Me - can I have a lettuce wrap with turkey, chicken, and bacon? Nothing else? Them - We don't have lettuce wraps, but we have gluten free subs. Me - Great! I'll do that. Them - Okay, so you want the club? Me - No, just turkey, chicken, bacon. Them - We don't have chicken. Me - Okay, turkey and bacon please. Them - So, the club? Me - Sure, the club. But no ham or mayo. Them - we can do a chicken breast. Me - Sure, that sounds good. Them - Okay, so you want the Santa Fe (or whatever it is with chicken breast, green peppers, and onions). Me - No, I would like a gluten free sub with turkey and bacon. Them - Oh, so the club. Me - Yes, but no ham or mayo. Them - Sure. What I got was a gluten free sub with chopped up chicken breast, turkey, bacon, and HAM. I took off the ham and gave it to the dog. It was an okay sandwich, but the amount of work that went into getting what I was asking for was painful and unnecessary. Just curious...is incredible stupidity a prereq for living in NM? Had two other encounters traveling through the northwestern corner of NM today where everyone was complete idiots. It was incredible to encounter that much ignorance in such a short amount of time. read more

OVERALL Jersey Mike's was much like the other chain: a simple, no frills sandwich shop that got our order right. For a moment I thought I heard Danny DeVito say, "a sub above" when I walked in, but it was just my imagination... RATING BREAKDOWN Food: 4 | Service: 5 | Ambiance: 4 | Price: 3 PARKING Ample free parking in a shared plaza lot. LOCATION/AMBIANCE The New Jersey-inspired restaurant was located in a plaza southwest of Santa Fe, NM. It's visible from Promenade Blvd which runs parallel to Cerrillos Road, a popular street. When I walked in at close to 8PM on Friday, February 16, 2024, the workers were already cleaning up for the night. THE GRUB Even after having not been to a Jersey Mike's and a couple years, I had a loyalty reward for a free mini (-$7.25). My oldest ordered a mini #7 Turkey and Provolone. My youngest opted for the #13 The Original Italian. They wanted plain potato chips and a bottled water each. The grand total after the reward was $16.96. LITTLE YELPER'S CLUB My kids are at this weird age where kids meals sometimes aren't enough food, but they do have kid's meals. SERVICE Very nice service from a young man who told me to "have a blessed night." MY FAVORITE PART... My order was ready to go and correct as soon as I got there. NOT SO FAVORITE PART... My daughter claimed she's had better Italian sandwiches, but she still ate most of it. TIP Order online or via the JM app for pickup. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - The kiddo's meal. 2/16/2024 - Fast Food Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

I went and picked up two sandwiches from Jersey Mike's on March 15. Although the workers were understaffed and overwhelmed, the guy running the register was changing gloves between every task. I love to see good food safety! the sandwiches were also delicious. read more

Great sandwiches. Employees are helpful and friendly bread was fresh and the ingredients. My favorite

My sub came out hot and fresh. If there was a little bit of a wait, they didn't tell me that they were backed up or anything so I was a little disappointed and made perfectly aware of my situation as I only have a half an hour for lunch, they threw a couple of brownies in there and I didn't know until I went to drive away to my delightful surprise. I found a couple of treats in there. I was very happy with my son in the end and they did a very wonderful job and apologize for the wait read more

I love Jersey Mike's. First time I ever had it was a couple years ago on a road trip when we stopped at one somewhere in Colorado. This Santa Fe location is the closest to me, and I eat there often. I always order online and do the in-store pickup. It's always right there in a bag on the shelf waiting for me with my name on it. My go to order is the Original Italian and I add pickles, jalapeños, banana peppers, and pepper relish. Today I tried the club supreme and added the same items, because I kept hearing this was some great viral online sub. I didn't like it as much as the Italian, but it was still great. I think where I messed up is that I didn't change the bread to the rosemary parmesan. Veggies are always fresh, meat and cheeses are excellent. The giant sub is massive, don't let the price turn you off as the quality and size are good. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Club Supreme with added banana peppers, jalapeños, pickles, and pepper relish. - Fast Food Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

The team at the Promenade location are the best. They were all so nice. They asked all customers how they were doing as they kept the line moving. It made such a nice atmosphere. Even the patrons were speaking to each other. Give them all a raise. read more

This was our second time here in a week. The place was very clean and the staff were friendly and welcoming. The sandwiches were tasty for the most part. My wife, daughter and I all had the Italian #13 the first time and all agreed they were great for the price. The second time they both had the same sandwich but I opted to try something new. Unfortunately I tried one of the hot subs, the Beacon Ranch Chicken Cheese sub. I was most disappointed with the chicken meat. I had expected something close to sliced chicken breast but it seemed more like finely chopped all most minced so it was kinda gooey. Adding the ranch and melted cheese made it even more so. If you like gooey then you may love it. We'll definitely go back. Nothing wrong with the restaurant just my selection that day. read more

We have always gotten great service here! The staff is friendly and listens well to what you want. The place is clean and the sandwiches are yummy. An easy meal when in a hurry or for dine in on nights you don't want to cook. read more

I recently had my first Jersey Mike's sub. I was working outside all morning. I didn't even realize it was lunchtime, but I was thrilled to take a break when my husband walked in and said he'd picked up lunch! The Italian sub was perfect. The bread was fresh, as were all the ingredients. Delicious! My husband said the sub shop staff was courteous and friendly and that shop was nice and inviting. read more

Not sure why you have to wait for them to make all of the to go orders when your the only one in the store waiting for a sandwich. Makes no sense. They need a better setup. Should be a station for to go orders and one for in store. Should t have to wait 20 minutes to get a cold sandwich read more

The substitute Jersey Mike's are very good. The roast beef was great. The tuna was great and the others are good. The staff are usually good hard-working and efficient. I always tipped them out because I can see how hard they work there. This is a good sub shop much better than Subway. read more

We stopped in after getting our car serviced across the street. The sandwiches we got - Philly cheesesteaks - were very good. And HUGE. I got a regular, and could only eat 1/2, my husband got the large, and could only eat 1/2. We could have gotten the large and split it and been happy! But now we have another meal. The service was, um, I will say meh. The young woman who took our order was surly, no manners, and obviously wanted to be anywhere else. Sorry, but she never smiled, said please or thank you, and mumbled her question "forhereortogo?" The ambiance was 100% fast food, and just what we expected. My only complaint was some dirty napkins on the floor by the soda machines, but the employees were all busy, so I will cut them some slack. Again, the sandwiches were really good and epic proportions. But was two sandwiches, one little bag of chips, and two sodas worth over $40? read more

Night crew closes 30 minutes earlier and then pretends everyone's is supposed to know. Very weird. I wouldn't waste my time coming here unless you catch them before 8pm. read more

The staff at this Jersey Mike's is always pretty attentive and detailed- and most importantly, they put out tasty sandwiches. I do wish they were a little better at cleaning- things seem a little sloppy, especially during busy periods. But the end product is always spot on. read more

The sandwiches here are always fresh and delicious. Customer service is great. I've never had a bad experience here.

Great subs. Friendly and competent staff. Nice place to eat. We usually get a footling and eat half and take half home.

Great value , great service, great selection, nice people working there ... We'll be back !! read more

I was out and about and happened to notice a new Jersey Mike's Subs just popped up. I looked them up on Yelp and they didn't have any reviews yet so I get to be the first reviewer. They were very nice, service was outstanding and the sub hit the spot. It was delicious. I went in to get my order and noticed it looked nice clean and organized inside. I did get my order to go though. It came in a really nice bag with plenty of napkins. Great job Jersey Mike! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Grilled Portabella Mushroom sub without the swiss. - Fast Food Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

See all

Fantastic sandwiches served by a fantastic crew, who are always smiling and remember your name if you've been in just once. The restaurant is clean, the bread is fresh meat is superb and the condiments are out of this world. Mike's way is a must read more

Place is dirty... Dude was making my sandwich on the dirty counter until another employee handed him a paper to put under it. Dude was shocked when I told him I didn't want it and I walked out. He was rude from the get go. It was the first time I had been there after the last mediocre visit. Must be a Sant Fe thing, the one in ABQ. on San Mateo is good and service is great. Won't go back to this one. read more

This review is for the two guys who were working there. We were on a long Road trip back to Denver. They were so friendly and helpful. We had a baby and they offered to help carry stuff to our car. Then offered to help my dad carry stuff. Our sandwiches were put together great and made well! Thank you! read more

Had a good experience the first visit when we just walked in, ordered and took subs home. This time, however, we ordered in advance - online. I arrived a couple of minutes before our pickup time (11:46 for an 11:48 pickup) and was told that they were waiting on 1 of the subs and it'll be right out. I said great, and figured it would be a couple of minutes. They were busy for the upcoming lunch hour, but not too slammed. I waited and more online orders showed up and left with their orders. I inquired again about noon about my order and they said they were still waiting on the one sub. I waited more, and waited. After about 25 minutes of waiting I asked for a third time about my sub and they asked if I wanted a complimentary drink while I waited. I didn't. I'd seen at least 40 subs get ordered, prepared, and served to people who simply walked in... I had ordered over an hour ago, showed up on time, and still no sub. I got the subs 33 minutes after the assigned pick-up time. It's a process thing, I guess. But when you see all those other orders go out, when they - clearly - know I'm waiting on my subs... it's infuriating. I will not be back - my wife may come pick them up. But I will not. Sorry, but you guys failed with my order today. Don't order online... and oh yeah, and the buffalo chicken sub sucks. read more

They suck they waited till I was all the way at the register for my lunch break to tell me they couldn't take $100 bill on a $70 order the sign of the cash register nobody looks at until you walk up to the register to pay if they want people to know put it on the front door when you walk in they can lose business right away instead of having to make mad customers after they waste their whole lunch break read more

The service was phenomenal all employees were friendly and helpful. Our sandwiches were perfectly crafted and the employee helping us talked about the meat types and why they were special which made the quick stop sandwich so much better! Will definitely become a regular over other sandwich shops for us because of the amazing service. read more

I just left JM for the first time and I just had to comment on how friendly the entire staff was from the time that I walked in until I left. Everyone I interacted with was so kind and helpful, that is rare these days. Just thought you would like to know that your staff is amazing. read more

We love this place! The food is delicious and fresh! The customer service is top notch! They go above and beyond. The manager is great! We had an issue with them forgetting a sandwich on a DoorDash delivery and we ended up going in to eat again a few days later, I mentioned to them the issue (it had already been resolved with DoorDash) they still wanted to make it right! read more

I just want to give a huge thank you to the staff today I stopped by on my way in to my 3 rd night at the hospital 12 hour shift and tired as hell ... I walked into the store to order and was greeted by the staff ... The guy who rung me up was very nice asked me how my day went and I let him know it was just starting! He thanked me for saving lives .. I was tired and not having a good day but just by his kindness made me feel in a better mood ... thank you ! Sometimes we don't realize how just being nice can make someone's day ! read more

I grew up next to a Jersey Mikes in California. Haven't had it in 10 years since moving here to NM. When we drove to Santa Fe last week to visit my in laws, I noticed a Jersey Mikes had been built and had to stop! I ordered the #9 Club Supreme (Mike's Way, which is all the fixings with the oil and vinegar) on White Bread, and it was super good! I will definitely be back when I'm in town again. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #9 Club Supreme (Mike's Way) - Fast Food Near Me - Santa Fe, New Mexico

I just found this place. The bread and sandwich is so good. Just wish they were more conveniently located in SF. Maybe add another place?

I had #13 The Original Italian, just as I remembered from New Jersey, so Good! Thank you! Nice packaging too!

We visited the evening of Saturday 9/4/2021 for dinner. This was our first time going to Jersey Mike's and the experience was by far one of the best experiences. The 4 young men who were were working were extremely friendly and welcoming and the food was amazing! 10/10 would recommend and will be returning soon! read more

I went to Jersey Mike's Subs after I called to see if they had gluten free options. They said that they did. I asked how they handle a gluten free order. Johanna asked me if it was a preference or an allergy. I let her know that I have celiac disease and need to be really carefully. She told me that she would make sure to sanitize all surfaces before starting my order. She asked how my sub turned out. She was very friendly. Felix helped to put the toppings of my choice on my sub. He asked if I would like it cut when he was done adding my toppings. He was very polite and friendly. He also asked how my sub was. They have a nice friendly atmosphere and very polite staff. read more