I got called fat for some reason. The worker named Kalabo called me a pig. Jenna called me a cow if they didn't feed grass. But I proceeded to order all there Dessert's it was sooooo good 3 stars. read more

Hibernia Diner - Yummers - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Tonight dinner at the diner was amazing. Their all day brunch menu included shrimp and lobster eggs Benedict. And they were so good. I asked if they were always available and sadly they said no they rotate. Well in all my years of going I've never seen them so I pray I don't have to wait years for the repeat because that would be terrible. Oh and drunken vodka fries that were good too. read more

Hibernia Diner - Shrimp and Lobster eggs Benedict. And drunken vodka fries - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Located in north jersey near Route 80 is this classic dinner, with a 70s looking exterior. Inside is warm, inviting with a nice up to date interior. Our waiter was on the younger side, but he was a pro. Friendly, attentive as needed, and good engaging conversation. We were impressed. I had the cream of turkey soup, well seasoned, excellent amount of turkey, and just enough veggies. Excellent. For my entree I had a shrimp po boy. Might have been one of the best sandwiches I've eaten at a diner. Fresh shrimp, well seasoned, perfectly cooked, Bread fresh and perfectly toasted. The sauce was perfect. We were too full to have dessert, but the display looked great. Will try next time! Lots of parking at sides and back of diner. read more

Hibernia Diner - Cream of turkey. Soup of the day. Amazing. - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Great diner. Food and Sofia's service excellent. The butter used for french toast is homemade and they have 100% maple syrup. Unique decor with 50's music piping throughout breakfast. Ample space for a party. Worth a special trip. Easily accessible off Rt I-80 in NJ. read more

See all

This place has quickly become a favorite for me and my husband if we're craving diner food, so much so that we'll drive the 20 minutes to it when there's plenty of other closer options. It's way bigger inside than it appears from the outside -- we've never had a problem being seated immediately, even on a busy Sunday morning. The prices are consistent with higher-end diner prices, so around $15-18 for a sandwich instead of $12-14 at divier places. Everything we've tried has been consistently great, and the servers are friendly. read more

See all

So happy that Hibernia is our local diner. We are renovating our kitchen and enjoy the yummy food and great service. I was too full so we took out rice pudding to go! read more

See all

I ordered the number seven breakfast... a little bit of everything, coffee hit the spot, service was excellent, food was typical diner fare, reasonable prices, we got a cheesecake to go that was just OK, I had ordered years ago and loved it... maybe a new baker(?) read more

Hibernia Diner - #7 - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

The best French onion soup I have ever tasted, but make sure it's at your preferred temperature The short rib nachos are a standout, too!

Been back several times. This is our go to place. I believe they purchase a high-quality burger, very tasty. Plump juicy wings. I like that they have V-8. See you again soon. read more

Our food was excellent - far above par and our expectations. The service was excellent too. Will definitely return read more

Hibernia Diner - Tex Mex Burger with beer cheese tots - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Handicapped parking is close to ramp to enter the Diner. Nice welcome and water served immediately. Coffee is fresh tasting and hot. Bathroom is clean too! Festive decorations added to the cozy feeling we got while waiting for our hotel. Both of our meals were tasty and while I thought my salad was a bit small, it was so tasty and just the right amount of healthy food. read more

See all

I was so excited to be back in NJ & stay at a hotel next to a diner. This diner's ambiance was great, the wait staff was attentive, but the food was mediocre for a NJ diner. Though the portions were huge, the Greek omelet wasn't great. The sheep feta that they used was not great--it tasted too sour? I wanted to think it was a preference thing but I think it was just a bad batch of cheese. The fries were great, the hash browns were soggy. read more

Hibernia Diner - Frankie's Favorite Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Great menu choices to satisfy varying audiences. Excellent service. Very reasonable prices.

Yum. Service A+ Go.. must try. I decided to stop by before driving to play golf - Menu looks Gr8 too this was an inviting sandwich. read more

Hibernia Diner - Turkey sandwich, dressing on a peach/cranberry toasted bread. - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

I've been a loyal customer at Hibernia Diner for years and have generally had good experiences--until now. I ordered food for pickup, and after waiting close to an hour, I sent my daughter inside to get it while I waited in the car. She's a young Black girl, and despite standing there for several minutes, she was ignored by staff. When I went in to ask what was happening, the host became defensive and blamed my daughter for the delay rather than offering an apology or explanation. The interaction felt unnecessarily hostile. To make things worse, when I got home, the food wasn't freshly cooked and the portions were much smaller than usual for the same order. I've supported this diner for a long time, but this experience left me feeling disrespected and concerned. No family should be made to feel uncomfortable or dismissed--especially a child. I hope management reviews this incident seriously and provides staff with training to ensure every customer is treated with basic courtesy and fairness. read more

As usual, great food, excellent service and wonderful people. New Specials are always really good! read more

Hibernia Diner - Pretzel crusted Chicken Apple sandwich - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Great, cozy diner with super friendly staff. We were looking for a nice bite to eat at dinner time in Thanksgiving Eve, and leave it to a local classic NJ diner to come in clutch. If you know diners then you know what to expect in terms of the menu. Breakfast, lunch, or dinner is a go, no matter what time of day. What sets diners apart is the atmosphere and the service. You can tell from the moment you walk in that this is a beloved favorite among locals, and that's all you need to know. Great option in the area. read more

The overall experience was pretty damn good for a busy Sunday morning, the weekend before Christmas. I ordered the #7 with French Toast, Bacon, and Scrambled Eggs. I also ordered a couple of French Vanilla Cappuccinos along the way. Everything tasted pretty good, the staff were courteous. read more

Very good as always. I prefer my potatoes to be more crispy though. My bacon was good also. read more

Hibernia Diner - Eggs Benedict - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Diners, diners, diners. Man NJ has plenty of Diners. With the advent of Food Network, many of them started serving every burger on brioche buns, removed the obligatory yet delicious "Pizza Burger" from the menu, and went with weird plating and unusual geometric restaurant ware. Generally, not a great fusion. This brings us to the Hibernia Diner, easy on & off from RT 80, super - friendly/efficient staff, and a modernized diner menu with a lot of innovation, that worked for our meal. I had this Turkey Sandwich platter, (Kind of like an old school Thanksgiving Sandwich) Cranberry Bread or mayo (can't remember) nice sagey stuffing, moist turkey, a winner. My GF got some kind of breakfasty egg thing, don't like eggs, can't remember, she liked it. Everything served fresh & hot, not sitting under the heat lamp for 10 minutes. My big disappointment (and I know this is a fraught issue for the different breakfast potato camps.) Hash Browns instead of Home Fries. Give them a try, a menu with something for everyone and a giant showcase full of pies, pastries and cakes. read more

very good food, friendly service, clean, good atmosphere, prices are good, menu variety is plentiful, loads of parking read more

See all

Went for lunch on Thursday early afternoon (9/19/24). Plenty of parking in adjacent lot. Typical dinner ambiance. Sat at a booth. Friendly service. Ordered gumbo; pretty good (except it had chicken, no chorizo): fresh okra blanched; could've used a little spice. Entree of Yucatán shrimp and avocado toast quite good, but could've use chipotle mayo. All in all very pleasant. Decent prices for today. We'll go back , for sure. Recommended. read more

Hibernia Diner - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Always wanted to stop on our travels from one end of the state to the other, and we were not disappointed. Got seated right away with a warm welcome, service was excellent as well as our breakfast choices. read more

When doordashing breakfast, ordering an "egg sandwich" with meat, the sandwich shows up meat, but no egg. After happening twice, we stopped ordering from them. My wife forgot why we stopped ordering from them after a couple of months, and ordered breakfast from them again. Of course the "egg sandwich" showed up with no egg on it again. They are consistent, consistently wrong. read more

We stopped in here during a road trip. It was dead inside. Makes me happy lol. I ordered the Faroe Island Salmon, instead of mashed potatoes, I got sautéed garlic spinach. It came out hot. The spinach was garlicky and delicious. Cooked perfect. Garlic sliced thin. The spinach wilted. So good! The carrots it came with were also delicious. They had cinnamon on them. And the salmon was delicious too! Cooked perfect. Thick and juicy! Highly recommend. My boyfriend said the eggs w/American cheese was excellent. The bacon was good, flavorful. The corned beef hash was cooked just how he asked for it. He said it was very good. His buddy ordered the Buffalo wings. He said they were good too. Service was a little slow for it being dead. Otherwise, I'd say 5 stars. read more

See all

Staff is pleasant and for thirty years I have been visiting the diner. They redid the place a few years back. Food is good and reasonable. Ambiance is decent. Pay a visit. read more

Hibernia Diner - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

So, came across this place through google and had great ratings. Great diner feel and right off the highway and major exits. Overall, it was 10am on a Monday and there was a good amount of people dining in. I sat alone and was seated by a younger gentleman. I was then handed over to Mohammed who was there doing his basic job, definitely different from how the service standard was presented by the manager, who was very attentive :[ he was the only reason the rating is at 3. My server took my order, dropped it off and totally forgot about me or didn't care, I only mattered when he dropped the bill. Did t come by to refill my coffee or check on me and see how my food was or even follow up on how everything tasted... I guess you would call this basic service... he did not provide it. The manager did see my distress look of "where the heck is my refill and I would like something additional look" and headed in my direction, twice. I wanted honey mustard and a coffee refill, but my server left as soon as he dropped my food :[ food tasted a bit warm and as if it sat for 5/10 minutes before it got to my table. He was just lacking, I have regrets tipping him :[ Will probably choose another server, food could have been great, but I feel like I didn't get it at a optimal time frame. read more

See all

Food and service were great. The Reuben sandwich was divine. Attentive but not obtrusive service. My companion loved his sandwich. Fries were perfectly done. The menu is quite extensive with a smattering of traditional Jewish deli items which made me happy I had been there for breakfast the previous day and had the salmon eggs Benedict, which were just wonderful. If you're in the area, definitely eat here. read more

Rudest owner I've met, and he had the gall to charge me for BS sparkling tap water. Try the Dunkin' donuts next door, it's better.

My wife and I have been coming here since 2017. The service and food is excellent. The portions are so large that we have to take food home. Their desserts are delicious. read more

I loved my server Jason - after greeting me he stopped at chatted about the book I was reading and told me a crazy story about a book signing he'd gone to recently. My tuna sandwich was all I expected, and the matzoh ball soup was excellent - as was the key lime cream cake! So happy I found this place for a little break on a road trip read more

Great neighborhood diner. Good food, friendly service and generous portions ! I had the Italian omelette and the sausage was superb. This is a great find - we will be back and so should you ! read more

Hibernia Diner - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

The specials are always great. Food and service is always great!! Hibernia Diner is always a good choice!! read more

Hibernia Diner - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

See all

Great! Nice big booths with wonderful selection. I'm so glad there was a sign on highway otherwise would have missed this gem. Perfect diner

Every time I go to this restaurant I love it more. The interior and exterior are a mix of modern and retro design which is stylish and comfy. The employees are friendly and attentive. The seafood bisque was chock full of seafood with no fake thickeners. It was one of the best I'd had anywhere. The slightly sweet browned coated salmon served with smashed potatoes, and savory asparagus with a touch of hollandaise melded both sweet and savory, luxe and simple, in perfect harmony. I brought home a peanut butter explosion cake and I expect it to be fantastic. I can't wait to go back. Kudos for providing elevated delicious food fast without being too fancy or expensive plus the diner classics. Much better than any chain restaurant or other diners around. read more

A New Jersey diner, which we have craved for in Florida! For those who have not experienced a NJ diner, hard to convey the feelings. A new piace, at least it was not here when we left the Garden State several years ago. Other than a small hiccup at being seated (manager was talking to a waitress while we sat at the hostess desk), a good service, with the young waitress very amicable and a good customer service. I tried the South Philly Italian Pork (Pork Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Potatoes, Roasted Tomatoes, Garlic Scented Spinach, Balsamic Drizzle, Ciabatta Roll), whip at $13 was a winner. I substituted the fries with coleslaw. I loved the tenderness of the cutlet and the balsamic touch! Two things that moved my vote to this low (other than how we were greeted): 1. a convenience fee added to the bill, which, according with the same manager mentioned above, "is the fee we charge for you using a credit card". Not cool, and it may be close to being illegal. 2. The young cashier was not trained to process credit card charges, was absolutely not her fault, rather management's. Who "throws" a young girl into it like this? read more

Hibernia Diner - South Philly Italian Pork - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

Service was friendly and prompt on a Saturday afternoon. Enjoyed the gyro platter, which was served with good French fries and a nice Greek salad. The beef gyro was not too salty, as it often can be, and it went great with a little tzatziki and pita bites. My son thought the chicken on the Bavarian pretzel chicken sandwich was dry, but the flavors were good (albeit very messy). read more

Hibernia Diner - Gyro (beef) platter with a Greek salad and French fries. There was tzatziki on the side and pita under the meat. - Diners Near Me - Rockaway, New Jersey

I had Sabrina she was an absolute delight!! She made my dining experience comfortable, she made my day if not my week! Her ambience and aura just light up a room, I wanted to roll her up in a ball and stick her in my pocket! The food was spectacular, the specials need to be tried because they are made with love. I will be returning soon! And Moe was such a help and pleasure as well!!! read more

Wanted to like this place ...but two stars for service is kinda generous. I think maybe you are supposed to go in the kitchen and make the food yourself and serve yourself. Great place if you have hours to kill. read more

This Diner has been a staple in Rockaway, Morris County , and NJ since I can remember. I remember coming here as a kid with my parents as I grew up in Rockaway. The food is always great, the people are always great. I want to pass this great tradition on to my children as well and I hope they stay and continue one of the great few diners and places left in this state. Of coarse no trip to any Jersey diner is complete without an order of disco fries and they have the best. They've done a Renovation on the diner and looks great and has more room and the food has got better and better over the years. The burgers are big and juicy and they accommodate any order and the homemade cheesecake is a must try. Best diner in the area without a doubt. read more

See all