Found myself on a rainy night picking out a take out order from here. Ordered the gyro meal which includes a salad and lemon potatoes. I clearly asked for extra tahini substitute on the side. I also ordered a grilled octopus. While the person that took my order read back my order to me and it was curbside I got home to find one piece of lemon potatoes, a salad w no feta and half a slice of pita bread and no tahini at all. They are a bit overpriced for the quality. I saw a lot of take out orders and I want to support local business but if you're going to charge me $35 for then get it right! Hope you read this as a tool to improve your service and food! Best Regards read more

Seriously good Greek food. Admittedly, it's an unassuming name and a regular looking exterior. Don't be fooled - it has amazing service, authentic tzatziki, and delicious food. We can't even finish the entrees there's so much. We order and then take another order to go for tomorrow. read more

A cozy Mediterranean located in Jericho. My wife and I stumbled on the restaurant one day while looking on google maps for somewhere to have lunch. We were greeted so warmly by the owner Bridgette as we were seated to enjoy our meals. I had the Greek salad with chicken souvlaki and my wife enjoyed the Gyro platter with rice pilaf. Both meals were so tasty and filling. The quality of meats and your portions are quite satisfying. A family ran business who treats there customers with such great respect and care. Clean, comfortable, and inviting restaurant. This restaurant has become our new favorite place to dine with plenty of variety to choose from on the menu. read more

This update is for my second time going to this restaurant and I can happily report that the experience only got better! The first time I came to this establishment was with my wife. We were heading to see a comedy show and we were looking for a place that would set us up for an excellent evening with some amazing food and great service. This restaurant did not disappoint. Now, during my second visit, I came for much the same reasons, although with friends in the mix. We totaled six and neither the quality nor the attention to details faded due to greater numbers. Moreover, each of my friends that came with me were also coming here for the first time and left glowingly delighted and swearing they would return. The taste, cost, service, and convenience to the nearby performance theater in Westbury make this place a jewel! I'll let my pictures speak for the wonderful selection of eats we were served, but just take my word for it and give this restaurant a shot; you'll walk off smiling! read more

See all

Won't be going back here!!!! This tiny cup of baba ganoush was 7$. I called the restaurant after my husband came home with the food because I assumed this was a mistake and the girl said "this is what it is, I'm just an employee , it does come with 2 pita". Skimpy !!!! Two pita doesn't even cover this little amount !!! read more

Gyrolicious - Baba Ghanoush - Greek Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

Been coming here for some time now. Food is delicious and always fresh. Family run business which is a big plus in my book. read more

This is an addendum: on my return, i ordered a gyro and was told extra tzaziki sauce would be .85 additional. Really? This doesn't hold well with me. read more

I was really excited to try the falafels from here and surprise my parents as they've been missing falafel. Food arrived on time but the falafels were SUPER DRY. Dry and hard as a rock. Needed a knife to cut into it. There was no flavor, needed to add our own salt, pepper and other seasonings. The only part of the meal I enjoyed was the tzaziki sauce. I threw out the sandwich after 3 bites. HIGHLY disappointed. Will not be ordering from this place again. Bummer, because we were all looking forward to this meal. read more

Gyrolicious - Falafel. Disappointed. - Greek Near Me - Jericho, New York

Fairly new restaurant that serves good Greek food. The lemon potatoes can be a little more lemony. The shrimp and chicken was well cooked but could use a little more salt. Some of the pork turned out to be slightly undercooked but was very flavorful and juicy. read more

See all

Great food and the owner is very friendly. Had chicken lemon soup and spicy chicken quesadilla. Both perfect

We had a wonderful lunch at this lovely restaurant made even more fabulous by the warm welcome we received from the gracious hostess/owner Bridget. First up was an excellent, authentic Greek salad big enough for 2 featuring all the greatest hits: a generous amt of superb feta cheese, kalamata olives, cubed cucumbers, a large dolma, sliced red onions, peperoncino and crisp romaine, all tossed in a perfect vinaigrette. A fab chicken (homemade) gyro sandwich was equally stellar highlighted by amazing tzatziki. The foregoing represents a fraction of a comprehensive menu. Striking yet soothing modern decor of the dining room featuring simpatico photos of Crete belies its suburban location. You'd think you came upon the coolest boutique Greek cafe in TriBeCa. As they say in the Plaka, poli kala!! read more

We had grill chicken gyro pita and shrimp wrap. The best shrimp wrap in Long Island. Hidden gem! read more

Food is normally good as I've ordered here several times in the past but for some reason, the meat was dry and didn't seem to fresh Fries weren't good either. Don't let it deter you as this was the 1st time food wasn't good. Will Go back. Staff friendly , place clean read more

My name is Rebecca I am like a food critic quoted one of my friends,not picky,JUST THE OPPOSITE I LOVE ALL FOOD,WOW GYROLICIOUS GREEK GRILL IS SOOOOO AMAZING.Everything so authentic,and fresh.The owners treat their customers like family.I wish I could give it 10 stars!They deliver too!Their french fries taste homemade.I am getting Hungry!AWESOME GO CHECK IT OUT OH make sure you try the dips with fresh pita . read more

Phenomenal staff, treats you like family. Food is amazing. Nicest staff ever. Super clean bathrooms and clean resteurant. Highly reccomend this place, will get the best experience ever. read more

Update I'm changing to 4 stars, Steve the owner sent me an offline message. Thanks so much Steve for reaching out. Good Greek food, owners are extremely nice. Husband and wife came over to the table and speak with us. I wish I could give 3.5 stars. Pork souvlaki was delicious. Both of my kids enjoyed chicken fingers with fries, portions are big for a kids meal. Gyro was over cooked and lemon potatoes were under cooked. If I'm in the area again, will stop by again. read more

It was our first time here based on yelp reviews. So delicious and the wait staff is very attentive. Gyro sandwich and salad combo really hit the spot. Our new Greek spot. read more

what a great find! the website gives the impression it's just a take out place and one may get that impression from the outside but it certainly is not! It's a very quaint sit down restaurant with amazing Greek food! Family owned and so friendly & accommodating! Looking forward to heading back! read more

Amazing food and Great service! The owners are very welcoming. Definitely will be back :)

I've been looking for a good Greek salad ever since I moved to the area about a year ago. On a whim, after a movie nearby, I stopped into Gyrolicious with my wife and tried the hummus sampler and Greek salad with chicken. The meal was incredible! Everything tasted freshly made, was perfectly seasoned, and a large portion. The service was friendly and incredibly attentive as well. This will now be my go to spot for Greek food from here on out! read more

We ordered the grilled plate for two and it was a lot of food! It was delicious. Their crazy feta is the best. Staff here are very friendly. We will return when we are in the area. read more

My family and I ate here last night before going to the Regal Movies which is only 5 minutes away. The place was great. We were greeted by the owner who showed us to our table. She was son nice and made a point to check on us at least 4-5 times. The place was immaculately clean and looked brand new. We ate gyros, quesadillas and a delicious salads. The food was amazing, large portions and the service couldn't have been more friendly. We ordered a slice of baklava which also was delicious. I rate them 5 stars. What a great place and we will surely be back again. read more

New ownership has brought this place to a new level of delicious! Highly recommend the food and the atmosphere. I can't speak more highly of this place. I love Mediterranean food and this place is GREAT. These are the plates that I get and recommend: Appetizer: Grilled Octopus (amazing!) and the Dip Sampler Entrees: Gryo Sandwich, Vegetarian Platter, and Chicken Slovaki A must-taste place with a great staff. The family that owns it now is extremely nice and willing to help with any of your allergy needs. read more

See all

We had a very enjoyable meal at Gyrolicious. Prices were a little high and the appetizer order of the grilled octopus was VERY small. Service was also slow, but the waiter apologized and explained that there was a mistake with the order. That being said, the food was very good. The grilled octopus mentioned above was excellent - tender and tasty. Another standout was the chicken gyro entree. Their tzatziki sauce was a hit with half the group. It was not as garlicky as most, which appealed to some, while I found it on the bland side. All in all it was a very good meal that I wouldn't hesitate to return for. read more

First time here & it was a great experience! The staff was friendly, professional, welcoming & attentive. The owner came by, greeted us, & asked how our experienced was. We had the mixed platter for 2 (not alone ) & it was great! Great sampler of meats. The different dips were also delicious! I really liked the spicy feta dip. Highly recommend! read more

Set in a small parking lot with a few stores, doesn't look like much on the outside and honestly wasn't sure what to expect. The hostess was inviting, friendly and made us feel like we had been there a bunch of times. My daughter and I both ordered the Augolemono soup and a small greek salad. The soup was very different from the typical Augolemono soups I've had in the past. This was a thinner broth but filled with chicken, carrots and rice. Broth was very favorful. Once I got past that it was different than other soups I've had, I loved it! It was a generous serving size and came with pita. And it was perfect on a rainy day. The small greek salad was a nice single serving size and had a lemony dressing. Overall would recommend and hope to be back again. read more

This is definitely my go to Greek restaurant. Just had dinner here tonight with my wife and my mother. The owner always finds the time to come out into the dining room and is the chef. The food is always delicious and the portions are huge. The have a mixed grill platter for two than can feed four. They have the best chicken gyro I have ever had. Boneless chicken is usually at best boring and sometimes dry but the chicken gyro is so good I could eat just that. The waitress Samara is excellent. She never makes you feel that you are making too many requests of her. Always a good experience. read more

I was in the area around lunch time and stopped in for a chicken souvlaki to go - which was quick and fresh! If it's not family owned it's a home cooked meal vibe. Attentive staff and clean restroom! read more

5 stars for delicious home cooked meal, warm and cozy atmosphere, good value and pretty great music ( Sirius Coffee House) Luckily, Lee and I missed the Westbury Music Fair dinners and were able to have a relaxing dinner tonight at Gyrolicious without any wait. The Avgloemono soup was perfect... both lemony and peppery, studded with chicken and carrots, orzo instead of rice. Delicious. Lee had the much raved about octopus and it did not disappoint.. together with lemon potatoes and Greek salad, this was the perfect plate. I enjoyed the pork souvlaki and Greek salad noticing how ripe and sweet the tomatoes were. I think I've gotten used to pretty flavorless winter tomatoes and these absolutely stood out, as did the fresh lettuce and homemade tzatziki sauce. For dessert, I asked for the baklava and loved how it arrived warmed and sprinkled with cinnamon and powdered sugar, while Lee said that he prefers his in the future cold and crunchy. To each his own. Coffee was good and piping hot. This is a welcoming local, family run restaurant. Steve, the owner, is the chef. Though it was a busy night, he was able to spend a few minutes chatting with us. Service was great and we look forward to returning with our kids. read more

I have crazy dietary restrictions due to health issues and they were SO helpful in taking the time to help answer ALL of my questions regarding ingredients in menu items so I was able to figure out which dishes were safe for me to order. They let me make 100 changes to dishes so I can customize them. I have been getting deliveries the past few months and everything has been amazing and really fresh (and my sensitive stomach has been very happy!) If I had to think of anything, I'm just sad that they don't always have delivery available, but they are already doing me a favor since I am slightly outside of the delivery zone, so that may be why... But when I am able to get it delivered, I'm SO happy! Very friendly staff willing to accommodate and delicious, fresh food... What more could you want? read more

This is mine and my husbands favorite spot. We have never had a bad meal. The mixed grill for 2 is our top favorite you can't go wrong, it's enough food for leftovers! The lamb souvlaki & lamb gyros are always scrumptious. Can't forgot a Greek salad or spinach pie or falafel. Hands down everything is delicious!!! read more

I love everything about this place! It's tasty, fresh and affordable. I came both times on a Sunday afternoon between lunch and dinner time with only a few other parties in the restaurant. Maybe this is why their food comes out so quickly! Within 10 minutes of entering the restaurant I have a salad, pita bread, and dips to feast on. I recommend the Greek salad, avgolemono soup, and mixed grill (excellent value by the way). They give such generous portions of pita bread with their dips. The gentleman who served us was prompt and polite. Gyrolicious is well-named, clean, fast and delicious! read more

See all

My first trip to Gyrolicious was for a Yelp event and I was so in awe of the flavor here that I came a second time in the same week! My SO wanted a gyro and I knew just the place, so we came and I ordered a chicken gyro and he ordered a combination gyro with lamb and beef. We ordered them to go and had a great conversation with the hostess, while I didn't get her name she was extremely welcoming and it was nice that she was keen on checking to make sure our orders were out quickly as I hadn't though about calling ahead. We waited at most 10 minutes which was incredibly fast in my opinion, and the gyros were wrapped neatly in bags that held the heat. The cut of the gyro was soft and crispy so I loved my gyro and my SO loved his. I look forward to coming back and eating the spicy feta dip with some homemade pita chips very soon as well as their souvlaki and I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone in the area! read more

Went there for dinner, food was great, had the falafel entree. Huge portions, I would definitely come back!! Service was quick, staff was knowledgeable & attentive read more

Gyrolicious - Falafel, lemon potatoes - Greek Near Me - Jericho, New York

Gyrolicious was amazing! For an appetizer, we chose the sample platter of dips including the spicy feta dip, hummus, babba ghanoush and tzatziki. The dips were homemade and served with soft pita. The spicy feta dip made me smile - that's how good it was. The other dips were also outstanding. This appetizer is going to be a staple for us when we come back - and that will be soon! We overheard the table behind us raving about the grilled octopus. I'm definitely going to try it next time we visit. Our party of four each selected from the pita menu for our main entree- chicken gyro, chicken souvlaki and lamb/beef souvlaki. We were WOWED by our entrees. The portion sizes were beyond generous, the meat expertly seasoned and cooked to perfection. There is a nice choice of sides to choose from. Some of us ordered fries which were terrific - crispy with just the right amount of seasoning. I had the Greek salad which I really enjoyed - all the produce was fresh. I can honestly say this was the best chicken souvlaki I've ever eaten. The owners were warm and welcoming - their presence and attention definitely an added bonus to the dining experience. The restaurant has a great feel to it with a cozy ambiance, great tunes playing in the background and comfortable seating. Our waitress was attentive and we felt well cared for. This restaurant also has another thing going for it - location, location, location. Located right on Jericho Turnpike it was easy to get to with ample parking. We are looking forward to our next visit and sampling more of the menu. We were happy to learn that the restaurant also does take-out/delivery. In the meantime, I'm dreaming about enjoying my Gyrolicious leftovers tomorrow. read more

Gyrolicious - Greek Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

EXCELLENT!!! Great food and fast friendly service. Out in LI for work and used yelp to find this place. Glad I did. food was awesome. read more

Yum yum yum!!! That's all I have to say. We were looking for a great place that served hummus and let me tell you it was amazing - as we ordered 3 orders of it. Steve the owner was friendly and made everyone felt like they're family. I would recommend this place and a must try is almost everything on the menu read more

This place is truly as good as it gets. From the service to the food, I did not have one complaint about my experience eating at Gyrolicious. First the service. I went on a Sunday afternoon, and was starving! I was greeted with a smile from a young waitress (the blonde one) and was sat down immediately. She took my order right away, and checked in often to make sure everything was okay. I had a fairly complicated order, and she got it correct down to a "t". She definitely made my experience a pleasant one. Then the food. The food was delicious. I ordered a chicken gyro, as well as some lemon chicken soup, and was delighted with the portion size, as well as the taste. Both foods had a great combination favor and texture, and I am looking forward to my next meal there. Overall, it was amazing. I would give it 6 stars if I could and I will definitely be back soon. read more

Probably one of the best Greek establishments I've had on Long Island ! Highly recommend. Sampler platter of hummus and feta etc is fantastic with pita and be sure to add veggies Had the classic gyros and they were delicious. Rice is 10/10 read more

Extremely nice extremely accommodating and the food is delish. Combo gyro with spicy feta is heavenly, octopus top Notch. The best strip mall style Greek under 50 bucks a head I've come across! read more