They sat our very large party and never missed a beat. Our waitress was amazing. The pizza slices were huge! I enjoyed my pepperoni and pineapple slices, they tasted great! I'd love to stop by again! read more

Why is everyone in the kitchen eating while they make my food??!! Is that even acceptable practice?

I went here the 2nd day they were open to give this place a try. I had looked up pricing online that morning and found a lunch special I wanted to try - 2 slices with 2 toppings each for $8.79. So when the actual lunch special was 2 slices with 1 topping each for $9.99 I was disappointed, but when I mentioned it to the manager she immediately tried looking it up and we discovered there is glitch in the matrix somewhere and on her phone it showed up correctly. My phone, the 2-topping version and pricing. So that is really weird but hopefully they will fix it soon. Anyway, the other elements of my lunch were all delightful. A clean, spacious dining space that is well lit, wood table and red chairs. The service was prompt and attentive. The water tasted very clean. The pizza was awesome. Very much a New York style foldable crust, thin but with the right amount of bite. I really like the quality and presence of the toppings - which was also on point: not too much, not too little. They brought me a cup of sauce to dip the crust in and it was very good as well, although it would have been much better warmed than ice cold. Overall this is a solid entry in the Pensacola pizza offerings, particularly on this side of town. read more

See all

The restaurant has only been opened for two days when we dined in. It was clean with bright colors. We were excited to try this New York style pizza. My husband is from NY and he is a fan of this style of pizza. It was busy and not flowing well (day 2) of opening but we got a tall table. We had free Garlic Knots as an appetizer and they were ok. We had chicken on our pizza and was unflavored almost like it was boiled. We did ask for sun dried tomatoes instead of fresh tomatoes and they were all over pizza. We have learned our taste for pizza is the Neapolitan Style. I can tell you the tall tables with the red stools & even the bar area were the most uncomfortable stools we have ever sit in. We came we tried we have no reason to return. Try it to see if you like it. read more

Johnny Brusco's Pizza - I can tell you the Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing was delicious - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

First time trying this restaurant. Got a to go order and brought it home. The calzone was really good and a great portion size. The wings smelled delicious (lemon pepper) they had a lot of meat on the bone and tasted great. They took my order over the phone with no issues. Would recommend and try again. read more

Johnny Brusco's Pizza - Johnny's Meat Deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

The food , service and Ambiance were Great as well. I love that they are Pet Friendly. read more

Johnny Brusco's Pizza - An all Johnny's Meat Deluxe.. it was yummy. I like that it didn't have too much sauce and thin slices. - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

Not a fan of their pizza, I didn't even eat the leftovers I brought home! I must say the service was ok and what I could see in the dining area it was clean, my palette just didn't like the pizza. read more

Great service, very clean restaurant. Pizza was not a NY style, crust too thick. Added jalapeño to the margarita pizza and it was smothered so much it was all I could taste. Garlic knots were not very garlic. Lasagna was decent but sauce was too sweet. Came from the west side of town to try this place and was disappointed with the food. read more

Comparable to Dominos. Defenitley not a new york pizza. Not awful but Founaris in pensacola has way better pizza nearby. Dont waste your money read more

I went day 2, excited ! I'm a Jersey girl and know good pizza. My takeout order was not what I expected, probably cause I had my expectations too high. The crust was thick on both pizzas, not at all NY Style. I would equate it to papa johns. Sorry, but I took it home and heated it, and ended up taking it to work to give away as it was too expensive to waste. I was sad as I did greatly appreciated the service at the bar, had a good conversation with Bryon as he's a very nice guy. Maybe I should have ordered a slice? Maybe the crust would be different. The salad was definitely fresh and tasty and I hope they do well. I'll be back, order a slice, lunch special or something else on their extensive issue. Love that we have more options on nine mile read more

Order thru website & driver arrived pizza was cold I got flatbread margarita pizza, my husband got pepperoni pizza a quick dinner we wanted but wait time was long. read more

10/10 experience! The service was excellent, and the food was amazing. I'm not sure why the reviews are so low--I had a great time here with my family and would definitely recommend it to others. read more

Johnny Brusco's Pizza - Hot Honey Pepperoni and jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Pensacola, Florida

See all

There ain't nothing New York about this awful pizza. Thick, doughy crust, very little terrible cheese and tasteless sauce. I ordered mushrooms which were absent. read more

As a New Yorker, this place is the closest to a NYC pizza you're gonna get!! Amazing hospitality and I would definitely recommend checking it out. read more

There is a saying in Food & Beverage that you can replace bad food with good service but you can't replace bad service with good food. My wife and I decided to try this restaurant during lunch today. They had been posting daily struggles that come with new openings and, for that reason, decided to give them some time before going. We arrived about 12:45, right after the main lunch hour. It was not busy at all, there were about 8-10 customers, two hosts, 3-4 servers in front of house area - defiantly enough coverage for the amount of guests. We were greeted very loudly and enthusiastically by one of the hosts and then told to sit anywhere. We sat there for over 5 minutes with servers walking by us with no acknowledgement, no offering of menus or greeting us to say that someone would be over. A server started clear a table next to us with one of the hosts coming to help, still nothing. I finally asked a server who was passing by us and he said he would get someone. Another server behind us was asked if she would help us and after seeing her negative reaction we decided to go. On the way out, we asked to speak with a manger. She quickly met us at the host stand and immediately began apologizing. She explained this was not supposed to happen then continued to explain that they had only been open a week and there was a new process that everyone was having to get used to then asked if there was anything she could do. We appreciated the offer but it sounded like a bunch of excuses. We declined her offer and said that if we decided to return we wanted it to be under different circumstances. Some reading may say our experience is not a big deal and it happens everywhere but it's expensive to eat anywhere now. To pay for a meal and then bad service on top of that is unfortunate and not acceptable. We hope this review can help this restaurant elevate their service to a better level. Better service always equates to returning guests and most times higher check averages that in turn mean higher tips and revenue. The good news is that with some additional training on steps of service, strong management role modeling & accountability and great food fewer people will have our experience. We may give this restaurant another chance but probably not anytime soon. read more

I WANT to like this place. I'm also from the NJ/NY area, this is NOT NY style at all. You'd find this pizza in Omaha Ne, not Jersey or NY. They need to work on the crust, thinner. And the sausage, not crumbles, but pieces. I'm cheering for them but needs polishing .... read more

I'm from Brooklyn NY, and this is not New York pizza. Never ever going back for bread sauce and cheese. You can miss me with this cheap imitation. read more

The NY style calling card has me confused now. Have had quite a few NY pizzas in NY and also Skys pizza in Pensacola. We ordered a large pizza and it was not even close to what one would consider a NY style pizza. I would compare it to Papa John's and that's being generous. I really wanted it to be what I was expecting but it will most likely be the last pizza I order from here.. read more

Best pizza I've had in a while, I recommend the hot honey hawaiin pizza and blue angelrita. We've been needing a place like this in the area! read more

We have one suggestion, but many, many compliments. I don't know why people expect perfection on a first week of opening!! The line was out the door and around the side!! The pizza was absolutely delicious, as well as the chicken fingers. The people were all very sweet, and working faster than could be expected. Some people just have to gripe, even when there's nothing wrong! Our one suggestion, please, cut your vegetables up smaller, including the lettuce. This is definitely our new pizza place!! Keep up the good work! read more