Moonlight Tavern is a Port Washington gem. The building…read moreexudes ambiance and charm. The interior is relaxing and easy. Staff is friendly and helpful. Reservations were not needed the night we dined but they ate suggested. The prime rib was decadent and perfectly prepared. The portion was generous. We'd definitely check it out again when in the area.

For supposed high end restaurant in Port Washington it was just OK…read more Martinis 1/5. Small and too much vermouth. Bread 3/5 Frozen reheated buns...just ok. Oysters 3/5. Nothing special..just ok. Small and tasted not super fresh. Shrimp pasta 3/5. Good taste but swimming in sauce Go to Plier's instead.

This place was great. Loved the steak, sides, French Onion soup, and the Key Lime pie might have…read morebeen the best I have ever had. Cool atmosphere and really inexpensive considering the quality of the food. Comfortable atmosphere too. Loved everything about it.

Awesome supper club, we enjoyed our visit. Food and service was great!…read moreWas recommend by our Airbnb host. She nailed it. It was our 11 wedding anniversary. Enjoyed

BEAUTIFUL location! The food was excellent! Exactly what I want in a breakfast! Would love to go…read moreback again sometime!

Best eggs Benedict I've ever had, outside of the British Isles! MAGNIFICENT!…read moreFrom the hostess, to the waitress, to the chef, to the exquisite way the eggs Benedict was prepared and presented...this restaurant looks after the details. It shows! We can't wait to return this summer!!! One of our very best experiences on this trip! Thank you SO VERY MUCH!!! Well-done, in every aspect! Sorry I'd half eaten it before remembering to take the photo - it was just THAT AMAZING!!!

Stopped for lunch. Good beer selection. Good bar grub. Pizza was traditional frozen type…read more Bratwurst patty was delicious. Solid cheese curds. Excellent customer service!!

The view of the lake is the main reason you are coming here. The views of Lake Michigan are…read moreincredible with an open air deck. I opted for the chicken. BLT with chips. Good was good but the chicken was a little chewy so that brought down my rating. Service was very good and they kept filling our water and sodas before we even asked. The menu isn't vast with many healthy options but expect good quality bar food with a great view of the lake

Super yummy local spot! Haven't tried much of the food, mostly just go for the custard! It is super…read morecreamy and if you get mix-ins they give very generous amounts! Service has always been good, and never too long of a wait!

I can only speak to the cheese curds but these are at least tied, if not outright the best fried…read morecurds I've ever had. Jalapeño and garlic, two orders were maybe not even enough. Big fresh curds, lightly fried, infused with flavor. Excellent portion for your money. My friend and I both agreed on this. A cute homey ambiance inside and friendly customer service (they are local so give them a minute if interacting with someone else) all adds up to a huge win and I may have to accidentally route myself back through Port Washington next vacation for some more... and some custard... nah I'll go get that right now!

It was a little strange how you ordered before you get to the table but it was well worth it. It…read morewas absolutely the best prime rib I've ever had. We got the Schwartz cut and it was huge. The service was excellent. The price was reasonable. It had an old school super club vibe. I understand why it is packed when the doors open at 3.

Start by throwing out the low stars. I've been to dozens of supper clubs and after visiting…read moreSchwarz's, I'd put it in the top 10. Classic Scony supper club. Get there early or you'll end up waiting. Don't drink? Too bad; if you don't get there early, you'll wait. Salad bar (which I love), not here. Muddled old fashioned, not here. Cozy atmosphere and solid customer service, definitely in the right place. We arrived with a veteran couple. They got us there early, understood the ordering routine and found us a place to sit. We ordered appetizers and drinks. Definitely get the onion rings as they are incredible! Drinks were solidly poured and reasonably priced. We ordered and were surprised by how quickly we were seated. The vegetable tray and bread basket were good. Our meals came out shortly after we were seated. The salads were nice sized and the blue cheese dressing with crumbles was great. Our entrees (ribeye, tenderloin with chicken, prime rib and fish) were all sized nicely and prepared as ordered. My dining partner said the chicken was some of their all-time favorite. My ribeye was seasoned well and cooked perfectly. Our dining partners loved their choices. Overall, I'd really like to give 4.5 stars, but my pals at Yelp still don't trust half stars. We all enjoyed our experience and will definitely put this on our list of supper clubs to return to!

If you plan on eating here it's best to make a reservation. Something was definitely wrong with…read moretheir table seating system. We were told it would be a 30 minute wait, it was well over an hour....... We came back here because the food is actually amazing.The fish fry is always good. Nice and hot , potato pancakes are my favorite..the coleslaw and tartar sauce are on point. This place is huge and busy it's definitely a lot going on. If they can fix the seating situation and be fully staffed this place is a recipe for success. ..... don't count them out...... give them a try The food was delicious!!!

Nice reboot. Great job in reconfiguring dining room…read more Menu is great, and we often recommend to family and friends.

Visited with a group of girlfriends to celebrate birthdays and the start of girls weekend and…read morequickly learned the rave reviews were true. Start to finish, we had a fantastic dinner. We tried multiple different cocktails, and loved each one. We all enjoyed our dinner entrees, which were beautifully plated. The service was top notch, even offering to take photos for us to remember our fun evening. Their menu appears to rotate often and is somewhat limited, so make sure to check the menu before you go if you are someone with specific food interests. We found the menu to offer multiple things each of us would enjoy. We can't wait to visit again!

I am so grateful to have such a delicious dinner spot nearby! I have been here a handful of times…read morenow and continue to have the best experience! The vibe is on point, low lighting, rustic - a versatile spot to go with girlfriends or for a date night. The wait staff is always attentive and informational, providing suggestions when we are looking for guidance on what to choose. This time around I went with a girlfriend and we decided to share a couple apps and an entre. We started with their seasonal burrata that was bursting with flavor. It was both savory and citrusy, a really nice compliment. We did have to order a side of bread with it, so that's one improvement the restaurant could make - bread is a necessity with a cheese dish! Next up we ordered their Mixed Greens Salad which was a perfect light & tangy salad with a little bit of sweetness. Highly recommend. Finally, we shared the seared walleye entree. I pretty much order fish everytime I come here because they cook it to perfection and it's something I can't make at home as easily. The walleye did not disappoint and was so flavorful and enough food for us to share. We ordered the perfect amount to split between the 2 of us. Can't wait to go back, keep up the good work!