Food was great, atmosphere was great. It was a busy, summer day and our waitress Erin was incredible!

Such a great place. I love coming here and grabbing foods and drinks on the water. They have great live music and an outdoor patio on the water too. I highly recommend stopping here. The service is friendly and fast. I can't wait to come back here. read more

Harpoons is the place to go for drinks, checking out the beach crowd and music if they have a band. Food is more Sysco then home-cooked. Clams and Sausage was very good. Their Italiano sandwich lost it's flavor. Use to be a fan favorite. Mahi sandwich was good. Chicken southwest was good. Service surprisingly was good, typically very slow and not friendly. Wouldn't run back. read more

See all

Usually busy during the summer,and the drinks were different prices depending on who was serving you at the bar. They seemed arrogant and prideful,did not notice them to be a friendly or sociable group of individuals. I would not consider it a trustworthy establishment. read more

Not sure why all the negative buzz about this place - the vibes are amazing, the food was high quality, and the service was friendly and with a constant smile. The atmosphere is Key West meets northern lakefront - tropical, chill, and ready to party all day. We sat outside at the bar, steps from Oneida Lake, perfect to eat, drink, and people watch. We found the entire staff to be actively engaged in servicing the guests. Beer was ice cold and wow do they have lots of beers to choose from - an overwhelming menu! My friend and I ordered two types of tacos: The chicken tacos came OVERSTUFFED with tender, flavorful shredded chicken which was juicy and delicious along with diced tomatoes and onions; we asked for the Mexican Crema on the side and the modification was adhered to. The beer-battered fish tacos came with gigantic shrimp which did not fit into the taco (in other words, excellent portion size) plus pico and pickles - yes, you read that right, pickles, and yes the tacos were perfect with the pickles tucked inside! We asked for the zip-zap sauce on the side and again, the modification was adhered to. The only thing I could say (if I had to pinpoint a negative) was that the food took over 20 minutes and the dining room/outdoor bar was not terribly busy; however, this did not take away from the experience as we made friends at the bar, conversed with the bartenders, and enjoyed the view of a beautiful summer afternoon on the lake. I'd suggest any potential guests just be prepared for ticket times to be a little longer than one might be used to. I will definitely be back, there's lots more I want to try on this menu and I want to enjoy some live music in the near future. read more

First time eating here. Service was as expected for a busy night to above average. Our waitress was very polite and attentive to our group of 5. Food came out and was hot, but the food was nothing to rave about. Burger I had was decent. Cooked to requested temp but that was it. Was just kinda blah. But a burger is a burger. lol. There were definitely some other interesting items on the menu I would try on my next visit. The restaurant for sure needs a cosmetic uplift, but I will give them credit it was pretty clean for being towards the end of what I'm sure is a busy summer season. I would give harpoon eddies another shot for sure. Love the view of the beach from our table. Would give another star if the food all around was a tad bit better. read more

Super summer vibe, plenty of outdoor seating overlooking the beach and lake. Shareable platter is abundant and deliciously fried. Wings are the greatest and everything was served as we liked, and without delay. Tiki bar outside too. A very relaxing atmosphere! And has their own parking lot. read more

See all

Amazing view, right on the lake. Great beer selection and the best Haddock you can find anywhere in CNY!

Stopped in because the view was amazing... too bad the food didn't get the memo. The chicken was so dry I'm pretty sure I could have used it as a paperweight. The veggies on the Sandwhich .. Shockingly better than the cement chicken, but let's be honest, that's not saying much. Service was fine not bad, not great, just kinda there (like my hopes for this meal). The only reason this place stays afloat is because you can stare at the pretty scenery while chewing through overpriced, dry .. subpar food. Come for the location. Stay because you're too hungry to leave. I'm sure the alcohol is fine read more

My boyfriend spoke about this place for months. He was looking forward to taking me here, and as a foodie I was looking forward to trying it. For an appetizer we got the pan seared scallops. It was served with bacon jam and a brown sugar sauce. It was absolutely amazing and tasty! That bacon jam was delicious and I want it on everything. For my entree I ordered the sausage and clams over penne. It was tossed with spinach, roasted red peppers, Parmesan and sundried tomatoes. There wasn't much sundried tomatoes, but overall the dish was tasty. My boyfriend ordered the 3 cheese pasta with lobster. There was a very generous amount of lobster in his dish! I tried a bite and it was yummy. He thinks the three cheeses were cheddar, Gruyere, and Parmesan. While the food was delish, service needed improvement. When I asked our waitress questions about the menu, she told me she didn't know. Then towards the end of our meal, she put someone else's dirty dishes on our table! That put such a sour taste in my mouth after our delicious meal. I would come back again as the food was yummy, but I would want a different waitress. read more

See all

Definitely a hopping spot out by Sylvan beach. It was packed and there was live music out on the deck. Our waitress was attentive and nice. The food is just eh. I got the shrimp po boy and the shrimp were good, but the sandwich itself was so dry. We also had their shareable app, which was full of fried stuff. It was good, but nothing crazy. My friend's lobster Mac was decent. read more

Inside very loud if the band is playing outside. Service was very good. This is a place to go and drink. The food is less than desirable. Nachos were store bought chips with some stuff piled on, no flavor. The fish sticks were bland and the riggies were awful. This place is also very expensive. read more

See all

I had credit card decline and card company or rather bank of my credit card declined because I was past due 3.46 and last payment was made of several hundred dollars less the 3.46! I am a good person and this never happened to me before where I could not pay a bill and I was treated more than poorly by management and the owner ! I offered to come back with cash and Rick the owner knocked my beer out of my hand and his wife told me to leave the food and told never to come back!! Disgusting behavior and yes I believe in karma! At 65, this never happened to me and they knew me from previous visits and staying in cabin in 2024 and also from applying for work to clean those cabins! Rick took my number to give to Mike a couple months ago ! read more

Haven't been here in years but glad to say things are still good. I had a great sandwich and we split a big plate of their awesome fries. I'll stop here next time I visit NY Mike M. - Pasadena read more

Your life is not complete until you visit Harpoon Eddie's. You need to come in the evening for drinks and live music. You should enjoy the company of your fellow island-goers and bask in the sunset with your blueberry mojito in hand. Definitely would recommend the chocolate lava cookie, see you there read more

See all

Enjoyed the Haddock Dinner and Long Island Ice Tea. Nice day at the beach! Cool inside. Like the outdoor bar on the beach!

I have been going to harpoon eddys for the last four years. The service is top notch, the prices are reasonable, the food is fantastic and people are wining and complaining about everything recently. Great place, ignore the idiots and grab a table outside have a beer and live it up. Also, cheese fries and harpoon clam roll will get it done :) Happy beach day! read more

Fun afternoon at Harpoon's listening to good music with tasty food and drinks! Harpoon's has never been known for speedy service but they were on point on a Sunday afternoon. Our food came quickly and our server made sure we stayed hydrated listening to the band. We would not have minded if our food took longer, we were there to take in the ambiance and tunes as much as the food. Don't let the negative reviews scare you away! read more

Food , service and ambiance all blend together to make for an excellent place to dine. Their entertainment is also excellent. read more

Great location obviously lol on Sylvan Beach. Good prices on drinks and food. Neat twists on classic menu items. Good entertainment, even on a rainy day at the beach. Had great fun here and think I even made a couple friends. Cheers! read more

We stopped in on a recent trip to Sylvan Beach. It was Memorial Day weekend so it was pretty busy. We did get seated quickly but it took a little bit to get some service. Once we did, our server, Emily, was friendly and attentive! She has quite the sense of humor too! Food here is ok. Average bar food. I had the broccoli cheddar bites and they came out hot and gooey! The portion size was decent. Drinks.. I ordered a polka dot bikini and the cup it came is was very small. Paying $8-$9 for a dixie cup isn't my thing. You can't go wrong with beer here. Just beware of the mixed drinks. They had live music as well and the patio was spacious. Plenty of seating. All in all not a bad place to stop into if you're in Sylvan Beach. read more

Harpoon Eddie's - American Near Me - Sylvan Beach, New York

The Caesar salad was probably the worst I've had in a long time. A lot of the lettuce was wilted and brown or yellow. The kids pizza was not good at all. Tasted like a frozen pizza. The sun was beaming on our table when we asked to move the server seemed annoyed then another girl came and put the shades down and it solved our problem. I would definitely not go back. read more

This place is a blast! Gets crowded so I would recommend going early. Service can be a bit slow because they seemed understaffed. Wings were great and menu is extensive. Pizza my friend had was good too! read more

Seven of us went on a Sunday afternoon, sat out side and service was quick and wonderful. I understand there could have been a few minutes wait time, but we did not incur that at all. People have to realize, it's summer and some restaurants are doing their best with the staff they have available. At least they are attempting to stay open and keep the help they do have, employed. No different than waiting in the drs office for a 3 PM appointment and not getting seen until 3:35 PM. Even though my time is valuable, there is not much I can do. We were all there to hang out and have a fun time. BTW - all our meals were great as were the cocktails ! read more

Nice ambiance by the lake but service is terrible. I ordered the flatbread pizza oh my it was terrible, hard, and burnt. Their drinks are probably their strength my sister's cosmo was fabulous and my mojito was delicious read more

WTF Ordered several "loaded Landsharks" #3 comes and it is clearly NOT what the previous two drinks were. Waiter brings it back and says the bartender/owner said because it was already poured they could not comp the bill and would not replace it with the RIGHT drink. So if you order a chicken sandwich with a beer but they bring you a cheeseburger and a Coke. Apparently your stuck with it because they already plated it. F' U Harpoon Eddies read more

Food was good. Had to sit inside. Music was horribly loud to point you couldn't have any conversation. Had to point to menu items as waitress couldn't hear you that's how bad it was. Will never go back if we can't sit outside. read more

Very slow service. We arrived at 5 o'clock and nobody even said anything for 15 minutes finally, we put our entire order in and it took another 15 minutes to get two waters and a beer. The food was decent, but nobody checked on water refills and there seem to be a fair amount of people wandering around and only one waitress taking orders. There is certainly a better way to deliver service even if you're shorthanded and harpoon Eddy needs to figure it out! read more

Before even having been seated, (we were not greeted at the door) the terrible attitude of the Host definitely made this experience a rough one from the start. The faces these girls were making were so inappropriate. Our waitress was inattentive, and very rude. In fact, just watching a few other waitresses come serve the two other guests surrounding our table it was clear this service is standard here, all throughout. Every single one of these ladies looked MISERABLE and did not try to hide it whatsoever. It was not busy- (if it was i would somewhat sympathize) but it was all around a bad experience and it's really unfortunate because we were really excited to come here and the location was so convenient. We were also a party splitting payment (2 cards) and our waitress decided on her own that because THEIR system was down when one card was charged and it didn't go through, it was okay to charge the full bill on the other card. When asked why she would decide this without asking for the card back, "everything you're being charged for is right there on the receipt". At that point, all we could do was walk away. Save yourself the trouble, try somewhere else. I don't ever leave reviews but this experience was insane. A star for decent food. but it's really nothing special. P.S. when we asked for a box to take our food to go- we opened it to multiple bugs inside the box and had to ask for another. The perfect cherry on top for this great experience. It felt a bit intentional, and that's being forgiving. read more

Getting drinks was annoying, expensive, and bad. I'll just harpoon myself next time, no need to get Eddie involved.

The location is nice. Right on the beach overlooking the water. My boyfriend and I came for dinner around 7pm on a Saturday night. We waited about 15 min for a table outside. The view is stunning. They have a good drink menu. Island type drinks including frozen margaritas and wine slushies. They were out of the wine slushies when we came though. The menu has an endless amount of options but the food is overpriced and tasteless. We ordered the white pizza panini and garlic feta burger. Each were over $10 each and were dry and tasteless. And for $10 a sandwich you think it would come with fries on the side? Nope you get dry house chips and you can't substitute anything. The waitress was very friendly but the service was ridiculously slow. While we were eating a young kid was picking bottles out of the garbage on the beach next to our table..... It was a appetite spoiler to say the least. They have live bands on the weekends & the sunset is gorgeous over the beach. 3 stars for the location & drinks. Food is 1/5 stars. read more

See all

Amazing service really nice employees and amazing food. They're pizza, especially you won't regret coming

This is an odd review because we have not eaten here. Based on all the negative reviews with poor service, what we would have tried out now will out on hold the idea. Time is too valuable to waste sitting there waiting forever to get waited on or extremely poorly trained waitstaff. Management needs to see what people are posting and correct it. The current issues restaurants are having such high prices must be countered with extremely great service and quality. We'll pass for now however and read future reviews, read more

Based on the negative reviews, I wasn't expecting much but I was pleasantly surprised. First of all, everything was clean and NOT sticky unlike many vacation town restaurants. It smelled like they just sanitized our table too, which was nice. Things seemed updated. They were also very accommodating, as we wanted to sit far from the live band so we could talk. They put us in the far corner which was considerate. Typical American fair but it has a homemade touch. I got the Green Hornet Burger and it was excellent. The side of homemade chips was great. My daughter got Mac and cheese and it was clearly homemade and excellent. (I believe it had Gruyere cheese in it!) wife got fires and coconut shrimp and it was all great. The fries were steakhouse style and battered. All around, a nice experience and surpassed my expectations based on previous reviews. read more

Harpoon Eddie's - Green Hornet Burger and Mac and Cheese - American Near Me - Sylvan Beach, New York

Stopped in for lunch today. Sat inside, wasn't overly busy. We were sat promptly, then ignored by every server as we tried to order lunch. I really wanted to give them some my money. read more

My daughter is a local and couldn't wait to share Eddie's with us. We finally got to go during a girl's weekend. I will start by saying it was a Saturday night and graduation weekend so it was busy. We were a table of 5 and were seated in less then five minutes. Our table was in the middle of the restaurant, but still had a pretty view of the lake. Our server was nice, but a little disorganized. Our cocktails took awhile to get to the table and were mediocre at best, definitely not worth the price. Our appetizers were probably the highlight of the meal. The garlic fries and the Beach Bread are a must try! Dinner was ok. The steamed clams were a hit, so was the lobster Mac and Cheese. Salads are fresh and huge, but the grilled chicken had a frozen chicken vibe to it, not appealing. For dessert the lemon gelato was worth trying. Key lime pie was a disappointment, but the cookie and ice cream a hit. Our last round of drinks took forever to come and showed up just as we were getting ready to leave. The live music on the deck was decent. However, for dinner and drinks for the 5 of us was $400! Definitely not worth the price for the what we received. read more

A decent place to come for some drinks or a meal. I came on a Saturday early evening in off season so we were able to be seated almost right away. Out waitress was attentive and kind. We all order our food and were served quickly. We all enjoyed our meals and we felt very full in the end. My Dad got sausage and clams penne, my Mom got a white pizza panini, Adam got wings & fries, and I got a BBQ burger. I loved the chips they were served with. The food was good. Nothing that was seriously amazing but you also have to remember you are in Sylvan Beach and you aren't going to get the most amazing foods ever there. The restaurant is right on the beach so you get some beautiful views especially during sunset however, you also get the sun right in your eyes. The bar area was cool and fun. My Mom said she loves to come here for some drinks and a burger which is exactly what I would expect someone to get from here. A bad thing was they had a band that was just way too loud for the small space. I am sure fit he bar was packed it would have been fine but we were eating a family dinner and we could hardly hear each other. Overall, an okay place especially for the area you are in. read more

Good food and drinks, good customer service. Recently went on the boat and anchored on the beach front and got take out, the order was on point, minus the side of bbq sauce which is ok. Food was good and as ordered. It's not often I get take out and open it from most places and have the correct items lol. Will return soon. read more

Great view, great service, great food options. Everything you want in order to feel like you're on vacation! Love this place!

Great atmosphere flush up against the beach. Too bad the food is lousy. The food runner brought our meals two mins after we received our appetizers, then gave me an attitude when I told her we weren't ready for them. I would say to come here if you want some drinks at the bar, relax, and eat somewhere else. read more