First impression when I walked in was not really good. The set down counter was cluttered and was being used for staff stuff. The area I could set at was visibly dirty and needed wipe down. The next thing was my sever. Her personality was very dry . Now listening to the rest of the staff. That is not the norm. Today I ordered the senior Haddock. That came with a drink and dessert. The fish was cooked to perfection. And the tapioca was freshly made. If I had to make any comment on the food it would be my soup was overcooked. Now setting at the counter I saw a lot of different dishes coming out of the kitchen. There was not too much that i saw I would turn my nose up at. This place was swamp. So I probably saw it all. So I'm sure with their menu they will have something for you. Do I recommend this place..,, Yes it's diner food. My meal was above average. I liked the overall value. It's beats the local competition down the street. At least compared to my last visit there. read more

Carlisle Diner - Baked Senior Haddock - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Good food. Fair service. Place seems a little dark. ................... Never full of patrons fish was good read more

Carlisle Diner - Seafood - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Our waitress seemed like she did not want to be there, and she forgot several things (my chips, my friend's side of Mayo and my other friends drink). My third friend asked to be sure the shepherds pie did not contain onions, as she is unable to eat them. She was assured that it does not contain onions, but it did. Fortunately, a different item was provided quickly. I did enjoy my BLT, despite the missing chips. The highlight of our visit was the hostess. She was super friendly and earned an extra star for this review. read more

The breakfast "Carlisle Feast" is fantastic and recommend if you are hungry and are ready to leave stuff. Once you arrive the host seats you with a smile and ask if you want water, after the server comes over to take your order and ask what would you want to drink. All this with a smile and professional demeanor. It looks like a comfy diner with enough seating to accommodate your needs. I recommend you stop-in for breakfast you will not be disappointed. read more

Carlisle Diner - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Mediocrity... Server was pleasant. However, she failed to remove plates, plastic cracker wrappings, dirty utensils throughout our meal. The table should have been tidied up as we continued our meal. There were only 2 other tables with guests, so, she was not too busy to stay attentive to details. But, she was nice, just poorly trained. FOOD! Just awful hamburgers...not fresh, rather frozen slabs of not great beef. Many diners in Carlisle area are serving the same, tasteless burgers. Do Not Waste your money on these. Soup, Clam chowder..okay, but again.. not freshly made on site. Cole slaw side...2 tablespoons in a plastic container. taste okay but an absurdly small serving. Pickle...outstanding. Water...Lemon was floating in the glass. This is not very hygenic...someone's fingers put that in my water...I don't want somebody's fingers in my water. Cost: Including $6. tip: 26.00. Botton line...I won't return there. read more

One of our favorite places to visit... Always receive good food, good service, and pleasant surroundings... We are what you would call "Regulars"... Really don't have to order anymore because when we come in, the coffee and Iced Tea just show up on the table... The only time we need to let our server know what we want is when she is new to Carlisle Diner... This is a GREAT place for breakfast.. I highly recommend a visit for a fantastic dining experience... read more

Today wasn't a good day. The breakfast was great except for two things. Got my toast and there was a tiny spot of butter on some of the toast and none on the others. Secondly, the new manager came in wearing heavy cologne, or body wash, that fumigated the front of the restaurant. He stood at the register the entire time we were eating, and the smell was enough to gag a maggot. It ruined the taste of our breakfast and the enjoyment of the moment for us. In general, we love coming here. Good service, good food and good price! Golden rule: If you work in food service you don't wear perfume or cologne as it can ruin the atmosphere and the flavor of the food being eaten. read more

Nothing special stands out, food typical diner fare. Wait staff friendly and attentive. Has a dingy, claustrophobic atmosphere.

Frequented this diner many times over the years in it's various incarnations - hadn't been by for a number of years, but found myself in town while waiting for an EARLY appointment - remembered the diner. Was seated quickly - typical no-nonsense 'let's get down to business' service. Food came quickly...ordered breakfast (ham & eggs). Food was decent as was the portion size. Ambience was '20th Century Diner' - which is fine for me. If you want food and no frills, this is your place....if you want an exquisite culinary experience...it isn't. I'm sure I'll check it out again... read more

See all

We love the Carlisle Diner. The meals are always delicious and the servers and service is great. Angel is wonderful. They always accommodate any special requests. We always order home-fries with veggies (not on the menu). Love their broiled haddock too. read more

Food was delicious and staff so friendly . Prices were good as well! We had breakfast! read more

Great diner food! Really great service and we loved the outdoor patio. Brought our dog too!

Was in town for business. I wanted some breakfast comfort food. Like any good diner, sit, order, eat, pay, leave. Food was ok, just basic. No homerun for sure. Good prices. Went there 2 different times. read more

Carlisle Diner - Meat lovers omelet - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

If you're looking for some good old fashioned diner food, then the Carlisle Diner is a great local dive to check out. They have a full menu of breakfast, lunch, and dinner options for you, and it's the standard affair you'd find most places like this. It's pretty cozy, but we didn't feel packed in at all. There are options to sit at a long counter or at a booth/table if that's more your style. My wife and kids enjoyed breakfast - the pancakes are huge! I ordered a monte cristo (my go to diner food), and it was alright (not the best, not the worst). I wouldn't recommend ordering a side of bacon - you don't get much at all for the price. The service is the reason holding it back from a full five stars. It wasn't overly busy at all when we were here, but we didn't see our waitress except to order and to pay the check (which we were ready to do, but had to wait around for almost 10 minutes for her to finally make her way back over to us). Like I said, it wasn't super busy, and I'm generally pretty gracious with service workers, but it was awkward, and that's why I mention it here. If you're looking for a diner, this place will help you scratch that itch just fine read more

Arrived around 5:30pm for dinner this past Sunday. We were greeted nicely and seated immediately. I requested a table (not a booth). Our drink orders were taken and served immediately & we were told our server would be there shortly to take our orders. Mind you, it was NOT busy at all. After waiting 25 minutes with no server to be seen, we paid for our drinks and left. Very disappointing. We went to Walnut Bottom Diner instead. read more

One of the few diners in the area that has online ordering. It was very easy to use and the pick up process was seamless. The food was everything you can ask for from a diner. It was fresh, well seasoned, and hearty. Its most definitely worth a visit and I will be stopping in again when I'm in the area. read more

This is a very good classic diner! I've been on a random weekday morning where there were only a couple other tables and on Memorial Day when it was very crowded and both times the service was friendly and fast. The food is good, I especially enjoyed the omelette I got the second time I was there. Huge portions, even for the kid's meals. Good parking. read more

Service was not very good today my wife and I had to wait longer than usual to get our order taken

This is a typical diner with a large menu covering everything from breakfast to dinner and in between. They have a parking lot but it's an easy walk from Dickinson College. They have Pepsi products. I had a BLT while sitting at the counter. Everyone was friendly and it was clean. I'd go back again. read more

Carlisle Diner - BLT - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

So it was a decent size dinner. The waitress was normal without much of a personality unless your a regular (aka they don't like new people unless possible student) nothing with telling soups or specials which I know there one the board. We had mott's sticks as an appetizer the lobster bisque was bland and fake crab. Shrimp basket fresh out of the frier and the fries yummy. And my fiance had the chicken croquettes it was really rich for him to me it was bland. I have had better. Someone did clean it makes me feel good but not with the blah of this. It is good if I was in college (because near Dickinson). As far as coming back wide selection of food but nope read more

Quick service for sure. The chipped beef was thick and had a fair amount of dried beef, not overly salty. The potatoes are well cooked but lacking any seasoning. One dish requested cheese n onion with potatoes so it was graced with some American on top. Sadly they don't make their own corned beef hash. read more

Carlisle Diner - Eggs, potato, side of sausage and rye toast - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

**Military discounts on Wednesdays only** Came in on a Saturday around 1100. Was seated promptly and the waitress was quick and friendly. This place probably ticks most of the boxes for the college crowd. PROs: + 24h + Friendly staff + Decent coffee CONs: - Food was bland. We ordered the sausage omelette, eggs benedict and hotdog. Haven't tried a majority of the menu items, probably will continue e search in Carlisle and surrounding area for more options. read more

I'm from New England originally. The AYCE fried cod makes me think of back home. Great fish and chips. Staff is nice. Portions are huge and we will be back! read more

Great Little diner outside on the outskirts of Carlisle! Gives you that old time Fifties Feel! Playing the old time Rock & Roll with Hot Rod decor and a table or booth choice! An American Menu! We were having a luncheon breakfast! The meals were very hot and the staff friendly an efficient! If your in Carlisle and looking for a meal this place is worth the stop! Maybe you'll even see Fonzie, Richie, or American Graffiti peeps! It's a. Great Throwback to another Era! read more

Carlisle Diner - the menu for carlisle diner - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

The food was very good. The eggs and bacon were cooked perfectly and the coffee was really good. Our waitress was efficient but she could have been a lot friendlier. The host up front should have been more attentive to guests coming in and guests that were trying to pay their bill as he was not up front very much. read more

I had their Carlisle feast and the portions were HUGE. The big sausage patty was good, and the hash browns were fresh and prepared pretty well, albeit a bit bland - the eggs were too. The service was fairly responsive and warmed up from a question mark at the host stand to a friendly waitress in the end. I couldn't finish my meal it was so much food. Not a bad pit stop overall. This isn't necessarily my favorite breakfast place, but it is worth a visit if you are in the mood for plentiful food at affordable prices. read more

Apparently there are 3 or 4 diners owned and operated by the same people, this being one of them. According to my friend who is local, I've now tried them all. I believe there's Walnut Bottom, Fairgrounds, and this one with possible one more. All in all a diner is a diner. I usually frequent them more so for breakfast, but occasionally I'll dine in. On this particular visit to a diner, I had a hot open-faced sandwich; prime rib to be more specific. It was served with mashed potatoes and another side, I opted for beets which were somewhat unsatisfactory, but overall it was a good meal. The price was right as was the portion. The only shortcoming I can really point out is the service seemed rather slow. Almost inattentive. Granted, there was a large party sitting behind us, but I only ever saw one server working with them and it wasn't ours. We hardly saw ours at all. This place is good for a meal, just not when you're in a rush. Of the multitude of diners mentioned above, Walnut Bottom is probably my most preferred. read more

Carlisle Diner - Pickled Beets. - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

I ate breakfast here and really enjoyed it. Their omelettes were fluffy (I had the farmers omelette) and had plenty of filling. The sausage patty was very thick and tasty. Paid about $8 or so so the price is right. Coffee was very good as well. read more

Just had the Carlisle Feast !! Always a winner ! Best place in town after Church to stop for a delicious breakfast. Staff are very nice ! read more

Cute little local place. Great customer service by Crystal. She answered questions about the menu and catered to my picky friend's needs. Menu was very extensive. They have everything and anything you want. read more

I was trying to enjoy my nice water but this stupid cart was being pushed around and it created an immense sound that could've broken the sound barrier. Our waitress had an insane attitude. what's the deal with this place. read more

See all

My fiance and I had stopped here while out running errands... The young man who seated us and got our drinks was very pleasant however our waitress never offered a breakfast menu when it was 10am, she was rude while taking our order, and it was very unprofessional that she only visited our table 2x throughout our visit. The food was undercooked and poorly presented. My fiance ordered a burger with chips, never got the chips. We were there there over an hour and a half, with only 2 other full tables in the diner. Overall a poor experience.. read more

One star for the extremely nice waitress and another star for the super short wait time for food. Sadly the speed that the food came out said volumes to the quality of the meal. The food was nothing special - sometimes a bit too salty, atmosphere was meh, and management was rude. I had a minor issue/question about my dish that the manager came over to answer. She was a petite, blonde lady with the customer service ability of a twelve year old. She plastered on a very condescending voice when she offered to bring me something else if I wasn't satisfied with my meal. I politely declined and thought that was the end of it. HOWEVER, when you have a wall made of MIRRORS, you should remember not to pull a face after turning away from your customers. Ya'know, with the reflection and all. She was so incredibly rude and had the poor waitress scrambling and apologizing to me. Obviously the tip wasn't affected because it wasn't the waitress' fault, but I really doubt I'll be going back any time soon. read more

On the plus side, I haven't had an edible breakfast for under 6 bucks ($5.95 including tip) since the 90s... On the not so plus side, the meal was not much better than edible. My experience might have been better had I not been within eavesdropping range of the biggest mouthbreathers ever. I think my rating would have been a 3 star if it had been 4:00 AM on a Friday night (sat morning). read more

Does this place close? Coming here was pretty much a tradition. Go out, get plastered, close the bar, end the night here. If we had to come home to Carlisle at 2 AM, then we for sure made a stop here to eat. It's diner food, nothing special, but it's good for what it is. I love the sausage links in particular here. I think I rarely had anything but breakfast foods, and I was always happy at the end. Not to mention it's cheap. What's not to like? read more

The wait staff is good, the food is diner food. Exceptionally fast kitchen. Atmosphere is a diner. You get a diverse group of people depending on the time you go. Unfortunately I am not allowed to go there due to the owners discriminatory practices and her judgmental attitude. I do not wear shoes for medical reasons. The only thing that has cured a nagging back problem has been to toss my shoes out the window. I tried to reason with her to allow my shoeless presence (there aren't any other diners that care that I've come across) but she wouldn't have it. Didn't even care that it was for medical reasons. It is not against any health code or law. It is no more or less unsanitary than one walking in off the streets wearing shoes. You see the same amount of foot as one wearing flip flops. Yet she still denies me entrance. I would say to go here anyway, but its very hard to support an owner with this attitude. read more

They pay no attention to detail. No nothing you ask for napkins. Forks plastic ect phone in and don't know until after you picked it up. They bored. It's a cheep No tip joint. read more

Half of the time when I order breakfast something is not cooked right and the other half of the time I'm missing something from my order. They're breakfast meals are kind of bland but they are reasonably priced and not many places in the area offer a value breakfast. read more

The food was good but I wasn't impressed with the service. The diner wasn't busy when I went there and I was seated immediately. However, I waited 15 minutes and a server still had not come to my table to get my drink order. I ended up walking to the counter to order my food. That server seemed annoyed because I wasn't in her section. My server did apologize but didn't pay any attention to me until I asked for the bill. read more

Carlisle Diner - Open faced hot roast beef - Diners Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

I understand that there are going to be people coming from the bars at 2:30 in the morning, but when a table of drunk girls are yelling, swearing, & banging on the table so loud that you can't hold a conversation on the other side of the restaurant, managers need to step in. We complained & nothing was done. But entitled jerks in the booth behind us didn't have there food within a few minutes of ordering & had their check comped. Several tables also left without paying. Apparently management doesn't care. I feel bad for the servers left to deal with that. read more