I still really like Jerry's but the quality is very variable. Sometimes you get a great pie, sometimes you get a disappointment. The last few times we ordered the 'nonnas pie' which is a grandma style pie and its been good and unique. they describe it as "Thin Crispy Oily Crust with a light amount of mozzarella, basil , spices and tomato sauce" and i think its worth checking out (if you aren't getting that special white sicilian pie) read more

Just moved to Middletown and was looking for a local pizza joint. I decided to try Jerry's and called at 11:15 on a Sun. They answered and took my order even though they did not open until noon. Said I would receive it a little after noon. At 12:40 I called to make sure it was on the way and was told it was the next one out. I live a mile away if that. At 1:00 I gave up and cancelled the order. read more

I have grown up eating Jerry's pizza. In my opinion, it's the best pizza around and I will stand by that. The crust is thin and the sauce is outstanding. Their white pizzas are out of this world. Recently, I had to change my diet and eat gluten-free. Jerry's offers gluten free pizza but it is not the best. The sauce and cheese are great (much like their regular pizza) but the crust is very thick and very dry. I hope that they are still trying to modify it and make it better. I've had some great gluten free pizzas and if Jerry's can master the dough recipe for it, it will be the best! Another thing that can be iffy is their delivery. Sometimes they're right on time! Other times they take a very long time. All in all, I recommend Jerry's to anyone who can eat gluten and is looking to pick it up or dine in there. read more

Well from the outside its not much... Pizza was good, not great. Under $10. Sells by the piece $2.50. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Entrance - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

We ordered takeout from Jerry's at 6:30, and did not receive our food until 9pm. We live the same town as Jerry's so it wasn't a difficult travel. Absolutely absurd. Definitely don't recommend them for takeout that is for sure!!!! read more

Jerry's is the standard by which I judge all pizza. I've been a loyal fan of Jerry's since I could chew. My father has been a patron since the restaurant was opened. It is a New Haven-style pizza with a blonder crust. I like my pizza that way, although it's not everyone's cup of tea. Their tomato sauce tastes deliciously simple. I also really enjoy their ziti, although it is just ziti with the sauce on it. I was disappointed when they moved from Washington Street to South Main Street because they lost a lot of their dine-in seating. Once they re-opened on South Main Street, they had only a few tables pretty much right in front of the door, so that made it a little uncomfortable in the winter. I have heard that they now have additional seating, but I have not yet witnessed this myself. I think it's some of the best pizza in the state, possibly, the country. read more

Oh, my fellow Yelpers. I have come to look to you for knowledge and guidance and am not usually disappointed. Tom and I took a drive down, as I'm always in the search for the best pizza. We had a small sausage, pepper and onion. It is an ok pizza. If this is the standard by which some of you are measuring pizza in the state, wow. There was nothing wrong with it, it was decent, but certainly nothing that stands out. Oh and before it came out, I was telling Tom about a pizza place I had been to that served pizza on paper plates, which when you cut it with a knife and fork, (yes I do) it tore up the plate into the pizza. Cue the waitress setting down the paper plate and knife and fork. Oh, and there was also some cretin picking up a pizza that was saying that someone had been flown in for the graduation in a helicopter that he didn't know who the person was, but probably came in from a private yacht. Yes, I'm sure that is what happened. And he went on and on about the secret service being in town and how that attention just brings trouble....cue the banjo. As anyone on a diet will tell you, when you decide on a weekend splurge, it had better be good. (Remember 'sponge-worthy' from Seinfield?) This was not worth the calories when I want to be dazzled. On a diet sidebar, am I the only one that after a splurge considered 'getting rid of it' as an option when it has not been worth the calories? I think not. My search continues but as of right now, Naples in Farmington (slices of cheese only) and First and Last are probably my go to pizza joints. read more

Really disappointed in this place. We've ordered delivery before and the wings came perfectly, even held heat with delivery. We placed the order yesterday via Slice, anticipating that they would be busy because of the Super Bowl and left a 20% tip prior, but when we got there, they couldn't find the order. And then when they did, we had to wait an additional 20 minutes. What's the point of ordering an entire day ahead when they don't even pay attention to order times? They told us after they "found" the order that the wings were getting sauced and would be ready shortly. We live 7 minutes away, and when we got home the wings were ice cold. Spending over $40 on wings plus a generous tip, we at least expected the quality we got the previous time. And to top it off, they weren't even busy. We won't be ordering from here again. read more

I absolutely love this place. The food is so bangin! I get the boneless wings all the time, peanut butter and jelly flavored boneless wings. Amazing! I eat it at least once a week. It's my favorite. read more

Have been eating at Jerry's since I was a kid, now I order it for my family. We usually stick to their pizza, though other menu items are decent, the pizza is (imo) the best thing they have to offer. The crust is perfect and doughy, my son always eats crust first then the pizza because he's too impatient to get through the cheese and sauce part first! Even though their delivery wait time is super long, we just plan ahead and call an hour and a half before dinner time so it arrives perfectly on time, (and usually, arrives before the time they say!) their delivery driver, Rick, is a very nice and friendly guy and has been working for the company for a very long time! We love Jerry's! Best pizza in Middletown. read more

Love coming here. Waitress is always so nice and friendly and takes care of us even if its just for 2 slices and a soda. Pizza always taste great. One of my favorite places for pizza. read more

Jerry's Pizza - Love coming here for a slice only 3$ always good - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

See all

We have been patrons for years. Must have new people running because the delivery and response to my calling was awful. We ordered at 5:42 and our food arrived at 8:15. I called at 7:15 and was told ours was next called at 7:55 told ours was the next one out again. Shameful. Not worth the wait. We weren't even given a heads up when we called that it was over 2 hour delivery time. read more

Honestly, This has to be one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten. I had the cheese pizza, The crust was a bit on the thick side but the cheese was gooey and the tomato sauce tasted fresh. 5 Star hands down the best pizza I've had in CT. read more

Ordered 2 pizzas and a slice. Menu says buffalo chicken pizza grilled or crispy. So I ordered crispy chicken. My pizza was under cooked crust was still white. Also there was grilled chicken under the cheese which tells me it was pre made. Then Tossed crispy chicken on top put it in the oven and dried it out. It had no flavor very bland. Also my medium cheese was also under cooked and still white. Very disappointed. To be honest my slice was cooked perfectly. 40$ for a small buffalo & medium cheese 1 slice pepperoni and 2 20oz sodas. read more

Idk how this place is in business with pizza palace right down the road better in every way. Two stars cause the wings are actually prettt banging. They outta be smacked for the chicken parm I got and their pizza is greasy and Bland as fuck. read more

When we moved to Middletown we loved Jerry's Pizza but it has gone way downhill in just the year we've lived here! We just received a pizza that wasn't even cooked all the way through. The middle was all dough! I am pregnant so I can't eat it like it is so we had to put it in the oven for 30minutes so not only did we wait an hour and a half for delivery, once it got here we couldn't even eat it. Probably our last time ordering from here read more

Love going here and mattys. Always a good time with great service and food that is a fair price for the amounts you get. Even take out is amazing. Most places dont work well with take out. You get it home and its soggy or not the same as eating in the restaurant. You dont have that issue here. Even with all the new wing places showing up in town they still have the best ones hands down read more

I want to like this place as a local pizza joint to grab take out or order delivery, but every time I go in or call to order take-out, the people have been so rude! I'm not sure I ever left a yelp review to complain of rude staff, I like to give the benefit of the doubt and understand that people have bad days, but this has happened one too many times. Also, their delivery is 1.5 hours as a standard. I ordered a grinder for pick up and the guy said it would be "at least" 30 minutes. I ordered at Illiano's instead and had a much better experience in general. It was packed and the pick up time was still 15 minutes. I'm done trying with this place. read more

Always love the buffalo chicken pizza! Picked up today and took 20 minutes like they said and was fresh out the oven! read more

Jerry's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

I just got Jerry's gluten free loaded baked potato pizza to go last night and OMGosh, it was FANTASTIC! The smell of the pizza was so incredible that I knew that the taste had to be just as good...and I wasn't disappointed! My father tried the pizza as well and he is always telling me how disgusting gluten free food is. Surprise, surprise my dad LOVED the pizza! The crust tastes fresh compared to many other pizza places that typically have frozen gf pizza crust. I will absolutely be returning for this outstanding pizza. It might just be the best gluten free pizza I've had in CT. read more

I work for a local hospital...and we have placed two huge pizza orders in the past 2 months. The folks at Jerrys' Pizza have been so accomodating! They bravely took, filled and delivered our orders with friendly and competent service. The pizza was delicious, to boot! Jerry's is quickly becoming my go-to pizza place and I look forward to doing business with them in the future. read more

Pretty good not great. Tastes really good the day of but doesn't reheat well. We like their thick crust but this is the type of pizza where you get about a one inch gap between the crust and cheese. The ingredients seem reasonably high quality. read more

Some of , If not, the best pizza (definitely in Middletown) in the state of CT. I grew up on this stuff and this place is a must visit every time I return to the area. To be fair, Jerry's is a very specific type of Pie. I have never actually had their Sicilian but I hear great things about it, however, their classic is one of the realest things I have ever known! I did not order a grinder this time, I went for the sausage and pepperoni and ordered a calzone for the misses... Wanted to give her the true experience. But there Grinders are something special too! I was actually very upset with myself for not ordering one before I left town. read more

All set with Jerry's. It really irks me when people in business establishments have attitudes. come across rude and want to get the last word because Im NOT GOIN BACK SO .. I WON . I called in a order of wings to go. On the menu the wing flavors are listed "bullet point " style . Except for some reason someone decided to use "bullets" along with comma's . So I called and ordered "garlic frisky" wings . I was IMMEDIATELY CORRECTED .. and told "we don't have that" rudely even though it was on the menu. No "I'm sorry sir maybe you confused one of our flavors". Which is what competent business people do .. so upon arriving I went to show the MISERABLE HEAVY SET person that answered the phone where at on the menu I got it from .. She decided to teach me english. Her comment was "thats how the english language works" So are you a english lit professor moonlight as a take out order taker ? She said as nasty as possible which is probably jus her regular miserable mood "there are comma's separating the flavor names" .It is not the easiest most understandable style . IE if you look at SLIDERS (the place Ill go in the future) if you put the flavors bullet style each line you put the full name of the flavor you separate it by lines not commas .She was jus down right nasty I don't have to go to JERRY's and deal with her theres a TON of other choices in Middletown to get wings . All she had to say is "oh I see how that might have been a bit confusing ,sorry bout that ". No harm no foul , we would have laughed it off ..Instead she wanted to teach me english. She was rude . Had my 12yr old not wanted the wings I woulda left her with them . Which Im sure she gladly would have eaten them . Sometimes you might want to look at the situation. Your working at 8:30pm ,dirty ,smelling like food,correcting people's english .. REALLY? Have you written many books? Maybe she should quit that job teach english during the day and get to the gym at night and do something about her weight and attitude. read more

The best pizza in the area! When they closed for a month or two to move to a different location, I tried about 5-7 other pizza places. They were all GARBAGE compared to Jerry's! I will honestly miss Jerry's when I graduate from college and move away from Middletown. The BEST pizza ever. (As a sidenote, one of the few places that gets pineapple pizza right) AND THEY DELIVER! How amazing! read more

I ordered Jerry's for the first time last night, as a result of seeing a post on NBC.com about how great this place was. NBC was wrong. I ordered my pizza at 5:51 and was told it would be delivered in 1-1.5 hours. At 8:01pm I called to check on the status and was rudely told it would be there in a few minutes. Finally, 30 minutes after that call, the pizza arrived, cold, and the soda I ordered with it was missing. When I called the restaurant to find out what happened, the girl on the phone snapped at me, got defensive, and only wanted to talk about the 'hot bags' the pizzas get delivered in. Yeah, my pizza tasted like it was steamed in that hot bag for over an hour. It was cold, chewy, and covered in wet condensation. When I realized what kind of service I was getting on the phone (none), I ended the call. 2.5 hours for cold pizza and crappy customer service?? Never again... First and last time ordering from Jerry's. Davinci pizza is waaaayyyyy better, they can deliver on time, and they are nice to deal with on the phone. read more

Read about Jerry's on Yelp, so made it a point to stop when we were in the area this weekend. Didn't expect it to be so small, it's really more of a take-out joint with a few tables. That said, it was fun to watch the kitchen work, and for mom to ensure her son took care of the few of us eating in. We started with a large caesar salad to share and an order of garlic bread with cheese. The dressing on the caesar I would classify more as an italian dressing, heavy on the garlic. For those used to a creamy, more commerical dressing this was oily. I'd probably skip it next time. The garlic bread with cheese needed more time in the oven, and was a little too white-bready to really enjoy. On to the pizza - this is why you must stop here at Jerry's. We ordered a small pepperoni, and a small shrimp scampi pie. The crust is wonderful - a little thicker than "new haven" style, but a great taste and chew. The toppings were very generous, and the crust held up nicely to that generosity. I can't wait to have the leftovers this week. The folks were really nice - it's obvious they know many of the people coming in the door, and it's a great neighborhood nosh. Come in for the pizza!! read more

Ordered delivery, a medium cheese pizza, boneless hot wings with side of blue cheese. I'm a fan of their pizza so I was excited to finally have it. I was sadly disappointed. The pizza wasn't cooked, almost soggy. The boneless wings were basically spicy, breaded chicken chunks that were mushy. The blue cheese tasted like they mixed dill or something, no idea what kind of mystery sauce this is, garlic maybe? It had black specks in it. Never had a blue cheese like this ever. The order was so off I almost thought they gave us someone else's. Not worth the $30. Giving 2 stars only because I grew up in Middletown, and was always fan of Jerry's Pizza. Maybe they lost their touch or got lazy. Might give them another chance. read more

Just had Jerry's Pizza Truck cater a graduation party and we were 100% satisfied. Everything ran so smoothly and the food was excellent- especially the balsamic reduction and onion pizza. I also ate at the restaurant recently and can't wait to go back for more Thai peanut butter and jalapeño jelly wings. Incredible! read more

This pizza was okay. We ordered a couple for delivery as payment for friends helping us move into our new apartment. The lady on the phone was kind of rude and very short with me. The pizza itself came pretty quickly, but it wasn't amazing. I've had better and for the price we paid, expected better. Probably won't order again from Jerry's because it wasn't the best I've had and I think we'd like to discover other places! read more

Delivery took 95 minutes. That is not an exaggerated number. When I placed my order, the girl said 45 minutes. It was a Friday so I was ok with that. But doubling the time and not calling to give a heads up is terrible. It almost caused a divorce. read more

Hadn't ordered since 2012 & heard they'd improved. Well, the food is pretty good, but OMG the prices! The food would have gotten 5 stars, but like I said, the prices... Ordered a 2 topping pizza (1 topping & extra cheese & they don't kid around with extra cheese!), a specialty pizza (Clam Casino $20.75), & 16 wings ($15.50). We wanted the hog wings, but were told they no longer have them. Anyway, not sure how they billed us for the 2 pizzas & wings, but with a $5 tip, we paid $70!! We tried questioning it & was told somebody would call us back. That was 2 weekends ago. I would go back for the food, but not the price! read more

Delicious take out salad with shrimp from Jerry's Pizza today! Literally topped with housemade dressings! read more

Jerry's Pizza - Incredible salad with shrimp from Jerry's Pizza! Perfect! - Pizza Near Me - Middletown, Connecticut

Great New York style pie. Their grinders are pretty solid as well. Really enjoy Jerry's delivery when we are craving a quick fix quality NY style pie. Delivery I'd usually prompt (even though they usually quote 1-2 hours on the phone every time). Don't order chain pizza when you can get the real deal delivered! read more

delicious, huge, inexpensive slices! my mouth is watering just writing about jerry's. i usually just get cheese, cause it's so damn good! it's more of a to-go place. the dining area is small and by the door so you'll be around a lot of traffic (it's usually busy, especially on weekends). that doesn't mean staying to eat is unpleasant, but it's not a sit and relax while being waited on sort of place. what more can i say? best pizza in middletown, easily. read more

I hate when pizza crust is so thin that when you pick up a slice it flops over like a piece of paper and all the toppings and cheese slide off. Jerry's crust is the perfect consistency: not too thick, not too thin slightly crisp on the outside and tender in the middle. And they know how to load up the toppings without overdoing it. It's all about having the right ratio of toppings to crust and Jerry's nails it. We've tried all sorts of pies there: plain cheese, meat-lovers, veggie, white clam, mushroom and eggplant... Have not been disappointed once. read more

Great pizza! We ordered a pepperoni, Hawaiian and a tossed salad for pick up. Folks behind the counter were super friendly, despite how busy they were. I HATE new haven style pizza and was pleasantly surprised to find that Jerry's pizza has nice, thick crust, plenty of gooey cheese and a nice assortment of toppings. We will definitely be back. read more

Recently moved to Middletown and wanted to try something different for pizza besides Mondo. Lots of people rave about Jerry's but I thought it was just ok. It wasn't great, but wasn't bad. Just ok. Kind of a sloppy presentation with not enough flavor and I ordered their special pizza. In a pinch I might try something else from there but it won't be my go to pizza place. read more

Pizza is always great and the waitress is so friendly and nice. Love coming. Thanks Jerry's

I love Jerry's Pizza! It is a great local restaurant that makes great food fast. While we enjoy Jerry's pizza, we love the sandwiches, wraps, grinders and appetizers just as much, if not more. Jerry's is our go-to take out place when we are running late, forgot to take something out for dinner, or when it's just too hot to cook. I'm so glad that it moved to our side of town! read more