We stopped in at the Hamilton because my preteen LOVES hotchee dogs for some reason. He doesn't particularly like onions but he loves his hotchee dogs with them! He scarfed down two of them and a good bit of an order of french fries. You can also get hotchee-burgers which I have yet to try. While I enjoy the toppings on the hotchees, that's a bit too much food for me on a day where we have an all evening outing at a far off baseball field. I will say, I love the fries here. Not only are they golden brown, hot, bite-sized,... they don't put too much salt on them!!! They taste amazing! I was trying to eat a little healthier so I ordered a house salad (i think - it's the one with kalamatas and feta) and it was great! The house greek dressing is wonderful, not too much not too little. Lettuce and tomatoes super fresh. I like the layout too--it feels accessible for all as I watched a wheelchair be pushed through. The middle of the afternoon is surprisingly peaceful and pleasant between lunch and dinner rushes. The big windows display the weather outside. It started raining not long after we got there and ceased before we left. Staff is helpful, kind, courteous and friendly, especially to each other. There are many desserts on display... But we were full! Multiple fruit pies and rice pudding. For those who don't know, the Hamilton began sponsoring our NYE events a few years ago. I'm extremely grateful for what they've invested into the community, though they were already a huge staple of our town. I don't venture out to this part of town and eat here enough, but as long as my son has a say, we're always going to come back here! read more

Hamilton Restaurant - I forgot to take a photo of the food! - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

For a unique experience, walk inside Hamilton Restaurant. It's a Carlisle landmark known for their chili hot dog with cheese. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Walk inside and staff will immediately greet you and walk you to a seat inside what feels like an old school diner.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] To eat, I ordered their chili hot dog with cheese. It comes with two on buns and a side. The cole slaw was a gentle compliment to such a heavy meal. To drink, I ordered their cherry Coke. They make it themselves with Coca Cola and cherry syrup. One thing worth noting is that it's cash only. There's an ATM inside, but it didn't work for me. The staff were trusting enough to let me go to another one and come back to settle my bill. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Chili hot dog with cheese - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Visibly clean, staff very nice[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]], but let's be honest, the people who hype this place up do so purely for nostalgic reasons. I got the "famous" "hotchee dogs" (chili cheese dogs) and to be completely honest, they were super mid. The hot dog is very thin and you can't even taste it over the fistful of onions on it, and the chili gets a 3 out of 5. Everyone who's been here recommended these dogs, but I 100% have had better. I also bought chili fries and those were also mid; they use sliced cheese so the fries end up clumping together. read more

See all

We found a gem! We had scrapple, eggs, pork chops, and Hot Chee dogs and it was yummy!!!

The Hamilton is a Carlisle staple!! Whenever I go home, I always have to go in and get a hotchee dog. I grew up going there and I'm always greeted as soon as I walk in the door. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The interior has always been clean and the food is the best.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Hamilton Restaurant - hotchee dog - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Hamilton Restaurant is a staple in Carlisle. Home to the famous Hotchee Dog! We always go in for a Hotchee Dog, hand pumped Vanilla Coke, and fries with a side of gravy. The service is amazing and everyone knows each other or makes a point to get to know you. Tommy and the whole family are incredible! [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance is very clean and classy and I love that the family shows there Greek heritage of art and statues around the room.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Hotchee Dog - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

The best hotdogs in Pa ! Hotchee dogs well know w/cheese .. onions ! Side of their delicious ckn gravy frys are enough to die for !!! Alllll other food there sooooo delicious too !! Noooo other place has this homemade sauce of theirs .. made right there ! On the historic list of places in Carlisle!!! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Beautiful historical sign out front of their restaurant!!![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] A must to go there place !!!! You will not be sorry and will go back ! I live in your York .., and always go there once a month. !!!! read more

Hard to go wrong at the Hamilton. We visited a couple weeks ago and I nearly got breakfast. Today we decided to try their breakfast and weren't disappointed: from the friendly service to the delicious food, it was very enjoyable. Don't be filled by the chocolate chip pancakes: they tasted like a Hershey bar was mixed in but the chips were all underneath so they were nice and gooey and melty. read more

See all

I had no intention of going to breakfast this morning, but I had made an appointment to drop off hazardous material at the recycle center, and as usual, I was really early. So I stopped in at Hamilton Restaurant. I was very pleasantly greeted by the staff with a glass of cold water in front of me before I even sat down. I decided to sit at the bar since it was just me, and I ordered my favorite breakfast. The omelette came quickly and it was hot and very good with generous portions. The staff were friendly and spoke Greek (which makes me know that the food is going to be good before I even tasted it!) [[HIGHLIGHT]]I thought that it was going to be insanely busy, but it was not as busy as I thought and there was ample space at the bar for me to sit and enjoy my food.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I'll be back! read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Breakfast: Mushroom and cheese omelette, home fries and rye toast. - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

I do not understand the hype! This place did not impress me at all! Their big deal is the hot chee dog! It's a gross hot dog with a piece of cheese on it! read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]This is a busy spot all the locals know.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's not fancy or pretentious.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Most people don't even need a menu. In fact, the most popular item isn't even officially on the printed menu. Just ask for a hotchee dog with gravy fries and cole slaw. 10 bucks later you're full and happy and ready for a night out on the town. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Gravy fries and cole slaw - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Always a fan of nostalgia and history. The hot dog was decent and the chili sauce was a bit on the bland side. Onions chopped fine like crushed ice which was good. Average taste. Cash only. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

This was such a cool and unexpected experience. We stopped while roadtripping and were just looking for hot dogs (we have a new goal to try as many hotdog places as possible). We saw it on the map and along with some fun history, we decided it was worth the stop. It looks like a diner, but when walking in it's obvious everyone comes for the dogs. We ordered what they're known for, and were absolutely delighted at how good the hotdogs were. We sat at the counter like you have to in a place so cool, and enjoyed our lunch thoroughly. Home of the Hot-Chee Dog baby! 10/10... and definitely recommend. read more

See all

Stopped in for the famous Hot-Chee dog. It was excellent and the white variety of cheese put a nice spin on the standard chili dogs. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

You gotta love a neat little family run local mom and pop. This place is neat it's a mus cost when in Carlisle PA. I'm a sucker for a chili dog and this place is famous for these tasty tubes. I'm sure they make other things but make sure to get a Hot Chee Dog. The people are wonderful the place is quaint and very "local" Enjoy!!! read more

Hamilton Restaurant - 2 Hot Chee Dogs - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

I'm not a fan of the popular hot dog. It's cold cheese and chili dog sauce and onions . I wanted to love it but it was actually not my thing and cold. cash only. fries were good. read more

We made reservations for Friday night. It was 6 of us . The table we were sat at was barely enough for 4. Service was quick to take our orders. The kitchen was very slow. The place was very busy. So it was understandable. Their menu has a nice selection. They do offer soups that are not on the menu. Our came out all messed up. The server knew it . And busted her butt to fix it .prices overall were high for the over value. Flavor of are meals was mixed. I would not rush back. Not enough bang for the money. Service was excellent from the entire staff from start to finish. I do however recommend the crab cake sandwich. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Hamilton is always going to be a staple in Carlisle! [[HIGHLIGHT]]It gives welcome family, come on in![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] From the food, to the service it is a must try. The waitresses run circles around the restaurant to proud for their customers. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance is family friendly.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Everyone has to try a hotchee dog in their li read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Hotchee dog - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Greasy spoon. When we walked in it smelled like grease.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] What I ordered was greasy. The prices were good but that's all I can say. read more

I've been going to "Tommy's" aka the Hamilton my entire life. There's no better place for good food, good desserts, and good service. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

My husband and I were visiting the downtown area and wanted something simple for lunch. When we found the pictures of this establishment we had to try it! [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's like walking back in time with a long counter to sit and eat at, and booths.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The waitress that served us was kind and checked in frequently. The dogs were good, simple and made with local pride. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Lots of history here, very neat![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Menu - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Absolutely amazing visit to this small local dinner Restaurant staff welcomed us were friendly Afforded is time, patience Chili was terrific Turkey Sandwich was REAL.ROASTED TURKEY DRINKS COLD [[HIGHLIGHT]]CLEAN ENVIRONMENT[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

First time visitor to this local well known establishment after a recommendation by a local hair stylist. Staff was phenomenal and welcoming. Vanilla Coke, and Hot chee special (hotdog, with fries (and gravy) and Cole slaw) was fantastic. Topped it off with a strawberry shake. read more

This place is fire ik the owner hes a close friend of my grandpas/dads and also he gave me mnms and i loveeeed the burger

Great food Great service it is reminds me of the tv show cheers the owner was really nice the food was good

A Carlisle staple. Absolutely one of the must do's in town. While famous for their Hotchee Dogs it is an authentic Greek diner the gyros and Greek salad are fabulous. The staff are pretty much all family I believe who interact really well with all customers as if everyone is a regular. Most probably are. read more

To me this was good old fashion diner food. Then it has its special items it's known for. The food is all pretty decent. The staff is all very friendly. The place has been in business a long time. They sure do know what they are doing. I love breakfast here. Any meal is very good. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Also the keep up with keeping the place clean looking.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Which can get hard because they have busy moments.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I have eaten here again. read more

While in Carlisle today. I had the opportunity to try the famous Hot-Chee Dog. If you are in the area and you like hot dogs, I highly recommend stopping in at the Hamilton Restaurant and ordering a couple of the House Hot-Chee Dogs (cheese, chilli and onions. You wont be disappointed. FYI......be sure to bring cash as they don't accept debit/credit cards. read more

Lived in Carlisle area 1986-1989, went to Hamilton House restaurant 5 days a week, while working at the Post office next door. Always for breakfast! I remember they had the best French toast, sausage patties, fries with gravy, fountain cokes, pancakes and eggs. and don't forget those home fries mixed with onions. I never ever had better French since. Sounds to me today it is still the same. Even, Tom (looks much older) in the pictures is still working there! read more

Other than the Hot-chee dog...there really is nothing special about the Hamilton. It is average diner style food. As for service...our server was average, but some of the rest of the staff were downright stand-offish and borderline rude. Beware...they do not accept cards and they aren't very nice about it either. The only option is an ATM which pilfers you for an exorbitant fee. The restaurant itself is small and tight...nothing special about it that makes it memorable at all. So...overall, with so many other interesting options in Carlisle, this would not be high on my list of go-to places. read more

I got a hamburger and onion rings. They were both very good!!! I highly recommend. So many people use pre-made frozen patties, I search for fresh made patties. The Hamilton has them!!! read more

A Friendly Local Restaurant in Carlisle! The Hamilton is a Carlisle Landmark and has been for years if your craving that old style family owned friendly diner food this is the place to enjoy it. Today we had the Cheeseburger Club it came with French Fries & Coke Slaw! Everything was delicious and our server friendly. If your looking for a quick Breakfast, Lunch or Dinner and your in Carlisle visit the Hamilton you won't be disappointed. read more

Delightful! Quick, friendly and efficient service. Loved the off menu hot dogs, and [[HIGHLIGHT]]old school diner vibe.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Will be back again and again and again. read more

The staff are super friendly and attentive. The food is great. I highly recommend this restaurant.

The hotchee dogs were delicious. The only reason I took off one star is because we were told we were getting cole slaw and gravy with our meal but it never came. Also the hot Chee dogs aren't on the menu. If you are known for this then high light it on your menu for out of towners. read more

See all

The food here is fantastic, the service is friendly! Get the classic hot chee dogs! A classic Greek American diner with both breakfasts and hot meals, the best food doesn't have pride of place on the menu, even though it's celebrated by a historical marker outside. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Home of the Famous Hot-Chee Dogs! - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

The staff was very attentive and friendly. They had great recommendations of what was their favorite and did not disappoint with their choices. They were very generous proportions for our meals. Definitely had leftovers. read more

Excellent food and service. I came here the other day with my girlfriend and son my girlfriend had eggs and scrapple I had a hotdog cause I seen them cooking on the grill and I couldn't resist I also ordered the steak and eggs steak was perfectly cooked home fries were light and fluffy and delicious. I wish I was closer I'd be a regular and come here every day the prices are super reasonable and the service is fantastic. The place is spotless and the bathrooms were clean read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Best hot dog ever - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

You can't go wrong with a trip to the Hamilton. A Carlisle classic, this restaurant has something for everyone at every hour of the day. Beware, cash only and closed on Sundays. Some Greek inspired dishes as well. read more

Hamilton Restaurant - Spinach & feta omelet - Hot Dogs Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Great service and the food was good. Even my picky 9 yo daughter raved about her breakfast. We were passing through town and would definitely return in the future while passing through next time. read more