I wish I could give them more stars. The positive: SERVICE. It was excellent! Very attentive, here for a special occasion with a fairly big group and service was great! The rest: most of us has the devour menu. It was ok. I feel like the shrimp was overcooked. The Cesar salad was GREAT!!! Mom has calamari appetizer and it was good. Our rib eyes were average. Truly nothing special and honestly, my steaks at home are better. Creme brûlée was great as well. Parking at the mall is ok right now with fewer shoppers and COVID. read more

Lunch is the way to go, especially the three-course lunch menu! Price was very reasonable and the three-course was technically four courses as the entree came with a large soup or side. We ate an early lunch and were full the rest of the day and skipped dinner! Portions were large and delicious! The prime rib sandwich was very juicy and tasty. Of the signature sliders, the filet one beat the shrimp po'boy by a landslide. Filet slider was very good. French onion soup was large and delicious! We all enjoyed the toasted ravioli that came with the course lunch, but our 5 year old devoured it before we could have more than a little taste! Shrimp cocktail is a must if you haven't tried St. Elmo's famous shrimp cocktail, just be sure to have a large glass of water close by as it packs a punch! Kids cheese pizza was okay. Overall a fabulous lunch date and treat! You will leave full and very satisfied! read more

See all

Great food! We sat in the bar and it took a bit for someone to approach us, as I think they were between shifts, but the rest was great! I would highly recommend this restaurant. read more

I've been here several times and it's our very favorite steakhouse in Indianapolis! We love their service and food. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I first went to Harry & Izzy's due to the Indy Burger Week promotion. My visit and experience was far above my expectation! The staff was very courteous and attentive, and the food was AMAZING! I had gotten the Homecoming hamburger with a side of onion rings. It was one of the best hamburgers I've had in a long time. Expect a higher standard of food quality and service. Please note that this is a classy establishment. You will feel out of place in casual attire. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Being classy at the Harry & Izzy's. :D - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We have been here like 3 or 4 times and every time we come it's excellent!!! Tonight we had an amazing server her name was Amy. Thank you Amy for your great personality and you are a wonderful server!!! read more

Harry and Izzy's is a great date night spot or somewhere to celebrate a special occasion. They do get busy so I would recommend a reservation if you are going on the weekend. The people are friendly and the service is quick despite them being busy. They have a great selection of appetizers and their steaks are to die for. I would highly recommend the Gorgonzola Horseradish butter on your steak. I am not a fan of either of those things but I am now a believer. So much so that it's all I wanted when I was pregnant. The restaurant was kind enough to make to-go containers of it as carry out for us so I could eat it on all my food at home. read more

Very busy and I definitely recommend making reservations well in advance on the weekends. Cool ambiance and great service. Phenomenal crock of French onion soup and a massive Caesar salad with anchovies on the side with glasses of merlot to start . I ordered a 8oz filet and my husband tried the N.Y. Strip, both steaks were prepared med. rare as requested but they lacked a good sear and flavor. Huge portions so I recommend sharing if you want to conserve room for their delectable desserts. Great spot for a special dinner. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Overview from top dinning area - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Harry & Izzy's is a jazzy little restaurant. Goes hand in hand with St. Elmo's steak house! I haven't been to this restaurant in a couple of years but I will say, the last time I went, we didn't have the most pleasant experience. There were patrons in the restaurant that made several racial slurs about an interracial couple. The man being verbally attacked was a colts player and attempted to defend himself verbally but was mistreated by the staff instead of being supported. They refused to ask the party making racial slurs to leave the restaurant. Following this situation, I attempted to correspond with the manager about the situation. While we can't precent racist individuals from entering certain spaces, we can control our response to them... do better! read more

Last week my office celebrated Christmas with a lunch outing to Harry & Izzy's. I really enjoy the cozy atmosphere, great service and scrumptious food. You got to get the Prime Rib Sandwich. So BIG and delicious! I practically inhaled mine. It's served with fries, but you can get any of their sides for an additional small fee. ($2 - I think.) I didn't know about the small fee before hand, so it didn't influence my opting for the grilled asparagus instead. And, I'm glad I did - it was tender and grilled-to-perfection! BTW, H&I is a sister restaurant of famed St. Elmo Steak House - an Indy favorite. So you can get the same great St. Elmo's service and delicious shrimp cocktail for lunch. And, if you have not tried their house-made horseradish cocktail sauce you should - at least once. But be careful - it does pack a punch! read more

Harry & Izzy's - The Prime Rib Sandwich - Delicious! - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Wedge salad and the burger. Both very good. Bar service was exceptional. Always a consistent spot.

A good friend of mine, whom I had not seen in 20 years, was coming to town and I wanted to take her somewhere I felt was representative of Indy. I chose Harry and Izzy's downtown. Aside from them having the best steak I've ever eaten, the wait staff was PHENOMENAL. Absolutely perfect. That means so much. Thank you. read more

BEST LUNCH IN YEARS! Amanda the bartender was jovial and very attentive. We had a short time to eat lunch as we were working at a Tradeshow nearby. She took our order quickly and with a smile. Drinks came quick. Food showed up very quickly as requested. The food was super tasty and priced right. The atmosphere was perfect for a chill business lunch. PERFECT read more

Amazing wonderful ans once in a life time place to go try. Typing this make my mouth water again it was wonderful

Harry and Izzys is like Ms Congeniality- a spinoff of St Elmo's, which is right next door- The restaurant is great and has a modern flair. Much of the food is very similar to St Elmo's and that perhaps is the problem. It's hard to not compare. With that said, they serve a bread that is yummy and I had salmon for dinner- prepared grilled with green beans, it was nicely executed and tasted wonderfully. Our waitress was great and she did a superb job of keeping track of our table and made sure everything was exactly as promised. I will go back, but in honesty, it's hard to walk past St Elmo's to go here. That's not a bad thing, it just is- read more

We had dinner last night at Harry and Izzy's downtown. We definitely had our share of appetizers to start...they were all fabulous! You can't go wrong with the shrimp cocktail, but a surprise hit recommended by our server, Stephanie was the Spicy Asian Shrimp. It's similar to a bang bang shrimp with so much flavor and crunch, the best we've ever had! Our entrees were hot and cooked perfectly...we ordered the sliders and Tuscan pizza. And do I even need to confess we had dessert? Everything was so good! I feel I need to mention Harry and Izzy's is doing a GREAT job with social distancing and extra cleanliness. We ate inside due to the weather, but they do have outdoor seating. We had plenty of space out from the other customers and even the pens are cleaned after every use. I would highly recommend this restaurant! read more

This was a very expensive mistake. We chose to have a late lunch and there were maybe 8 other diners. I had a strip steak and my husband had a filet. The steaks were really good, but for $28 each, I would like a salad and a roll. All we got was steak and mashed potatoes. Baked wasn't an option either. Our bill, with tip and 1 soda, was $70! The posted dinner menu for what we had was about $50 per steak, and no salad and bread there either. There are at least 20 other steakhouses in the neighborhood, so I think a better meal could be elsewhere. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Drew gave us the best experience! Had a filet and NY strip, they were beautifully cooked. You MUST try the crab beignets! Will definitely be back for more! read more

Could I really visit Indy without eating a St Elmo steak? Not a chance. Harry and Izzy's is a good option if not everyone in your party is a fan of steaks. They have a ton of other menu items at different price points. We started with the classic and famous shrimp appetizer. I wasn't quite sure what to expect with the spicy cocktail sauce but holy moly it will clear out your sinus cavity. The wasabi flavors are on fire!! The jumbo shrimp tasted very fresh but the cocktail sauce was too much for me. No wonder they serve it with some saltines to kill the spice. I got the prime rib pizza and my husband got the scallops. Both were delicious but the pizza was so incredibly unique that I would highly recommend trying it. Where else do you get pizza with horseradish ricotta? I single handedly ate the whole thing because I liked it that much! We were with some other friends who went the steak route and they were equally as pleased. The steaks were the perfect medium rare temp which meant juicy and just the right pink on the inside. Aside from the food the service was spectacular. I'm so glad we didn't pass up this dining opportunity. read more

Atmosphere is a little nicer than casual. Purposely has an old feel and look. A lot of wood and servers are professional. Had the French onion soup and the Vegan. Food was timed well and didn't step on each other. Soup was hot but not so much that you have to wait 20 mins for it to cook off enough to eat. A thick layer of cheese on top and not overdone with too many onions. Vegan was very colorful in appearance and had a nice heat to it. The mixture made for a good variety of textures and had a lot of flavor. read more

Harry & Izzy's - French Onion Soup - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Super delicious food! I ordered the steak burger. We came in with a group of 10 and they served us quickly. I called in advance for a reservation, you can also do that online. They are extremely celiac friendly, the manager even came to double check the order with my friend who can't even touch gluten. Our waitress Sara was amazing!! Incredibly friendly, quick, and organized! She checked on us frequently and was very attentive. Highly recommend for a more fancy place with great service. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We came in with a group of 15 for lunch. The waitress was super nice and worked hard to take care of us. But the kitchen was super slow. It took so long to get each part of our food and well over an hour probably closer to an hour and a half, to get our main dishes after we ordered. One of the steaks that was ordered was requested to be cooked to medium. It came out bloody and more like medium rare. The waitress gladly took it back and when it was brought out it was well done and dry. Nobody apologized, no body asked him to cut into it to check it and nobody came back and asked how it was. When you pay $30 plus dollars for a steak you expect it to be excellent and if it's not for them to make it right. No money was taken off for the wronged steak or the wait. Nothing was mentioned about the extensive time it took for our food. read more

I tried getting into St Elmos but they were too busy and told me to try Harry & Izzy's since they serve the same food. I called Harry and Izzy's and got a reservation 7:15 reservation. We arrived by 6:50 and decided to sit at the bar because 7:25 rolled around and we still didn't have a table. The bar tender was great and the shrimp cocktail was fantastic...that was the only thing good about this place. We ordered 3 ribeyes (2 rare and 1 med) and 1 salmon entry. It took over 45 minutes for the food to come out. When the steaks came out, there was no crust on the steak and the two rare steaks came out med to med-well. None of us finished our food because we did not find it appetizing. I never ever add additional salt to my food and I had to add some to the steak and dip in creamy horseradish to be able to eat it. read more

Amazing!! Worth the $! It's not outrageously priced but it's higher than your chain steakhouses and for good reason. My husband and I had steaks with fries and they were delicious and cooked to our requests perfectly. Our bread pudding dessert with Woodford Reserve bourbon was outstanding. I wish we could remember our waitresses name she was the sweetest! And our waiter Benjamin was fantastic as well. If you're looking for an mid-upscale restaurant with a well trained staff and great food this is definitely a top spot. read more

Harry & Izzy's - NY Strip and Fresh - Cut Fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I travel to Indy regularly and this is a must stop on every trip. Yes its a destination dining place with fancy dancy chow and such - but you can also come often for reasonable aps, salads and expense report-friendly options. Easy to grab the shrimp ap along with a couple of sliders (filet and chicken - $6 ea) along with a couple of drinks of good hooch and not kill your budget. Underrated ap is the toasted ravioli. They say its sharable though no one has the guts to try and take one from me yet. The ceasar salad is awesome (don't tell anyone I recommended). If you do want "real food" - such a diverse menu. Steaks of course but pizza, pasta and great sandwiches. Prime rib sandwich will knock socks off you folks that still wear socks (save your bending over for picking up quarters). As a traveler I usually grab a bar seat and enjoy some truly pro bartenders that are few and far between these days. The location does not matter. I started downtown where you can't go wrong but a little more congested and now stay out near Castleton location where its just touch more laid back but no less professional. read more

This place was recommended to me and to say I'm beyond satisfied, is an understatement. Calamari, shrimp cocktail, Ceasar salad and the Alfredo penne with shrimp.... what a meal and not one item was under a 10. HIGHLY RECOMMEND read more

My favorite steakhouse in the Midwest. Excellent service and exceptional food! The wait staff is warm, welcoming, and extremely knowledgeable. The food is unbelievably great! Extensive wine list and they never rush you out! read more

Harry & Izzy's - French Onion Soup - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is a more affordable version of St. Elmo's. We love the Izzy Style NY Strip, can't go wrong! Start off with the shrimp cocktail and end with the dessert. The brownie sundae for dessert is so big, you need to share with a friend or two! It's a great to go with a group of people. Every Sunday, they are using the Devour Downtown menu...$30 for 3-course meal. Can't beat that! read more

This is great place for a date or just a really good steak. The wait staff is attentive. The bar area is lively and something is always going on. Ask for table 18. read more

Two times I've eaten here, two times with a large group, two times with amazing service. Oddly enough we [my entire lot of family 15 strong with 2 babies] sat in the exact spot the first time we ate here - upstairs overlooking the restaurant, against the rail. Such a great view. It's a little cramped though upstairs since we were close to the stairs the service staff take up to the 1923 Lounge. Our service was nothing less than perfect. Drinks were never empty, none of us had issues with our appetizers, main courses and dessert. We obviously started with the famous shrimp & cocktail sauce. I wasn't feeling for steak - I opted for a wedge salad and the pan seared scallops. So tasty! Also - there were a lot of scallops for the plate to my surprise. If I had enough room in my stomach then I would've eaten the sugar creme pie on special that night. read more

Harry & Izzy's is the place to go when your looking for a good steak at a reasonable price if you find yourself in downtown Indy. To those unfamiliar with H&I, it can be described as St. Elmo's more casual little brother. What makes H&I great: - You can still get St. Elmo's classic shrimp cocktail. If you have some sinus issues, the sauce will clear that up for you - Reasonable prices in a more relaxed environment. Lunch time is the way to go if you have a smaller budget, but want to enjoy the food. - The servers are very friendly and knowledgeable about the different menus and offerings - Decent Bloody Mary's - They do a good job of cooking your steak to order and the cuts of meat are of good quality - Lower level bar with tv's to watch the games while enjoying your meal - Separate gluten free menu with a nice selection of items, including fries! They have a small separate dedicated fryer for fries only. They also do a really good job of handling gf orders and try to reduce possible cross contamination. A manager usually comes out to make sure of your order and verify any questions and gf procedures. - Online reservations accepted via OpenTable. If you want a specific meal time, make sure to schedule, especially prior to Pacers and Colts' home games - Paid parking is right across the street. It is one of the Circle City garages, or you can just valet. read more

So lucky to have been able to get a reservation while in town for a short time. Everything was delish and worth the wait and price! The fried green tomatoes were amazing and the Brussels sprouts with bacon. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Pork chops and Brussels sprouts with bacon. - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I enjoyed this place and would visit again! Food and service was very good. I was a little disappointed with the St. Elmo's shrimp cocktail. One would expect a larger shrimp, the shrimp I had at Fogo were larger and as tasty if not more. But all our steaks were cooked to perfection. Sides were good and a strong wine selection. The staff was on point and dealing with a group of 24, fast and efficient. I strongly recommend dinner here! read more

This was my first time here. If you've ever been to St Elmos, they share ownership and a kitchen. I had the ny strip and it was amazing. It passed the no steak sauce test. A little tip for you, they quit serving lunch at 4. So if you wanna eat an early dinner, you can save money by ordering food just a couple minutes before hand. The girlfriend has the sliders, which looked amazing. There sliders didn't have the same effect on her that white castle sliders do! read more

Harry & Izzy's - Ny strip and fries - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We celebrated my husband's 30th birthday Sunday evening. I wanted to take him somewhere nice so I decided to book a reservation for 6:15 pm. Got there around 6 and was seated right away. They decorated the table and even gave him a signed birthday card. I thought that was very sweet. We decided on a caesar salad to spilt which was plenty for us both. The waitress Andrea was wonderful. She even split the salad for us. For entrees my husband got the 6oz filet mignon and mashed potatoes. He absolutely loved his meal, he went on and on about how perfect it was cooked. I was so happy. I ordered the calamari, which was divine! I loved the sweet chili sauce and grilled lemon. We ended our evening with the most rich and decadent chocolate and caramel brownie topped with vanilla ice cream and a heaping amount of whipped cream. Uh-amazing! Might I add - on the house for the birthday boy! Truly enjoyed our evening. Will definitely be back for lunch soon! Heard the shrimp sliders are to die for! read more

See all

Harry & Izzy's exceeded every expectation we had. We made a reservation and were seated within 5 min, from the hostess to our AMAZING waitress Paige, everyone was extremely nice and kind. Once we were seated, Paige introduced herself and told us all about their menu and famous shrimp cocktail. We have been to St. Elmo's before and that was a pleasant experience as well. We just found Harry and Izzy's a lot more our style! Their famous shrimp cocktail was great as always, the toasted ravioli blew us away, and the bone in filet was a work of art!! I had a bootlegger and my husband had the St Elmo's cocktail and both were wonderful. The Crème brûlée was out of this world!! Overall, we had an wonderful night, and we cannot thank Paige enough for making us feel so welcomed. We will be back read more

Harry & Izzy's - Bone in filet and red skin mashed potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Ok sure this is a fancypants steakhouse but please, do not miss out on the grilled slab bacon appetizer because it is perfection. This is the bacon that all other bacon aspires to be, thick, flavorful with a root beer glaze that only serves to enhance the bacony goodness of the bacon. This is the kind of place where you get what you pay for. It's a classy, old school steakhouse that delivers the goods. My girlfriend and I both ordered the dry aged New York strip steaks with the horseradish gorgonzola butter because sometimes you've gotta treat yourself, right? The horseradish flavor was subtle without being overpowering, and the gorgonzola only served to enhance the perfectly cooked medium rare steak. In other words, this place lived up to the hype and then some. It's not cheap but, again, you get what you pay for and what you're paying for is a top notch meal with excellent service. I'll be back next time I'm in Indy. read more

Located in the heart of downtown this classy restaurant maintains it's unique presence amongst many surrounding steakhouses and taverns. I absolutely love the mystery movie feel to this restaurants ambience, for some reason I keep thinking who exactly are the two men in the hats in the logo? I find the food very well made here. Obviously the steak lives up to it's name. I recommend the filet mignon more than the ny strip though. I have also tried the blackened chicken which is served with qinoa and asparagus. Truly enjoyed it! For appetizer, you can't go wrong with the shrimp cocktail, however go easy on the horseradish! I thought it looked like salsa so I took a whole blob of it the first time...I didn't require a CPR but yes it made me cry. Don't get the creme brulee it's very average. Go for the Brownie obviously! Besides the food, the restaurant is quite fun yet graceful. Highly recommended for special occasions! read more

Harry & Izzy's - Blackened chicken - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Always a great restaurant before attending sporting events! My family went here before the Pacers game this past Sunday. We chose to sit in the bar, which has a relaxed atmosphere. It's bright and airy and really inviting! You cannot go wrong with the shrimp cocktail at Harry and Izzy's. I first experienced this amazing appetizer at St. Elmo's and now I just love it! I ordered the wedge salad for my second course and then the 8 oz filet with green beans. The wedge was huge!! I ended up splitting this dish with my boyfriend. The blue cheese and bacon that accompanies the lettuce is truly amazing. My filet was cooked perfectly and the side of green beans was delicious an lightly sautéed. The portions at Harry and Izzy's are quite large. I ended up taking half of my steak and green beans home. Harry and Izzy's is a wonderful addition to downtown! Nice, relaxing steakhouse with top notch food. read more

See all

Expect to see some classy, 1920's esque, Jazz Age-like decor upon your entry into this fine dining restaurant. Our server, Patrick, was probably one of the most attentive and engaging servers that I have ever experienced. We had a party of four including one child, and he made sure to be fun and accommodating to the child's needs while also making sure that we were well attended. For example, he helped serve slices of the pizza (from the kid's menu) for the child (we were also surprised to notice the large portion for the pizza - it was a whole pizza!)). We ordered the Halibut (which isn't on the menu but was recommended to us by Patrick), the 14 oz Ribeye, and the 18 oz "Cowboy) bone ribeye. The ribeye was served at a perfect medium-rare and the halibut was amazing. I would also recommend the bread pudding dessert as it is absolutely flavorful and delicious. We will definitely be back here, should we be in the Indy area again. read more