Delicious take out salad with shrimp from Jerry's Pizza today! Literally topped with housemade dressings! read more

Jerry's Pizza - Incredible salad with shrimp from Jerry's Pizza! Perfect! - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Best pizza in Middletown! Prices are steep, but the pizza is good. A little thicker crust and great sauce.

Recently moved to Middletown and wanted to try something different for pizza besides Mondo. Lots of people rave about Jerry's but I thought it was just ok. It wasn't great, but wasn't bad. Just ok. Kind of a sloppy presentation with not enough flavor and I ordered their special pizza. In a pinch I might try something else from there but it won't be my go to pizza place. read more

Ordered take out tonight. They were very busy. I counted 11 employees working and the teamwork was impressive. Pizza was great. I have no complaints. read more

Pizza is always great and the waitress is so friendly and nice. Love coming. Thanks Jerry's

We ordered a medium cheese pizza and garlic bread with mozzarella.  First of all, it was 10:30 when we ordered and they told us itd be about an hour, which in itself is a bit long. It arrived at around 12 *sigh*.  Our delivery man had brown curly hair, and was a bit sketchy the whole time.  He didnt give us change at first and then he almost LEFT without giving us our pizza. Once we finally got our food things weren't much better. The garlic bread was okay, a little salty though. The pizza was awful, the texture of the crust was soggy and soft, and the cheese was snail like it was so slimy and gross. Definitely not worth the $22 spent. For shame. Do not ever order from Jerry's Pizza, be sensible and get your moneyd worth, get your pizza from Newfield Street Pizza or Illianos. read more

I ordered two pies for a local party. One was a tomato basil and the other was Hawaiian. Both were pretty good, but not extraordinary. The restaurant is on the old side of things, the staff was friendly. It did take a little long to get my order. I was able to use a yelp coupon for 5 bucks off, so that's a plus. Overall, I'd come back if I needed pizza in Middletown, ct. 3.5 stars read more

Great Sicilian pizza! Dough was thick and chewy, sauce was delicious, the extra cheese was on point. I had two slices and I was full! Excellent pizza and I can't wait to go back! read more

First time having this pizza... Medium was a good size. Fluffy crust and had a great smell to it. Sauce was good but a little too salty...cheese had good texture but slid off pizza. I would return! read more

This is my favorite pizza in Middletown. I'll drive to the other side of Middletown for there sausage pizza .

Best pizza around. It's pricey, but it's so worth it. I wouldn't reccomend any other pizza place in town.

Jerry's Pizza! I have yet to find a delicious doughy cheese pizza I like better than Jerry's. He's awesome, come say hi, bring your family, have a pie. One family tradition I've kept! (Ps, there is no Sally's or Pepe's, there is only Jerry's- it may not be super artsy but it is GOOD) read more

Overrated pizza. Not a bad pizza, but doesn't even belong in the conversation of best pizza in Middletown. Thick, chewy crust and a lot of sauce and grease. I'd rather go to Big Cheese for half the price and better pizza. If you feel like spending over $20 on a pizza just go to Illianos, it's right up the road. read more

Got my order wrong (BBQ chix vs buff chix) Hawaiian pizza isn't the greatest, took over an hour.

One of the best pizza's i've ever had! Been going here for years! Very cheesy and saucy. A little greasy sometimes, service is friendly. Pasta is good too! read more

Ordered a large pizza, garlic bread, calzone, and a stuffed shells dinner online at 5:35pm. Was told pick up would be between 6 & 610. At 5:45 we got an email that they were behind and it would be ready between 630 & 640. Okay, fine, they're busy; it happens. Then a woman calls me at 610 to tell me they were out of shells. (I had to substitute for raviolis). Fine. We drive there and there's no parking left and you had to wait outside in the cold so one group at a time could come in. We finally go in and it's still not ready. They never cooked the raviolis, but we watched the guy take a frozen bag and throw them in to cook. They said go wait in your car and we'll walk it out in 10. 20 mins later we walked back and got our order. Our food took 2 hours!! Won't be back. Food was mediocre overall. Cheese pizza wasn't bad, if we stuck with just that, we might have gone back, but frozen bland mushy meat raviolis are a no-no. Sauce was Chef Boyardee flavored and crushed red peppers on the garlic bread? It was so spicy for no reason. .5 stars for the pizza crust. read more

Hands down the best pizza around. However I find that they make more mistakes in delivery orders than most. The normal wait for delivery is 1 1/2 hours but it's worth the wait. read more

We never had a problem in the past. We ordered a cutlet grinder and wings. My daughter and my husband both had terrible stomach aches after eating it. They both did not taste like they did in the past. We will not return. read more

This place is over priced for its "New York" style garbage it produces. I called around 8pm to have my order arrive close to 10pm. I took one bite into it and the bottom of my chesse pizza was burnt. The dough was incredibly tough and chewy. I was appalled at the quality of this pizza being that I'm from queens, ny and know good pizza. I called the restaurant and spoke with the manager that explained he doesnt give refunds but he would more than gladly send me over another pizza... I questioned why would I wait another two hours for piss poor quality pizza. He asked it if was my first time ordering and that next time I should order it slightly underdone. Like no man. You will never get my money every again. Your customer service was awful. My husband just buys the dough at the super market and makes a true New York style pizza. This place is a complete mess. If I could I would give it negative stars. read more

Food is great, one of my favorites. Problem is delivery. If you order on a Friday or Saturday it will be roughly 2 hrs. They will tell you an hour or an hour and 15, but this is false. I delivered for both Chinese and pizza restaurants for 5 years and there is no excuse for this consistent length. I have given them a few more chances but has not ONCE come in less than 2hrs. I fully understand restaurants get busy sometimes but this is totally unnecessary and have lost a customer that orders every single week. Sad tbh read more

One of favorite pizza joints in town! Love their pizza and the staff is great! They also have a variety of wings that are delicious. The subs and salads are also good too. read more

I Love, Love, Love Jerry's Pizza. I think their Pizza is the best in the area. The staff is super friendly and always willing to help with special orders. Never leave Middletown Jerry's !!!! read more

This is the 1st pizza place we went to when we moved to CT in 2011 my son always loves going here. They all so friendly and great food!

When I am away at school in nearby Cromwell, this place always cheers me up. The people that work there are friendly. (I always order by phone and then drive to the shop to pick up my order. I enjoy striking up a conversation with the owner, his daughter, or the young girl that answers the phone when they aren't busy. They have a great sense of humor.) The place is clean. And the food is always hot, generous, and awesome. I tend to order more than anything else - a large pizza with onions and anchovies. (I know that isn't appealing to most people, but all of the pizzas I have tried at Jerry's are wonderful.) Their sandwiches/grinders are good, too. And their prices are relatively inexpensive. I am a Catholic student priest, so I travel around the East Coast a lot. I just wish I was in the Hartford/Middletown area more often. Jerry's is a winner. My name is Chris. read more

My first experience with Jerry's was with fried pickles and a couple of appetizers for a get-together I was having with a few friends. The fried pickles were coated in some awkward crunchy breading of cornmeal or some other device, and they were incredibly overseasoned to the point where they didn't even have a taste. The only thing that anyone actually finished that night was the eggplant fries. Not to mention the fact that they took forever just to make a few snack. I called ahead and was told "20 minutes" by the girl on the phone, and when I got there (30 minutes later) the food still wasn't ready. In fact, it took them another 30 minutes to finish my order and all they kept saying was, "that order is here." I figured, maybe their pizza is better. So my second experience was last night, and it was so awful I had to write about it. I placed an order for delivery with eggplant fries, the brushchetta, a tomato mozzarella wrap and a "margarita" pizza. After waiting almost TWO HOURS for my food to be delivered, I finally called and was told that the drive had apparently left 20 minutes ago. AN HOUR AND A HALF TO MAKE FOUR THINGS!? Was everyone and their mother ordering from Jerry's pizza last night? Needless to say, by the time the food got there, it was ice cold. Instead of being kept in a heat bag it was scotch taped together and covered in snow. The Eggplant fries and the wrap had gone soggy and the margarita pizza had to be reheated in the oven. The MARGARITA PIZZA was hands down, THE WORST margarita pizza I have EVER had. EVER. There was probably about four pieces of mozzarella cheese draped on top, way too much garlic and some weird burnt basil spread or something. Not to mention that the crust was burnt. AND THIS PLACE IS RIDICULOUSLY EXPENSIVE. And not worth the quality. For $20 for a large pizza, I would expect artisan quality, frankly, I've had better pizzas from Walmart. NEVER going to Jerry's again. read more

I am 51 years old I first met Jerry when I was 10 years old he used to give me free Pizza I grew up,, my daughter new Jerry he actually gave her free pizzas I love everything about your restaurant I will always come back...... You are a restaurant that has always gave to the community it's part of our heritage. read more

Best pizza I've had in a long time. Fresh tasting sauce, perfectly crispy crust, just the right amount of cheese. I'd drive hours to have it again. read more

Pizza that is edible and ok if nothing else is available. A few miles away in Durham we have Carmines. So much better! Much more like New Haven pizza. But, Jerry's grinders are pretty good so we get those instead when we don't feel like driving too far and they deliver too and they deliver quickly which I like. Carmine's also delivers but they take forever to get here! Worth waiting for though cause their pizza beats Jerry's by a mile. read more

Was my choice by default if I wanted delivery. The customer service is terrible. You are not doing me a favor by answering the phone and taking my order. I do not expect people to be overly joyful but is it in any way possible for you to at least pretend you are not a completely miserable human? The food can be good. I guess it depends who is running the ovens that night but that's far from a compliment. I'm done with this dump. I'd rather drive a few towns over for take out than have to order another pizza of uncertainty from someone that seems to be working the phones at gunpoint. read more

I don't understand the hype. Went to Matty's last night with a couple of friends. They ordered the lasagna and the veal parm respectively. Those dishes seemed okay, but I tried to keep it healthier and ordered the seafood fra diavalo. Big mistake. It was on spaghetti instead of linguini (though neither was noted in the menu) and the spaghetti must have at in the pot for hours because it was waterlogged and the consistency of Chef Boyardee. The "seafood" was about 8 small shrimp and a generous amount of in - shell mussels. Not sure about the sauce, there wasn't a lot of it and most of it washed down into the waterlogged spaghetti. For heat, instead of red pepper flakes and garlic there were sliced jalapeños (Wtf?). I ate the mussels, rooted around for the shrimp, and left the rest on my plate. The bartender was very apologetic and seemed as surprised as I was. All in all, pretty disappointing, especially for Middletown. This I would expect in dubuque, not in a city with an historically large Sicilian population. read more

Serious joke for pizza. We live in a state where pizza can be good. So what's your excuse? Over an hour late for delivery from what was originally told. Messed up with the address and messed up the order. An on going theme.. Overall pizza was cold and soggy. read more

I was extremely disappointed. We were visiting my sister and brother and law in Middletown, CT and decided to order out for dinner. It took 2.25hours for our food to get to the house! We called several times to check on the status and see if it'd be quicker to just pick it up, and everytime they told us our order was the next one out. Once our food FINALLY came we couldn't believe how bad the sausage calzone tasted. It was definitely not worth the wait. We will never be ordering from Jerry's again. read more

Blizzard pizza mix up (I admit it, I'm a damn "Sally" at ordering, sigh) was called in and Jerry's had a replacement pizza offered and delivered, free of charge, faster than I could have imagined---and amazing as usual. Special props and thanks for great food and even better customer service. read more

Food was good but delivery took way wayyy too long. We ordered around 7pm and the food wasn't delivered until 10pm. They did give us a discount to make up for it- but it was after the third time we called to see the status of our order. They didn't really seem apologetic- more that they were trying to get us off the phone. read more

This used to be the best place to get a slice in the area. It has gone way downhill. My most recent order tasted like dish soap. It also took 90 minutes for delivery. 90 minutes! Who expects to wait that long for a simple pizza? Will not be going back. read more

I'm not sure why my review was pushed into "not recommended " but my review was accurate to my experience. Carmela responded to me which made me feel good and I appreciate that , but I do not appreciate my review being basically thrown out like that. read more

We've ordered from Jerry's several times. The food has been consistently good every time. The pizza is the best I've found in this area. I've tried the white Clam, a Meatball and a Mozzarella. All were very delicious. They also have gluten free which is something needed more and more lately. The wings are delicious and with the addition of flavors you can switch it up. I've had a couple different salads; the small antipasto and the crispy chicken salad. I LOVE the freshness of the salads. Both salads have mushrooms, olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, and provolone cheese and you certainly can't beat the price of the salad. I've also had an Italian Grinder which did not disappoint. Another thing I love is paying with my credit card. The delivery man brings a machine to run your card through so you don't have to give your card number out over the phone. I also should add the delivery man is always friendly and courteous with a cheerful greeting. I highly recommend Jerry's Pizza. The ONLY reason I give 4 stars is it typically takes over an hour for delivery. But it's consistently the same amount of time and the food is good so just give yourself the added time when ordering. We've ordered several times and will absolutely continue. Do yourself a favor and call in an order or go visit them. I don't think you'll be disappointed read more

Best pizza around!!! Thin, but still soft crust, perfect sauce, amazing cheese. Keep meaning to try toppings, but I love the cheese so much I don't want to ruin it... Didn't much care for the breadsticks - they're kinda of bland and hard - I'll stick with the pizza. Unfortunately, if you eat there they seem to have gotten rid of the fountain soda and just have bottles and selection can be slim right before a delivery, but since I usually get it to go it's not a big deal to me. I drive about 35 minutes to get Jerry's - it's that good!!! read more

If you are planning a party for a lot of people, this is place is a horrible choice. We had a big event that cost $600 and we were alI shocked at how little food there was for that price. We were all afraid we were going to run out of food. Many people put very little on their plates and some did not participate because they were considertate of others. And the food was run of the mill, lack luster, and blah. Very disappointing. There are other local places who will throw in a little something extra when you spend that much money. But don't expect anything extra from this place. In fact, the last time we had a pizza party for a big event, we were short a pizza. You will not get the biggest bang for your buck here. read more

Got wings here again after giving the place another chance to redeem themselves. When Matty's next door opened up is when the kitchen was at their peak. The wings were some of the best you could get around. But I don't know what happened to the quality of the food in recent times. We got 24 wings and to our disappointment, the wings have gotten even worse from the last time we were in. They are VERY salty. And there should never be breading on a bone-in chicken wing period. The pizza the last few times we had gotten it is way too salty. Couldn't drink enough water to balance the amount of salt in the pizza. It's really unfortunate because the food used to be worth coming in for. I really hope they make some changes soon. It's going to be a while before we attempt to get food here again. read more