First time for Guiseppe's Pizza. Had to try it after reading great reviews. I have not found any pizza in Stark County as good as Guiseppe's. Yes it's a drive but put your pizza in a thermal bag and it will be hot when you get home. Or eat it in your car. We got the pizza with everything. Only thing I'd change was opt out of the pepperoni. It was pretty greasy. But oh the dough!!! It was so so so good. read more

I had Guiseppe's Pizza for the first time about 7 years ago, since that time I have moved darn near walking distance from the little pizza shop, short of going downtown this is the only pizza we eat. I have learned that Tuesdays is not a good day. Why you ask? Well, it's simple. The pizza Nazi is off that day, and for some reason when he's not there the pie just doesn't taste the same. Maybe it's just me, not sure, but there is something to be said for that dry monotone voice answering the phone and sitting there on the stool when you walk in giving your name. We like our crust more crunchy than they normally bake it, thus it is ordered extra crispy. I will say that that simple request makes the pizza taste so much better! I find that they always have just the right amount of sauce and toppings. Not like some places where you get sauce oozing all over the place and one piece of pizza with 80% of the toppings. And as silly as this sounds, it is cut all the way through. You don't have to get the pizza cutter or knife out and finish the job. They do offer chicken, but honestly I think it is because some people think that you have to order chicken and potatoes with pizza. I found the chicken to be very greasy and unable to taste anything but the grease to say anything more than that. Maybe it was an off night, not sure. Don't know if I want to try again based off that experience. Is it the best pizza I have ever had, no. But it is defiantly on the top 5 list. If you are looking for atmosphere, go somewhere else. But if a simple good pizza is what you are looking for, then this is the place. read more

Giuseppe's makes the absolute tastiest, cheesiest, sauciest pizza ever! I'd put it up against any pizza anywhere! Biting into a piece of Giuseppe's loaded pizza is like opening yourself to a phenomenal sensory explosion! It just grabs your taste buds with the most titillatingly scrumptious, epicurean adventure! You know you've been captivated and eagerly yield to Italian decadence. Susan Deitrick read more

Outstanding pizza! Both the regular & thin crusts are great. All the standard toppings, & choices of regular or spicy sauce, or try the white pizza for variety. Salads are fresh, iceberg lettuce with mozzarella & goodies. They also carry Gold'n Krisp chips & the original Lawson's chip dip. What else could you ask for? Call in your order & pick up in 20 most nights. Big crowd in a small room on weekends & game nights, but worth the adventure! Classic place with great pizza. read more

Great pizza and salads. Always hot and ready. Hasn't tried anything but pizza but have heard the sandwiches are amazing. If you are around Portage Lakes, call and pick up a pie!! read more

If you can't eat gluten for whatever reason, rest assured that they are very careful with their food preparation. My family has been obsessed with this place for as long as I can remember and for good reason, their pizza is amazing read more

This pizza is great, but the customer service is top notch! My family ordered 2 pizzas, one of which with white sauce (my fiancé hates tomatoes) . When we picked it up, the pizza had red sauce (the order slip said light sauce-understandable). The woman at the counter (didn't get her name) apologized right away and said they would make another one. My mom and I were waiting in the car and saw a bunch of people leaving with root beer bottles, which sounded good. I ran back in with some cash to buy them while we wait. She again apologized and told me we could have the drinks. It was a short wait until our pizzas were ready, and they gave us the pizza with light sauce for free. Kudos to you Guiseppes, for being so awesome! We will definitely be returning and telling everyone we know to support you! read more

Always the best sheet pizza! I had a situation a few weeks ago where I thought I ordered 3 sheet pizzas for a celebration of life. I show up there just in time! Long story short I ordered from the one not related near Cleveland. The young manager there made it right for me even though it was totally my fault! He got 6 pizzas In The oven and had them out super fast! I am so thankful! When I got to the luncheon everyone ran up to get pizza because everyone knows it's so good! Best place for party pizzas! Thanks for your excellent service! read more

Some of the best pizza in Akron. It can be a little greasy, but good, not like some big chains. The red sauce, cheese, pepperoni and sausage are to die for. If I was rating this place with only other pizza shops within driving distance in mind then I would give this place 5 out 5. read more

Pizza crust is delicious Sauce has the right amount of seasonings Sausage is delicious Wings are some of the best ever. Mild wings are award worthy. read more

Beat pizza in town!!! Highly recommend this place. Pizza is awesome. Great local spot. Great people and staff. Usually pretty busy on weekends so order ahead! read more

I have not been back to this place in a few years since they got rid of the Hot Italian sausage that was the best. But last night we decided to give the place another go and ordered pizza. We ordered 2 large pizzas one with Pepperoni and Onion and the other with pepperoni, Onion, Mushrooms and Sausage. Well I have to say this was the worst pizza I have ever ate, it is garbage and I say that because the remains of both pizzas went right n the trash with very little eaten. It had stringy tasteless cheese and they may have had one little bit piece of onion on each slice of pizza. As for the taste it was so bland and had zero and I mean zero taste. I even tried adding Italian seasoning to mine and that didn't even help. I WILL NEVER GO BACK read more

Go there in a non peak night. Their pizza is 100 times better in non peak nights vs peak. I'm guessing that on peak nights they rush the pizzas out faster which is why they always come out doughy. The last few times we had to put it back in the oven and cook it longer to get it crispier. Get a pizza here in a Monday night and it's better than perfect. read more

Terrible experience with the employees! A cook in the back and the young lady at the register were extremely unprofessional and immature! Not a good look for business. Just lost a customer. read more

I was excited to give Giuseppe's a shot after hearing people rave about it and winning awards for best pizza but I was left disappointed. The pizza had no flavor, not even the sauce. I may give it another try sometime down the road but overall I was not impressed. read more

Overrated,I heard so much about how great of a pie this place made.when I finally tried I was very disappointed. You can find a comparable pizza In this price range in every city in the usa.Maybe my expectations where a little high, so I tried it a second time and was even less impressed. read more

Best pizza in southern Summit County. Very nice crust and sauce. It's worth the wait and a staple of the community. Very friendly and helpful staff. Our go to pizza from now on. read more

Hands down, the best pizza in the world. It doesn't look like much on the outside and there's not much seating on the inside (it's meant for to go orders) but that's because it's all about the pizza. Truly the perfect pie. Their salads and homemade italian dressing also shouldn't be missed! read more

The dude that runs this place hates you. But the pizza is pretty darn good. I especially like their mushrooms, the cheese seems to have taken a turn downhill, though it could be my taste changing. I am kind of afraid to call in my order if a football game is on. Like he'd rather watch the Browns lose than take my money. read more

You won't find better pizza for the price in NE Ohio. The "pizza nazi" guy won't be schmoozing with you, that's true, but he's not unfriendly, just not a schmoozer. Excellent sauce, just-right medium thickness dough, and great sausage; no new-age California pizza here, just the best in traditional. It is a hole-in-the-wall, but a pleasant one. Has a few tables for eat-in if you must (the very small dine-in area is an afterthought), but if it's warm I'd recommend asking for paper plates and napkins and head to the nearby Nimisilla Reservoir State Park for a nice picnic (less than a mile away). Have been eating Guiseppe's since 1969 and it's still the best. Forget the chains and get the good stuff here. Soft drinks and and chips available; chicken, too, but it would just crowd out the pizza so have never tried it : ) . read more

Consistency great pizza! The crust is always cooked properly (never soggy or over cooked). They had a decently size menu. I've always done carry out but the inside dining area looks comfortable. The staff is always nice. read more

I had my first Guiseppe's experience this weekend. I ordered a pizza and some wings. The wait was said to be 25 minutes. I arrived 15 minutes after placing my order and was greeted as soon as I walked in. I instantly received my pizza when I arrived. However, my wing order was forgotten, I then received my wings nearly 30 minutes after my pizza. My pizza wasn't fully cut, and I received 6 wings when the menu states 8-10. The employees were kind enough to compensate me with chips or drink of choice. The employees were very polite and overall creates a good environment. I've been wanting to try this place for some time now, but it was not the ideal first experience. Granted it was later in the evening I ordered, but everyone else coming in was there less than 5 minutes. I'll be giving Guiseppe's a second chance in the future, hopefully a better experience and a 4-5 star review next time around! read more

This pizza is OUT OF THIS WORLD! The sauce and crust is so good I can salivate thinking about it! Friendly, good service. Wish they delivered, but it is totally worth the drive to pick it up. Wings could use some help but everything else we've had is delicious! read more

Always consistent great pizza! Wished I owned part of that company, cash register goes all day and night!

Don't go on busy night pizza is made differently than when u go during week. Probably spend more time.during the week therefore pizza tsste BETTER read more

Excellent pizza. Nice, dense crust. We ordered this pizza at home and offered to pick up the drive was a few moments and then back again, and the pizza was still piping hot. My family told me this pizza won some awards for best pizza... I was a skeptic at first but this pizza really was delicious. I've eaten at over 150 pizza shops in Los Angeles and this one would rank right at the top of it were there. read more

I am 56 years old and have eaten hundreds of pizzas from Columbus to Cleveland and this is the best pizza ever!!!! The crust is amazing, the sauce tasted great, not greasy at all. The only criticism I an come up with is that I ordered a jumbo size and it was only a 14 inch. read more

Usually when I order Guiseppes I know what to expect. Today, however, I was highly disappointed. The pizza was very tasteless and it was almost like it had been an old leftover pizza. The sweet sticks were not what I had expected them to be either. As someone who frequents Guiseppes I am severely disappointed...unsure if I'll be eating here again. read more

The best. I drive 20 minutes each way just for this. I've been to NYC and Chicago and I'll still take this place over anything else I've had. Pepperoni, banana peppers and sausage. Darlene's favorite is also great. read more

Reminder me of the Soup Nazi from Seinfeld. Pizza is worth it every time. Love love it!!! Pepperoni is on point too!

Meat Lovers and Anti pasta salad. I quit eating pizza then decided to try something not a chain! This is only place we get pizza now! I have never had a problem with my order and usually everyone as friendly as most any other place. read more

This is my favorite pizza place in the Akron area. The prices are reasonable and the quality is top notch. I have worked in many different pizza places in my life, but none of them were this good. read more

Great pizza, salad, subs, and service. You can't beat a place that has been family owned and operated for more than fifty years. Fair warning, their pizza is addicting. read more

Absolutely the best pizza in the area. They don't deliver so the prices are way lower for an incredibly good product. It's worth going to pick up because it great pizza. Can't say it enough...very very good pizza!!! read more

Very good, most definitely better than any chains. The garlic cheesy bread is an excellent add on. There were 7-8 people waiting in line so a busy place and sign of a good pizza. I'll visit again. Cashier was nice, too. read more

Best pizza in the Canal Fulton area. We like it square cut. They have a thin crust option.

Been searching for GREAT pizza in the Northern Ohio area for some time. I can honestly say - the very best pizza I've found! I recommend the deluxe. Wonderful sauce and excellent crust. Highly recommend! read more

I have been all over.....New York, Chicago, Philly and Guisseppis in Green is and always will be the best.

The best barbecue chicken pizza! Without pineapples of course :) . Their basic cheese pizza is great although it's a little greasy. Good customer service!!! read more

Awesome tasty pizza. Ready on time, consistent and priced right. No delivery, and the staff wouldn't win Miss Congeniality, but it's not a place to hang out at anyways. I've never found them rude, I think curt would be a better description. All I really want from them is my pizza anyways, so I'm glad the staff is trained to make pizza, not chitchat with customers. read more