Great flavors. Nice seating outdoors. Friendly service. They let you try many flavors. Note that cash is not accepted and there is a 3% charge for credit. We used a debit card. read more

We were in Bainbridge island for a marathon and found this ice cream place at the finish line. Good assortment of ice creams and sorbets. The staff offered us samples to try. We got the pistachio and cheesecake. Probably the best pistachio ice cream that I have ever had. It had pistachio nuts in it and the flavor was amazing. They have a second location in Kingston by Sourdough Willy's Pizzeria. read more

See all

Chill vibe. They offer many Lopez island ice cream choices. Cute decor up front too. We wanted to try the root beer float but they were out. The scoop size may vary depending on how much is in the bin. My boy whined about it a bit. Other wise it's a fun little ice cream joint. read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - Pistachio ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

Ice cream was yummy! Do the employees hate each other though? Island Cool? More like Island Heated the way the two girls working clearly wanted each other dead. I got flashbacks to my parents' divorce. Luckily the blackberry flavor was delicious enough to alleviate those flashbacks read more

Great ice cream place. They have lots of different locally made flavors and house flavors as well. They also have a handful of sorbets for the GF and Dairy free people. I got the pistachio and cherry amaretto. My partner got the mango sorbet and mint chocolate chip. All the flavors we got were good. They also let you have as any samples as you want so you can see what you like /don't like. The staff is super nice as well. read more

Weird vibes. really weird vibe. No music and awkward employees just staring at us and giving us weird looks read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

The ice cream we had was delicious and we liked that the single scoop could be two different flavors. I got the Dark Elf and the vegan Coconut. My husband got Rocky Road and Salted Caramel. The young man who waited on us was okay and not especially friendly. read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - Dark Elf and the vegan coconut. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

The ice cream is delicious, and great service too. Cute shop surrounded by beautiful nature.

After stopping for lunch at Proper Fish my parents and I made the short walk to Island Cool. My mom was craving pistachio ice cream and though Island Cool doesn't list their flavours online, the other nearby ice cream place didn't have pistachio on the online menu so we made a gamble. My mom loved the pistachio ice cream but I thought the flavour could have been bolder. To me, it was like having plain vanilla ice cream. I opted for a mini scoop of strawberry ice cream in a cup. The ice cream is local made with local fresh strawberries that were sweet. I just wish there were more strawberries in the ice cream to really get that full-bodied strawberry taste. My dad ordered toffee coffee which my mom tried multiple times to steal. The coffee was delicious and I loved the texture the bits of toffee in the ice cream created. I also appreciated how generous the toffee was in the ice cream, there were multiple pieces in every bite. The restaurant was clean with compostable cups and the staff were friendly and attentive. Though there was a line when we first walked in, it was taken care of quickly and we were served promptly. There is plenty of outdoor seating and my parents and I enjoyed eating our ice cream on the benches outside while people watching. There was also an activities cart inside the creamery with board games, crayons, and colouring sheets for little kids which I found pretty thoughtful. My parents are already planning to come back. Next time I'm really looking forward to trying their mango sorbet. read more

See all

A nice selection of flavors but I felt like the ice cream and sorbets fell a little short for me. It's a tad bit pricey for the portion and when we came the line was on the longer side so it there was a bit of a wait. Understandable because it was a hot day. I ended up sharing a mango sorbet with my husband but after eating it awhile it just didn't taste like authentic mango. read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

Cute ice cream shop with yummy ice cream. Staff was friendly. The line moved quickly. I appreciate their efforts to be eco friendly. But I hated the paper spoons they provided for the ice cream. They were really hard to use and bent a lot. read more

I don't normally crave ice cream but I liked what I got from here. They have unique flavors like almond poppyseed, cucumber lime, and P.O.G. (passion organe guava). I had a single scoop (you can choose two flavors) and tried almond matcha as well as cookies and coffee. They are both delicious! I liked the thick consistency and creaminess. The portion was also generous. I'd come back if I'm back on the island again and craving something cool and sweet. read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - Almond matcha, cookies and coffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

The ice cream was great! All the flavors we order were amazing. Service was super friendly! The place is beautiful, great location, very clean! read more

They have a wonderful array of yummy flavors! The staff was very welcoming, and the place was clean and comfortable. I highly recommend ICIC for when you're in the area! read more

We were walking around on a hot, sunny day, so we had to grab some ice cream. There was a long line, and was moving slow because there was only one worker and the other one was on a break. The second one came back by when we were closer to the front of the line. Staff was friendly. I got the S'mores and my bf got Cookies and Cream. Both were tasty. read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - Cookies and Cream and S'mores - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

So many flavors to pick from and they let us try as many of them as we wanted before making our selection. It was a great afternoon treat on a hot day! read more

I had the green tea and blackberry icecream which was so delicious! Pleasant and courteous service as well and the interior was clean. Highly recommended! read more

See all

It was raining so not a lot of customers. They let you try samples. The thing is Fresno has this amazing ice cream place called Ampersand where everything is made in house and it's farm to table and they are just the best ice cream with seasonal offerings. Island Cool doesn't make their ice-cream in house, but it was delicious. I got the cookies and cream with the matcha and almond ice cream. It's a very cutesy store. read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - Matcha and almond and cookies and cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

They had the flavor profile I liked and I'd come back . Service was fast and friendly. Ambiance was cute read more

The shop offers many flavor choices, and I was glad that it had some dairy-free options. Each of our group who ordered liked our ice cream.

Was looking forward to going there yesterday but ultimately was disappointed. They state up front that they don't take cash. Not sure why, but that almost turned me around. Seemed arrogant. But I went in anyway and was told that they only had milk chocolate flavors. No dark chocolate. Disappointed! Tried the banana split flavor. It was served soft, probably because that made it easier to scoop. No banana flavor until the aftertaste hit after about an hour. Disappointing. You'll get better ice cream at Cups Espresso in P'bo. Or at Scoops & Bites in Bremerton or Cold Stone in Silverdale. Way back when this was Mora Ice Creamery they had way better selection, including dark chocolate, which was what I was looking forward to, and the ice cream was cold enough to make it harder to scoop but better to enjoy. read more

Are you kidding me? $8 for a small cup of mediocre ice cream? Baskin Robbin's would have been better. Staff was lovely. Atmosphere was fine. $8 dollars?!?! Not worth it. read more

This location has changed over (previously Mora) - before the ice cream was so good, it was worth taking the ferry just to get our fix. The new establishment is meh, and when you add in the cardboard straws it is a definite avoid. read more

Super cute spot within walkable distance from the ferry terminal! The one downside was that there weren't any great vegan options for my friend, so I'd skip if I had dietary restrictions. But besides that, there's a great selection of flavors and I was personally a big fan of the pecan praline! read more

Island Cool Ice Cream - menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bainbridge Island, Washington

Prior name was Mora. Island cool came in and added so many great and unique flavors. Reasonably priced, great staff and worth the wait if weekend summer lines get a bit long. They have a few locations! Yum read more

Wish they had the long hair employees wearing a hair net. Was in last week and witnessed the employee with French braids scooping my ice cream with her hair down inside of the cooler. I threw it away before I was out the door. read more

First off the place smelled so bad the whole shop and area smelt like humid trash instantly making it really unappetizing. The employees were so slow and by the time I paid my ice cream was half melted and messily dripping down the cup. Additionally the cashier was making fun of and being rude to the people ahead of me for barely tipping which was not okay. Also there was a very limited selection of ice cream and the sandwiches were mid at best. read more

Sorry to say but in my opinion, the ice cream here is below average. According to the person who served us, this shop sells Snoqualmie ice cream. So you're getting the same thing sold in the grocery store and it definitely tastes like it. The cinnamon was bland and the salted caramel gingersnap surprisingly not flavorful. I'm sure others won't mind and but this place was not for me. read more

The staff were super friendly, and even allowed for free samples of the ice cream flavors we wanted to try, so we knew what we were getting. I loved that they had so many options to choose from, and they do milkshakes too! I got the cherry-flavored one and it was something else; it was a delightful tasting experience. The theme of the place is very colorful with a creative theme, with checker boards and coloring sheets for you to fill in. For visiting Bainbridge for the first time, I'm really glad this was one of the first places I've tried. Definitely going back to try the other flavors for sure! read more

I sent my 10yr old to get two 16oz raspberry smoothies. I thought he was teasing me when he told me it cost $25. I just looked at my credit card app...$25.66!!!? For two smoothies! Fuck you Island Cool. And don't blame inflation...you're fucking robbers read more

we used to literally take the ferry from Seattle to Bainbridge to visit Mora. shattered when realized it was a victim of some pe driven late stage capitalism. this ice cream place is no better than store brand grocery ice cream. Worth skipping for sure. read more

They had lots of unique ice cream flavors and I like that they let you sample before deciding what flavors you want. I got matcha almond which was good and it had a subtle green tea flavor. The sizing they have is very confusing. Mini scoop = 1 scoop, single scoop = two scoops, and double scoop = four scoops. I said "I'd like single scoop size of matcha almond please." She asked "What size?" and I replied "Single scoop size." I told them TWICE that I wanted the matcha almond single scoops expecting two scoops like everybody else, but was confused how little she scooped (it was literally half a scoop of ice cream). At the register, she charged $4.37 and that's when I realized it's a mini scoop. She'd already went back to scoop ice cream for other customers and it was busy so I left but I am disappointed how much I paid for a mini scoop which honestly didn't even look like a full round scoop. It was tiny like they barely scooped the ice cream :/ read more

I just stopped in for ice cream at Island Cool. I confess, I hadn't been there yet as I was still grieving the loss of the shop that was there before. The service was welcoming and helpful. I tried two flavors recommended by my server and was pleased with both. The interior has been refreshed and is pretty and inviting. Earl Grey and White Out ice creams were delicious. I will definitely be back. read more

I too was craving some ice cream and wanted something local, Oreos milkshake to enjoy on my drive to Portland. Unfortunately for me, they were out of milk. I then chose a single scoop and headed to use their restroom. It was out of order. So I canceled my scoop and moved on. I would have loved to support a local business and sample a good cool treat. read more

There is nothing I love more than a scoop of ice cream. I have eaten ice cream all over the country and all over the world, and maybe it's recency bias, but I truly think one of (if not THE) best ice creams I ever tried was at Island Cool. My family and I were visiting Bainbridge Island for the day, and wanted to get something sweet to top us off before the ferry ride home. I typically opt for chocolatey flavors, but on this day I decided to go for the Skagit Valley Strawberry and the Honey Lavender. They were out of this world!!!! The strawberry was refreshing and sweet without tasting fake at all, while the honey lavender was light and airy, with a delicious hint of that lavender kick. The flavors had a beautiful complexity too; I was just blown away by the quality. I was so disappointed to see that they didn't ship their ice creams, because I would have ordered pint after pint of their strawberry! You HAVE to try this place if you visit Bainbridge. Trust me, you will not leave disappointed. read more

I love coming here for ice cream! The staff is always so very sweet! All of the flavors of ice cream are so good! This place is definitely a destination when traveling to Bainbridge Island! read more