Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Goat Island Tavern

    3.3 (3 reviews)
    Closed 5:00 pm - 12:00 am (Next day)
    Updated 3 months ago

    Order Goat Island Tavern Takeout or Delivery

    Goat Island Tavern Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Goat Island Tavern

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of K K.
    0
    17
    1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Chicken Wings 194 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Brickery - Buffalo chicken pizza

    The Brickery

    3.1(115 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    I have been eating at The Brickery since it opened and have always enjoyed the food so much. I…read morethink it's awesome that the small town of Jackson has a local restaurant with a brick oven! I mean you can't talk about the Brickery without at least mentioning the pizza gets cooked in the brick oven. We have always had a gorgeous crust on our pizza and Strombolis with that tasty brick oven char. Over the years, I have tried the pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and salads. The pizza and pasta are made in house and the portions for the pasta are quite big so I always have leftovers. My family always gets a Stromboli to share (a pretty good size for 2 adults and a small child), but I also enjoy the lasagne as well as the meatballs. Our toddler loves the meatballs, and we share those as a meal occasionally since they are a great size and a great price (appetizer). My husband really likes the french dip sandwich and I like the Swiss melt. I really don't mean to be "that person" because ... it's a salad .... BUT... the Caesar salad is so good and the size of the salad is big. Always crispy and refreshing with an appropriate amount of dressing! Not too much and not skimpy. We have ordered online and appreciate that you can always customize whatever you order and add different meats, sauces, and toppings. We usually add meatballs to our Stromboli.

    The food was truly a chef's kiss. The wood-fired pizza oven gave the pizza incredible flavor, and…read morethe pasta salad was easily the best I've ever had. Their homemade dressings take the salads to another level. The Philly steak was outstanding, the music was great, and the overall vibe was on point. Our server was fantastic, and the entire staff made the experience even better. Good people. Good space.

    Photos
    The Brickery - Fried zucchini

    Fried zucchini

    The Brickery - Chicken parm with water pooling at the bottom and no taste

    Chicken parm with water pooling at the bottom and no taste

    The Brickery - Burnt and old cheese sticks

    See all

    Burnt and old cheese sticks

    Red Phone Booth - Humidor with over 100 cigars.  High quality fresh air & filtration make for an enjoyable experience for all except the very most sensitive.

    Red Phone Booth

    4.2(747 reviews)
    40.2 miDowntown
    $$$
    Locally owned & operated
    Luxury

    Neat speakeasy with cool vibes. We sat at the bar & got served our cocktails with a nice…read morepresentation. Open until late. Servers are all nice.

    I stopped in for a quick drink before heading to my next destination, and my experience was not…read moreonly disappointing--it was unacceptable. I sat at the bar and had a little light banter with the bartender who is a brother looking to be in his late 30's-early 40's. When I asked about two fruity cocktails from the menu, he flat-out said he wasn't going to make them. That alone was off-putting. Trying to move forward, I asked what he specialized in, and he said he'd "come up with something." I agreed--but very clearly stated: no rum, because my body does not react well to it. After watching him make drinks for people who ordered after me, he eventually handed me a cocktail I never even saw him prepare. That already raised a flag. I took a few sips, and sure enough--my stomach immediately started reacting the exact way it does when I've had rum. When I asked what alcohol he used, he said, "I don't even know." That response alone tells you everything you need to know. At that point, I reminded him I specifically said no rum. Instead of taking accountability, he tried to argue and backtrack. Let me be clear--when a customer tells you not to use a specific liquor, you don't ignore it, guess, or "forget." That's basic service and basic respect. This situation completely threw off my evening, as I had plans afterward and ended up feeling sick. To make matters worse, I reached out to management and received no response. That lack of accountability speaks volumes. At the end of the day, this wasn't just a bad drink--it was careless service. This staff does not prioritize customer care, and that's a problem. If you choose to visit, be very direct, pay close attention, and don't assume your requests will be respected.

    Photos
    Red Phone Booth - Amazing selection of bourbons and whiskies

    Amazing selection of bourbons and whiskies

    Red Phone Booth - Classic Red Hook and Bramble

    Classic Red Hook and Bramble

    Red Phone Booth - Mafia kitchen - available for private events

    See all

    Mafia kitchen - available for private events

    Molinos Mexican Grill - Food!!

    Molinos Mexican Grill

    4.1(25 reviews)
    9.8 mi

    Great food great service and we loved the fresh lime squeezed classic margaritas - we enjoyed the…read morechicken and beef enchiladas and the salsa and chips were better than other places we've visited. Close proximity to most hotels and very reasonable prices. We'll be back. Happy eating!

    I was going to go 5 stars, because seeing how the staff here interacts with the community, almost…read moreeerily on a first name basis, giving normal patrons hugs and conversing in a familiar matter, a definite staple in the immediate community. The cohesiveness of the staff, is phenomenal. Brandon and Michael were my service personnel, and the hospitality that they provided was nothing less than stellar. Seriously, I've dined at a ton of upscale eating establishments, but these guys are five star / Michelin star restaurant type of staff, minus the vest, cummerbund and bowtie Think I'm lying? Look at all my reviews. I'm staying across the parking lot at the rat roof inn. I've stayed in this hotel before, and have seen this place multiple times throughout the last year, I can't not see it, because it's directly outside my window on the third floor, but I'm just so overly critical about my Mexican food and never came in, but I did today. I really wish I would have given this place a try before. Anything less than four stars about this place is an absolute robbery. Even from a stranger. The amount of unity in this restaurant is uncanny, it definitely has a small town vibe (sorry, I HATE using that word). These guys know everybody, and it seems like everybody knows everybody! So seeing so many people as repeat customers is obviously a good sign. Michael and Brandon made me a very generous jalapeno margarita.. I'm a drinker, daily drinker, liquor, and after throwing this bad boy back, I was definitely feeling like a smooth barracuda! I sat there for a good couple hours. Conversating with other restaurant goers at the bar. Everybody is just so nice, that is why I love the South. I'm only pulling one star, because my food was cold. I hate I hate I hate to say that, because everything else was so spot on. Even in the middle of my rice it was a little bit over room temp and my enchiladas weren't melted at all.. I was going to ask them to take it back and heat it up a little bit longer, but as the night went on they got really busy so they were hustling and bustling taking care of other customers. I'll definitely be back the next time I'm here in the area. You guys have a great staff, and I know the food is good, a lot of the food that they carried by me to other tables was actually sizzling. I might have just got the bad luck of the draw. ***DISCLAIMER*** This pure, uncut, honest review is federally protected under Federal Law by way of Bill #EO14149. Removal or alteration of this review by Yelp and/or their affiliates without Expressed consent by it's author is strictly prohibited by FEDERAL law. VIolators will be prosecuted and litigation imminent.

    Photos
    Molinos Mexican Grill
    Molinos Mexican Grill - Experimental salsa. Off the rip

    Experimental salsa. Off the rip

    Molinos Mexican Grill - Main entrance

    See all

    Main entrance

    Goat Island Tavern - chicken_wings - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...