Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Hilary's Cookies

    4.6 (51 reviews)
    ModerateBakeries

    Hilary's Cookies Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Hilary's Cookies

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    a horse cookie in front of a christmas tree
    Caren J.

    What's not to like? Delicious, flavorful, gorgeous cookies. Get over there!

    Jacob J.

    Ever since a random trip to Fort Bragg, California in the fall of 2011 where I found this bakery that made these divine chocolate chip cookies with everything in them, I've been on the search for other bakeries with a suitable replacement. Which began a cookie trek still in the making. So, recently I had a hunger for chocolate chip cookies so I was on Yelp thumbing through reviews. I found this place and quickly scanned their website to see what flavors were offered. I wish the "New stuff" area on their main page was highlighted or in a larger font because I completely bypassed that paragraph and missed what would have told me that their cookies are all completely Vegan. Nothing wrong with Vegan cookies but it just wasn't something I was looking for at the moment. Traditional is what I was jonesing for. Their vegan cookies are composed of no dairy, no eggs, ingredients like organic unbleached flour, organic sugar, unsulfured dried fruits, organic etc. Note that for cookies created this way to get a consistency that is close to the traditional cookie, other ingredients are used. Not chemicals or complex sugars but natural ingredients found in any fruit or vegetable market. I wonder if they supply ingredient lists to customers that need to know. They are catering not only to the vegan crowd but understandably those that are living with dietary restrictions. Nowadays there are a lot more of children and some adults that cannot have dairy or eggs. I walked in expecting to spend less than five dollars and walk out with a few cookies. Nothing is ever as expected. Many of the flavors of cookies on deck were as they say "unique" flavors. Luckily I found a chocolate chip cookie and a chocolate coffee, which I purchased. Also got a couple chocolate chip minis and a 10 or 12 oz cup of fresh, chilled, organic lemonade sweetened with organic cane sugar. Total was just above $12 dollars! Big cookies are $2.50 each, lemonade $4. Pricey. The chocolate chip has an interesting flavor, I tasted hints of coconut in it and its texture was like that of a soft baked cookie. I would return for another in the future. The mini's were like pecan sandies or biscotti in it's texture, I wasn't thrilled but the lemonade was perfect. It was a sultry 95 degrees that day and the lemonade was equally tart and tasty. Needless to say I would order another the next time it's humid. It's shared knowledge that they sell cookies at Whole Foods as well. I commented to the store keeper that I travel through the area often and have never seen this shop. It'd be awesome if they sent cookie pushers onto Lincoln ave, hopping the stretch of so many bars out there. Which are a few mere blocks away. Some of which have beer gardens or open exteriors in the warm months. If I saw a cookie pusher with a great price and a smile, I'd buy a cookie.

    two muffins on a plate
    Ashley M.

    Every summer my husband daughter and I look forward to the Horner Park farmer's market because of Hillary's Cookies stand. The scones are among the best I've ever had aside from a friend's Irish granny. We absolutely love them. The man who works the stand is such a joy and makes our Saturday so much better! We love seeing him- he's like a legend in our family because we get so excited to talk to him, haha! He gave me the most amazing tip for the scones which is cut them in half and stick them in the oven at 350 for like seven minutes.. serve with butter and your in heaven. Wish I could really convey what joy this baking company brings to my family but I'm truly not even doing it justice!

    Pros: Cookies were warm, soft, and delicious. Made me forget about all my problems for a few seconds as I gobbled them down. Cons: My hopes were raised when I looked at the menu and started to order but were then dashed quite expertly as the server said that it was outdated.

    Gluten-Free Brownie goodness!

    See all

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of John G.
    144
    3
    0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Chris R.
    12
    104
    5

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    The Vegan Pumpkin pie cookies are absolutely delicious! They taste just like a slice of pumpkin pie. Soft and creamy. YUM!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    absolutely love the cookies. a wonderful deal and perfectly made in every possible way!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Hilary's Cookies

    Review Highlights - Hilary's Cookies

    If your not able to stop at her store in Lincoln Square, no worries, you can pick up her cookies at Whole Foods too.

    Mentioned in 10 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 27,410 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Jennivee’s Bakery

    Jennivee’s Bakery

    4.4
    (722 reviews)
    3.3 mi
    $$

    This is my absolute most favorite bakery. So this is my ode to the bakery and Dom, who is a gem of…read morean employee there. I've been a customer of almost 10 years and have been obsessed since they first opened their doors at a different location. I literally live an hour away without traffic and even longer with traffic, but I make sure to stop by or send someone else to get it for me at least once a month or more. I love the amazing cakes that are so delicious and unique but on top of that, it is Asian owned, LGBTQ supporting, etc. A lot has changed since their little storefront with no seating. The bakery is now a full on cafe and I'm so happy to see how much they've grown and how successful they are. And while it is glorious, I will say I miss the sweet neighborhood charm and great customer service it used to have. Getting in touch with the bakery through phone or text can be tough and to be honest, sometimes one of the people working there is kind of...very mean. It had me questioning if I should keep coming back. I just love this bakery so much though and being raised by parents that had a small food business, I can't help but want to support. I had a particularly difficult last minute request for the bakery a few weeks ago and I was reminded why this place is so great. It had been YEARS since I made this specific request, which was an order for a slice of cake for every flavor and a cupcake for every flavor. This is a BIG and time consuming request, especially if it's last minute. Unfortunately I come to the city whenever the traffic isn't atrocious, so it's always last minute. Dom absolutely pulled through though. Even though there were other employees there (I saw two others but one disappeared and then another male was kind of walking around the cafe and such), Dom took this giant request and fulfilled it himself. The other gentleman (not the mean person previously mentioned) was actually who I made the request to, but he told Dom to do it. I was kind of confused why they didn't do it together but idk, maybe the other guy isn't allowed to handle food? Who knows. Regardless, this request obviously took a long time and the line was getting longer; people were getting a little restless but Dom stayed calm but was swift. I swear he was moving faster than most people in the industry could with a cake knife like that. He was not impatient or rude to me at all. He was just there to do his job as fast and well as possible. It's so rare to see that type of work ethic. He is also so obviously proud of the bakery and the food they serve which makes you feel good about being a patron there. So although I continue to have an unpleasant experience with one particular employee there, Dom keeps my love for this bakery alive. He reminds me of what this bakery was like when they first opened their doors. I hope Dom is cherished there and I bet he is considering his work ethic. I will continue to support this bakery and I recommend everyone else to support as well. It may not be that small little shop anymore but Dom is a reminder of the heart of the place.

    I've been to Jennivee's twice now and I also got my college graduation cake from here last year for…read morepick-up! They did a beautiful job. For my graduation cake, I chose the tres leches and it was so creamy, moist, and delicious. I basically ate half of the cake by myself lol. This most recent time, I needed a snack and wanted something sweet. Everything here looks amazing and I'm sure tastes amazing too, so it's hard to choose. I chose to get the berry chantilly cake slice since it was a hot day, and it was the perfect refreshing treat! It was soooo good.

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Jennivee’s Bakery
    Main Squeeze Cupcake and Hazelnut Bomb Cupcake

    See all

    Main Squeeze Cupcake and Hazelnut Bomb Cupcake
    Chiu Quon Bakery & Dim Sum

    Chiu Quon Bakery & Dim Sum

    4.2
    (650 reviews)
    8.8 mi
    $

    This is the best bakery in Southside Chinatown, without a doubt, the line just never stops like…read morethey're handing free food but they're not. Although the prices are very reasonable, you could come here everyday...BTW, make sure to bring cash as it's cash only. I really love coming here after a meal because the buns are soft, light, airy, and sweet. Thus far, my favorites are: - egg custard topping with a red bean filling and - the coconut bun with whipped creme Wow, those are really good but do try their other offerings and determine your own favorite item. I have to try their Argyle location to see if they're consistently great!! Oh, one more thing, there is a ledge by the window where you can eat quickly whilst standing up but it can get very crowded in there. Xie xie Chiu Quon!!

    This is a staple if you visit chinatown in Chicago. It has fast service and the workers are all…read moresweeter than sugar, and has wonderful atmosphere to it. It was incredibly bustling, which was ambient and also a sign that the pastries here would be good. The egg tart I had was the perfect amount of flakiness and wasn't too sweet. The texture reminds me of flan. There is a wide selection of bakery items to choose from, so I reccomend you try mutiple. It is worth the price. Please go here.

    Photos
    Custom order cakes
    Custom order cakes
    Portuguese egg tarts with their tantalizing brulee tops and tasty BBQ pork bun filling
    Portuguese egg tarts with their tantalizing brulee tops and tasty BBQ pork bun filling
    Portuguese egg tart, coconut bun & BBQ pork bun

    See all

    Portuguese egg tart, coconut bun & BBQ pork bun
    Fat Peach Bakery

    Fat Peach Bakery

    4.3
    (78 reviews)
    9.1 mi

    Finally had time to drive over and try the pasteries! Service was super fast, no wait time. It's a…read morecompact and cute store. Only 3 window tables that fill up pretty quickly. I bought 3 and my friend got 2. Calamansi cream + pistachio paste danish was my favorite. The Calamansi cream was the perfect texture and density with a fragrant citrus note. When I took a sip of coffee afterwards it made my coffee taste like I was drinking fresh orange juice. The pistachio is more cake like inside than full paste and isn't too sweet. Flaky dough, soft pistachio center and creamy top with a sharp citrus cut. Peach + raspberry Melba danish. The peaches were soft. I'm not familiar with a Melba dessert but the center of this was almond paste which is not my favorite but if you like almond and tart danish it would hit the spot. Raspberry espresso cream cheese cinnamon roll was a fun fruity twist to a cinnamon roll. Couldn't really tell there was espresso though. Blueberry lime cheesecake danish. I also liked this one because of the lime. It really cuts through the heaviness. The fruits on top were also fresh. They also have one day old blind boxes. I grabbed a 6 piece day old box to go and it was actually 6 different pasteries, half sweet and half savory! It only repeated 1 of the pasteries I had originally tried so I'm excited to try more, especially the savory ones. It's an amazing deal if you just want to try a variety of flavors. Tried the Hot dog danish - really good! Upscale pigs in a blanket vibes. The tiny fried are seasoned perfectly and add a fun crunch. The splashes of Dijon cut through and it doesn't feel oily at all.

    I've been on the hunt to find the best bakeries in Chicago and had been dying to visit Fat Peach…read morefor awhile after seeing rave reviews! Let me tell you, it was all I hoped it could be and more. The storefront was pretty small with a few tables- between the size, hours, and popularity (they were only open a few days a week and closed at 2pm), I suspected that the shop sold out often. I went on a weekday and there was still a good selection of pastries left around 11am. The staff was super nice and helpful as I struggled to make a decision. They shared that the strawberry milk croissant was their bestseller, so I opted for that. It was filled with fresh strawberry mascarpone and fresh strawberry puree. Despite the croissant's decadent appearance, it was not at all too sweet. I'm not typically the biggest croissant fan (I know, I know, no one is perfect) but this pastry blew me away. The filling was super generous without overpowering the delicate dough, which was baked to crispy perfection. Sadly, I don't get to the area often, but I will 100% be back asap to try more of the menu. Run- don't walk to pay a visit!

    Photos
    Fat Peach Bakery
    Strawberry and cream croissant
    Strawberry and cream croissant
    Fat Peach Bakery

    See all

    Sugar Moon Bakery

    Sugar Moon Bakery

    4.8
    (119 reviews)
    3.3 mi

    You've heard it all before. What can I say except everything you've heard about Sugar Moon is true!…read moreThis is easily now my favorite bakery in the city. Shout out to everyone that works there because they are super nice and helpful. Let's get the logistics out the way: yes if you show up when they open at 9, there will be a line, but it moves quickly! I'm usually out with my order by 9:25! I have a huge sweet tooth and let me tell you the savory pastries are my favorite. I will not visit without getting at least one miso mushroom pastry. I absolutely hate eggs and the jalapeño popper pastry is so good, I barely noticed the egg in it until I'd eaten half of it This place is the TRUTH. Every pastry is flaky, every bun is fluffy and the flavor combinations are so unique. Let me stop typing so I can go stand in line!

    um absolutely yes this is what they mean when they say support small businesses!! I stumbled across…read morethis bakery on my way to the suburbs and it's sooooooo good! I see why they're known for their banana pudding croissant. There were so many things I wanted to try, the people working were so nice and despite being small inside, it gave a very intimate cafe feeling. Will 100% be back to try more things. Come early to get first dibs on everything before it sells out.

    Photos
    Inside of Focaccia ($5/slice) - harissa cauliflower, caramelized onion, gouda, cheddar, rosemary. Delicious.
    Inside of Focaccia ($5/slice) - harissa cauliflower, caramelized onion, gouda, cheddar, rosemary. Delicious.
    Inside of Sweet Brioche ($5.50) - cara cara orange & passionfruit filling. It's nice: the dough is rich and chewy.
    Inside of Sweet Brioche ($5.50) - cara cara orange & passionfruit filling. It's nice: the dough is rich and chewy.
    Chai cinnamon roll, espresso cornflake cookie, banana pudding croissant

    See all

    Chai cinnamon roll, espresso cornflake cookie, banana pudding croissant
    Bittersweet Pastry Shop

    Bittersweet Pastry Shop

    4.1
    (916 reviews)
    2.7 mi
    $

    Our experience with Bittersweet Bakery was exceptional from beginning to end. We ordered our…read morewedding cake from Bittersweet, and they made the entire process enjoyable and stress-free. The cake tasting was a wonderful experience, giving us plenty of delicious options to choose from while helping us create the perfect cake for our special day. Throughout the entire process, their communication was outstanding. They kept us informed every step of the way and worked directly with our wedding venue, "Firehouse Chicago", to coordinate the delivery and logistics. Everything was handled seamlessly, and our cake arrived exactly as planned without a single issue. Planning a wedding can be overwhelming, but Bittersweet's professionalism, organization, and proactive approach gave us one less thing to worry about. Their attention to detail and commitment to excellent customer service truly stood out. One feature we especially love is that they keep the recipe and design of your wedding cake on file. Every anniversary, they can recreate your wedding cake or a cake in any size you choose. We've continued this tradition, and each anniversary cake has been just as delicious as the original while bringing back wonderful memories of our wedding day. If you're looking for a bakery that is responsive, dependable, and delivers an outstanding product, I highly recommend Bittersweet Bakery for your wedding cake or any bakery needs. They responded promptly to our questions and requests, unlike some businesses that never replied to estimate inquiries. Their customer service and quality were truly exceptional. A heartfelt thank you to Samuel who conducted the Cake Tasting and the entire staff at Bittersweet Bakery for helping make our dream wedding a reality. We will always be grateful and look forward to celebrating many more anniversaries with your incredible cakes.

    The pastries at bittersweet will never disappoint. I grew up going to this bakery and the quality…read morehas never wavered. The quiche is always fantastic, and anything out of the pastry case is a must. Drinks are good as well! Such a cozy spot to grab coffee with a friend (or give in to the temptation of snagging a pastry on your way to the brown line)

    Photos
    Bittersweet Pastry Shop
    Bittersweet Pastry Shop
    Beautiful and delicious - a sweet table by Bittersweet

    See all

    Beautiful and delicious - a sweet table by Bittersweet

    Hilary's Cookies - bakeries - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...