Pi,za is the best in the area. It's the closest to NYC pizza I have ever tried and Im from NYC. Also their hidden Subs are the,best. Footlong Subs are the same price as Jersey Mike, as Mike's has small Subs. FOR great food go to Jimmy's pizza. read more

Hot subs, like steak and cheese, are good. Turkey sub I had was really good. Wings were pretty good--cooked well. Pizza is hit or miss--sometimes soupy with few toppings. Pasta sauce incredibly BLAND; tastes like tomato paste mixed with water and no seasoning. Alfredo was soupy. read more

Same order 1 week apart, one was amazing one was bad. It was the sub special. One was huge and well made the other looked like a subway sub and was like 90% bread. I won't go back read more

I used to come to Jimmy's regularly about 20 years ago and it was great to see it is still going strong. Pizza is still very good for upstate and was very tasty. I also liked the staff and always found the service to be warm and friendly. Great to see some things don't change and highly recommend Jimmy's for a great slice. read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

This place needs some serious upgrades. Tried this 3x in one month; I worked in food service sales for 20+ years, worked kitchens and bars for another coupla decades and know any place can have a bad night, so I reserve judgements based on one meal. Visit 1: ordered the special - Italian Sub...waited about 40 minutes and saw that they sent a staff member to the next door Price Chopper for some of the sandwich ingredients....ok, maybe their food order comes tomorrow and they just got clobbered? I get that! It was a good sandwich, though they did not make it with the items I asked for ( some green peppers, pickles if you have them, black olives) and no cheese...again, forgiven by me due to my food service experience. Visit 2: went in for whatever and was told it was at least a 40 minute wait ( Yay, would rather know now than AFTER placing my order) and since you can't chill out with a beer or a glass of wine while waiting, shoved off and went somewhere else. Visit 3: tried for 20 minutes to make the mealeo app from their webpage work to order and failed; so I called, ordered lasagna ( reheat from prepped food - quick and easy right??) told it would be ready in 25-30 min. Went in with about a 5 minute expected wait time and was there almost an hour. There were 5 people total in the dining area, 3 of those folks were already served....and they were not particularly mobbed with walk- ins or calls.... Went back to my hotel room ( travel for work) and no fork, napkin, or dressing for my "garden salad" ( comes with)....which was brown edged iceberg lettuce with one green and one black olive, and a wrinkled up partial slice of purple onion. The entree was cold in the middle and basically was 2 smooth pasta sheets rolled around the ricotta, with some meat sauce and lots of mozzarella cheese. I had also ordered a side of meatballs ( also cold) which were weirdly peppery / spicy....probably hot italian sausage but this was not indicated anywhere on the menu.... I always try to support a local business rather than the chains which are pretty abundant in Malta, and since I am a woman traveling solo ( albeit with a dog) I'd rather get "to go" and have my meal in the comfort and safety of my hotel room. Will NOT be going back and am very sorry that this place has so much promise ( the bread is good, and I like the sauce recipe) and hope that whoever owns it sees my review and can implement some systems to keep the business alive. read more

We called our orders for pickup and when we arrived there there were a couple of cars lining up to pickup the orders. Due to covid, the staff brings the order out. The problem is they have to find the owner of the orders by asking around at each car in a cold weather. Maybe they are better off by calling when an order is ready for pickup. Pizza: pretty good, nice crisp thin crust. Wings: good size and spicy. Salad: fresh greens. Our order came with bread. The bread is ok, a little bit dry in my opinion but soft. read more

See all

Great pizza, wings, garlic knots, etc. Really enjoy their buffalo chicken sub as well.

Ordered two 6 cut pizza's last night. They were amazing & hot when they were delivered in the time the person told me they'd be delivered. Definitely recommend Jimmy's. They did not disappoint read more

Ordered the eggplant hero and it was amazing. Also brought home a couple of cannolis that were made to order and also wonderful. Will be going back. read more

First time at Jimmys!! Pizza, wings and calzone. Food was flavorful and delicious. Wings crispy! Pizza was perfect! Cant wait to go back!

This is the 2nd time in a row that our order was incorrect, the 1st time we let it slide. This time I called to at least get my money back on what I ordered, but wasn't provided. I called Jimmy's to inquire on how to order a buffalo chicken pizza, with one of their very polite female employees, she assured me I was ordering it properly & asked me to put our level of spice in the comments section, which I did, as well as requesting ranch on the side (I completely expected to pay for that additional request) When I arrived home and opened up the pizza only 1/2 had the chicken & the other 1/2 was plain cheese. I called to make the shop aware of the mistake & hopefully get a little money back since I paid for chicken on the whole thing. The young man that answered the phone argued with me & told me that I didn't order the right way. Meanwhile I informed him 3 times that I was on the phone with an employee of the restaurant when I was ordering on line, he continued to argue & speak disrespectfully to me until I finally told him I'd never be ordering from Jimmy's again! There are SO many other pizza options in Malta, this place has been fully crossed off the list. Horrible customer service read more

It's been a while since I've been here and I'm not sure why I waited so long. Got a pepp and mush pizza and it was amazing!!!! We also got an order of chicken tenders with Buffalo sauce and they were really good too! We will be back soon!! read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Sooooo good! - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

Disgusting. People rave about the food here but over the past few years it has gone down hill. Its just cheap, thrown together fried garbage. The eggplant is the absolute worst. So slimy. And I'm pretty sure they pre make their salads and just let them sit in the cooler. The onions literally turned my lettuce purple. And the food is SO INCONSISTENT. Never made the same, like they have 6 cooks just making food however they want. Never on time, always cold by the time you get it. I gave them a few chances but it was the same thing everytime. I've waited well over an hour for delivery and I've stood in there waiting for my food for 30 mins after the time they told me. The last straw and the main reason for this review...I was just in there and the FRUIT FLIES ARE SO BAD. I didnt even want my food. Jimmy's is no longer the place for pizza & pasta in Malta. Final note.....the kids they have answering the phones are the absolute WORST. read more

soo you can't make this stuff up. I just called in and ordered a large chef salad with Italian dressing and the girl asked me..... are you ready for this ...... she asked if I wanted lettuce on that. are you f#*|£ing kidding me. SMFH‍ read more

We were visiting Lake George. I reached at this restaurant at 10:30pm with my two very hungry children. They had locked the door but still opened to let us in. There were two women inside closing up (I wished I had asked their names). They took our take away order kindly and prepared everything in time. We ordered a large pizza with some toppings, poppers, garlic bread, salad and spaghetti. Everything was really tasty. We really appreciate their kindness to our family that night when I'm sure we would not have found food anywhere else. The food was also very good and we enjoyed every bite of it. A nice little gem in that area! read more

Had to throw them in the garbage. Gross. Greasy and over fried. I've enjoyed their pizza for years but these are a miss and shouldn't be served. read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

My family has been ordering here for years. It's a staple for every nostalgic event we've ever had. Last night, I went to visit my father and noticed he had some collect 10 coupons from the Pizza boxes you buy ever since I was 16. I'm 24 now. This place is so unique and really delicious. Let me start off by saying I have worked in many different pizza places for the last 6 years, some really good ones, and I'm very picky when it comes to pizza and my food. This place is so unique and nails the pizza. The dough is thick, the sauce is really great, sweet, goes well with their cheese. All of their sauces are great, the BBQ chicken pizza is way better than any I've ever had. I really love this place for that. It's really quality ingredients. The girl on the phone was very patient with us despite the two of us deciding to order other pizzas on a whim. Great place, another wonderful memory to look back on and encourage me to keep cooking well. read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

Good pizza. Not a lot of grease and good undercarriage. Very tasty pizza with the right amount of sauce

Great Pizza and subs! Eat there three times a week when I'm in the Saratoga neighborhood.

Love Jimmy's slice with sausage on it. Probably the best tasting sausage I ever had on pizza. Reasonable prices. They heat it up so the crust on the bottom a little crispy. Real good. And I've eaten a lot of pizza in my 67 yrs. :) read more

Ordered a sausage and green olive pizza. Whole green olives??? Not sliced. The sausage looked more like Canadian bacon or something but not Italian sausage. Crust was ok. Just never thought I'd have to specify 'sliced ' green olives and Italian sausage but I guess you do here. Delivery was good and that's why the one star otherwise I wouldn't have bothered. read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Whole green olive pizza with something that was supposed to be sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

Meatball subs terrible threw a little meatballs on doughy roll cold hit or miss there not liking here anymore think I'm done use to be good

It's a hit or miss with Jimmy's - now we only stop for pizza or wings. Their sandwiches are okay at best and their pasta and salads lack flavor. Their fried mushroom app is soggy and jalapeno poppers lack consistency. Their pizza is decent, thin crust and generous toppings but lack consistency. Their wings are probably the best thing on their menu but it's nothing to die for. read more

1st time there, ordered a lg pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, bacon and onion. Excellent crust, sauce and toppings, especially the bacon. 4 stars only because it could have been cooked a few more seconds considering it had extra sauce on it. read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

I used to really like this place but today I came in with two kids order 3 slices of pizza a soda and two chocolate milks and the older women who took my order seemed fine at first but like she wasn't paying attention. BTW... The place wasn't busy at all & there were atleast two other people working so this wasn't a "she was super busy thing" Anyways, I paid by debit & wrote "cash" for tip which I intended to leave on the table as I always do, I was given my drink and asked for the kids drinks which I was told would be right up and I sat down. A few minutes later she came with the pizza and I had to ask her for the chocolate milk (for a second time) but she seemed annoyed and came back with them a few minutes later. Less than a minute later I'm wearing the contents of a whole cup of chocolate milk because she didn't mix the chocolate syrup and one of the girls in attempting to stir it ended up dropping the cup in her lap! NOT ONCE did this woman come over to help or apologize, not even when I specifically asked for her assistance! Another woman helped us (the only reason for the second star). My new pants are now ruined and this B!tch didn't even make an effort to act like she gave a shit! How hard is it to mix chocolate milk? Needless to say I won't be back. read more

Been meaning to write a review about this place for years now. I go there with a group of friends fairly regularly (weekly, pre-Covid), and the food and service are always great. Their wings are among the best around, and according a friend who is a Buffalo native, they rival those at the best establishments in Buffalo. We are an obnoxious bunch, and their staff puts up with us and sometimes joins in on our banter. Been going there for years and always look forward to seeing Rachel and Pam. Their food and service a great, and for a fair price. Four of us split the family special (8 cut pizza, a dozen wings, and a pitcher of soda) and it comes to like $24-5 before tip. Their white broccoli pizza is also a favorite of mine as well. read more

The pizza and some of the sandwiches are okay. Do not order one of their "dinners". They are overpriced and terrible. We ordered two of their pasta dinners one night and not sure what happened but it was supposed to be sausage and peppers and they put ONE link of sausage on top of some pasta cut lengthwise down the middle. Veggies were sparse. The dinner itself tasted OVERWHELMINGLY of salt. My boyfriend likes salt and usually piles it on and even he was complaining that all he could taste was salt. It was like someone just dumped a salt shaker into the food. It was disgusting., The salads that came with it were small and pathetic and contained only lettuce. I think one of them had a small chuck of tomato in it. 100% horrible, so much so that we don't even order pizzas from them anymore despite our prior experience with the pizzas being "okay". read more

Called the week after Christmas to inquire about ordering a tray of eggplant parm. I told the young lady that I was having 6 adults and 3 teenagers. She said a small tray was more than enough. Ok. So I order it for the next day to be picked up 5:30 PM. And asked for extra sauce on the side. A few minutes later I called back and asked that they change the pickup time to 5:00. She said no prob. But when my son got there at 5:00 the next day to pick up, the food wasn't ready. Had to wait a half hour. AND no extra sauce as I had requested. AND, and most importantly, wasn't nearly enough food. Good thing I had lots of bread and salad to serve. I even cooked up some pasta for filler. In fact, I didn't even get to taste the eggplant parm because there wasn't enough for my guests. Something is messed up at Jimmy's. read more

Ordered tortellini Alfredo, side salad and a largepepperoni calzone... tortellini was okay, side salad had lettuce I wouldn't consider fresh, and the calzone was dissappointing. Filled with ricotta cheese, way too much! Where we are from, calzones do not have ricotta in them. And the menu had no statement sayi g there would be a mountain of ricotta in it... will not eat here again. Sincerely, Dissapointed. read more

Malta's best pizza & wings. Love their specials! You can't beat the prices. Always great food and service.

Pizza is very much a personal thing. Everyone has their preference. I prefer a medium-thick crust and here they serve a thin crust. Not wood-fired-oven thin since they don't cook with wood, but any-mall-USA thin. But I've eaten my share of thin crust pizza so I don't intend to fault that aspect of it here. Our host enjoys pizza from Jimmy's so we picked up a couple of 8-cuts on our way to her house. One with just cheese to please her and the other with sausage, onions and peppers (they don't offer roasted peppers) for us. I thought $28 and change seemed a bit expensive. Many places will remove the pie from its baking tray and let it continue to bake on the floor of the oven for the last few minutes to crisp the bottom of the crust. If they did that here it wasn't evident since after the 7 minute drive to the house there was no crispiness to the bottom of the pizza.and no golden-brown color. The sauce seemed somewhat bland and the sausage consisted of paper thin slices that mostly lacked flavor. I had only one bite that had some fennel flavor. The onions and green peppers were average and the salt level was a bit on the higher side. Next time we may force our host to be satisfied with a thicker crust from a different establishment in the area. read more

The wings are dripping with Grease and pizza was ok nothing special. Was a last minute on the way home purchase and unfortunately the Grease leaked every where. read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Wings with a side of oil - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

I'm at Jimmy's Pizza and pasta right now and it's over I ordered a turkey sub with cheese it's so good I ordered mozzarella sticks it's also really really good I mean I really like that the fact that you can get like a lot of stuff like 100 like a really big party and you want like lots of chicken wings and yeah well really it's a great place to go if you want pizza or pasta or like subs chicken wings salads you can get Italian dishes mushrooms and you know how do you spell answer no appetizers well yeah you can help by stop Jimmy's Pizza and Pasta read more

I'd been wanting to try this restaurant for awhile; it always smells yummy when I pass it on the way to my nail salon. Well what a huge disappointment! The pizza was greasy and limp. The salad was all iceberg and wasn't even fresh, it had lots of brown on it. The Italian dressing was mostly oil with some herbs not mixed at all. Save yourself and go elsewhere! I'll post pictures of the salad but they really don't do it justice as it looks and tastes worse than depicted. read more

See all

I love this place normally but last night I spent $46 for food for my family BUT I did NOT pay to have a acrylic nail in my pizza! I'm in pain today because it cut into my gum. I went back last night and the woman gave me my money back for 1 if the pizzas but when I called this morning the woman whom we spoke to last night was the woman whose nail it was and she didn't admit it until this morning! I told her I didn't know what to do and she told me the only thing that I can do is go to the doctors and she will pay my bill! What about the pain and suffering of my mouth? read more

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Malta, New York

See all

Really quite acceptable New York-inspired pizza, especially when one takes into consideration that this is in Malta, NY, which is about as close as you can come to Dumbf**k without actually being in Dumbf**k. And you can't beat the price. Alas, if only they served beer. read more

Jimmy's is our go-to pizza place. We love the family special. Great service. Only 4 stars because sometimes the pizza is inconsistent - too much moisture or overcooked. It's never been inedible. read more

Used to love their food... got sick after eating a meatball calzone, called to let them know, and they verbally ripped me apart. There are a ton of great pizza places around.. I now patronize elsewhere. read more

Best sub ever . I know it's not fine done but when you are craving a sub this place is the place . I ask for extra turkey and lettuce . Yum . The calzone stuffed pizza was delish . Reasonable . read more

Slow service (more than an hour) for one pizza to get done which then turned out to be not good. Not a great experience with this place!