olive oil that added a perfect kick to the pizza. We started with the Burrata Caprese--the cheese was delicious, and the rich balsamic glaze even made the arugula enjoyable. The Star pizzas are the highlight; the crust is light and crispy, and the ricotta-filled points are a brilliant touch. The Beckham (bacon and ranch) and the Luca/Alessandro (pepperoni and zucchini) were both hits. We finished with the decadent banana Nutella calzone. A must-visit!

Didn't have an good experience here, restaurant was crowd so we ordered takeout, some pizzas were…read moreready, some took 30 min more than the first one, they do taste good, but wish Margherita had more tomatoes! Will come back to try again, but service was horrible, I understand some days are really busy, so will give another chance