Very nice and casual restaurant by the water. The view is beautiful! Drinks and food were surprisingly delicious. We got the Mahi fingers, the Lobster Roll and the Lobster Mac n Cheese - everything fresh and super tasty. Island Grill was a great surprise in Islamorada and I highly recommend it! read more

See all

The food was delicious but a little undersized for the price. I had a mahi mahi that had a crab cake and shrimp on top. For the sides I went with garlic mashed potatoes and sweet potato fries. You just have to top it off with a passion fruit margarita. The waiter was nice enough but he wasn't the most attentive server I've ever dealt with. Especially considering the place was far from busy. I did enjoy the open air seating right next to the waterway. The cool breeze may have blown the napkins around but it felt so refreshing. read more

See all

Classic FL venue offering casual American food. Reasonable menu offering of with staple favorites burgers, fries, etc. Good customer service. read more

First time here. We were headed back up north and wanted to have brunch. Our host was also our server and he brought everything out together while assisting the front with seating - impressive to watch. Our food was tasty. We can't wait to come back. read more

Island Grill - Crab cakes egg Benedict - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

We had some time to kill before we could check into rental so, stopped here on our visit to the keys for a late lunch. Seated right away by the water, it is kind of off season. Ordered a margarita with tequila. Was very strong...loved it great start to our stay. Ordered blackened Mahi Mahi tacos that came with rice and beans. My wife had Tuna nachos. Both dishes were excellent. We gobbled it up. Fish was fresh and tasted great. For dessert we ordered key lime pie. It had a good tart flavor and wasn't super sweet. Restaurant was clean and staff was friendly. Will definitely be back again. read more

See all

Food was very good as was the service. Clean bathrooms. A chicken quesadilla and snapper sandwich and 2 drinks came to $80 A bit excessive. read more

Island Grill - Chicken quesadilla - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Food wasn't great especially for the prices. We love to try local food and this was not something I would try again.

The vibes were immaculate, beautiful outdoor seating next to the river and it did not feel too hot. The noise level was great and the waitstaff were very attentive and all around friendly and willing to do anything to make the experience better. The food was out of this world and fairly priced. Highly recommend for a casual night out or a special event. read more

Island Grill - THE ORIGINAL TUNA NACHOS - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Sat in the indoor space as it was a bit windy and don't like sharing my meal with the flys. I ordered the fillet mingon (med rare) with seared vegetables and a house salad. The fillet was a little under but melted in my mouth. The veggies were mushy but tasty and the salad was a salad. All in all a really good meal. Finished it off with their key lime pie which was delicious. I'd go back. read more

Island Grill - Key lime pie - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Nice open air restaurant on the channel that serves breakfast, lunch and dinner. We had the normal breakfast that was good. Only slightly negative thing I could say is when we first arrive everyone seemed like they were not in a good mood. No one smiled at all, maybe it was too early and they are not morning people, lol! Had we been greeted with a welcoming smile I would have given them 5 stars. read more

See all

Th food is delicious. Douglas was phenomenal! Highly recommend the tuna nachos. Thanks island grill!

Very disappointed with our experience at Island Grill. We ordered a dozen oysters and two grouper filet dinners, and our bill came to $155. For that price, we expected a much better meal. The food was mediocre and definitely not worth the cost. The one bright spot was the service--it was friendly and attentive. Unfortunately, good service alone isn't enough to make up for an overpriced meal. We won't be returning. read more

I don't know what anybody's talking about but this place deserves a five! The ambience is amazing. You literally have the ocean right next to here was boats tied up to the dock at the restaurant. Emily was our server. She was great! Helped me with my picking mess. We ordered the purple bowl, chicken, Cobb salad, island tacos, and crunchy grouper sandwich. Amazing! You will not go wrong being here it is outside, but it's cool enough that it won't make a difference. Come in whatever you're wearing they don't care. See you guys again soon thanks so much for a great hospitality. read more

Island Grill - Mahi Island tacos - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Drinks like tea and water were in very small cups and never asked us for a refill. Conch fritters were not good. Will not be back!

Ordered the Caeser salad with grilled shrimp to go and it was great so we went back to have lunch onsite the next day. While the outdoor waterside seating was nice the food was average at best. The crispy Hog fish sandwich was over fried and dry with zero flavor. Sandwich sauce came in the closed plastic cup, one overly thick slice of onion, a slice of tomato, and about a quarter of a Romain lettuce leaf with an un toasted bun. Wife's sandwich was just as unimpressive. Service was marginal even though they were not very busy. read more

Read reviews, figured nice location, that's where it ends. Dinner 6 pm, only couple inside, 97° out. Server insisted on on calling my wife and I Mommy and Poppi just loco. Food sub-par, oysters were previously frozen, you know when you know. Seafood paella, which was note on menu, please add 20 minutes extra...came out in less than 10 minutes, frozen mussels, clams and shrimps, the fish was no existent.Fish imperial was overdone and crab cake murdered. Entire meal, Mommy & Poppi were rushed. 2 stars for location,if hot mangroves are your thing. read more

Island Grill is a great spot in Islamorada if you're looking for seafood. It's waterfront too and shaded! The service was a bit slow and forgetful towards the end of the night, it was a weekday when my family went so that might have a part in it. Hopefully it's better during the weekends! read more

See all

Literally some of the best chicken wings I've ever had! Awesome restaurant in the Keys, worth stopping at for lunch and/or dinner. Kind wait staff, quick service. Bar vibes on the water in a quiet area. Great for families, dates, quick bites. read more

The view from the outdoor seating at Island Grill is beautiful & breezy. We enjoyed watching the marina traffic pass by and park. We ordered two items: the tuna nachos and the coconut encrusted snapper. We would suggest the tuna nachos which were flavorful & fresh. Unfortunately, the snapper dish is not recommended. The fish and no flavor & the beurre blanc was also flavorless and unappealing. The broccoli was decent, but the French fries were old and tasted like the heat lamp that kept them warm. read more

Island Grill - Tuna nachos - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Lobster Mac n cheese. Thats it. Soo creamy, beautifully cooked lobster. Star of the night. The live music entertainment was great, average service. But their lobster Mac n cheese can't be ignored. We also had some stone crab chowder which was good as well. I would return to try some of their other dishes read more

Island Grill - Lobster Mac n cheese - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Poke Bowls are excellent, conch fritters are great, fish sandwiches are good enough. Staff is attentive and fast, drinks are good. Recommend . read more

Island Grill - Fun times - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

What a horrible place to eat ! We ordered clam chowder and was brought conch chowder without telling us they had run out of clam chowder at 4pm. The frozen key lime margarita was watered down. The lobster roll was so bad it was uneatable. The lobster tasted old, was dry and had nothing added to it. It was $36 and we left it intact. The chicken wings were tasteless, also dry and presented very poorly. They had a Happy hour quesadilla which was the only half decent food item. Do yourself a favor and keep driving by ! read more

Mediocre food at an expensive price. Dolphin tacos overcooked. Chicken fingers and fry's looked and tasted like they were leftover from last night. Tuna nachos were just good. Nice server. read more

My aunt and uncle live nearby and are frequent customers. Today's visit this afternoon was my second time and just as enjoyable. The Islamorada Roll was delicious, and our server, I think it was Shane, was excellent! Despite being very busy he was attentive, kind, and a great ambassador for this restaurant. Highly recommend! read more

Island Grill - ISLAMORADA ROLL - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Driving down south and we decided to stop at Island Grill. We were seated right away on the covered outside deck. Nice breeze even though it was 93 degrees! Very comfortable. We tried the daily special appetizer: coconut Thai mahi finger! Delicious! Had a few cocktails and dessert. Our server Daniel was very nice and efficient. We had the homemade key lime pie and the daily special dessert rum cake with vanilla ice cream. They were both incredible! I didn't expect the rum cake to warmed! With the cold vanilla bean ice cream on top.....oh my goodness! Delightful. The key lime pie was light and tangy! Beautifully done! Thanks Island Grill. Well stop by again! read more

Island Grill - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

This place is AMAZING! Laid back with great food and service. Shane is a sweetheart and a terrific server! Food, service and drinks are fantastic. You also must try the home made lime pie. read more

Island Grill - Key Lime Lie-- homemade! - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Island Grill in Islamorada is a fantastic spot for waterfront dining in the Florida Keys. Conveniently located on the south side of Snake Creek Bridge at mile marker 85, this restaurant offers a laid-back, tropical vibe with beautiful water views--perfect for enjoying a meal while watching boats pass by. The food is great, and the menu has something for everyone, but the tuna nachos are an absolute must-try! They're fresh, flavorful, and easily one of the best appetizers in the area. Whether you're in the mood for seafood, salads, or sandwiches, you'll find plenty of delicious options to choose from. The ambience is casual and inviting, with plenty of outdoor seating where you can soak in the coastal atmosphere. It's a great spot for lunch, dinner, or just drinks with friends while enjoying the ocean breeze. The service is generally friendly and attentive, adding to the relaxed, island-style experience. If you're looking for waterfront dining in Islamorada, Island Grill is definitely worth a visit. Highly recommend the tuna nachos--you won't be disappointed! Keywords for SEO: Waterfront dining Islamorada Island Grill Islamorada Best restaurants in Islamorada Tuna nachos Islamorada Restaurants near Snake Creek Bridge Seafood restaurant Florida Keys Islamorada waterfront dining read more

See all

Awesome experience all around! Great views, vibes, service, and food!! Our waiter Shane was great. Will be back! read more

Island Grill - Michelada - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Waterfront location is great. Service was quick because it was not too busy. food was nothing great. The tuna poke was good but no crazy flavors. The mahi Rueben was not good with no thousand island dressing and soggy bread. Caesar salad and fries were good. read more

Island Grill - TUNA POKE BOWL - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

The oysters are pre-shucked and the sushi is not fresh. It seemed pre-made also. I worked in food service for many years. I understand why places do it, to save money on labor. But it sacrifices SO MUCH on quality. I should have asked if the oysters were pre-shucked, but a restaurant with a sushi menu fooled me into thinking the seafood would be fresh. read more

The food was just OK. But what was really upsetting was how incredibly rude and aggressive the waiter was. The service was terrible. This was a bad experience at very expensive prices read more

This was our 1st time here and we stopped because the sign said AHI NACHO! How can you go wrong with a choice like that? They also have brunch- FYI. The Ahi tuna was to die for! Fresh and delicious with ample toppings...but there were only 3 chips! Its a shareable app...how do you share 3 chips? 4 Makes more sense! Either way they were very tasty! The service was fast and helpful. We were able to taste test beers before selecting. The views were beautiful of course and very large indoor area for many guests. The staff was fast with the turn around of tables which makes for less wait time. We will definitely return! See you Soon! read more

See all

We stopped here on our way down to the Keyes looking for an oasis from the traffic, and it certainly hit the spot! To kick off, we ordered the Hemingway cocktail... It was just what the doctor ordered to take the knots out of your rope! Super casual With fast service and eager to please, this certainly hit all the right notes. We watched all sorts of groups and small groups come and go, including a few dogs! This place is super casual, family, friendly large group friendly, and has some pretty good eats... Including the grouper sandwich - which we highly recommend! So if you're looking for a place on the side of the road, that also has a spot on the water, this is your oasis! read more

Island Grill - Untie your knots with the Hemingway - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Our experience at this restaurant was disappointing from start to finish. When we arrived, the host asked if we preferred to sit inside or outside. We told him we didn't care as long as we weren't too close to the live music. Despite that, he seated us directly in front of the performer, who was playing quite loudly. Things went downhill from there. The food was almost entirely flavorless and tasted like it had been previously frozen. Even the oysters looked and tasted frozen. Our waiter kept pushing the expensive lobster dish--maybe because it was the only fresh item on the menu. By the end of the meal, we waited nearly 20 minutes for our check while the waiter repeatedly walked past our table without making eye contact. We were so frustrated we almost left cash on the table and walked out, but we had no idea what the total would be. Everything was overpriced, under-flavored, and the service was terrible. We will never return. The only reason this review is one star is because my wife said her drink was decent. read more

We enjoyed our dinner last night and the service!! Had a simply amazing poke bowl!!! Fresh and delicious!!!! Thank you read more

Ehhh we came here with high hopes after a few recommendations. It's quite cute being right on the water and service was phenomenal. Serving that much tuna on the nachos for that price is a red flag. Tuna was not high quality but we didn't get sick , sushi was okay and grilled mahi mahi was actually my favorite. Not bad but we just had higher expectations. Definitely come Check it out and the view. read more

Great food with great views. Very attentive staff. Quick service and prices were reasonable

Such a fun spot! Right along the water's edge, with seating inside and out, this grill gives off crab shack vibes. Way cool! Our host greeted us warmly and our waiter was very helpful with answering all of our questions about the menu and (mostly) the specials of the day. I was happy with my Lychee Tuna Carpaccio (one of the specials). My girlfriend was equally as happy with her meal of Lobster Plantains. A must-do on my next trip to this area. read more

Island Grill - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

You can sit at the bar or in the open dining area. Parking on site. Tuna Nachos to start. Tuna poke bowl and coconut shrimp after a long day traveling. Our server reassured us our selections were great. We agree. I had enough tuna to last me all week. It was a bit windy sitting by the water but we love watching boats pass by. read more

Island Grill - Tuna Poke, Tuna Nachos and Coconut Shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

This restaurant is good for breakfast! Family friendly and nice water views. They have $15 per person bottomless mimosas you cannot beat! The service is good and it's reasonably priced. They offer kids meals and kids get colors and crayons and can see the boats drive by. read more

See all