This was a bit of a mixed experience, so I'm settling on 2 stars. The pub has a cozy, hole-in-the-wall feel with a separate dining room and game room, making it seem like a fun neighborhood spot. The service was also a highlight--our food came out quickly, and the staff was friendly throughout our visit. Unfortunately, the food just didn't meet expectations. The cheese fries sounded promising because the fries themselves were crispy and well-seasoned, but the cheese topping had an unpleasant flavor that completely overwhelmed the dish. The wings were another disappointment since they arrived without any sauce, leaving them pretty bland. The ranch was decent, but nothing memorable. On the positive side, the pretzels were warm, soft, and easily the best thing we ordered. While I appreciated the fast service and laid-back atmosphere, the inconsistent food quality made this one a miss for me. There's potential here, but based on this visit, I'd probably choose another spot next time. read more

See all

Cool dive bar a block from the beach. I've never been to Ireland but it sure seems authentic on the inside. I ordered a hot dog with sauerkraut which was pretty darn good but the Irish Reuben the next day was tasty but mushy and greasy. The fries seemed like they were boiled in oil instead of fried. Their pepperoni is eatable but my my favorite. Nice friendly employees. I'd go there to drink but I would not order any chow until I was pretty lit up didn't care. read more

None of the games worked, and ate all our money. The whole reason we went was so my 3 year old could get a cool arcade experience and nothing worked. read more

Local bar, fun and very attentive finger food amazing and the staffs is amazing (Jerrien) bartender was great enough to make me a sangria on the spot (Anna) bartender amazing and very attentive, not to mention Tony security guard very informative, visiting from a different city for the first time in st Maria. Great whole in the wall (Dive bar) arcade and I must not say it enough staff alllll was amazing , Thursday night. must visit will def visit again before I leave . 5++++ read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

See all

Waited 20 minutes no one came to our table they weren't busy. It was filthy on the inside - definitely would skip this place too many other good options to waste your time hers. Only reason it gets one star because isn't an option for zero read more

Best dive bar aroud!!!! Great pizza Great Phillies The best wings!!!!!!!!!!! read more

went today ... will never go there again!!! waitress very rude and said they will not serve tables 12 or more. we could have split but her attitude had us walking out very quickly read more

I love a local dive bar, but $14 for a house wine is just unreal. I will not be back!

Outstanding Philly cheese steak! Others at our table had burger and grouper sandwich (blackened) also delicious. Bartender was our waiter (even though we were at a table) and service friendly and quick. Large variety of beers on tap. Fun background music, we really enjoyed our dinner read more

Perfect dive bar to get away from all these friggin kids and suck a few beers down. Must note the whitetail on the wall clearly not shot in FL read more

All of the game machines were broken. We lost a few dollars trying each of them. The place was packed. If you need a late night drink, this is an okay option, but I wouldn't pick it on purpose. read more

Served inedible chicken sandwich. Texture like chewing cartilage. I don't know if it was bad before it was cooked (maybe freezer burned throughout), but knew it was wrong from the first bite. Didn't swallow any of it - couldn't. Sent it back. They took it off the bill, but no apology from the server. Everything else about the place was fine. Guinness was very very good. Atmosphere was popular local spin on Irish pub. Other food was fine. Service wasn't friendly but wasn't bad either - except for the lack of any real apology for serving spoiled food. Plenty of other good places to eat. No need to throw the dice with this place . . . unless you just need a Guinness! read more

Only locals are welcome. Bartenders are extremely in-convinced to perform the job they signed up for. Major issue to pour up 12 shots when asked. Asked for a card and to close out before they would make them. After $150 1st round of shots they were nice enough to pour the second round of fireball with a watered down bottle that multiple groups questioned. Not special people, not special players, not special plays. Go any where else in the panhandle! read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

Talk about a go to spot!! This place is always on point! Cold beer and delicious pizza, what else can you say?? read more

See all

Love this place. I great neighborhood bar and restaurant. We sat at the bar during Happy Hour. The bartender was very friendly and the drink prices during Happy Hour some of the best we have found in the Santa Rosa Beach area. The locals sitting at the bar were very welcoming and engaging. We had a fun time and will definitely return. Also had the smoked tuna dip appetizer which we both enjoyed. Looking forward to trying the corned beef and cabbage. read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Funky bar - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

See all

Pretty good dag gum service, the waitress was pretty dag gum nice, the only problem was how long it took for our dag gum food to get to our dag gum table. Dag gum!!! read more

I first want to say that we are former service folks so we do understand being short staffed and take in consideration the post-COVID staffing issues. That being said I like to review my experience on the following, service, atmosphere, and food (taste and quality)! Service: You must seat yourself! Who knew?!? Once seated, we were greeted fairly promptly. We sat in a high top in the bar area because that was where everyone else seemed to be. We thought that would be easier on the waitress. Service was prompt on drinks, refills, and taking our order. Atmosphere: it is OK. Very sports bar feel (which is fine)! I wouldn't consider it family dining or Irish ! Other than offering "Irish inspired" drinks I didn't understand it! It is dark, it basically a bar that you can bring your family that has a kid game room.... Until 11:00 pm‼ Food: we ordered the tater tots nachos and pretzels as an appetizer and then a meatball sub and philly for our entrees. 1. The nachos came out approx 25 mins after we ordered . They were OK and would consider your typical bar food. The pretzels came out over an hour after we ordered. Also, they aren't really pretzels. It is just bread twisted without salt. We ate them because we were pretty hungry at this point. 2. It was over and hour and 15 mins after ordering that we cancelled our sandwiches. I would love to tell you about them but I cannot. When we ordered there were about 8 people at the bar and 3 tables filled at the bar. There were none in the dining area. I'll let you come to your own conclusions on the cause of the long delay on our food. We left hungry. Other observations! People came in after us and got their pizza and lots of to-go orders. They could have been swamped with pick up orders or maybe our order got lost. ‍. I am not sure and I wasn't sure I wanted to ask. I just know that it shouldn't have taken that long for the small amount of food we ordered! There was a bartender (our waitress) who was busting her butt. She had a fairly descent size crowd when we left (not when we got there) and little help. There was other people working there but I am not sure what they were doing other than watching the game and socializing with what appeared to be regulars. I hope to try this establishment again but may need to read a few more positive reviews and some changes prior to going back. read more

Enjoyed a delicious meal....grilled Reuben with onions rings and side of homemade soft pretzels...generous portions...average prices....friendly staff...A+. Will definitely return when in area. read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Reuben with onion rings. Delish! - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

See all

I can't attest to the atmosphere, as we just got food for takeout but the pizza was impressive. Looking for food after being stuck in traffic trying to drive into town, my sister found this place. I loved the pizza and the tater tots were good. They also ordered the soft pretzels, which I regret not eating now because the looked delicious. I would definitely recommend trying the food. read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Pizza yuuummmmm - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

Awesome meal!!! Very fresh and tasty. We ordered takeout and it took about 20 min for our food to get ready. We ordered a large pizza with Italian sausage, pretzels with nacho cheese and an order of onion rings - everything was delicious and hot. The pizza was definitely large and could've prob gone for a medium for 2 people. Onion ring sauce very good. No complaints!! Highly recommend!! read more

See all

I encountered the most miserable waitress who hates her job. They should keep her in the back washing dishes so other patrons don't have to endure her utter disdain for the customers who pay her bills. Food was adequate. read more

I have to say after living in LA and going into Irish pubs there (there was always an Irish accent somewhere ) it was a cultural shock to only hearing southern accents in a place decked out in Irish memorabilia. There's a side that's just video games and love the air hockey table. The food was good, it's even better after you've had your drinks. read more

Did I miss something? Could be! Maybe I need to try it again, but it seems like a dive to me, and contrary to the way they promote it, it doesn't seem family friendly - unless you want to teach your kids how to smoke. If you describe a bar or club as a dive, you mean it is dirty and dark, and not very respectable. The food was underwhelming too. read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

See all

Great pizza and sandwiches. Game room for the kids! Gets quite noisy after 9pm as it's a locals hangout. That shout speak for itself!!!! Food is awesome, drinks are top notch and it's just a great place to hang out. Can't go wrong with McTighe's!!! read more

We got take out Pizzas and they were really great! There were kind locals inside at the bar. I probably wouldn't eat inside, but was impressed with the pizzas we received. read more

Legit shop, Jack the owner is a beauty and the food and staff are phenomenal. Right across the street from the beach. Go see Kay the bartender and order some wings and zaaa. read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

Probably one of the most underrated places on 30A. It is an Irish pub so there's that. Great food and great value. Everything is fresh. Fries are awesome. It's a bit dark and you might have to wait just a bit so if you're chill you'll love it but if you're high maintenance then just stay away. read more

Going here on my Birthday and Hurricane Irma's Birthday was bittersweet. I'm Going against my rule of reviewing a joint on an impossibly busy day (like Mother's Day - no place should be overly scrutinized on an awful day). It's an Irish Bar - if there's such a thing as a divey/ neighborhood pub in these parts it's definitely this place. Prices are great compared to other local spots - not to normalville where most people live. For here - this is cheap. Only place open for miles so naturally they were understaffed and packed to the gills!! No one knows how busy they're going to be when everyone is supposed to stay inside. Hmmmm. Good Caesar $10/ Wings / Cheesy Bacon Tots Got a Lg pizza to go $22 Good Beers Woman waiting on us did what she could- obviously insanely busy working every table in the place - she Kicked butt. Then a big guy, Dion, (looked like a Hockey player) came in and took care of us. He was busy but very calm considering his predicament. BEST of All PITTSBURGH STEELERS PUB - there's a Pittsburgh Steelers bar/pub/restaurant in every city!! read more

See all

McTighe's is the only bar/restaurant of its kind along 30A. Its a proper dive, open late, a long menu filled with bar food greatest hits done expertly, low priced drinks, a killer happy hour and wide selection of beer and liquor. This is a far cry from the hyped up 1/2 assed, overpriced slop both poured & served in the area. They don't crank up terrible music and they've got sports on all the time on 4 televisions. Service is friendly but not too friendly. Chicken wings, cheesesteaks and meatball sandwich are standouts but there truly are no duds on the menu and everything is from scratch. Nice mix of locals, regulars and tourists. Only drawback is long wait time for to go orders(don't call in orders) and the restrooms needs to be freshened up. read more

We are new to Santa Rosa Beach, and heard from multiple people that they have the best wings in the area. My wife and I showed up excited to give them a try. Place was about half way full, and we stood at the door for a few minutes with zero help or guidance from the staff. Finally, a member of the staff walked by and said hello after sitting on his phone the entire time we were there. That was it I then go up to the bar to ask if we need to sit ourselves, and the very careless and rude bartender with long hair (in a ponytail) just said "yes you do". He didn't offer menus, or to send a server our way. We were very disappointed after hearing great things about the food. The service was absolutely terrible and couldn't careless about customer experience. We went next door to Blue Mabel read more

I used to go here for lunch 3x per week with friends. There subs and pizza are some of the best in our area. Plus the coldest beer... It's a dive bar yes. But try there CHEESE STEAK OR PIZZA SO GOOD! Not the most ideal place for dining as a family but Takeout Is always available. read more

Being local, I've been here many times and I try hard to like McTighe's. The food is decent, its got that old bar feel and smell, and the characters working the bar and waiting tables are a lot of fun. What makes me give them a 2Star Review is the draft beer. No matter which one you pick, the beer if flat and tastes "skunky". The tap system in this bar badly needs to be replaced. My friends and I come to McTighe's a few times a month and we have all transitioned to bottled beer but a draft beer is what we would all order if it didn't suck so badly. Come on, Johnny McTighe's, replace that tap system! read more

It's been a couple of years since I first wrote a review for Johnny Mac's. It's still my favorite local dive. I eat lunch there several times a week. The food is always great and the staff is awesome. They tend to look after the locals first, and tourists second. So if you aren't a local, wait in line. This is a huge plus for me, as a local! Cheers. read more

This place sucks.... Two people working the bar on a full Friday night only serving a couple of there friends. Buddy working looks hammered.

Always a fun time. A good mixture of locals and tourists Good pizza great bar food.

We stopped by a couple times during our stay in town. Pretty good Happy Hour and the pub pretzels are very good. Pizza, burgers and the fish & chips looked amazing but did not try. Server staff at bar pretty good. Local hang out. read more

Service has really gone downhill over past couple of years. Bartenders with an attitude. Food is always great.

I would give a zero based on tonight's visit. Cheesesteak was worst I ever had. They must be trying to cut some corners because of COVID-19. Only one person waiting on bar and all tables. I couldn't even taste the cheese on my cheesesteak. It was so dry. I've had the cheesesteak here before and I was pleased but not anymore. Based on tonight's visit I'll never eat here again and I recommend anyone else choose somewhere else to eat. The quality of the food tonight was subpar as the service was as well. Don't waste your money here go anywhere else you will be happier. Oh yeah warm beer read more

Johnny McTighe's Irish Pub - Philly cheesesteak with onions and hot and sweet peppers - Irish Near Me - Blue Mountain Beach, Florida

See all

I live very close to this place but have never been. Mostly because it's a) a Steelers bar (gross) and b) it didn't look that appetizing considering all the other options I have. I decided to swing by late at night because I wanted wings and their menu says they are world famous. If these wings are famous, it's only because they are the most basic wings in the history of mankind. I've been to probably 100 places for wings in my lifetime. Not only are these wings not famous but they are not good. And they take 30 minutes when there's no one else ordering from the kitchen. Hate giving bad reviews, especially when a place is close by. I want it to be good. It's just not. And it makes me Angry that they put that their wings are especially good on their menu. B.S. If you are looking for a dive bar to get drinks late at night on 30-A, this place is fine and likely one of your only options after 10. However, if you are looking for food (or decent wings) think again. read more

Visited this pub for the first time on the evening of March 7 and was very impressed! Kaileigh and Tatianna, who worked together at a previous job where I was an occasional customer, do an outstanding job here! The homemade pretzel appetizer with marinara sauce was great and so was the Maine lobster bisque. Kaileigh also made my visit memorable by hooking me up with a free Johnny McTighe's T-shirt. Although I live more than two hours away in Alabama, I would definitely return at some point and try out other menu items. read more